Hawkeye feats vs. Legolas feats

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



FrothByte
Ok, this is not a fight between them. Here's the scenario:

Hawkeye is armed with a wooden long bow and standard arrows (like what Legolas uses) and is recruited as part of the fellowship of the ring and stands in Legolas' place throughout all 3 LOTR movies.

Can Hawkeye replicate the following feats:

1. Shoot arrows accurately while skidding down a staircase on a shield skateboard?
2. Take down a monster mammoth on his own
3. Survive in the battle against the Urukhai by using bow, arrows, and fighting knives in close counters but never getting hit once?
4. How will Barton's replacement of Legolas impact the mission of the fellowship? Will they have an easier/harder time with Hawkeye as the resident archer over Legolas?

ON the other hand, Legolas is armed with Barton's equipment of hi-tech bow and trick arrows and is given instant knowledge and skill on how to use said equipments. He is then recruited in the Avengers initiative and goes through the entire Avengers movie in Barton's place.

Can he replicate the following feats?

1. Make the trickshot that blew a hole in the hellicarrier
2. Give as good a showing against BW in h2h
3. Take on the multiple chitauri in the New York battle with the same kill rate and without getting seriously injured?
4. How will Legolas' replacement of Barton impact the overall performance of the Avengers? Will it make it easier/harder for the Avengers to accomplish their mission if it was Legolas as resident archer?

BlackZero30x
Hawkeye

1. Yes. I don't see why his accuracy would diminish.

2. Yes if he has the knowledge of where to shoot it.

3. I say he could do it with his bow and last a little while with knives but he would definitely not go untouched and maybe die

4. I doubt it would change a whole lot. but he would probably stay back as a "sniper" more often as apposed to up close combat

Legolas

1. Judging from feats Im not sure he would be up to the task as I don't recall making any shots like that. correct me if im wrong though.

2. Yes. I actually think he may do a little better.

3. Im undecided. I don't know if he could replicate Hawkeye's ability to fight h2h with his bow. If he has his blades then I think he would be ok. Though Im doubtful he could make the Loki shot.

4. Overall I think it would be different because Legolas wouldn't be able to re create Hawkeye's biggest feats.

ares834
1. Not sure. He never displayed agility to match Legolas.
2. No.
3. Doubtful.
4. Probably as well of. I think the biggest advantage is he wouldn't have a massive PIS moment and would kill the Uruk-hai with the torch that sets off the bombs at Helm's Deep.

1. No.
2. No.
3. Yes.
4. Wouldn't make much of a difference. Hawkeye never did anything that important.

Mindset
Jeremy Renner is better than Legolas and he would solo the LotR verse.

Mindset
Originally posted by ares834
1. Not sure. He never displayed agility to match Legolas.
2. No.
3. Doubtful.
4. Probably as well of. I think the biggest advantage is he wouldn't have a massive PIS moment and would kill the Uruk-hai with the torch that sets off the bombs at Helm's Deep.

1. No.
2. No.
3. Yes.
4. Wouldn't make much of a difference. Hawkeye never did anything that important. If Hawkeye didn't stop Loki he would have gotten Black Widow. He was also directing the team where to go, helped IM.

Lord Lucien
Legolas>Katniss>Hawkeye.


But Hawkeye is still >>> Legolas.

FrothByte
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Legolas>Katniss>Hawkeye.


But Hawkeye is still >>> Legolas.


Is it just me or did that make no sense at all?

BlackZero30x
it makes sense if you don't think about it lol

seriously though Katniss>anyone is just not happening. At least movie version that is. Never read the books.

Casper Whitey
Jin rapes them both.

Lord Lucien
Originally posted by BlackZero30x
it makes sense if you don't think about it lol

seriously though Katniss>anyone is just not happening. At least movie version that is. Never read the books. Katniss hit the middle of a target. She's clearly better than everything.

BlackZero30x
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Katniss hit the middle of a target. She's clearly better than everything.

not sure if joking or serious.... confused

lol

Casper Whitey
Originally posted by Casper Whitey
Jin rapes them both.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.