Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Which fantasy dragon is superior ? Who wins ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Which fantasy dragon is superior ? Who wins ?

Current Drogon would lose.

Smaug is bigger for now.

Smaug vaporizes him

Originally posted by carthage
Smaug vaporizes him

Actually i was thinking more of a physical fight. I doubt dragonfire can harm themselves.

smaug is much more intelligent and much larger also; he flash fries all three let alone drogon

Smaug stomps.

Originally posted by relentless1
smaug is much more intelligent and much larger also; he flash fries all three let alone drogon

I think he can beat drogon. All three...not really.

So no one says Drogon wins. Smaug for the uncontested win.

Considering Smaug is both larger and more intelligent with fewer weaknesses than Drogon, I don't see how drogon could win. I'd say it's more even if it were Balaerion, but that;'s neither here nor there.

Originally posted by quanchi112
So no one says Drogon wins. Smaug for the uncontested win.

On a 1 to 1 battle yes.

Is this intel for our battle?

Hahahahaha

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
On a 1 to 1 battle yes.

Is this intel for our battle?

Hahahahaha I do agree Lotr has a superior dragon to GoT. This is the only movie/tv film universe comparable to Lotr. Harry Potter is a little different and they have too many wizards so it's more fun to compare these two since magic/sorcery is there it's just not as widespread.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I do agree Lotr has a superior dragon to GoT. This is the only movie/tv film universe comparable to Lotr. Harry Potter is a little different and they have too many wizards so it's more fun to compare these two since magic/sorcery is there it's just not as widespread.

Hmmmm. For now though. Cause give Drogon a couple of years and Smaug would lose.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Hmmmm. For now though. Cause give Drogon a couple of years and Smaug would lose. I highly doubt it plus we will only have season 8. No more GoT after that save the spinoff which will be in a different era. Maybe we will see Balerion someday.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I highly doubt it plus we will only have season 8. No more GoT after that save the spinoff which will be in a different era. Maybe we will see Balerion someday.

There is no doubt of that. Balerion can DEFINETLY surpass Smaug in size. Once he does Smaug is on the losing side.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
There is no doubt of that. Balerion can DEFINETLY surpass Smaug in size. Once he does Smaug is on the losing side. Smaug still has intelligence and we don't know about Balerion since we haven't seen him in action. There have been bigger dragons in Lotr lore but until we see them on the big screen we can't assume.


Smaug would scare the shit out of Westeros IMO.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Smaug still has intelligence and we don't know about Balerion since we haven't seen him in action. There have been bigger dragons in Lotr lore but until we see them on the big screen we can't assume.


Smaug would scare the shit out of Westeros IMO.

Intelligence isnt of much help in a melee fight.

Smaug would die once Drogon is bigger.

Bigger teeth, bigger mouth, bigger wings, bigger tail, thicker scales.

Smaug would die.

No. Smaug would just be another dragon.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Intelligence isnt of much help in a melee fight.

Smaug would die once Drogon is bigger.

Bigger teeth, bigger mouth, bigger wings, bigger tail, thicker scales.

Smaug would die.

No. Smaug would just be another dragon. When you can fly and use battle tactics it definitely is an advantage.

Smaug like most Lotr characters are superior to the more realistic of the two universes. More durable, smarter, more dangerous, etc.

Originally posted by quanchi112
When you can fly and use battle tactics it definitely is an advantage.

Smaug like most Lotr characters are superior to the more realistic of the two universes. More durable, smarter, more dangerous, etc.

There is little tactic you can implement at open airs.

Smaug is smart but he is also proud. Pride would also work as a downfall for him.

Once Drogon is bigger Smaug will only have his intelligenxe to win.

The odds would go on Drogons side.

Drogon would most likely win.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
There is little tactic you can implement at open airs.

Smaug is smart but he is also proud. Pride would also work as a downfall for him.

Once Drogon is bigger Smaug will only have his intelligenxe to win.

The odds would go on Drogons side.

Drogon would most likely win. Many different angles you can attack or you can retreat to swoop back in for another attack.

Drogon is less durable and hasn't impressed me. Smaug has the superior size as well. He has all the advantages.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Many different angles you can attack or you can retreat to swoop back in for another attack.

Drogon is less durable and hasn't impressed me. Smaug has the superior size as well. He has all the advantages.

I agreed to that.

We were talking about what would happen when Drogon surpasses him.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I agreed to that.

We were talking about what would happen when Drogon surpasses him. All we will have is season eight. So it doesn't look likely.

Smaug at this point in time. Keep in mind that Balerion the Dread was hundreds of years old, whereas Drogon is what? 5 years old? He could easily grow to be bigger than Balerion eventually. Whether or not we see him grow to full size in season 8 is uncertain, but still.

Season eight can't have that large of a time gap between these two seasons. That being said Smaug decimates this loser dragon asserting Lotr's dominance over GoT.

Smaug for the win.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Season eight can't have that large of a time gap between these two seasons. That being said Smaug decimates this loser dragon asserting Lotr's dominance over GoT.

You are falling out of context here!

This thread is Smaug vs Drogon, not LoTR vs GoT!
Stick to the thread please.

Drogon 10 years from now devours Smaug.

Originally posted by Darkstorm Zero
Considering Smaug is both larger and more intelligent with fewer weaknesses than Drogon, I don't see how drogon could win. I'd say it's more even if it were Balaerion, but that;'s neither here nor there.

Ancalagon would swallow Balerion whole, tho.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Ancalagon would swallow Balerion whole, tho.

Well, thats a separate debate but yeah... when you are the size of 3 Mount Everest sized volcanoes, you get to eat whatever you want.

https://i.warosu.org/data/tg/img/0363/04/1416589409930.jpg
https://i.redd.it/rocid35zwofz.jpg
http://new2.fjcdn.com/comments/ Abstractpink+rolled+image+21+_38633d59beb233dc07e5
58413878f492.jpg

Sooo yeah

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Ancalagon would swallow Balerion whole, tho.

Originally posted by Darkstorm Zero
Well, thats a separate debate but yeah... when you are the size of 3 Mount Everest sized volcanoes, you get to eat whatever you want.

https://i.warosu.org/data/tg/img/0363/04/1416589409930.jpg
https://i.redd.it/rocid35zwofz.jpg
http://new2.fjcdn.com/comments/ Abstractpink+rolled+image+21+_38633d59beb233dc07e5
58413878f492.jpg

Sooo yeah

The Mighty Ancalagon the Black!

Lets talk a bit about LoTR fire drakes shall we!?

First of all, LoTR Dragons are easily oversized by they destruction they cause when they "fall". Samething applies for Ancalagon which ISNT the size of the Everest nor bigger than Thangorodrim's mountains.

Let me explain. Tolkien likes to be very Poetic when writting. When he said that Ancalagon's fall broke Thangorodrim it must NOT be taken literally. Instead, Tolkien actually meant that by the Time Anacalagon died, the destruction left was enough to devastate the Mountains.

A similar thing happened with Smaug. In the books it is said that Smaug's fall destroyed the entire Lake town (Full on the town he fell. His last throes splintered it to sparks and gledes), but this DOESNT mean that Smaug was the size of Lake Town; he was much more smaller!

Another thing that disclaims Ancalagon's size is that he had to fit in Angband. So, its for sure he wasnt the size of a mountain or bigger than Thangorodrim's.


Now am not saying he isnt bigger than Balerion! But the size of Everest is a mass exaggeration.

Nice to have you back DarkStorm Zero.

Also remember guys that Balerion was the Largest Targaryen Dragon. Not the largest Dragon Over All.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
You are falling out of context here!

This thread is Smaug vs Drogon, not LoTR vs GoT!
Stick to the thread please.

Drogon 10 years from now devours Smaug. You already agreed Smaug is far greater than Drogon. Case closed. It's a wrap. Quit speculating. I go by facts not what ifs.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You already agreed Smaug is far greater than Drogon. Case closed. It's a wrap. Quit speculating. I go by facts not what ifs.

Lol i said 10 years from now, which is a fact!

Drogon can easily outsize Smaug in 10 years!

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Lol i said 10 years from now, which is a fact!

Drogon can easily outsize Smaug in 10 years! We won't see Drogon in ten years so who cares. Smaug is more durable and smarter than this bum.

Originally posted by quanchi112
We won't see Drogon in ten years so who cares. Smaug is more durable and smarter than this bum.

Lol, the Long Night can las generations! We might see him 20 years older!!!

Shouldnt the OP be moderating the thread and not taking active and even personal discussions of his thread?

Lol

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Lol, the Long Night can las generations! We might see him 20 years older!!!

Shouldnt the OP be moderating the thread and not taking active and even personal discussions of his thread?

Lol Nah, the thread has been decided so just shooting the shit now.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Nah, the thread has been decided so just shooting the shit now.

Smaug is bigger, stronger, more durable, and far more intelligent. He wins for sure.

On top of the size difference, and the fact that smaug has a diamond waistcoat. I was always under the impression that smaugs fire was a alot more powerful. His fire is said to be able to melt nigh indestructible rings of power. We know aegon used dragon fire to melt stone, and the theory is it was used to make valyrian steel. But for all we know dragon fire cant melt the steel but just went into its construction. All in all to many points in smaugs favor.

Edit: I know i came in late i just wanted to say my piece lol.