The Critic Game

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Impediment
The premise of this game is to try your hand at critiqing a movie in one phrase or less.

You know how you see a movie trailer or commercial, and those one phrase or less critiques by critics like Roger Ebert are shown saying stuff like: "A powerhouse of modern cinema", or "The best action movie of the year", or "Eventful and imaginative" and so on and so on?

What I'll do is name a movie. Then the next person will type their own one phrase or less review/critique, beit positive or negative, about the movie I just named. Then that person will name another movie for the next person to critique and then name their own movie and so on. Be honest, now. We're looking for both positive and negative responses.


Let's begin.
----------------


Fight Club

(Now the next person will type a one phrase or less review/critique about Fight Club, then list their choice of movie for the next person, and so on.)

Strangelove
Entertaining and thought-provoking

Dr Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb

Impediment
"A brilliant satire for the ages!"




The Abyss

Lighthammer
A non stop action thrill ride!

Aliens

Impediment
A terrifying sci-fi epic destined to scare for generations


Clerks

Röland
"A laugh out loud cult classic."

Saw

Impediment
"An ultimately unsatisfying, mediocre horror film that braved new ground."


Pulp Fiction

Strangelove
"An innovative story structure that broke the mold and became an instant cult classic."

Hellboy

Impediment
"Another comic adaptation destined for cult status!"



Predator

Strangelove
"One of those movies I haven't seen yet"

Sin City

Impediment
"Like watching a living comic book, the best adaptation yet!"


The Princess Bride

Lighthammer
"I heard this is supposed to be a great movi zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz"

Wayne's World

Impediment
A funny movie that, ultimately, spawned a new era of catchphrase fads."


Superman (1978)

Strangelove
"A classic adaptation with an all-star cast!"

X2: X-Men United

Impediment
"An action packed, yet thought provoking movie."


Rain Man

Strangelove
"Dustin Hoffman in a stunning, heartwarming role!"

True Romance

Impediment
"A violent love story that shines."


Dazed and Confused

Strangelove
"Destined to become a hit among high school students!"

A Night at the Roxbury

Impediment
"I want my 90 minutes back."



The Incredibles

Lighthammer
" Like Superman(tied to kryptonite!)"

The Dirty Dozen

Impediment
"A movie that sets the standards for all movies like it."



Animal House

Strangelove
"A slapstick comedy about fraternity life that never fails to deliver laughs!"


The Man with the Golden Gun

Impediment
"Roger Moore gives great Bond performance!"



Child's Play

Strangelove
"Pathetic excuse for a Leprechaun ripoff

The Ninth Gate

Impediment
A gothic and evil thriller that stimulates the mind."




Labyrinth

Strangelove
"David Bowie entertains in this mind-bending cult classic!"

Boondock Saints

Impediment
"A violent, yet spiritual film about vengeance."



Road to Perdition

siriuswriter
"Tom Hanks in a fresh role makes a seemingly standard gangster movie intriguing again."

When Harry Met Sally

Impediment
"A feel good movie for good friends to watch."



The Abyss

Lighthammer
Excellent movie for which Michael Biehn got robbed of an Oscar nomination.

Michael Collins

Strangelove
A great telling of the liberation of Ireland. Liam Neeson is stunning.

Shaun of the Dead

Lighthammer
Proof British humor is ten times funnier than American humor.

The Descent

Impediment
Proof that horror still has a chance.



Beerfest

Strangelove
A slapstick comedy that puts the emphasis on fun over substance, and that's just fine.

Diamonds are Forever

Impediment
"Bond at his best!"



Robots

Strangelove
A fine try at a film, but it ain't no Incredibles

300

Impediment
"Perfection."


The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.

Lighthammer
Overrated movie with average performances

Super Troopers

Impediment
"So utterly stupid that it's brilliantly hilarious."



Goodfellas

Impediment
.......................Goodfellas................ninja

Strangelove
................I've never see it ninja

Impediment
"The greatest mob movie ever made."



Constantine.

shksprtx
Originally posted by Impediment
"The greatest mob movie ever made."



Constantine.

"A typical Keanu Reeves whoa-fest."

Highlander

Impediment
"A fantastic sword swinging saga."


Alien 3

Impediment
Anyone? Alien 3?

Lighthammer
Special edition better than theatre version
Lethal Weapn

Impediment
"A good film that lead to crappy sequels."



Cars

SnakeEyes
"An rehash of every Pixar movie I've already seen; I want my money back!"

Minority Report

Impediment
"Not Spielberg's best work, but good, nonetheless."


Jaws 4: The Revenge

SnakeEyes
"Another sequel that wasn't worth my time."

Memento

Clementine
shot chronologically, a half decent murder thriller, but the way it slowly ties all the loose ends together bit by bit leaves you feeling satisfied at the end, almost like you had just solved the mystery yourself.


Catch Me if You Can

Impediment
"A surprisingly fun film from Spielberg."


A Nightmare on Elm Street

backdoorman
Somewhat entertaining but not great.

Crash (1996)

Why do people use quotation marks for commenting on the movies indicated by the poster above?

Impediment
Originally posted by backdoorman
Somewhat entertaining but not great.

Crash (1996)


"A very good film that humbles you."

Originally posted by backdoorman
Why do people use quotation marks for commenting on the movies indicated by the poster above?

Because you're supposed to be a critic. Critics use punctuation. yes





Mallrats

Impediment
Bump.

deathbucket
Never saw "Bump". However, plenty of critics give reviews from skimming film posters, so:

Yet another tedious, oscar-baiting indie French New Wave paeon with a standout performance from Laura Linney.

Impediment
You're supposed to name a film afterwords so the game can continue.

Fine, I'll go.

Lethal Weapon

Impediment
"A fun film that, eventually, became a dreck series."



Dazed and Confused.

Impediment
*bump* (I wanna keep this game going.)

"The best high school comedy ever!"


Harold and Kumar go to White Castle

JediSamuraiMRB
"A very funny film. Kal Penn at his best."

Master and Commander

Impediment
"A sea faring epic that excites."


The Nightmare before Christmas

celestialdemon
"A Jaw-dropping breakthrough in animation."

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

Impediment
"Eternal Boredom of my mind"


Crash

JediSamuraiMRB
"A compelling, riveting story"

Jumper

The Mean Queen
A thrilling movie that had great story lines
Superman returns

=Tired Hiker=
"Totally gay."

Eight Legged Freaks

High Priest
ill pass this game looks hard .

celestialdemon
"Yet another movie David Arquette butchers with his 'acting'."

The Frighteners

JediSamuraiMRB
"A frightening tale"

Batman('89)

Impediment
"A good movie, but not the true vision of the Dark Knight."

Spongebob Squarepants: The Movie

JediSamuraiMRB
"A good kids movie"

Invasion of the Body Snatchers('56)

Impediment
"A black & white classic for all horror fans."


Snatch

JediSamuraiMRB
"One of Guy Ritchie's best"

A Tout de Suite

Impediment
"One of those movies I have yet to see."


Ratatouille

celestialdemon
"One of Pixar's best and surprisingly most human stories."

Casino Royale

JediSamuraiMRB
"One of the better James Bond movies"

La Vie En Rose

Impediment
"A movie I have been told by 5 people to go and see."



Tombstone

High Priest
Big guns ready to go off ,west coast killers riding horses i ear this film is a classic westrern

texas chain saw massacre (orginal)

celestialdemon
"Today's slasher films could learn a think or two from watching this classic."

1408

Impediment
"A very good adaptation of King's work."


Last of the Mohicans

celestialdemon
"Better than expected with solid performances from Daniel Day-Lewis and Wes Studi."

The Brotherhood of the Wolf

JediSamuraiMRB
"A good historical horror movie"


Trainspotting

Impediment
"A truthful, gripping drug story that makes us all laugh and think."


Animal House

JediSamuraiMRB
"A very funny comedy. Jim Belushi at his best."


Ratatouille

Impediment
"One of Pixars most colorful and vibrant films!"


Ransom

celestialdemon
"A solid, suspenseful movie with just a little overacting from Mel Gibson."

Dark City

Impediment
"Ultimately unsatisfying."



Platoon

JediSamuraiMRB
"One of the best war movies ever. Excellent acting"

Saving Private Ryan

celestialdemon
"The most realistic war movie ever made."

The Aviator

JediSamuraiMRB
"A fair portrayal of Howard Hughes"


Superman(Original)

Impediment
"One of the very best comic book movie ever made."



X-Men 2

JediSamuraiMRB
"The better of the three X-Men movies"


Them('54)

Impediment
"CLassic. Total classic."


Disney's Sleeping Beauty

BruceSkywalker
"A timeless, classic tale"


Godzilla('54)

High Priest
"A slapstick comedy about fraternity life that never fails to deliver laughs!"


The Man with the Golden Gun

celestialdemon
"Not one of the better Bond movies."

Minority Report

Impediment
"Not the best work by Spielberg or Cruise."

The Ring

celestialdemon
"Solid adaptation of the original and almost as scary."

Heaven Can Wait

BruceSkywalker
'A very sad movie. One of Beatty's best"


Reds

celestialdemon
"Beatty's best with stellar performances all around."

Good Night, and Good Luck

BruceSkywalker
"A decent portrayal of Edward R. Murrow"


The Joy Luck Club

Impediment
"A real chick flick"


Revenge of the Nerds

BruceSkywalker
"A very funny comedy that shouldn't be remade"


Porky's

High Priest
A good teenager film with some sexy women .

Stripes

celestialdemon
"A decent Bill Murray comedy."

Heathers

BruceSkywalker
"Fave black comedy movie"


Silkwood

Impediment
"Decent, but nothing I'd own."


Mystery Men

celestialdemon
"A better than I expected comedy."

Phonebooth

Impediment
"Ultimately unsatisfying."

Grindhouse presents: Death Proof

BruceSkywalker
"One of Tarantino's worst"


The Bridge on the River Kwai

Impediment
"An awesome performance by Alec Guiness."



The Great Outdoors.

celestialdemon
"A decent comedy but not close to either Candy or Aykroyd's best."

Starman

BruceSkywalker
"A fair Jeff Bridges movies."


Flags of Our Fathers

Impediment
"Overrated and uninspiring"


Dracula: Dead and Loving It

BruceSkywalker
"A very funny version of Dracula"


Babel

Impediment
"It was somewhat entertaing, but not that great."


The Simpsons Movie

BruceSkywalker
"As funny as the Simpsons have ever been"


The Onion Field

Impediment
"Meh."


Revenge of the Nerds II: Nerds in Paradise

celestialdemon
"Not as good as the original with a not as hot girl this time around."

Fallen

BruceSkywalker
"Denzel's horrible attempt at the supernatural"


Glory

Impediment
"A heart wrenching tale of the Civil War that is nothing short of perfect."


The Untouchables

BruceSkywalker
"One of Sean Connery's best roles"


Ali

celestialdemon
"A great and surprising performance by Will Smith."

The Doors

BruceSkywalker
"A fairly accurate portrayal of Jim Morrison and a good performance by Val Kilmer"


Sid and Nancy

celestialdemon
Finally saw it.

"One of Gary Oldman's best performances."

Rear Window

BruceSkywalker
"One of Hitchcock's best and my second fave Hitchcock film"

Giant

Impediment
"Meh."



Hot Fuzz

celestialdemon
"A hilarious and worthy follow-up to the classic Shaun of the Dead."

Hamburger Hill

Impediment
"Glorious and inspiring."


"Futurama: Bender's Big Score"

BruceSkywalker
"A movie my nephew loved"


10,000 B.C.

Impediment
"Just another popcorn flick."


Capote

celestialdemon
"A slow movie made interesting by powerful performances from Hoffman and Collins Jr."

Traffic

Impediment
"Overly preachy."


Boogie Nights

BruceSkywalker
"An unfair look at the porn industry"


Enter the Dragon

Impediment
"A must see classic martial arts film. Fantastic."



Kung Pow: Enter the Fist

celestialdemon
"Has funny parts but ultimately disappointing."

O

BruceSkywalker
"Bad acting by Julia Stiles and Mekhi Phifer"


Rumble in the Bronx

Impediment
"One of Jackie Chan's funnest movies."


The Last Unicorn

BruceSkywalker
"Unforgettable classic"


The Last Starfighter

Impediment
A fun, if not cheesy, sci-fi adventure!"



Halloween (2007)

BruceSkywalker
"A horrible remake of a cult classic"


Halloween(original)

Impediment
"A timeless horror classic that will scare for ages!"



The Devil's Rejects

celestialdemon
"Far superior than House of 1,000 Corpses."

Serenity

BruceSkywalker
"An OK sci fi movie"

Yojimbo

Impediment
"It was a good watch."



Sweeney Todd (2007)

BruceSkywalker
"Third or fourth fave Depp movie"


Stigmata

celestialdemon
"Another attempt at horror that falls flat."


Fahrenheit 451

Impediment
"A true classic adapted from an important novel."


Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children

celestialdemon
"A breakthrough in computer animation."

Scanners

BruceSkywalker
"One of Cronenberg's best"


Videodrome

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>