Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

sorry if this doesnt seem like a good thread to some of you. i know im not smart enough to think up such good threads as 200 younglings vs kit fisto. and i forgot about AOTC Maul. hes a badass


anyways, this seems like a good master and apprentice battle to me, so i posted it

I actually think that Tyranus is not as good as Malak, and I also think Bandon is better than Ventress. However, this thread has a good quality that I like very much. A feel-good piece of work. Anyways, it's my opinion that Team Tyranus will take this.

Wait, you think Malak is better than Dooku. And you think that Bandon is better than Ventress, but Dooku and Ventress wins?

Crap! I wrote the team I think would lose because I was thinking how nice an alliteration "Team Tyranus" made. I wrote it by mistake. Thanks for catching me there. Anyways, Malak & Co. will end up winning, I think.

Same here. Malak and Bandon will win.

Originally posted by Human Vader
sorry if this doesnt seem like a good thread to some of you. i know im not smart enough to think up such good threads as 200 younglings vs kit fisto. and i forgot about AOTC Maul. hes a badass


anyways, this seems like a good master and apprentice battle to me, so i posted it

This is worse than mine. Mine is logical. Yours is not.

What the F*ck is your problem? His thread is a thouand times better than your crap. Always begging for an answer and then not giving one on another thread. You suck.

lol, sorry but i agree with glentract. How is this thread worse than yours. U must be a blind man to not notice whats logical and whats not. He shows show good matchups instead of an uneven fight, childish thinking, or better yet, a thread where its pretty obvious who the victor is.
Dont brag about this thread just becuz he thought yours was full of idiocy. Respect, and answer.
Dooku has this just becuz i tihnk he is a fine swordsman with experince and is one step away from being better than yoda, so my vote goes to him. Although i dont know a whole lot about bandon or malak becuz i just started playing Kotor1 and beat kotor2.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
What the F*ck is your problem? His thread is a thouand times better than your crap. Always begging for an answer and then not giving one on another thread. You suck.

Your a very stupid person.

Darth Tyrannus and Asajj Ventress vs Darth Malak and Darth Bandon

Malak was born around 4000 years before Dooku and Ventress. So was Malak.


Kit was around at the time when younglings were being trained. How do we know that he didn't kill 200 younglings in his time?

But i am guessing it is logical for a 4000 year old carcass of malak and the 4000 year old carcass of Bandon to start fighting with a headless Sith lord and another Dark Jedi?


My answer is.... Dooku would kick all of their asses.

By the way... I never "begged".

So why don't you shut up?

...................

you just lost any respect anyone on this forum had for you with that post. you really did

these fights are hypothetical moron. meaning what if these people were to fight, who would win? it has nothing to do with when they were alive or whether or not they died.

you just embarrassed yourself beyond belief sorgo

Originally posted by LordSorgo
Malak was born around 4000 years before Dooku and Ventress. So was Malak.

Haha. You retard. Or moron. Whatever you prefer. I don't want to be enemies with you, but the last time I offered to stop arguing with you, you might as well have cussed me out.

Originally posted by Human Vader
...................

you just lost any respect anyone on this forum had for you with that post. you really did

these fights are hypothetical moron. meaning what if these people were to fight, who would win? it has nothing to do with when they were alive or whether or not they died.

you just embarrassed yourself beyond belief sorgo

Not the point, Human Vader. The Posts are still Beyond any sense or Logic. Kit and the Younglings were in the same time frame. Malak and Bandon were not in the same time frame as Dooku and Asajj. Calling my thread Stupid makes you Stupid! Hypothetical or not, that doesn't change the fact that this thread is stupid! Mine has more sense, being that Kit and the Youngling were in the same timeframe.

timeframe doesnt matter in a hypothetical situation when it is this sort of a hypothetical sitituation.

haha. Malak was born around 4000 years before Dooku and Ventress. So was Malak.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
timeframe doesnt matter in a hypothetical situation when it is this sort of a hypothetical sitituation.

haha. Malak was born around 4000 years before Dooku and Ventress. So was Malak.

Whoops! Ment to say Bandon there.


Timeframe doesn't matter in Hypothetics?

....

forgive me. what I was implying is that timeframe, over the course of periods of time that they lived in is unimportant during a fight that is impossible. It is like saying could Michal Jordon at his prime beat Tim Duncan in one-on-one? We never will know for sure. Time is important during the battle itself, but other than that, it is unimportant.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
forgive me. what I was implying is that timeframe, over the course of periods of time that they lived in is unimportant during a fight that is impossible. It is like saying could Michal Jordon at his prime beat Tim Duncan in one-on-one? We never will know for sure. Time is important during the battle itself, but other than that, it is unimportant.

This all doesn't change the fact that my thread was not stupid, let alone "more stupid" than this thread.

morest stupider.

lol

seriously though, Malak is as good as or better than Dooku and Bandon far outclasses Ventress. The KOTOR Sith have this.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
seriously though, Malak is as good as or better than Dooku and Bandon far outclasses GG. The KOTOR Sith have this.

...

Dooku seemed to be one of the greatest duelest and force user in the galaxy. He may defeat Malak. And GG is Grievous right? What does Grievous have to do with Assaj!?

COME ON! Dooku and Ventress totally overkill this one!

Assaj don't know. Dooku would kill Malak!

Originally posted by General Zodiac
Assaj don't know. Dooku would kill Malak!

Hell yeah!

Originally posted by LordSorgo
This is worse than mine. Mine is logical. Yours is not.

Oh bullshit. 200 younglings vs. Kit Fisto is a better fight than this? How old are you, ya senile fool?

And as for the fight, I think Malak would beat Tyrannus (not by much) and Bandon would beat Ventress.

Everyone says: Dooku is far stronger then Obi-Wan ROTS and Anakin ROTS in terms of lightsaber combat and the Force. So Dooku would defeat Malak.
Which means Dooku is one of the few who can take Reavn on one on one.

wtf

yes dookus superior, although not by much, to anakin and obi wan in ROTS. but how does that instantly say he wins against malak. and just because you beat malak doesnt mean you can take revan. your logic is really f*cked up

Really. Malak seemed to hold his own well against Revan.

really? i dont seem to remember that

Really. Final battle.

really? theres no FMVs of the final battle

which means youre going by how hard malak was to defeat which means youre going by game stats which means im wasting my time talking to a ****ing noob

Zodiac, your logic blows harder than a prostitute with a crack addiction.

Dooku>Obi + Anakan does not = Dooku>Malak.

So drop the crack pipe and learn some logic.

Anakin= Chosen One, Powerful Jedi
Obi-Wan= One of the strongest Jedi in the galaxy
Dooku= Master of Form II, Powerful Force user, defeated Obi-Wan twice, Anakin, and stood up to Yoda. Only ran because he had tha plains for the DeathStar and didn't want to lose plus he knew clones were coming.

Originally posted by General Zodiac
Really. Malak seemed to hold his own well against Revan.

Are you kidding? Malak got owned by Lord Revan twice in a row and then Revan got far stronger.

omfg anakins the chosen one he pwns all!!!11!1!1111!1!!!!!!


um yeah so what, that still doesnt prove any of the three of them could beat malak let alone dooku

Really. You killed Malak on the Star Forge without healing?

yes actually, i didnt heal, i used death field on the stasis jeedai lawlz

seriously though, you cant go by game stats, everyones character was different, had different weaknesses and strengths depending on how you built up revans stats. and plus malak had to be somewhat hard considering HE WAS THE FINAL F*CKING BOSS.

Originally posted by General Zodiac
Anakin= Chosen One, Powerful Jedi
Obi-Wan= One of the strongest Jedi in the galaxy
Dooku= Master of Form II, Powerful Force user, defeated Obi-Wan twice, Anakin, and stood up to Yoda. Only ran because he had tha plains for the DeathStar and didn't want to lose plus he knew clones were coming.

Chosen One = ****all plot device. Note that Obi-Wan beat Anakin soundly. Anyone who's been here for a couple of months know this prophecy was pwned by me and a few others before. It does NOT stand as an argument for a versus battle.

Obi-Wan does not = the strongest nor one of the strongest in his own time until it is just him and Yoda left. And if you are comparing PT Jedi as equals or superior to Golden Era of the Sith jedi you are knocking back the NyQuil way too much.

Dooku may be a master of Form II but that doesn't give him license to whup all ass. If that was the case, he would have slain Obi-Wan and Anakin in AOTC and whupped Yoda, while going on to kill Sidious and Mace Windu, etc. etc.

Dooku is probably about as good as Malak.

Anakin being the Chosen One doesnt mean jack, especially since Windu began to think that either the prophecy was misinterpeted or Anakin was not the Chosen One. Anakin is particulary powerful though.

Obi-wan is ROTS kicks butt. He beat Anakin, one of the strongest. He's probably behind Yoda and Mace as most powerful Jedi alive at that time.

Dooku beat both of them. He was one of the Orders strongest Jedi. He beat Mace for pete sake. Sure Mace could now beat him, with him being DS and all, but he did beat him at one time. He's the fourth strongest alive in ROTS. Yoda, Sidious(Mace if fighting a DS), Mace(Sidious if Mace is fighting a DS), Dooku, Obi-wan.

Malak is the second strongest in KOTOR 1. I think he use's form four. He has fought as second in comand against the Mandalorians. Fought the Republic, and therefor Jedi, for a long time. I think that Revan probably taught him a lot of what he learned in Malacor V.

Bandon is a Jedi killer. He fought in the Mandalorian Wars. Was chosen to be Malaks apprentice out of hundreds, maybe thousands, of Sith.

Asajj is not great. She apparently uses form X. Displayed relativly little force powers when fighting Anakin in the Clone Wars. Trained by Count Dooku. I dont think she killed any "powerful" Jedi.

I think that Dooku and Malak are about equal, but Bandon would beat Asajj fast enough to help Malak kill Dooku. Bandon would probably die in the fight. Malak would then kill Dooku.

Ventress is outclassed here, but she does get a ridiculously bad rap. She was able to defeat Kit Fisto in combat, and two jedi masters in Dark Rendezvous.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
forgive me. what I was implying is that timeframe, over the course of periods of time that they lived in is unimportant during a fight that is impossible. It is like saying could Michal Jordon at his prime beat Tim Duncan in one-on-one? We never will know for sure. Time is important during the battle itself, but other than that, it is unimportant.

Tim Duncan would get killed. Just putting it out there.


And this goes to Malak and Bandon, since Dooku and Ventress aren't nearly as accomplished.

I guess I need to read that. Still, Malak and Bandon win.

Assaj kills a lot of Jedi. Her death count was like 17 or so on wikipedia. Dooku's form is for lightsaber combat and form IV isn't that well on the defense as shown in Episode I.

actually I think that Malak would have been a form V user, agressive, powerful, wide sweeps. It would certainly use his muscles and height. But either way, Malak and Bandon would win this. Malak was a front line general in the Mandalorian wars and fought a lot, he was also more powerful than thousands of sith to become Revans apprentice and was one of only two people who could control the star forge. Bandon is also underestimated on this board, sure he lost to Revan, but think about it it is Revan, most people would lose when they fight him. Bandon was superior to thousands of sith to become Malak's apprentice and had killed several jedi and nobody was a match for him (until he met Revan). So Bandon beats Asajj and Malak beats Dooku, battle over

I personally think that Dooku would defeat Bandon. Assaj sucks. And Revan would eventually take out Dooku.

So Revan wins.

^^ what the heck, why did Revan come into this thread? seems we have another noob

And ok, if you have Dooku vs Bandon and Malak vs Asajj, then Malak wastes Asajj before Dooku can kill Bandon, and then Bandon and Malak together can kill Dooku. Or if you want, I will say Dooku can kill Bandon at the same time Malak kills Asajj (very unlikely, but lets just say), then Dooku would be more tired than Malak would and Malak could still kill him

I completely agree with Darkstar.. Malak and Bandon win this..

Nice to agree with you for once btw :P

I have little respect for the jawless wonder, but I say he and Bandon would win.

I have more respect for him then I do for some other Sith Lord that will remain nameless but is loved far to much. Although the way he got his title just makes me want to kick him in the nuts... The coward.

Malak and Bandon take this, and pretty easily. Ventress is a non-factor really. She's pretty good, but she's got nothing on either Bandon or Malak. Bandon will engage her, and maybe she'll hold him for a bit. But in the end, Bandon will win. Tyranus is the only threat; he's no pushover, and he'll put up a fight, but Malak will finish him without too much effort.

Originally posted by Emperor Revan
Oh bullshit. 200 younglings vs. Kit Fisto is a better fight than this? How old are you, ya senile fool?

And as for the fight, I think Malak would beat Tyrannus (not by much) and Bandon would beat Ventress.

Oh bullshit. 200 younglings vs. Kit Fisto is a better fight than this?

OH MY GOD! THE GREATEST COMEBACK IN HUMAN HISTORY! I AM BEATEN!

I have already explained to you why it's better. Besides, who says a bunch of n00bish younglings can take on the Kitman?

As for this Malak/Dooku situation, I think the fight would be hard but Dooku would stomp Malak.

Dooku would stomp you. HA!

200 Younglings against Kit Fisto my god...

Yeah. Sorry about that. I get Revan and Malak confused for some reason.

sorgo, he wasnt trying to insult you or make a comeback, revans becoming one of my "friends" on this forum and you need to grow a brain and see that he was trying to talk about the thread rather than fight with oyu


and let the fisto and younglings thread die, people forget about it but then you bring it back up, it was truly a craptastical thread and we all know it, so just let it go and move on

Well said HV.

Ok ok your right I shouldn't have brought up that ridiculous thread.


Sorry Sorgo.

Originally posted by Human Vader
sorgo, he wasnt trying to insult you or make a comeback, revans becoming one of my "friends" on this forum and you need to grow a brain and see that he was trying to talk about the thread rather than fight with oyu


and let the fisto and younglings thread die, people forget about it but then you bring it back up, it was truly a craptastical thread and we all know it, so just let it go and move on

I'm LordSorgo, not Oyu. (Had to play with the Typo, Human Vader.)


Mine makes more sense. Whether it was crappy or not, it just makes more sense. Bottom line.

"You need to grow a brain"

Malak and Bandon no questions asked

Originally posted by LordSorgo
I'm LordSorgo, not Oyu. (Had to play with the Typo, Human Vader.)


Mine makes more sense. Whether it was crappy or not, it just makes more sense. Bottom line.

"You need to grow a brain"



That took oyu a while sorgo, next time try to defend yourself at least in the same day as a post made against you, not four days afterward.

And if oyu want to keep believing that 200 younglings vs fisto is a good thread and this is not, then I suppose oyu truly have gone past the point of no return into stupidity.

Dooku team wins. Ventress loses both arms :P

How the hell? Give reasons

Originally posted by Human Vader
That took oyu a while sorgo, next time try to defend yourself at least in the same day as a post made against you, not four days afterward.

And if oyu want to keep believing that 200 younglings vs fisto is a good thread and this is not, then I suppose oyu truly have gone past the point of no return into stupidity.

Sorry if took a few days to reply to you're pathetic crap, but i have a life.

And if that's supposed to be an insult, it is just as pathetic as the last PATHETIC crap you posted to me. Eat it.

Eat what? Your meaningless words?

. . . . Oooookay. Malak and Bandon. Malak, as I have tried and failed to inform you about, is greater than Dooku in terms of power. Even if Dooku was a better duelist, Malak's superior knowledge and power would make up for it.

Okay, so let's say that Dooku was stronger, okay? Now, many people have compared Bandon to Maul, others, that he is greater, which I agree with. Anyway, who here thinks Assaj could take Maul? Not me. So let's say Bandon defeated Ventress first. He would then be free to assist his master in destroying the good Count.

I too have to say Malak and Bandon. Dooku is a Sith and a Jedi Master, so he is clearly well versed on both sides of the force. His form II is well refined, and he is a master with the saber. However, Malak is no slouch, and while he got beat up by Revan a couple of times, he does exhibit abilities that stack up well with what Dooku has done.

Asajj was beaten by Anakin in a fair duel (not to mention she is far Dooku's inferior in combat); I may even say that it was Asajj with the advantage, given that she led Anakin into a trap. She falls relatively fast.

As good of a duelist Dooku is, I don't see him being able to defeat Malak and Bandon at the same time.

Originally posted by HimoKun
Eat what? Your meaningless words?

I don't believe i was talking to you, let alone recognizing you.

Shoo!

Dude, you got shoo'ed.

can tyranus solo?