Cascador
This is something written on another forum, I found it quite interesting...I don't agree but I like to know your opinions...I think it just takes logic sense to find out that Palp is Sid/emperor:
Slapping myself in the head for not having noticed this continuity error before. And how could Lucasfilm possibly miss that one?
The Jedi Temple has been overrun. Bail Organa returns to Coruscant with Obi-Wan and Yoda. He receives a message saying that his presence is requested in the Senate, for an emergency meeting. Yoda suggests that while this emergency meeting is held, Obi-Wan and himself will have a better chance of getting inside the temple to shut down the fake coded retreat message.
So, while Bail Organa goes to this emergency meeting, Obi-Wan and Yoda go to the Jedi Temple.
Now, the purpose of the emergency meeting was for Chancellor Palpatine to reveal the treason of the Jedi, the attempt to take his life and above all, that the war is over and that the Republic is to be reformed in a new Empire. So, this is basically where Palpatine declares himself Emperor.
Meanwhile in the Jedi Temple, Obi-Wan watches the security tapes. After seeing them, he talks to Yoda and refers to Palpatine as the Emperor. But how could he know about Palpatine calling himself Emperor already? Not one reference to 'Emperor' or 'Empire' has been made beforehand and the emergency meeting where they were first mentioned was obviously held at the same time (Yoda's point about sneaking in while it was going on).
Slapping myself in the head for not having noticed this continuity error before. And how could Lucasfilm possibly miss that one?
The Jedi Temple has been overrun. Bail Organa returns to Coruscant with Obi-Wan and Yoda. He receives a message saying that his presence is requested in the Senate, for an emergency meeting. Yoda suggests that while this emergency meeting is held, Obi-Wan and himself will have a better chance of getting inside the temple to shut down the fake coded retreat message.
So, while Bail Organa goes to this emergency meeting, Obi-Wan and Yoda go to the Jedi Temple.
Now, the purpose of the emergency meeting was for Chancellor Palpatine to reveal the treason of the Jedi, the attempt to take his life and above all, that the war is over and that the Republic is to be reformed in a new Empire. So, this is basically where Palpatine declares himself Emperor.
Meanwhile in the Jedi Temple, Obi-Wan watches the security tapes. After seeing them, he talks to Yoda and refers to Palpatine as the Emperor. But how could he know about Palpatine calling himself Emperor already? Not one reference to 'Emperor' or 'Empire' has been made beforehand and the emergency meeting where they were first mentioned was obviously held at the same time (Yoda's point about sneaking in while it was going on).