Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Reverse Flash

Weather Wizard

Captain Cold

Mirror Master

Gorilla Grodd

Pied Piper

Captain Boomerang

Heatwave

VERSUS

Fin Fang Foom

Ultimo

Blizzard

Living Laser

Mandarin

Controller

Boomerang

Firebrand

Reverse Flash wins it for his team. A lot of the other fights could go either way, but Reverse Flash is going to own whoever he faces instantly and it will avalanche from there.

Don't most rogues-galleries share most of the same archetypes, modified for theme and power-level?

Grodd, Mandarin, Ra's Al Ghul, and Mongul are all foreign barbarians. Grodd is goofy, because he fights the Flash. Mandarin is a rich douche and warmonger, because he fights Iron Man. Ra's Al Ghul is a rich ninja-king, because he fights Batman. Mongul is a cosmic conqueror, because he fights Superman. But they are all versions of the foreign savage.

Heatwave, Firebrand, and Firefly are all fire-themed. Heatwave is an everyman crook, because he fights everyman Flash. Firebrand is political fanatic, because he fights Iron Man. Firefly is a self-destructive nutcase, because he fights Batman.

And I'm sure someone could come up with equivalents for most villains of most heroes.

Honestly, aside from Reverse Flash, depending on which version of Captain Cold shows up to this fight, it's almost a stomp in favor of Team Flash Rogues. That dude can reach temps below absolute zero (I know it makes NO SENSE even for comic logic but hey it's there on panel) and he has AoE moves so avoiding his attacks is going to be hard to impossible.

OP, couldn't you divide the fight into individuals vs other individuals? Because team fights are extremely difficult to analyze.