Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Has anyone seen this movie by riddle scott ? Is It any good ?? its on tv tonight and wanted to know if its any good thanks

it is a pretty good movie

the best way i ever heard it decribed was

"porn for gun nuts"

worth a viewing although i have the feeling that some of the more extreme gore is going to be cut

man getting blown in half...guy getting an unexploded rpg stuck though him from the side

eric bana's character is the stand out in it...

Thanks alot sounds intresting

It's a ok film, I don't think I could watch in multiple times however. It gets tedious towards the end, the night scenes tend to drag a bit. However somehow Scoot gets us to feel a little empathy for Josh Hartnett, which is a stunning feat in my opinion.

Just be wary of Ewan McGregor's acting in this, possibly the worst I've seen from him.

Ewan McGregor's a great actor !!

Yeah he is, but his acting in this doesn't justify it. Just watch and find out
for yourself.

ok cool thanks

its a good movie if you think of it as a zombie flick!

I thought it was a war movie ? any own the 3 disk set ? (abit off topic)

Pretty good movie. I'm not big on war movies but this is one of the few I enjoyed.

Scott did an excellent job with this movie. With everything going on, it was still easy to understand and watchable.
Read the book about the event, and I though the writers and Scott did an good job making an very complex book into and easy to understand movie.
It also was shot very well and the sound is fantasitc.

I really like this movie.. it could be down graded a lil on tv though. Be better to sit down with the DVD not just for what would be edited for tv, but also to not be taken out of the atmosphere every commercial break.

should i buy the dvd then ?

I'd say it's rental worthy. I can't imagine watching it enough times for it to be worth the purchase.

Then again... the 3-disc set probably isn't available for rental in many places.

ya the 3 disk looks cool and can be brought for if am lucky 7 pounds

Hated this movie, bored me to tears.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=2408&highlight=Black+Hawk+Down+forumid%3A2

search function-its like magic

this is an excellant movie one of my favorites even the game is good

Originally posted by masterkit
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=2408&highlight=Black+Hawk+Down+forumid%3A2

search function-its like magic

Pretty good action flick.