Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Dredd and Batman had a serious dislike. How's the future's most fascist cop gonna like fighting with the present's most fascist vigilante?

Both smart, experienced and tough as nails : it's almost impossible to decide who is better or more "powerful". But I'd say Dredd.

I'd say Punisher, the original is always better...

Originally posted by jgiant
I'd say Punisher, the original is always better...
Since when is Dredd a Punisher clone ?

Frank's not gonna like being told "You're next, Punk!"

Well he uses a gun doesn't he?

ummm, do you even know how long Dredd's been around?

"Well he uses a gun doesn't he?"

Does that makes Punisher a clone of any wild west cowboy?

And Dreed. Hes overall better. And more feared.

Damn right he's over all better, he's in Batman's league.

Who ? Dredd ?

Yes, Dredd.

Well, i dont think so !

Bats is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay tougher, he can beat the whole angel host of DC wth 1 minute prep !!

Doesn't Dredds armor bounce bullets off? plus he can produce many types of ammo...
"Grenades .. ." BANG!

Originally posted by Juntai
Doesn't Dredds armor bounce bullets off? plus he can produce many types of ammo...
"Grenades .. ." BANG!

certain calibres yes, and yes he sure can.

Originally posted by MERCILOUS
ummm, do you even know how long Dredd's been around?
No, enlighten me...Originally posted by olympian
"Well he uses a gun doesn't he?"

Does that makes Punisher a clone of any wild west cowboy?

And Dreed. Hes overall better. And more feared.
Sarcasim...Originally posted by MERCILOUS
certain calibres yes, and yes he sure can.
certain calibers, well puns got grenades too, but i guess dread may have the upper hand here because he is from the future...But i wouldn't count Frank out...

Originally posted by jgiant
No, enlighten me...
Well not that long in the states but just about forever in the U.K. He's like on issue 2500 over there and i'm pretty sure he has at least a decade on Frank. So if you really think they're that similar Franks the rip.

Originally posted by jgiant
certain calibers, well puns got grenades too, but i guess dread may have the upper hand here because he is from the future...But i wouldn't count Frank out...

Fragmentation? Shrapnel won't do it. And yes he does have the upper hand. Better armor, better fighting skill, better tactics, better hand to hand, better weaponry, just as resourceful, more experience, better training, more will power, just as tough, basically...Frank's got nothing on him.

Judge Dredd. He not only has the technology and the training, but he has better style. Then again the nazis did have good fashion sense..

Dredd, but only because of the tech advantage(better armor and weapons)
Even the playing field by giving them the same equipment, and Dredd goes down

dredd wins he is one tough cookie and is even more business then the punisher perhaps

Pretty even. I'd say its probably close to 50/50.

Originally posted by MERCILOUS
Well not that long in the states but just about forever in the U.K. He's like on issue 2500 over there and i'm pretty sure he has at least a decade on Frank. So if you really think they're that similar Franks the rip.

Actually Frank was 1974 and Dredd was 1977. But still no one rips off each other. There have been a number of real life people that have took things in their own hands and killed people with no remorse before these guys ever came around that the creators could have based these guys around.

Maybe all the Dredd Punisher threads should be merged.

Oh and anyone thinking Pun wins just check out Dredds thread.