Originally posted by What If...
I can't present an argument with actual proof against an opinion with no actual proof
You bend every rule you possibly can in order to make it in favor of the beloved Phoenix. We all know what "Dark Phoenix" the thread starter is referring too, but yet in your polluted cesspool of a mind you take WC Phoenix, give her no morals, and use THAT Dark Phoenix in this debate.
You realize others might catch on to what you are doing, so you immediately try to defend it by saying that the 134-137 Dark Phoenix isn't the only DP there is....that the WC Phoenix could potentially be DP, even though that has never actually happened.
Once again i will reiterate to you what Dark Phoenix is. The Phoenix Force among many things embodys passion and destruction. It is more a force of passion and emotion than intellect, therefore if its avatars are not strong of mind, they will be overwhelmed by that passionate, destructive side of the force.
http://img1.putfile.com/thumb/12/33711273156.jpg
http://img1.putfile.com/thumb/12/33711273224.jpg
Jean Grey was overwhelmed by this side of the Force after being manipulated by Mastermind.
http://img1.putfile.com/thumb/12/33711192568.jpg
http://img1.putfile.com/thumb/12/33711192567.jpg
Dark Phoenix is not Phoenix specifically in the issues of Uncanny x-men 134 to 137, Dark Phoenix is a Phoenix consumed by its passionate destructive side with little thoughts for the consequences.
Dark Phoenix has been seen in New X-men and also in Endsong. It has been seen outside of those issues. Your logic dictates that we should only ever use Dark Phoenix from those four issues because it was the most well known story she has been featured in. I tell you that is poor logic
Dark Phoenix is a state of mind that dictates Jeans behaviour. It is not a power change, it is not an upgrade or a downgrade. Beg to differ? Come up with goods stating the point.
As such Dark Phoenix = Phoenix = White Phoenix. Difference between them is the state of mind as we've been shown on panel.
After being taken over by Dark Phoenix in Endsong, Jean reverted to the White Phoenix not through an upgrade, or some secondary mutation, but instead through a telepathic projection which let her feel how much she was loved and valued, which in turn resulted in a change of mindset.
Unless a forum starter states that a thread involves the Phoenix character from specific issues then i'm perfectly entitled to argue as i have done.
Your outburst is both unwarranted and irrelevant.
Originally posted by What If...
Spare me your craziness, sir.
Your'e only farther proving my assumtion of your mental illness correct if you actually believe you have earned yourself any respect here
Who's here for respect? Im here to chat comics and have a laugh doing so. Whether im respected or not matters little me. As i've said before and as i'll say again why would i go out of my way to earn respect from a bunch of avatars and sigs on my pc screen?
You are misguided, young man, this really isnt that important.