Namor vs. Thor

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



batdude123
Any ideas?

snoopdogg
Originally posted by batdude123
Any ideas? Namor is tough but he is kinda outclassed here in most areas.

Namor is a notch below Thor.

batdude123
Oh really? Because I know that DC will probably defend him as a god and then it will be a god vs. a god! big grin

snoopdogg
Originally posted by batdude123
Oh really? Because I know that DC will probably defend him as a god and then it will be a god vs. a god! big grin I think Namor took a hit from the Uru hammer but I just don't think Thor would have too much trouble with Namor is he went all out.

batdude123
I know, but let's see what DC has to say about this.

Marcus4600
Poor Namor. He's had a lot of matches lately where he just dominates, and now this.

batdude123
^ Exactly.

TheKahn
If Thor didn't have his hammer, it would be a better fight. But as it stands Thor should win 8/10. He'd get 10/10 if he wasn't quite so dim sometimes.

batdude123
Wow. I'm surprised that DC hasn't responded to this thread yet.

outarddwarf
i say that Namor could take this. He could dodge most blast thor shot from the hammer and could dodge the hammer itself. If he played it safe and didn't get over confident like he does sometimes than he could make this quite the fight!

batdude123
^ Even then, I think Namor would be in over his head with this fight.

Droopy
Namor loses to Thor

Comicbook_kid
Been done before...check it out here....

http://www.coreyblake.com/nwcc/spotlight/Sub-Mariner59.html

I've read this issue before, but it's been a long time ago; but if I remember correctly, Namor gives Thor one hell of a fight...this is one of those rare occurances where Namor uses his ability to take on abilities of certain sea-life...he zaps the #$%# out of Thor when he summons the abilities of an electric-eel...and he also manages to snap the thong at the end of Mjolnir into!!! stick out tongue

batdude123
This isn't a fight underwater however. This is a fight on pure dry land.

Horrificus
Namor is listed as Class 100

Namor has broken the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak

Namor hit the Hulk so hard, he knocked him out of the ocean, miles away, reverting him back to banner and causing tidal waves everywhere.

Namor has lifted submarines and destroyers, even used them as clubs, both weighing waaay over 100 tons.

Namor has been able to dodge lasers.

Namor has taken a nuke in the face,and been ok.

He has been suckered from behind by Thor's hammer, and just got up, ready to go.

Namor has beaten the Hulk 3 times or more.

Namor can absorb huge amounts of electricity, and discharge it as an attack.

Well, you get the idea.

Wolverine2006
Thor would bash his head in with a hammer, and when his brains oozed out Thor would fry'em

spideycarnage
Originally posted by Horrificus
Namor is listed as Class 100

Namor has broken the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak

Namor hit the Hulk so hard, he knocked him out of the ocean, miles away, reverting him back to banner and causing tidal waves everywhere.

Namor has lifted submarines and destroyers, even used them as clubs, both weighing waaay over 100 tons.

Namor has been able to dodge lasers.

Namor has taken a nuke in the face,and been ok.

He has been suckered from behind by Thor's hammer, and just got up, ready to go.

Namor has beaten the Hulk 3 times or more.

Namor can absorb huge amounts of electricity, and discharge it as an attack.

Well, you get the idea.

namor is the man but thor can do that and sum..thor wins 9/10

Horrificus
Originally posted by spideycarnage
namor is the man but thor can do that and sum..thor wins 9/10

Um... when has Thor

Broken the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak.

Hit the Hulk so hard, he knocked him out of the ocean, miles away, reverting him back to banner and causing tidal waves everywhere?

Shown the speed to be able to dodge lasers?

Taken a nuke in the face, and been ok?

Beaten the Hulk 3 times or more?

You really think it would be that easy? He can take electricity, hits by Thor's hammer, and be unfazed.

Come on!

Marcus4600
Thor's done much more than what Namor has done. I mean, he's the god of Thunder, dude. Check the Ragnarok series.

Validus
Purely hand to hand Namor has a pretty good shot. If Thor is using Mjolnir at any level approaching competent (like how BRB uses Stormbreaker), Namor gets creamed.

Horrificus
Ok. I concede that if Thor gets "exotic" on Namor, he will beat him.

But, if they just did a toe to toe, I still think Namor has shown that he can hang with Thor.

Hit and Run
Originally posted by Horrificus
Um... when has Thor

Broken the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak.

Hit the Hulk so hard, he knocked him out of the ocean, miles away, reverting him back to banner and causing tidal waves everywhere?

Shown the speed to be able to dodge lasers?

Taken a nuke in the face, and been ok?

Beaten the Hulk 3 times or more?

You really think it would be that easy? He can take electricity, hits by Thor's hammer, and be unfazed.

Come on!
Well, Thor has pulled the Midgard Serpent off the Earth; and it was big enough to wrap its body around the entire planet.

He has stalemated the Hulk in pure h2h fighting (no hammer)

Taken an indirect hit from a planet-destroying bomb.

Defeated Ego, the living planet with a thermoblast.

Defeated Super-Skrull with an anti-force.

Drove off Galactus.

Stalemated Immortal hercules in armwrestling. And Immortal Hercules has shown that he's stronger than Namor, even underwater.
http://img354.imageshack.us/img354/308/herculesunderwater2eu.jpg

Stalemated Zeus for months (although Zeus seemed to be holding back)

Namor's tough, I'm not saying he isn't. he can hang with top-tiers. But in terms physical strength, stamina, and durability, I'd say Thor's above Namor.

Without the hammer, I'd say Thor takes it more times than not, but not without a fight each time.
With the hammer (and no PIS/CIS), Thor just has too many advantages to lose. The uru hammer can do a lot more than just shoot electricity.

CaptainStoic
I couldn't say it any better than Hit and Run... Unless Namor has gotten stronger than Immortal Hercules over the years. Thor won't need help from his haamer to over power Namor, and I like Namor as a character... he's simply out classed. Just a little off the subject, what ever happened to Dale Keowns character The Pitt? Marvel should buy him, or try, what a waste.

Droopy
The Hammer is everything

DarkCrawler
Originally posted by batdude123
Oh really? Because I know that DC will probably defend him as a god and then it will be a god vs. a god! big grin

roll eyes (sarcastic)

If you'd check the similar threads, I have never said that Namor would win against Thor (or Wonder Man, since you seem to believe that I'd defend Namor against him too).

I'm not a fanboy. And after your showings in Wolverine VS Cyclops threads, I wouldn't have a nerve to call someone as one if I'd be in your position...

I only defend Namor in threads where he CAN beat the opponent and has the means and skills to do so. Here, he doesn't.

Thor wins. And next time, read my posts one more time before getting bitter.

batdude123
Originally posted by DarkCrawler
roll eyes (sarcastic)

If you'd check the similar threads, I have never said that Namor would win against Thor (or Wonder Man, since you seem to believe that I'd defend Namor against him too).

I'm not a fanboy. And after your showings in Wolverine VS Cyclops threads, I wouldn't have a nerve to call someone as one if I'd be in your position...

I only defend Namor in threads where he CAN beat the opponent and has the means and skills to do so. Here, he doesn't.

Thor wins. And next time, read my posts one more time before getting bitter.

You know what, "fanboy" came out of your mouth, not mine. I was just saying that when you defend him, you usually post about a thousand (non PIS) things that demonstrate Namor's power and I thought you might do it here. And by the way, I admitted that Cyclops could take Wolverine down, so why don't you read some of MY posts.

Horrificus
I'm glad we were all able to agree that Namor would kick Thor's feathery helmet right into the ground.

Thanks for backing me up. And thanks for seeing things my way.

Back to you, Bob!

Wolverine2006
Originally posted by batdude123
You know what, "fanboy" came out of your mouth, not mine. I was just saying that when you defend him, you usually post about a thousand (non PIS) things that demonstrate Namor's power and I thought you might do it here. And by the way, I admitted that Cyclops could take Wolverine down, so why don't you read some of MY posts.

AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!! Betrayed

batdude123
Originally posted by Wolverine2006
AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!! Betrayed

Hey, you even admitted it too! stick out tongue

DarkCrawler
Originally posted by batdude123
You know what, "fanboy" came out of your mouth, not mine. I was just saying that when you defend him, you usually post about a thousand (non PIS) things that demonstrate Namor's power and I thought you might do it here. And by the way, I admitted that Cyclops could take Wolverine down, so why don't you read some of MY posts.

"I know that DC will probably defend him as a god"

Defending a character that isn't a god as a god is something that is basically one of fanboy definitions. And you only admitted that he could take Wolverine in the end, before that we had to do quite a lot things to convince you.

Sorry that I sounded a bit rough though, had a bad day.

batdude123
^ It's okay! wink

JTGuy
Originally posted by Comicbook_kid
Been done before...check it out here....

Sub-Mariner59.html

I've read this issue before, but it's been a long time ago; but if I remember correctly, Namor gives Thor one hell of a fight...this is one of those rare occurances where Namor uses his ability to take on abilities of certain sea-life...he zaps the #$%# out of Thor when he summons the abilities of an electric-eel...and he also manages to snap the thong at the end of Mjolnir into!!! stick out tongue

You must be remembering a different issue, because in this one Thor knocks Namor around like a sack of potatoes. It is very clear in this issue that Namor is less powerful than Thor. The fight ends with Thor taking Namor, wrapping him up in his cape and hurling him out to sea. It's not clear if Namor is conscious when this happens or not, or perhaps he is KO'ed by Thor's throw, but either way, Thor's toss rockets Namor for miles before he plunges into the sea. Namor is so shaken by his encounter with THor that the idea of flying back to NYC to continue the battle doesn't even occur to him.

This story was horribly written. I'd love to see a realistic, long fight between these two. Namor would go down in the end, but it should be a cool fight, with plenty of opportunity for these two pompous ones to spout off lots of boasts...

DarkCrawler
Yeah, that story is umm...crap. (Thor was being effected by water high pressured water)

Here's a good one (Thor is influenced by Morgan Le Fay, that's why they are fighting)
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/7666/namorvsthor13cu.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/5135/namorvsthor26hy.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/8512/namorvsthor33dk.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/4816/namorvsthor48yh.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/5492/namorvsthor58lw.gif

Mindship
There are multiple scenarios here:
1. Thor sans hammer fighting Namor on land.
2. Thor sans hammer fighting Namor in water.
3. Thor with hammer as club/projectile fighting Namor on land.
4. Thor with hammer as club/projectile fighting Namor in water.
5. Thor using hammer's full energy powers fighting Namor on land.
6. Thor using hammer's full energy powers fighting Namor in water.

1. Thor wins 6/10
2. Namor wins 6/10
3. Thor wins 8/10
4. Namor wins 5/10
5. Thor wins 10/10
6. Thor wins 9/10

Just off-the-cuff estimates.

AJ4LIFE
i got a namor thor fight and namor does very well should i post it
namor uses his suroundings

DarkCrawler
Is it this?

Originally posted by DarkCrawler

http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/7666/namorvsthor13cu.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/5135/namorvsthor26hy.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/8512/namorvsthor33dk.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/4816/namorvsthor48yh.gif
http://img438.imageshack.us/img438/5492/namorvsthor58lw.gif

AJ4LIFE
no not the one u showed earlier a earlier one its pretty funny should i then

DarkCrawler
It might be the older one...go on if you like. smile

AJ4LIFE
yeh proberly

il do now

elephant_man
thor.

AJ4LIFE
1

http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/9541/17md3.th.jpg

2

http://img515.imageshack.us/img515/2167/21ni.th.jpg

3

http://img320.imageshack.us/img320/1487/30co1.th.jpg

4

http://img281.imageshack.us/img281/764/42xj1.th.jpg

5

http://img461.imageshack.us/img461/8835/58ha1.th.jpg


here it is

DarkCrawler
Oh yeah, it's the one.

Maybe the lowest portrayal of Thor ever...?

JohnR
Wow, that was truly terrible writing. Either way, as poor of a showing as Thor gave, he still defeated Namor.

JTGuy
Originally posted by JohnR
Wow, that was truly terrible writing. Either way, as poor of a showing as Thor gave, he still defeated Namor.

My feelings too. Bad, bad writing, but still, the best Namor could do was squirt Thor with a firehose or smack in the face with a flagpole? I think anytime that your opponent wraps you in his cape and hurls you miles away from the fight, I think you can safely say that you got manhandled supremely.

DarkCrawler
I don't really think that that is a good portrayal for either of them...

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.