Your 3 favorite episodes!

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



commander fox
My 3 favorite episodes are EP:3,5 and 6 what are yours? smile

J.M FcThumbs-Up
We've seen too many "favorite....."-threads....
Here we go again>1.Ep 5
2.Ep 4
3.Ep 3

Exador
I liked Episode 1: The Phantom Menace, Episode III Revenge Of The Sith and Episode VI: Return Of The Jedi

Scarecrow756
My three favourite episodes are....

Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back
Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith
Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope

Alliance
1, 2, 5 cool

TheOnes2
in order:

5, 3, 2

KingDubya
Episode VI
Episode IV
Episode V

Yep, that's the whole OT. I liked it much better than the PT movies; don't know exactly why, though...

J.M FcThumbs-Up
You couldn't be more true!
What's not to like about the OT.....?

I prefer Ep3. as a standalone apart from the PT.
Episode6 isn't that good in my oppinion, except for having the Emperor, Father vs. Son....and the final space battle.

steverules
4, 5 and 6

Rampant ox
Episode II
Episode III
Episode VI

exanda kane
5, 4, 6 in that order.

sithsaber408
Empire
Sith
Hope
Clones
Menace
Jedi.

Guess that means 3,4,5, a good trilogy in its own right.

Ermac_Master
1. A New Hope.
2. Revenge of the Sith.
3. The Pantom Menace.
4. Return of the Jedi.
5. The Empire Strikes Back.
6. Attack of the Clones.

Just thought I'd state them all before a "list your favorite episodes in order from 1-6" again.

EPIIIBITES
1 Clones

2 Empire

3 New Hope

((The_Anomaly))
1. ROTS
2. ROTJ
3. ESB
4. ATOC
5. TPM
6. ANH

MEDVOCK
1. Episode III
2. Episode II
3. Episode V

systemshock2
1) The Phantom Menace (due to Qui-Gon Jinn)

2) Revenge of the Sith (due to the standout role given to Palpatine)

3) Attack of the Clones (due to Dooku)

Rampant ox
Originally posted by systemshock2


3) Attack of the Clones (due to Dooku)

DAMN STRAIGHT!!!!!!!!!!! eek! eek! cool

Lord Saboteur
In order: III, IV/VI, V/II, I. In all actually, I think of all of the movies as equals in their own right.

Tangible God
Originally posted by KingDubya
Episode VI
Episode IV
Episode V

Yep, that's the whole OT. I liked it much better than the PT movies; don't know exactly why, though...

commander fox
Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
1. ROTS
2. ROTJ
3. ESB
4. ATOC
5. TPM
6. ANH

I agree with the first 3 ! smile

commander fox
In my order : 3/5,6,4,1/2 YUP! big grin

Jedi Priestess
Originally posted by J.M FcThumbs-Up
We've seen too many "favorite....."-threads....

PVS
its still tough to answer. i need another year or two for the dust of ep3 to settle, and the personal hype to subside. then i can give a genuine opinion.

right now its:

1-ep6
2-ep5
3-ep3

however, if i grow weary of ep3, strike it from the list and add ep4

smoker4
Ep5 the 3 then 1 smokin'

sithsaber408
Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
1 Clones

2 Empire

3 New Hope

Really Mike?

Clones over Empire or the original Starwars? confused

((The_Anomaly))
ANH is boring, I cant even watch it from beginning to end. I watch the start With Obi-wan and Luke, then watch the end. The only good part in ANH IMO is when Ben is talking about Anakin and the Clone Wars. Even the Death Star attack isnt very exciting....And the stuff in the Death Star is horrendously boring. Even the Duel between Vader and Kenobi is pitiful, even slightly painful to watch.

Thats just what I think anyways, and I grew up loving the OT, but AOTC>>>>>>>>>>ANH IMO.

Sith Master X
Revenge of the Sith
Attack of the Clones
The Empire Strikes Back
The Phantom Menace
A New Hope
Return of the Jedi

OB1-adobe
3,4,5

I like the middle of the story the best I guess

In reality,

A New Hope
Empire Strikes Back
Revenge of the Sith
Return of the Jedi
Phantom Menace
Attack of the Clones

PVS
Originally posted by smoker4
Ep5 the 3 then 1 smokin'

no mention of rotj.......blasphemy!!! mad schmoll
Originally posted by Sith Master X
Revenge of the Sith
Attack of the Clones
The Empire Strikes Back
The Phantom Menace
A New Hope
Return of the Jedi

beyond blashphemy................just.......wrong sad

JaehSkywalker
4
1
5

smoker4
Originally posted by PVS
no mention of rotj.......blasphemy!!! mad schmoll


beyond blashphemy................just.......wrong sad

Ewoks my friend, friggin ewoks smokin'

J.M FcThumbs-Up

smoker4
Thats as good an arguement as any

JaehSkywalker
Originally posted by JaehSkywalker
4
1
5

+

6
3
2

chinabing
laughing
True, how come nobody ever asks what are your 5 or 6 favorite episodes?

smoker4
7,8 and 9 are pretty good too.................fear

Blue_Hefner
ROTS
AOTC
ROTJ

moviefreak_173
What are you smoking? Those are the worst!

aj_vader
1. Star Wars Episode III - Revenge Of The Sith
2. Star Wars Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back
3. Star Wars Episode IV - A New Hope
4. Star Wars Episode VI - Return Of The Jedi
5. Star Wars Episode II - Attack Of The Clones
6. Star Wars Episode I - The Phantom Menace

wink

DeVi| D0do
Empire Strikes Back - 10/10
A New Hope - 9/10
Return of the Jedi - 8/10
The Phantom Menace - 7/10
Revenge of the Sith - 6/10
Attack of the Clones - 5/10

EPIIIBITES
Originally posted by sithsaber408
Really Mike?

Clones over Empire or the original Starwars? confused

Yeah...I'd say it's my favorite...but in no way would I recommend it to anyone if, say, they wanted to check out a Star Wars movie for the first time...It's a crap film...but beautiful crap.

Empire is w/o a doubt the best...and I'd have to go w/ the one that started it all as the second best.

But I just love clones...don't know why...seen it billions of times. Love the feel of it, the look of it. I think it's Lucas at what he does best...Bubble-gum sci-fi...It's where his star shines the brightest. To put it plainly, he tried to do LOTR in space for EPIII...and that's why it sucked so bad and didn't even seem like a Star Wars movie. It was forced and contrived. The rule...stick to what you're good at...or people will see right through it.

Well...some people.

JaehSkywalker
Originally posted by smoker4
7,8 and 9 are pretty good too.................fear

titles??

hehehe...

J.M FcThumbs-Up
Originally posted by smoker4
Thats as good an arguement as any

Smoker.....are you on the chronic-sticks my friend?
Just kidding.....thanks! smokin' big grin

smoker4
Always laughing out loud

J.M FcThumbs-Up
laughing out loud smokin'

Sith Master X
Originally posted by EPIIIBITES
Yeah...I'd say it's my favorite...but in no way would I recommend it to anyone if, say, they wanted to check out a Star Wars movie for the first time...It's a crap film...but beautiful crap.

Empire is w/o a doubt the best...and I'd have to go w/ the one that started it all as the second best.

But I just love clones...don't know why...seen it billions of times. Love the feel of it, the look of it. I think it's Lucas at what he does best...Bubble-gum sci-fi...It's where his star shines the brightest. To put it plainly, he tried to do LOTR in space for EPIII...and that's why it sucked so bad and didn't even seem like a Star Wars movie. It was forced and contrived. The rule...stick to what you're good at...or people will see right through it.

Well...some people.

I couldn't agree with this more. I've been dying for someone else to feel the same way about AOTC. Where I differ though, I thought Revenge of the Sith was great. lol

sithsaber408
Well, I love Clones too, I enjoy it just as I enjoy all the PT.

I'm one of those that like's em all as a big story.

I actually saw AOTC more times in theatres then any of the others.



I couldn't be persuaded that its better than: ROTS, Empire, or possibly ANH.

They're about the same, I guess.

I didn't mean to come off like I hate the film, because I don't, I just couldn't see anybody rating it as the favorite for all 6.

JediRobin23
Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
Empire Strikes Back - 10/10
A New Hope - 9/10
Return of the Jedi - 8/10
The Phantom Menace - 7/10
Revenge of the Sith - 6/10
Attack of the Clones - 5/10

No way man, your way off....

ROTS - 9.8/10
ESB - 9.6/10
ROTJ - 9.2/10
AOTC - 8.9/10
ANH - 8.9/10
TPM -8.7/10

Darth Dean
V, III, VI
then IV, I, II

smoker4
laughing out loud I see the rule of 3 has gone out the window

JediJim
1. The Empire Strikes Back
2. A New Hope
3. Revenge of the Sith

stunna1773
empire strikes back
phantom menace
return of the jedi

J.M FcThumbs-Up
Originally posted by JediJim
1. The Empire Strikes Back
2. A New Hope
3. Revenge of the Sith

Yes yes to JediJim you listen...

Lord Tyrant
They are in correct matrix order.........

SWE3ROTS
SWE2AOTC
SWE5TESB

JediJim
Originally posted by J.M FcThumbs-Up
Yes yes to JediJim you listen...

big grin big grin big grin stick out tongue

greenangel
1. Empire Strikes Back
2. Attack of the clones
3. Revenge of the Sith

My top 3 even tho I love them all....... angel

commander fox
Originally posted by greenangel
1. Empire Strikes Back
2. Attack of the clones
3. Revenge of the Sith

My top 3 even tho I love them all....... angel

heheangel

Infinity
1-5-3 tied with 6

Infinity
lol can i ask why people like aotc its the biggest disgrace in star wars history lol.. sorry for being a little ruff but it is.. :s even clone wars vol 1 n 2 are better

Akira99
I'd say:
1] Ep 5
2] Ep 4
3] Ep 6

The prequels are too just painful to watch from beginning to end. I have to constantly fast forward. I'm not saying they don't have their good bits...

DudeHunter
Originally posted by Commander Foxy
My 3 favorite episodes are EP:3,5 and 6 what are yours? smile

exalky same for me dude wink

Commander Foxy
Originally posted by DudeHunter
exalky same for me dude wink

Hello! happy

DudeHunter
Originally posted by Commander Foxy
Hello! happy

hello rolling on floor laughing

Commander Foxy
Originally posted by DudeHunter
hello rolling on floor laughing

How are you doin? rolling on floor laughing

DudeHunter
Originally posted by Commander Foxy
How are you doin? rolling on floor laughing

good and U ?

Commander Foxy
Originally posted by DudeHunter
good and U ?

I am fine..happy Wass`up!? eyes

smoker4
Try and stay on topic if possible multiple name changer, you can do this kind of shit in OTF

Mr Parker
Originally posted by Scarecrow756
My three favourite episodes are....

Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back
Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith
Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope

Mine are similiar to Scarecrows.
Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back
Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope
Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith

Mr Parker
Originally posted by Akira99
I'd say:
1] Ep 5
2] Ep 4
3] Ep 6

The prequels are too just painful to watch from beginning to end. I have to constantly fast forward. I'm not saying they don't have their good bits...

I agree with you,i dont like the prequals either,but I Hate jedi even more than Sith.The only good star wars made I feel are empire and a new hope.the rest suck.

pr1983
Best: Empire, New Hope, Jedi...

Favourite: Jedi, Empire, New Hope imo...

Caledor
My favourite would be the first three, with my favourite being
EP 3
EP 1
EP 2
(in that order)

Kongu_Dude
happy

JaehSkywalker
Originally posted by smoker4
Try and stay on topic if possible multiple name changer, you can do this kind of shit in OTF


nice sig

Akira99
In my opinion:
TPM: 4/10
AOTC: 3/10
ROTS: 5/10
ANH: 8/10
ESB: 9/10
ROTJ: 7/10

Kongu_Dude
Originally posted by Akira99
In my opinion:
TPM: 4/10
AOTC: 3/10
ROTS: 5/10
ANH: 8/10
ESB: 9/10
ROTJ: 7/10

I think ep 3 is much better than only 5 points.. smile ..

SpaceMonkey
1. Ep. 5
2. Ep. 3
3. Ep. 6
4. Ep. 1
5. Ep. 4
6. Ep. 2

Sith Lord Windu
1. Revenge of the sith
2. Return of the jedi.

I don't have a third, after the above two, they are equally the same IMO. but that's just me.

Kongu_Dude
Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
1. Ep. 5
2. Ep. 3
3. Ep. 6
4. Ep. 1
5. Ep. 4
6. Ep. 2

Kinda like that...hmm

Akira99
Maybe I'll change my ratings as the ones I typed b4 are not that accurate when I really think about it:
Heres the worst ratings I'd give the films:
Ep 1: 4/10
Ep 2: 3/10
Ep 3: 5/10
Ep 4: 6/10
Ep 5: 7/10
Ep 6: 5/10
And the best:
Ep 1: 5/10
Ep 2: 4/10
Ep 3: 7/10
Ep 4: 8/10
Ep 5: 9/10
Ep 6: 7/10

Kongu_Dude
Originally posted by Akira99
Maybe I'll change my ratings as the ones I typed b4 are not that accurate when I really think about it:
Heres the worst ratings I'd give the films:
Ep 1: 4/10
Ep 2: 3/10
Ep 3: 5/10
Ep 4: 6/10
Ep 5: 7/10
Ep 6: 5/10
And the best:
Ep 1: 5/10
Ep 2: 4/10
Ep 3: 7/10
Ep 4: 8/10
Ep 5: 9/10
Ep 6: 7/10

Happy Dance

barand1
Episode III
Episode V
Episode II
Episode IV
Episode I
Episode VI

MattLeatherface
My favorite episode would be episode 1, I can't decide between the other 5.

Darth Martin
In order......


1. TESB(BEST Star Wars film PERIOD!!!, Vader, Yoda, and Solo, and Calrissian)
2. ANH(Classic masterpiece, Tarkin, Vader, and Alec Guiness as Kenobi, Han Solo)
3. ROTS(Most action, Mace Windu and Yoda)
4. ROTJ(Vader's redemption and the Emperor also green lightsaber)
5. AOTC(Darth Tyranus and big Jedi battle, arguably most visually stunning)
6. TPM(Darth Maul and Qui Gon Jinn)

Don't get me wrong all of them are masterpieces in cinema, but the ones with Darth Vader are just cool. If there's one that should be redone it's ROTJ.

sithsaber408
Topic is about fave 3 episdoes?


Thats a toughie.

1. ESB
2. ROTS
3. ANH/AOTC (Tie)

and for fun:

4.) TPM
5.) The last 45 min. of ROTJ

queeq
They're NOT all masterpieces.

1. ESB
2. ANH
3. ROTS/ROTJ
4. TPM






5. AOTC (the worst of them all)

Rogue Jedi
Originally posted by queeq
They're NOT all masterpieces.

1. ESB
2. ANH
3. ROTS/ROTJ
4. TPM






5. AOTC (the worst of them all)

1. ESB
2. ANH
3. ROTJ
4. ROTS
5. TPM
6. AOTC

queeq
FRIEND! wink

General G
FOE!

1. ESB
2. ROTS
3. ROTJ (excluding ewoks)

queeq
Where's ANH?

General G
Not in the top 3, probably number 4, leaving the last two to fight over the last spots.

JackieCD
Ep 3, 5 and 6

queeq
How can ROTJ outrank ANH?

General G
Because, the only thing I didn't really like in ROTJ was those damn ewoks.

queeq
Which take up a lot of screen time.

And you did like Ford's wooden acting? And Leia being Luke's sister? And a rambling rebel fleet beating a superior Imperial Space Force?

General G
Alright! You are bringing all the bad stuff out! The only saving factor, one which I have watched countless times was the Luke/Vader/Sidious scenes.

queeq
Okay I agree with you. I love those too. ROTJ has quite a few good scenes unparralled in the PT, but unfortunately they make up only a relatively small part of the movie. ANH is much better balanced IMHO.

Smoki
Originally posted by General G
FOE!

1. ESB
2. ROTS
3. ROTJ (excluding ewoks)
i like

JediSamuraiMRB
Easy...1. ESB
2. TPM
3. ROTS/ROTJ

queeq
I can live with that.

Rogue Jedi
I cant.....TPM as number 2?

queeq
Nah...

Rogue Jedi
dude....thats frightening.

queeq
Why? TPM is boring.

General G
Yeah, it was actually. Too much politics.

queeq
Yup... bleeehh...

What was that blockade and treaty about??? Taxation of Trade routes???WTF???

General G
laughing out loud

I have no idea, I don't think anybody know unless they read up on some other website, they had no background whatsoever on that...

queeq
There is no background to it, is there? Could be mistaken, but it must be very boring.

General G
I personally have't looked up on it.

queeq
And why would ya? laughing out loud

General G
No kidding, I have no idea, but there are some folk who do.

queeq
I know...

General G
hehe

You might be able to be considered one of them...you read a 200+ page first draft...mind you...I will be too...

OB1-adobe
I rate all six:

Empire strikes back
A new Hope
Revenge of the sith
Return of the jedi
The Phantom menace
Attack of the clones

Empire just flows its a great movie
A new Hope is fun
SITH was the best Star wars movie people seen in years
Return of the jedi is cool, could have been better, maybe not
Phantom menace is good start, kinda weird a little, not bad
Clones is good in the begining, drags for about a hour, then is really entertaining in the last 45 minutes

General G
Not bad, but I wouldn't put ANH that far up personally.

queeq
Originally posted by General G
hehe

You might be able to be considered one of them...you read a 200+ page first draft...mind you...I will be too...

But that is considered to be historical research: how did a movie like SW get to be...

General G
Historical research on Ep 1 then.

queeq
No, ANH.

General G
I realized what you meant...I was referring that people could use that same execuse to justify why they looked up things on Ep. 1.

queeq
But it doesn't work for EP1 anymore. Too much has changed.

General G
As in?

queeq
All of it. Completely different characters.

General G
No, because they would be looking up history on Ep. 1...

queeq
These drafts are historical in the sens of how SW came to be as a movie, not historical as in the background of the SW history IN the movies.

General G
But it can be twisted to say as such.

queeq
Twisted... everything can be twisted. What's your point?

General G
I have said my point. People can use that same statement to justify them finding out more on Ep. 1.

Antaeus
Ranked List of all 6 (they are all GREAT, some are just a little greater):
1. Ep. 5
2. Ep. 6
3. Ep. 4
4. Ep. 2
5. Ep. 3
6. Ep. 1

Darth Martin
Originally posted by Antaeus
Ranked List of all 6 (they are all GREAT, some are just a little greater):
1. Ep. 5
2. Ep. 6
3. Ep. 4
4. Ep. 2
5. Ep. 3
6. Ep. 1 I agree but I would rank mine like this.

1. Ep. 5
2. Ep. 4
3. Ep. 3
4. Ep. 6
5. Ep. 2
6. Ep. 1

Antaeus
Ep.5: Fight on Hoth, Luke vs. Vader, Im your father, Luke and Yoda, Luke getting some power, Sky city - fine balance.

Ep.6: Would probably have been the best if it there has been no Evoks. Very fine start at Jabbas palace, Luke showing more power, Luke and Yoda, Sister Leia, And of course the greatest of all scenes: Luke vs Vader vs Sidious.

Ep.4: Fine balance, again a good start, Ben as the teacher, Darth Vader is great, Solo vs Leia, Space station.

Ep.2: Fine start again, Anakin shows a lot of power, good action, the fight in the arena and a lot of Jedi's in battle, Dooku vs Anakin and Kenobi, Dooku vs. Yoda.

Ep.3: Anakin is one of the best now (a lot better than Kenobi) love when he shows his power, Good fights: Anakin and Kenobi vs. Dooku, Yoda vs. Sidious, Sidious vs. Windu vs. Anakin is not great - but okay - Was Windu better than Sidious or...., Padme was not so good, the fight between Anakin and Kenobi sucked (no way that Kenobi could win the fight - Anakin was to strong), The way Anakin was turned into Vader could have been much better. The Jedi's were to easy killed.

Ep.1 It is a great movie, but the other episodes are just greater. Qui-Gon is great, the finding of Anakin, talk of mediclorian, Darth Maul. Fight: Maul vs Qui-Gon vs Kenobi. Hate Jar Jar Binks.

Darth Martin
In order......


1. TESB(BEST Star Wars film PERIOD!!!, Vader, Yoda, and Solo, and Calrissian)
2. ANH(Classic masterpiece, Tarkin, Vader, and Alec Guiness as Kenobi, Han Solo)
3. ROTS(Most action, Mace Windu and Yoda)
4. ROTJ(Vader's redemption and the Emperor also green lightsaber)
5. AOTC(Darth Tyranus and big Jedi battle, arguably most visually stunning)
6. TPM(Darth Maul and Qui Gon Jinn)

Don't get me wrong all of them are masterpieces in cinema, but the ones with Darth Vader are just cool. If there's one that should be redone it's ROTJ.

queeq
The top three varies a bit... but it's rather clear what the general three best SW movies are, and what the worst.

All we need to agree on now is that ESB is the best and AOTC the worst. wink

Darth Martin
Originally posted by queeq
The top three varies a bit... but it's rather clear what the general three best SW movies are, and what the worst.

All we need to agree on now is that ESB is the best and AOTC the worst. wink AOTC isn't that bad really, just isn't better than some of the others. Apart from the potrayal of Anakin by Hayden Christensen in this film, I like it.

queeq
It's an obsolete film. It takes well over two hours to tell us hardly anything worth knowing.

General G
I would say it is either Ep. 1 or 2...still not 100% on it.

Darth Martin
Originally posted by General G
I would say it is either Ep. 1 or 2...still not 100% on it. On what? confused

queeq
Originally posted by General G
I would say it is either Ep. 1 or 2...still not 100% on it.

I disliked TPM more than AOTC until ROTS came out. Then I noticed how obsolete and pointless AOTC really is. TPM seemd to hold a lot more plot points relevant to the story and its progression than AOTC did. Ever since ROTS came out I keep wondering: why the heck was AOTC made??? WHYYYYY???!!

General G
Yeah, I see what you mean.

But even still, no matter how bad it may be, it is still needed.

Sith Master X
Well, I'll throw my 2 cents in. Then you can all flame me and tell me what a moron I am, and I won't really care, but whatever...

1. Revenge of the Sith (The darkest of them all, great action)

2. Attack of the Clones (Probably one of the worst SW films, yet somehow it's fun to watch. Plus who couldn't love Dooku?)

3. A New Hope (Entertaining from Start To Finish

4. Phantom Menace: Great fun, a little draggy at times, but I was in
the 4th grade. I loved it as a kid, and that kid inside of me always has a place in my heart.

5. Empire Strikes Back: The most mature, best written and developed movie of the 6. And you know what, that's what bothers me about it, because to me it wasn't that fun to watch. The second half is great, but I've never cared much for the hour wasted on Hoth.

6. Return of the Jedi: Damn ewoks.

Now, before you all kill me for putting ESB as 5th, just remember a few things- there are some people that are normal, and like ESB the best. There are other people, like me, who aren't normal, and put AOTC 3 places higher then the best developed film. I don't care. I grade SW differently than most people, on fun-factor, (to me) and I just find the prequels for the most part fun to watch. Are they necessarily better? NOPE. But to me, more fun.

queeq
Fair enough. Still strange that you grade AOTC so high and ROTJ so low though. Ewoks are ubercorny, guess that should add to your sense of fun...

Originally posted by General G
Yeah, I see what you mean.

But even still, no matter how bad it may be, it is still needed.

No, only a few plot points are needed. In fact, only one: Anakin falls in love with Padme and maybe the death of his mother.

General G
What I meant was that you can't just watch Ep. 1 and then Ep. 3., it is still needed for the start of the Clone Wars, showing the relationship between OB1 and him.

queeq
Oh yeah, that they hated each other's guts.

Point is, AOTC takes almost 2,5 hours to tell two vital plot points. THat is way too little to justify a movie of that length. They should have made ROTS into two movies, incorporating Anakin falling in love with PAdme and losing his mother.

And showing at least something more than a thank-you-master line to show that Anakin and OB1 were 'good friends'. THat would have upped the drama of the final battle a bit more.

General G
How did you get that they hated each other at all?

And I agree, I have said so before, it is too long to tell us so little, but no matter what you do, you cannot go from Ep. 1 to Ep. 3 with no information from Ep. 2.

ROTS into two movies would have been better, show more between OB1 and Anakin, but I still felt that the final battle was done well, but could have been done better.

queeq
Originally posted by General G
How did you get that they hated each other at all?

And I agree, I have said so before, it is too long to tell us so little, but no matter what you do, you cannot go from Ep. 1 to Ep. 3 with no information from Ep. 2.

ROTS into two movies would have been better, show more between OB1 and Anakin, but I still felt that the final battle was done well, but could have been done better.

I agree with not stepping from Ep1 to Ep3 without Ep2... but EP 2 is such a weirdly loooooong step.

You never noticed how totally unpleasant OB1 and Anakin are to each other? All the y do is ***** and moan at each other. Where did the ANH line come from: "And he was a good friend."? I never saw that in the movies. Anakin was no good friend at all, all he did was ***** and moan and do his duty at times.

General G
Good, that was all my point was.

Well, even after he was told not to, he went to save OB1 at Geonosis, almost fought Dooku together...from the beginning of ROTS, we can tell in the space fight scene that they work well together, understanding each other and whatnots, was going to carry him off the ship after beating Dooku, i can see a nice friendship there.

queeq
Really? Strange concept of friendship.
Anakin completely disboeys OB1 in everything, hates him for holding him down and OB1 accuses Anakin of arrogance to the Council. Some friendship.

General G
He disobeys him because he is still arrogant and does what he thinks is good, even if it goes against what his master says, he still respects OB1 and is why he considers it first and not just totally disregards it.
OB1 accuses him of arrogance? I am pretty sure everyone could see his arrogance anyways.

queeq
Well, there ya go. OB1 doesn't like it, Anakin doesn't like OB1. And just respect doesn't mean 'good friendship'.

General G
With a Master/Apprentice relationship, you would have to be good friends, you do everything together.

queeq
I never saw it.

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>