choosewisely vs. 7-11 (Round 1)

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



ThePittman
choosewisely vs. 7-11

Judge: The Pittman

Theme: Marvel Comics

Criteria: Max size 540x150 or 150x540 and no larger than 150KB and must include your name somewhere in the design.

Deadline: Sep 30th, at 5:00 PM MDT

Good luck and happy sig'ing.

pitt_signspin

Alliance
Good Luck Duelists!

7-11
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/658/carnagedr9.jpg

Took me about an hour, I like how it turned out ^^

Alliance
Expedient.

TOH
Originally posted by 7-11
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/658/carnagedr9.jpg

Took me about an hour, I like how it turned out ^^
Why did you take so long? no expression

Thorinn
fan

Alliance
ermjuggler

TOH
Originally posted by Thorinn
fan

What the f**k? hmm homer ... "insert random smilie here"

7-11
Originally posted by TOH
Why did you take so long? no expression

Because I'm lazy and take my time stick out tongue

Barker
Originally posted by TOH
Why did you take so long? no expression
No kidding. no expression

DragonWoman
Originally posted by TOH
Why did you take so long? no expression

I took longer for mine and his looks more difficult stick out tongue

DigiMark007
Anyone tell wisechoosely about this?

ThePittman
Originally posted by DigiMark007
Anyone tell wisechoosely about this? I PM'ed them

choosewisely
oooh 2 days left
what is Marvel Comics??

oh that spiderman os?

Council#13
Nice sig, Choosewisely. I mean the one you're currently using. It's funny smile

ThePittman
Originally posted by choosewisely
oooh 2 days left
what is Marvel Comics??

oh that spiderman os? Any thing from Marvel Comics from movies, to books or artists or what ever, anything at all about Marvel Comics.

http://www.marvel.com/

choosewisely
k can I 're-draw' one? stick out tongue

ThePittman
Originally posted by choosewisely
k can I 're-draw' one? stick out tongue What ever you want.

choosewisely
Ok own style, i don't like marvel comics.
and it's not to big that's because it's uploaded.
telle me if the max size has to be 115 when uploaded

Syren
I quite like that hmm

ThePittman
Now that they are both in, I'll judge it tonight.

ShinobiRikari
laughing Nice.

choosewisely
ok good

Originally posted by Council#13
Nice sig, Choosewisely. I mean the one you're currently using. It's funny smile
thnx smile

ThePittman
7-11
http://img158.imageshack.us/img158/658/carnagedr9.jpg
+ Good use of the render, though I would have like to see a larger design to use more of the render.
+ The text and logo are well done and time and though went into the design.
- The text blends into the background and makes it hard to read.
- The background is overpowering/busy and doesn't fit well into the theme of the image.
- The image over all is dark and no real focal point of the design.

choosewisely
http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i244/caslandr/misc/naamloos-1.png
+ I like the childish feeling to the design, its bright and refreshing.
+ I like the drawing of Spider-Man and brought more of the personality to design.
- The overuse of the outer glow is a bit overdone and looks like no real thought went into it.
- The background looks a bit pixilated and over stretched.


This is a tuff one because of the different styles and I like them both for different reasons but I do have to choose a winner to go into the next round so I pick 7-11. Great duel to the both of you and good luck in the next round.

choosewisely
i totally agree with the - points
my fould i didn't want to spent more tima at it.
it's hard tho to make something you like to see and i like to make because i totally hate everything about spiderman and stuff.
(i like the windwaker and that's the drawing style, to bad i ruined it with the outer glow)

maybe a tip for other judges to more specify the theme for the signature.

gl with round 2 7-11

ThePittman

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.