Thorinn VS. Quickshot

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Artemis1860
Thorinn vs. Quickshot

Judge: Artemis1860

Render: Link

Criteria: No larger than 540x200 and 50kb

Deadline: January 3rd 6:19pm (GMT-6 timezone) aka. 96 hours from thread start (roughly, normally I give 72, but extra time due to new years)

You may begin. big grin

Thorinn
Links a girl? ermm

Artemis1860
Originally posted by Thorinn
Links a girl? ermm

rofl, what's sad, is it actually took me a minute to understand what you meant.

And no, Link isn't, but this is a link, as in url.

I thought it was better than "pink elf"

Thorinn
laughing out loud


I'll get started in a day.

Artemis1860
lol. alright, sweet. big grin

quickshot
Any specific name or anything?

Artemis1860
Nope. Just be as creative as possible.

quickshot
my entry

http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/7223/dueljb5.jpg

masterkit
Originally posted by quickshot
my entry

http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/7223/dueljb5.jpg

laughing out loud

Suckup. stick out tongue wink











*steals render*

Artemis1860
Originally posted by masterkit
laughing out loud

Suckup. stick out tongue wink











*steals render*

laughing

quickshot
i only chose Artemis's name as it hardly suited me

cain marko
Originally posted by quickshot
my entry

http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/7223/dueljb5.jpg

nice thumbsup however brightness loses detail

Thorinn
http://img169.imageshack.us/img169/5476/quikduelkh1.jpg

Entree. smokin'

Artemis1860
Quickshot's Entry:
http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/7223/dueljb5.jpg
+ Color works well with the render
+ Nice border
+ Text has good placement and is readable
- Brightness washed out the render a bit, though it added a softness that seems to go well with the sig.


Thorinn's Entry:
http://img169.imageshack.us/img169/5476/quikduelkh1.jpg
+ Nice background for the most part (though if you stare at it long enough it looks a bit like someones bare butt, just blurred. confused )
+ Colors showed the render in more detail.
- Render Placement. Needed to be a little lower, as her one eyebrow is cut off and it makes it look odd.
- Top and bottom only border kinda makes it look like a movie, but needed to be at least a little thinner. The eyes are drawn to the border before anything else.
- Text, though it fits into the sig well, it fits too well, half of it is kinda hard to make out.


Damn you guys made this hard. Honestly, I think both sigs are amazing, I couldn't give an actual judgement until just now when I typed out all the good and bad of the sigs.

I must declare the victor... quickshot!

BakaXero
there is nothing wrong with the top/bottom border lookmhm

masterkit
I love this render

I must make more sigs.

Artemis1860
Originally posted by masterkit
I love this render

I must make more sigs.

same, I may have to make a sig with it myself. rofl. I like yours btw.

TOH
Originally posted by BakaXero
there is nothing wrong with the top/bottom border lookmhm
my thoughts exactly... ermm

masterkit
Originally posted by Artemis1860
same, I may have to make a sig with it myself. rofl. I like yours btw.

thanx

Right now i'm turning her into a dark elf. big grin

Artemis1860
Originally posted by masterkit
thanx

Right now i'm turning her into a dark elf. big grin

sweet. I'm actually making a sig with her myself, which is odd, as I don't often make girly sigs.



And to Baka and TOH. I never said there was anything wrong with it normally. But in this case with this render and that sig, it does not work in my opinion and experience.

masterkit
Originally posted by Artemis1860
sweet. I'm actually making a sig with her myself, which is odd, as I don't often make girly sigs.



And to Baka and TOH. I never said there was anything wrong with it normally. But in this case with this render and that sig, it does not work in my opinion and experience.

i can't use it

the quality is bad mad

Artemis1860
Originally posted by masterkit
i can't use it

the quality is bad mad

huh?

Souichiro Nagi
Damn you rock Quickshot! Your sig totally matched it's render.

quickshot
Thanks Souichiro Nagi.Nice entry Thorinn

IceJaw
Ano no one thanks the judge for judging?

quickshot
Thank you artemis

masterkit
Originally posted by Artemis1860
huh?

i made a kool one but the quality was badsad

I like yours though smile

juggernaut66666
Originally posted by BakaXero
there is nothing wrong with the top/bottom border lookmhm

Thorinn
Thanks guys. 31

Artemis1860
Originally posted by IceJaw
Ano no one thanks the judge for judging?

Meh, doesn't bother me none.

Originally posted by quickshot
Thank you artemis

No problem, quickshot.

boobsmagee
no offense to quick shot but bfore i got all they way down the screen i really thought thornin had it, man nice job both of you

Barker
Who's the Helen Keller that judged this? What the f**k?

Artemis1860
Originally posted by Barker
Who's the Helen Keller that judged this? What the f**k?

back off barker, disagreeing with me is fine, but don't be a jerkoff.

BakaXero
who's Helen Keller?

Lana
Okay guys.

People are perfectly free to disagree with a judgment. Frankly, I disagree with the judgment of this duel myself.

So I shall say three things.

1) Like everything else in life, you cannot expect everyone to agree with you. And this goes for all parties.

2) If you are going to disagree, be polite about it.

3) It's a goddamn sig duel and not that big a deal, and none of the dissenting comments in this thread are bashing and thus not against the rules. If you're getting bent out of shape from something in a duel, I think you need to back away from the computer and rethink your priorities.

So certain parties need to lighten up and calm down, and others need to be a bit nicer.

Barker
Originally posted by BakaXero
who's Helen Keller?
Some blind lady.
Originally posted by Artemis1860
back off barker, disagreeing with me is fine, but don't be a jerkoff.
Calm down.

boobsmagee
helen keller is a womans rights activist idont remember the whole story but eh shes blind and deaf (died like a hundred yrs ago lol)

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.