Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Luke as of Return of the Jedi.
Maul as of Son of Dathomir.

Setting: Jedi Temple

*Maul is only equipped with his darksaber*

Maul. They're roughly equal as duelists but Maul is much more powerful.

Maul without the inconsistency that Luke or Vader were equals in spite of conflicting points. Good fight though

I wouldn't even put ROTJ Luke on TPM Maul's level personally, let alone SOD Maul's level.

If he's Rage Enhanced Luke might give him a run for his money in Pure Sabers. But he stands no chance in an All-Out against SOD Maul.

Maul. Luke isn't awesome...yet. Give him time, though. Give him time.

Yeah, Maul. Even TPM Maul should be able to win IMO.

Any Skywalker supporters?

If it's any consolation I would back RotJ Luke against TPM Maul for a stalemate.

I'm not sure where I have ROTJ Luke, but I know I'd back him against Ventress, and the majority of the PT Council.

His physical feats and lightsaber skill is at least on par with Maul, if not slightly higher.

I don't really know where to place him, either. Maybe the new comics/book(s) will sort of flesh out his power level in that era with more consistency.

LOL. Luke wins if we're talking about RotJ Luke. ESB Luke loses though.

This is like, the 6th random member that's popped up this week.

Something is upon us, something sinister.

Luke/

Originally posted by Emperordmb
I'm not sure where I have ROTJ Luke, but I know I'd back him against Ventress, and the majority of the PT Council.


This is fair Imo.

But anyone suggesting ROTJ Luke is going to match or actually even beat SOD Maul in any kind of direct combat, is just plain out crazy.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
This is like, the 6th random member that's popped up this week.

Something is upon us, something sinister.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Yeah, Maul. Even TPM Maul should be able to win IMO.

Luke did beat Vader, beating Maul doesn't seem out of the question.

Originally posted by Q99
Luke did beat Vader, beating Maul doesn't seem out of the question.

PT > OT, TPM Maul faster and equally skilled and strong as RotJ Vader.

Originally posted by Q99
Luke did beat Vader, beating Maul doesn't seem out of the question.


He beat his Dad who was trying to sway him to his side. Vader never once used any kind of TK on Luke. Maul won't be so nice.

And SOD Maul is probably > Vader in Sabers.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
He beat his Dad who was trying to sway him to his side. Vader never once used any kind of TK on Luke. Maul won't be so nice.

And SOD Maul is probably > Vader in Sabers.

Or Emperor didn't let Vader to use his force powers on Luke, similar to what happened in Dooku vs. Anakin maybe ?

Originally posted by Marco1907
PT > OT, TPM Maul faster and equally skilled and strong as RotJ Vader.


Wrong. The only reason why it appeared that Maul was faster than Vader is because the special effects were vastly improved in the new trilogy...and you're crazy if you think Maul was equally as skilled and strong as Vader. Vader would hand Maul's *** to him on a platter.

The Courtship of Princess Leia reveals that Vader was holding back on Luke, and could have killed him in their duel on the Death Star.


I haven't been reading any new material on Luke circa Battle of Endor - but what I know of the movies and his skills around that time period, he would get destroyed by Maul pretty easily.

He's slow and clumsy with a lightsaber, and while he has potential with TK, he isn't very focused with it, yet.

So I'd say Luke has no chance, here.

Originally posted by Star428
Wrong. The only reason why it appeared that Maul was faster than Vader is because the special effects were vastly improved in the new trilogy...and you're crazy if you think Maul was equally as skilled and strong as Vader. Vader would hand Maul's *** to him on a platter.

That's nothing to do with f*** special effects , lol.

Vader has lots of comic books where says he is still slow. Start to read SW comics.

TPM Maul faster than RotJ Vader. It's a canon information, I don't know which Vader fanboy used mind trick on you guys but you need to learn the truths on this.





By TPM, Darth Maul has an agility never seen before Star Wars



And here Lucas says PT is the prime of the Jedi, PT > OT, he wanted to be faster means ; TPM Maul > RotJ Vader

Originally posted by Star428
.and you're crazy if you think Maul was equally as skilled and strong as Vader. Vader would hand Maul's *** to him on a platter.

Even TPM Darth Maul is one of the most skilled Sith Lord in history of the Order, his skills as a warrior nonpareil, and yes Maul is physically strong as Vader, his strength feats suggests that. And also he kicked Vader's ass via strength before while he was just a clone.

http://i1273.photobucket.com/albums/y418/karasakal_teach/StarWarsTales09-038_zpsbacd8c3e.jpg