Rey vs. MCU Scarlet Witch

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



carthage
Endgame Wanda

Who wins

Starting distance 30 feet

BruceSkywalker
rey prolly..

she could just use force lightning on wanda

NotAllThatEvil
Haven't seen the new star wars yet, but wanda was holding back an infinity gauntlet amped thanks with one hand in infinity war and absolutely clowned normal than in in end game. She should be strong enough to take rey

BrolyBlack
Rey

NotAllThatEvil
After seeing the movie, I stand by wanda

Psychotron
Wanda should win, but she won't because Rey has the thickest plot armor.

Silent Master
I thought her name was Mary Sue?

Psychotron
It's MaRey Sue.

riv6672
Originally posted by Psychotron
It's MaRey Sue.
^^^clever. She wins.

Bane dies.

Yuuki158
Debating who's stronger is pretty much useless tbh,both are glass canons with the ability to one shot each other so we goes to the combat/react speed

And in that aspect,i find Rey more consistent and better,so she wins for me

stan5677
Mary Sue wins

FrothByte
The only MCU character who can hold up against Rey's plot armor is Captain Marvel.

Josh_Alexander
Wanda ofcourse! Rey's force powers, although powerful are untamed.

Wanda 7/10, if she goes all out from the beginning.

Psychotron
What if Rey goes all out and fires lightning at her from the start?

BrolyBlack
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Wanda ofcourse! Rey's force powers, although powerful are untamed.

Wanda 7/10, if she goes all out from the beginning.

Rey 10/10 you clown

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Psychotron
What if Rey goes all out and fires lightning at her from the start?

Highly unlikely. Rey has only portrayed Force Lightning against a ship and never against an opponent.

It's more reasonable to believe she will attempt to use her saber or use TK. Either of this can easily be countered by Wanda.

Psychotron
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Highly unlikely. Rey has only portrayed Force Lightning against a ship and never against an opponent.

It's more reasonable to believe she will attempt to use her saber or use TK. Either of this can easily be countered by Wanda.

That makes no sense...

She was using her TK when she fired the lightning.

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Psychotron
That makes no sense...

She was using her TK when she fired the lightning. '

She never used Force Lightning against Ren or Sidious or Snoke. Which actually makes sence, as she identifies herself as a Jedi not a Sith.

Ergo she using Force Lightning against Wanda is highly unlikely.

Psychotron
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
'

She never used Force Lightning against Ren or Sidious or Snoke. Which actually makes sence, as she identifies herself as a Jedi not a Sith.

Ergo she using Force Lightning against Wanda is highly unlikely.

She can identify as whatever she wants, but she's constantly pissed. Sidious didn't use Force lightning on Mace or Zabrak brothers for most of the battles but that doesn't mean he can't or won't. Saying anything is out of character for Rey is silly, because Rey doesn't have a character.

This is pure speculation. Rey is used to charging head first with her lightsaber, but that won't work on Wanda, so she'll likely try her Force powers instead.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by Psychotron
She can identify as whatever she wants, but she's constantly pissed. Sidious didn't use Force lightning on Mace or Zabrak brothers for most of the battles but that doesn't mean he can't or won't. Saying anything is out of character for Rey is silly, because Rey doesn't have a character.

This is pure speculation. Rey is used to charging head first with her lightsaber, but that won't work on Wanda, so she'll likely try her Force powers instead.


A little different tbh. Iirc Palpatine has used FL against Maul, Mace and Yoda.

Rey on the other hand only ever used it once and even that was by accident. All we can say is that she might accidentally Lightning strike Wanda while shes attempting to telekinetically overpower her.

Psychotron
Originally posted by Darth Thor
A little different tbh. Iirc Palpatine has used FL against Maul, Mace and Yoda.

Rey on the other hand only ever used it once and even that was by accident. All we can say is that she might accidentally Lightning strike Wanda while shes attempting to telekinetically overpower her.

Which is just as good.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by Psychotron
Which is just as good.


Nah because she had no control over it, so no guarantee of when or if shell even use it.

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Psychotron
She can identify as whatever she wants, but she's constantly pissed. Sidious didn't use Force lightning on Mace or Zabrak brothers for most of the battles but that doesn't mean he can't or won't. Saying anything is out of character for Rey is silly, because Rey doesn't have a character.

This is pure speculation. Rey is used to charging head first with her lightsaber, but that won't work on Wanda, so she'll likely try her Force powers instead.

It was clear that Rey regretted using lightning. As DT has mentioned already, the only reason she used it was by accident.

And again, she identifies herself with the lightside of the force, ergo she using Force Lightning goes against her character traits.

Psychotron
Except Rey is constantly angry in and goes straight for the dark side. Luke even said it in TLJ. She's a horrible Jedi.

I can easily see Rey and Wanda getting into a TK stalemate, which frustrates Rey and results in a lightning bolt.

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Psychotron
Except Rey is constantly angry in and goes straight for the dark side. Luke even said it in TLJ. She's a horrible Jedi.

I can easily see Rey and Wanda getting into a TK stalemate, which frustrates Rey and results in a lightning bolt.

If it does come to lightning, the battle could turn to Rey.

But again, when did Rey ever used lightning against Kylo? She was pretty pissed at him.

Psychotron
She was also in love with him. Don't forget that part.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by Psychotron
She was also in love with him. Don't forget that part.


She really is a shit Jedi.

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Psychotron
She was also in love with him. Don't forget that part.

Why didn't she use it on Palpatine?

BrolyBlack
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Wanda ofcourse! Rey's force powers, although powerful are untamed.

Wanda 7/10, if she goes all out from the beginning.

Rey>Wanda

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by BrolyBlack
Rey>Wanda

Your baseless claim has been noted.

BrolyBlack

Josh_Alexander

Eon Blue

BrolyBlack
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
It's Sidious! Damn! You are truly a disgrace to the SW fanbase.

Your baseless opinion is respected again! Now, go drink your steroids.

I could care less how to spell that losers name.

BrolyBlack
Concession Accepted, Rey Winsthumb up

Eon Blue
Originally posted by BrolyBlack
Concession Accepted, Rey Winsthumb up thumb up

Psychotron
Originally posted by Darth Thor
She really is a shit Jedi.

That's an understatement. And her taste in men is just terrible.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Why didn't she use it on Palpatine?

Cause she didn't get the opprtunity? He drained her and then she reflected his lightning back at him.

Darth Thor
Rey died killing Palpatine. And that was with the help of multiple Jedi spirits. Hence theres no credible argument to place her > Palpatine.

And of course Eon and Broly will say Rey wins. They both claim Khan beats Palpatine laughing out loud

Psychotron
To be fair, Palpatine was also amped by the Sith spirits and the life force of Rey and Kylo.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by Psychotron
To be fair, Palpatine was also amped by the Sith spirits and the life force of Rey and Kylo.


There were no Sith spirits. Any amp he received was by his own power.

Whilst Rey clearly got aid from Jedi spirits. Like we literally hear their voices coming to aid her.

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Psychotron
That's an understatement. And her taste in men is just terrible.



Cause she didn't get the opprtunity? He drained her and then she reflected his lightning back at him.

Naah, that's too much of an assumption.

And again, she doing lightning was more of a mistake than her will.

BrolyBlack
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Rey died killing Palpatine. And that was with the help of multiple Jedi spirits. Hence theres no credible argument to place her > Palpatine.

And of course Eon and Broly will say Rey wins. They both claim Khan beats Palpatine laughing out loud

Dude shut up already and get a job

Darth Thor
Get a job? Lmao

BrolyBlack
Yea get a job

Psychotron
Originally posted by Darth Thor
There were no Sith spirits. Any amp he received was by his own power.

Whilst Rey clearly got aid from Jedi spirits. Like we literally hear their voices coming to aid her.

What are you talking about? He clearly says "I am all the Sith". There's no way Palpatine is equal to a Rey powered by Anakin, Luke, Yoda, Mace, Obi-Wan, Ahsoka, Qui-Gon and who knows how many other Jedi under his own power.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by Psychotron
What are you talking about? He clearly says "I am all the Sith". There's no way Palpatine is equal to a Rey powered by Anakin, Luke, Yoda, Mace, Obi-Wan, Ahsoka, Qui-Gon and who knows how many other Jedi under his own power.


Yes but it was his own amp. He seems to have somehow gained all their power. But There was nothing in the film about Sith spirits coming to aid him. I mean aid him against what lol

And pretty sure in canon there are no Sith spirits. Unless Disney has retconned that now. But no mention of them in TROS. No Sith voices or ghosts either.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by BrolyBlack
Yea get a job


More unsubstantiated accusations.

You should get a life, instead of wasting your time trading insults, stalking and bullying people online.

BrolyBlack
Says the guy who does the same thinglaughing out loud

Darth Thor
Nah, my claims against you have been substantiated.

Just look at what a shit pool youve made the off topic thread. Youre a literal waste of space.

BrolyBlack
So stop responding to melaughing out loud

Eon Blue
Rey wins.

Psychotron
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Yes but it was his own amp. He seems to have somehow gained all their power. But There was nothing in the film about Sith spirits coming to aid him. I mean aid him against what lol

And pretty sure in canon there are no Sith spirits. Unless Disney has retconned that now. But no mention of them in TROS. No Sith voices or ghosts either.

That makes no sense. He was half-dead. He couldn't even walk on his own. And what does "I am all the Sith" mean in that context?

Didn't Darth Bane's spirit appear to Yoda?

Darth Thor
Originally posted by Psychotron
That makes no sense. He was half-dead. He couldn't even walk on his own. And what does "I am all the Sith" mean in that context?

Didn't Darth Bane's spirit appear to Yoda?


What im saying is he has all their power by his own means. Hes taken it. Theyve not come to his aid, like the Jedi spirits clearly did for Rey.

No that wasnt a spirit of Bane. Was specifically mentioned it was some sort of memory/illusion.


Originally posted by BrolyBlack
So stop responding to melaughing out loud

Thats the first reasonable thing youve said one weeks thumb up

Psychotron
Originally posted by Darth Thor
What im saying is he has all their power by his own means. Hes taken it. Theyve not come to his aid, like the Jedi spirits clearly did for Rey.

No that wasnt a spirit of Bane. Was specifically mentioned it was some sort of memory/illusion.

So... it's amped Palpatine. It doesn't matter how he got the power, he has it.

Fair enough.

Josh_Alexander
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Rey died killing Palpatine. And that was with the help of multiple Jedi spirits. Hence theres no credible argument to place her > Palpatine.

And of course Eon and Broly will say Rey wins. They both claim Khan beats Palpatine laughing out loud

thumb up

BrolyBlack
Concession accepted Rey wins

h1a8
Wanda easily. Her force powers are stronger by feats plus she has TP capabilities.

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
rey prolly..

she could just use force lightning on wanda

That's OOC and only happened in a particular extreme situation by accident.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.