Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

takes place in new york no prep popeye has a spare can of spinach ready incase of imergency popeye is strong even without his spinach and its ovious that he has some boxing skills so who win
out of robin or pops

bump

bump

Popeye has super speed, super strength, matter manipulation and reality manipulation powers.

oh.........then how about popeye vs magestic

Originally posted by A.J
oh.........then how about popeye vs magestic

how about no.

...

You'll never really get a good Popeye thread...no one takes it seriously.

well im requesting people take this serioulsey popeye is very strong, good fighter and gets super strong after spinach but can robin take him out

Then why don't you pit him against Thing or something? I mean his strength level is clearly way above that of Tim's.

only after spinach, he is a very strong person but no thing stength lol

Originally posted by A.J
only after spinach, he is a very strong person but no thing stength lol

Seriously, I used to watch the cartoons all the time when I was a kid.

Even without the spinach the guy could juggle a piano with one hand.

Without the spinach the guy punched a buzzard so hard that he cooked it. And I don't even know what that means!

Originally posted by Psyquis52
Seriously, I used to watch the cartoons all the time when I was a kid.

Even without the spinach the guy could juggle a piano with one hand.

Without the spinach the guy punched a buzzard so hard that he cooked it. And I don't even know what that means! well what was his durbiltiy like, lol, but seriouley im trying to get scans of the respect thread but my pc not working

Originally posted by A.J
well what was his durbiltiy like, lol, but seriouley im trying to get scans of the respect thread but my pc not working

His durability doesn't matter. Because as soon as he's knocked out the can of spinach will inexplicably open up and pour in his mouth (probabiltiy control?). Then he will chew it up (while he's unconscious I might add) and he'll have battleships in his arms and he'll destroy the opponent.

not really he wont use it unless hes loseing or is deperate and i think it wont be a beat down so if tim cn beat him it wil be a surprise victory,

bwt can u bump the popeye respect thread I cant get in it from a link or the first page so if you could do that for me it would be great

Originally posted by A.J
not really he wont use it unless hes loseing or is deperate and i think it wont be a beat down so if tim cn beat him it wil be a surprise victory,

bwt can u bump the popeye respect thread I cant get in it from a link or the first page so if you could do that for me it would be great

I'll give it a shot.

ok thanks, see digi we can debate properly about popeye

well i now say popeye takes it

Popeye definitely. Tim might be able to pull an escape of some sort, but I can't imagine him winning. Even without spinach, Popeye is already super-strong -tough and -fast.

My favorite no-spinach Popeye feat: Dropping a piano out of the window of a high-rise apartment and then running down a several flights of stairs to the street below and catching the piano before it hits the ground. He has done this on more than one occasion. Again, this is Popeye at base level.

wow so is he above street level or about spideys

Without spinach, I'd put him a bit above spidey in terms of strength and durability, but a bit below him in agility.

Here's a 1937 short with Popeye and Bluto engaged in some Spidey/Daredevil-esque rooftop to rooftop fighting. Hooray for the public domain!

lol nice one

Originally posted by Psyquis52

Without the spinach the guy punched a buzzard so hard that he cooked it. And I don't even know what that means!

No joke! He even pulled that move on the Giant Roc from the 1001 Arabian Nights. I wasn't kidding with the Popeye vs Superboy Prime thread. How stong do you have to be to punch your way out of the Phantom Zone or beat a tank into appliances? In both cases physical strength is something of a non-sequiter to the effect that was accomplished.

omg..............

Popeye pwns all

yep

It's hard to get a serious topic about a comedy character, but Popeye is far above Robin in power. I mean, he wouldn't even me street level, he's higher than that. Popeye wins this with or without spinach.