Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Setting: Palpatine's throne room onboard Death Star II

Starting distance: 50 feet

Who wins?

Azronger: Plagueis 'cause midi-chlorians.

Sidious beats yoda in a hard fight, plagueis shits on vader. or sidious beats vader before yoda beats plagueis and then yoda gets raped

Knightfall Vader is supposed to be = RotS Sidious, right? If so, he can take Plagueis.

Originally posted by Stigma
Knightfall Vader is supposed to be = RotS Sidious, right? If so, he can take Plagueis.
no he isnt that's a retarded agenda just as stupid as many other agendas pushed on this forum. unfortunately this really has plagued (lol) sw debating because people are all about just wanking characters instead of wanting to know who wins a fight by discussing different aspects lol.

Originally posted by semenwithjuice
no he isnt that's a retarded agenda just as stupid as many other agendas pushed on this forum. unfortunately this really has plagued (lol) sw debating because people are all about just wanking characters instead of wanting to know who wins a fight by discussing different aspects lol.
Except it's actually supported by several quotes that he is. Including one from GL himself I believe.

mmm

Sheev solos

Sidious solos.

This comes down to whether Sidious can avoid saber combat as that's his weak spot here. Plagueis should last a while against Yoda.

OR

Can Anakin defeat Plagueis before Yoda dies to a more powerful version of Sidious.

Again, Anakin's strength is saber skill while he brings nothing to the table force-skill wise.

Knightfall Vader destroys Plagueis as Yoda and Sheev 50/50.

Palpatine solos

Originally posted by Kurk
This comes down to whether Sidious can avoid saber combat as that's his weak spot here. Plagueis should last a while against Yoda.

OR

Can Anakin defeat Plagueis before Yoda dies to a more powerful version of Sidious.

Again, Anakin's strength is saber skill while he brings nothing to the table force-skill wise.

how do you figure sabers is Sidious' weak spot? the guy manhandled Maul/Savage easily and killed 3 council members before they knew what happened. The only time hes legit been out matched was against Yoda and that was only because the environment favoured the little speed toad more; put them in an area where Sidious can move around and i guarantee the outcome of that fight is vastly different

Originally posted by relentless1
how do you figure sabers is Sidious' weak spot? the guy manhandled Maul/Savage easily and killed 3 council members before they knew what happened. The only time hes legit been out matched was against Yoda and that was only because the environment favoured the little speed toad more; put them in an area where Sidious can move around and i guarantee the outcome of that fight is vastly different Because this is RotJ Sheev. I'm assuming he hasn't touched a saber in nearly two decades. His augmentation alone won't save him here against those as skilled as Anakin and Yoda.

plagueis is a massive power boost below tpm sids so he's gonna get rekt vs anakin or yoda. The question is how much more powerful is ROTJ sids than ROTS sids, imma wanna see arguments made for that.

Not powerful enough to make up for it.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
plagueis is a massive power boost below tpm sids so he's gonna get rekt vs anakin or yoda. The question is how much more powerful is ROTJ sids than ROTS sids, imma wanna see arguments made for that. Is that why he had to get him wasted and then fry him in his sleep rather than do it in a fair fight?

Originally posted by Kurk
Because this is RotJ Sheev. I'm assuming he hasn't touched a saber in nearly two decades. His augmentation alone won't save him here against those as skilled as Anakin and Yoda.

Emperor Sidious is just as deadly with a lightsaber; see Lords of the Sith novel which is canon

Originally posted by Kurk
Is that why he had to get him wasted and then fry him in his sleep rather than do it in a fair fight?
That was before the power boost in question.

Originally posted by relentless1
Emperor Sidious is just as deadly with a lightsaber; see Lords of the Sith novel which is canon That's still nearly two decades before RotJ

Vader can't do anything here. He is out-matched.