Vinny Valentine vs Galan007

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Starhawk
Vote and the results will be posted in 5 days.

http://img463.imageshack.us/img463/9554/gib0.png

vs

http://img463.imageshack.us/img463/9631/vinhx9.png

I know both are exceptional works. Which do you prefer?

BakaXero
mate!
that is not how things work here.

Starhawk
What do you mean?

BakaXero
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f51/t388220.html

Starhawk
Oh okay, my bad, I just thought these fine artists deseved recognition, Mods please close.

juggernaut66666
doh

Starhawk
Unless people wanna vote? I mean I shoudlve checked the rules, but since it's already here.

Alliance
My vote goes to Vinny.

Galens' has a much better technical approach, but the render gets lost and some childish things like the blue break in the border and the random boxes ruin its chances.

Vinny's is simpler (not worse, but just lower skill displayed...you can show skill and be simple) but the layout is fantastic. The border is weak, but the basic design is what real sig artists should immediately consider.

Ok we can close the thread now cool

Please follow the rules next time.

Starhawk
Why close it? AS long as no one has a problem with it.

cain marko
Oh the irony niether of the made their sigs. oh and although a bad thread you should have put a poll on it.

LifeInSepia
vinny! you still hang out here?! i thought all of the old crowd would have buggered off by now! i used to be pacmaniac, but u still probs dont remember me sad

TOH
Originally posted by cain marko
Oh the irony niether of the made their sigs. ...

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.