Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Both at their peak and best in the following:

1.Commic book versions

2.Movie versions beast from xmen bane from DKR etc..

Who wins in each of the above how and why??

1. Bane by way of back breaker.

2. ?

Beast tEars him apart. Easy he is to smart strong & fast.

New 52 version of Bane is easily stronger than Beast, not any other version though.

Movie versions go to Beast.

Why does everyone think bane was all that impressive?

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Why does everyone think bane was all that impressive?


Because he broke the Bat. Bane is a great character, he's in my top 5 all time best Batman villains when portrayed correctly.

Originally posted by Stoic
Because he broke the Bat. Bane is a great character, he's in my top 5 all time best Batman villains when portrayed correctly.

He is bigger & stronger then batman he better break batman.

Beast pulls the tubes from Bane's back after a crafty backflip... both scenarios

Beast wins

i think beast takes a majority against comic bane, but i def think bane could take at least a couple.

Beast needs more respect.

He wins both.

What did Beast do in the movies that was impressive? All I can recall is him jumping far and knocking people down in the 3rd film. Probably wins a majority in comics though.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Beast needs more respect.

He wins both.

you'd think so but really, who has beast beaten in 1 on 1 battles? shrug he typically gets lost in team stuff...

Beast was jumping 20-30 feet no problem, and was knocking people out/sending them flying with his acrobatic assaults. He's also a lot faster than Bane and has claws and teeth, as well as durability to go with that.

As for comic Beast, one of his best feats is restraining a raging She-Hulk for a bit, he also took down a Danger Drone(Cat Beast). Ripped it apart like a chew toy.

Originally posted by leonidas
you'd think so but really, who has beast beaten in 1 on 1 battles? shrug he typically gets lost in team stuff...
He took on Sabertooth in incredible fashion in space recently.
And Sabs had all the advantage.
He also schooled Logan in Astonishing.

Originally posted by ares834
What did Beast do in the movies that was impressive? All I can recall is him jumping far and knocking people down in the 3rd film. Probably wins a majority in comics though.
The question more is what did Bane do in his movies to stand a chance against Beast?
Batman Forever Bane got owned by Clooney with ease.
TDKRs Bane is just an enhanced steroid man.

Beast jumping high into the sky is a sign of his strength in his legs alone. Plus claws.

He tears Cheesy Banes' tubes out of his back.
And knocks TDKRs Bane's head in.

Originally posted by the ninjak
He took on Sabertooth in incredible fashion in space recently.
And Sabs had all the advantage.
He also schooled Logan in Astonishing.


The question more is what did Bane do in his movies to stand a chance against Beast?
Batman Forever Bane got owned by Clooney with ease.
TDKRs Bane is just an enhanced steroid man.

Beast jumping high into the sky is a sign of his strength in his legs alone. Plus claws.

He tears Cheesy Banes' tubes out of his back.
And knocks TDKRs Bane's head in.

do you happen to have the logan scans. i'd love to see that!

Sorry I don't have them.

It's the early issue where Logan is trying to stop Beast from escaping with the cure for Mutants. And Beast just kicks him around.

Logan screams "You BEAST!"

I'm guess you're talking about Whedon's run.

That wasn't a schooling. They both got some hits in, then Emma telepathically stopped them. I'll post scans shortly.

I put the scans into an album rather than posting all the pics here. I skipped a page that was dialogue since it's not relevant. Let me know if it doesn't work.

http://imgur.com/a/9QIf4


Anyway, the only schooling was done by Emma. Beast and Logan were relatively even during the short exchange.

Beast is everything Bane is, and a good deal faster/more agile. Beast wins in both scenarios.

Didn't beast run at super speed in the movie at a much weaker state.? He also had super strength.

By the way, the answer to Leo question, Beast beat the hell out of Danger, a Robot that destroyed the Xmen.

Beast stomps this fight.

Beast got his as whooped by Creed...though Victor does think Hank is superior to Logan.

Originally posted by Estacado
Beast got his as whooped by Creed...though Victor does think Hank is superior to Logan.

Wait a minute. Does Creed=<Bane?

Originally posted by carver9
Wait a minute. Does Creed=<Bane?
Nah...I just forgot to quote Ninjak's post where he said Beast was taking on Creed 1 on 1.