Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Both are great fighters, one on one with swords and any armor they had, who gets bested?

Considering that Achilles didn't survive the Trojan War and Aragorn led Gondor and Rohan to victory in the 2nd War of the Ring, my vote is to Aragorn.

Aragorn takes this, but not easily. He casually walks head-long into vast numbers of Uruks, he's also not an arrogant prick, which is what brings down Achilles.

Achilles...he's half-god...better screen feats

To be fair, saying "half-god" here is kind of a moot point, considering the man was killed by a cowardly girlish man-boy with a bow. His divine status was also very vague at best.

Better feats for Achilles, I agree in part.

Paris was only pretending to be his Legolas character for one scene lol...Truth be told, Legolas would have been more on Achilles' level than Aragorn

Achilles wins.

Achilles is superior. Much more superior.

Achilles..., if not simply because he has a swifter sword and a shield.