Should Yoshi have another game of his own?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Yoshi Fanatic
Yoshi is the green dinosaur that is part of the Super Mario franchise. We all know that Yoshi's popularity almost surpasses that of Mario. Shouldn't Yoshi come out with a 3D game of his own?

MadMel
thats news to me laughing out loud
yea maybe he could, but some time after mario galaxy comes out erm

SpadeKing
I miss yoshi cry

Morridini
What was the name of the Yoshi game where baby Mario was riding on his back and he was throwing eggs? I liked that Yoshi game so see no reason why he shouldn't get another game.

Yoshi Fanatic
There were a couple of games in which Yoshi had Mario ride on his back. All of his previous games were 2D sidescrollers. He needs to have a 3D game.

ESB -1138
Yoshi needs to be in Galaxy. Like he was in 64.

MadMel
yea, but with a better role big grin

JToTheP
No, Yoshi's Island was a classic, Yoshi's Island DS was far too difficult by World 5, and I hate Yoshi's Story.

Yoshi Fanatic
Originally posted by JToTheP
No, Yoshi's Island was a classic, Yoshi's Island DS was far too difficult by World 5, and I hate Yoshi's Story.

That seems like a personal problem. Overall, all of his games were fun with high replay value. None of his games were difficult, it just had some puzzles in them that made the player think.

JToTheP
Originally posted by Yoshi Fanatic
That seems like a personal problem. Overall, all of his games were fun with high replay value. None of his games were difficult, it just had some puzzles in them that made the player think.

All of World 5 had lifts with those stupid spikes, and they just went on and on. No platform should be that difficult, thus was the downfall of Mario Sunshine; Harder than suicide game, and one of the easiest boss's in gaming history.

Morridini
Really? I found Sunshine to be a pretty average game difficulty wise, not hard, not easy.

Yoshi Fanatic
Yeah, but Yoshi didn't like water in that game. I mean, COME ON! Every single stage was set on an island, beach, harbor, etc. Yoshi couldn't be used that much because there was too much water and if he came in contact with it, he would disappear. If he's in Super Mario Galaxy, he better not have any weaknesses...

Violent2Dope
Yoshi is beyond gangster of course he deserves a 3D game. Yoshi's Story is one of my favorite N64 games of all time, beaten only by Zelda, Starfox, and The Banjo games.

MadMel
and mario 64 and conkers BFD laughing out loud

JToTheP
Originally posted by Morridini
Really? I found Sunshine to be a pretty average game difficulty wise, not hard, not easy.

Well, I guess patience for intense trial and error, AND 8-9 total stars per world when it only shows 6 is really easy for you. The game irritated me, and just made me want to play Mario 64 again.

MadMel
nothing wrong with the latter stick out tongue

Violent2Dope
Yeah Mario 64 was gangster!

((The_Anomaly))
Hell yes Yoshi should have his own game. Yoshi FTW!!!

xNIXSONx
there might be a problem if they make yoshi's island 3d, like Sonic for example, who only works in in 2d

fanboy 1988
Hell yeah!

Yoshi Fanatic
I'm pretty sure that the video game programmers can make it happen. Playing Yoshi Island in 3D with a different storyline would interesting...

§P0oONY
I'd like to see another Yoshi 2D platformer... Like Yoshi Story.

xNIXSONx
maybe make yoshi's iland wii, with new or old story line, baby mario loses his bib and needs to get it back, and because of the loss of the bib or w/e its called, baby mario drools A LOT = new ability to waterdown enemies with drool as well as other new abilities and characters (all on a 2d plane, like pseudo 3d or something)

wii control: make yoshi jump by flicking the wiimote up etc.

creative much?

Violent2Dope
Or how about a Yoshi shooting game!?2gunsgunsmilieOr a game where you drive around in planes and tanks!?tomcattankLol jk if that happenedgiljotiini

xNIXSONx
if it was a toy tank that baby mario got, and yoshi babysits baby mario on this new exciting journey with innovative, intuitive, and creative controls of the wii

Yoshi Fanatic
Yoshi shouldn't be in a shooter game. It's not his style to use guns and other heavy artillery.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Violent2Dope
Or how about a Yoshi shooting game!?2gunsgunsmilieOr a game where you drive around in planes and tanks!?tomcattank

...replace Yoshi with Sonic. Do you really want a game like Shadow the Hedgehog?

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
Lol jk if that happenedgiljotiini

I'd thought now.

Gregory
Originally posted by Yoshi Fanatic
Yoshi shouldn't be in a shooter game. It's not his style to use guns and other heavy artillery.

I think he was joking.

If they can make a good new Yoshi game, they should. If they can't, they shouldn't. Just like every single other video game character.

ESB -1138
Tell that to Sonic Team. All the new good Sonic games have been made by a different company.

Violent2Dope
Anyone know how the XBOX 360 and the Wii Sonic games were?

Yoshi Fanatic
As if anybody cares about the Sonic games. Anyway, I'm pretty sure that Yoshi is going to have his own game on the Wii sometime in the future.

Xenogears
Yoshi's a queer.

xNIXSONx
Mario got to shoot people but with water...so if Yoshi had baby mario on his back but it was a nerf gun

Yoshi Fanatic
Yoshi isn't a queer. How can you possibly say that?

pinkfloydkor
yoshi is by far my favorite nintendo character and i was about to make a thread just like this just a minute ago

i have thought for a long time that yoshi needs his own 3D game, and that each different part of the game you should control a different color yoshi or something

I think it stands a good chance as being the next "mario" type game, simply because what else can they do?

after SMG, its too early for another SPM and too early for another mario party (thank god)

what else can nintendo do?

Violent2Dope
Originally posted by Yoshi Fanatic
As if anybody cares about the Sonic games. Anyway, I'm pretty sure that Yoshi is going to have his own game on the Wii sometime in the future. pissed

Menetnashté
Originally posted by xNIXSONx
there might be a problem if they make yoshi's island 3d, like Sonic for example, who only works in in 2d
I liked some of the sonic 3D games, not the latest ones, since Heroes came out I think they all suck. But I liked them on Dreamcast, and I think my friend had one on Gamecube I really liked. The game itself was average but I loved Chaio worlds. Maybe they should do that in a Mario game, instead of having a Chaio world they have a Yoshi world, that'd be straight up awesome.

Yoshi Fanatic
Weird, but interesting idea...

§P0oONY
Originally posted by Yoshi Fanatic
Yoshi shouldn't be in a shooter game. It's not his style to use guns and other heavy artillery.
I guess you've never seen Yoshi's Safari.

Yoshi Fanatic
For your information, Mario was the one with the gun in Yoshi's Safari. Mario was riding on Yoshi's back the whole time. Yoshi never even touch a gun in that game.

Ozone
I wouldn't mind playing a 3D Yoshi game in the future. It should be on the Wii so that the game would have some interactiveness to it.

MadMel
well its Nintendo, so were else could it go??

Ozone
The Nintendo DS.

shin_gear
Originally posted by shin_gear
Yoshi's a queer.

Venomous Yoshi
Originally posted by Venomous Yoshi
Yoshi isn't a queer. How can you possibly say that?

shin_gear
I'm kidding. stick out tongue

Venomous Yoshi
I know. wink

Yoshi Paradise
happy My first bump.

Since Super Mario Galaxy is a very successful game, what do you all think are the chances of Yoshi having his own game on the Wii?

Violent2Dope
I don't know. He definately should have one tho. I would say maybe...60-70%?

Yoshi Paradise
I really hope that he gets a game on the Wii.

I would buy it the day it comes out.

Cosmic Cube
Yoshi should have 5 games, each released within 2 weeks of one another.

Violent2Dope
Lol. Yoshi is cool. What was his last game?

Yoshi Paradise
His last game was Yoshi Island DS.

It's a good game.

Violent2Dope
Hmmm I haven't played it. If a new Yoshi game comes out, and it's half as good as Yoshi's Story, it will be great.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
happy My first bump.

Since Super Mario Galaxy is a very successful game, what do you all think are the chances of Yoshi having his own game on the Wii?

Aww come on. If Yoshi gets a game then Luigi should get one too!

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by ESB -1138
If Yoshi gets a game then Luigi should get one too!

haermm Yeah, right.

Ozone
Yoshi better have a game on the Wii in the future.

It doesn't have to be 3D, though.

Neo Darkhalen
Perhaps a remake of Yoshi's island.

Yoshi Paradise
They already remade Yoshi Island on the Gameboy Advance.

Now, if they were to make a 3D version...

Violent2Dope
Originally posted by ESB -1138
Aww come on. If Yoshi gets a game then Luigi should get one too! I agree.

Yoshi Paradise
Yoshi should have a game on the Wii before Luigi does.

Violent2Dope
True. Mostly because Luigi has had more.

Yoshi Paradise
Well, the only game in which Luigi had the spotlight was "Luigi's Mansion".

Neo Darkhalen
Yep where he battled HIS archenemies.

Yoshi Paradise
Since Yoshi has a series of games, he might as well get one on the Wii.

It's only fair.

Neo Darkhalen
Luigi is older, more preferred and well better then Yoshi in any game, however I like Yoshi he needs another game, I want Bowser or Kamek to get a game.

InnerRise
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Since Yoshi has a series of games, he might as well get one on the Wii.

It's only fair. Fair? I don't know.

One could say that because he's had so many more games than Luigi that it's only fair that Luigi finally gets another one on the Wii before Yoshi.

Yoshi should have been gotten an Arch Nemesis by now.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Neo Darkhalen
Luigi has one, Luigi is better, could you count Kamek as Yoshi's Arch Nemesis.

AstroFan
Id rather have a Luigi game than a Yoshi game.

Neo Darkhalen
Well Lugi has King Boo as his foe, the king of the boo's not a bad villain to have.

AstroFan
No, no more ghost games, give Luigi his own platformer. lol





Damn Peach got one. roll eyes (sarcastic)

Neo Darkhalen
Very true, but hers was pathetic, yeah but what would you call it.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by InnerRise
Yoshi should have been gotten an Arch Nemesis by now.

In Super Mario RPG, there was a mean Yoshi named Boshi.

I wouldn't mind seeing him in another game.

Neo Darkhalen
Oh is he the one with the shades, anyway Kamek is Yoshi's Nemesis.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Oh is he the one with the shades?

Yeah.

InnerRise
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
yeah but what would you call it. Super Luigi Universe of Course.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Neo Darkhalen
That is a very good title, what would the plot be?

pinkfloydkor
Originally posted by InnerRise

Yoshi should have been gotten an Arch Nemesis by now.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

are you serious?

anyway

yeah i agree with boshi coming back

Neo Darkhalen
Kamek is there main enemy.

InnerRise
Originally posted by pinkfloydkor
are you serious?

anyway

yeah i agree with boshi coming back Yes...Yes I Am.

Are you seriously asking me if I'm serious?

Anyway per say and the like such as.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Neo Darkhalen
*Cough* Oooook then, so what sort of plot would the game have.

pinkfloydkor
Originally posted by InnerRise
Yes...Yes I Am.

Are you seriously asking me if I'm serious?

Anyway per say and the like such as.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

i meant about your grammer

but whatever

i really hope they dont overdo this game. that would really suck.

Neo Darkhalen
Keep it in the traditional values.

InnerRise
Originally posted by pinkfloydkor
i meant about your grammer

but whatever

i really hope they dont overdo this game. that would really suck.

There's nothing wrong with the grammar in that post.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by InnerRise
There's nothing wrong with the grammar in that post.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka..... Actually, there is. There is a gramatical error in your last post as well.

There are 5 periods in the ellipses at the end of your signature 'awata blah blah whatever" quote, though an ellipses most certainly consists of 3 periods.

I rest my case.

InnerRise
Originally posted by InnerRise
There's nothing wrong with the grammar in that post.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

doped

ANATA WA WAKARIMASU KA.....

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by InnerRise
doped

ANATA WA WAKARIMASU KA..... KA...*

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by pinkfloydkor
yeah i agree with boshi coming back

That would be good because Boshi would be the evil counterpart of Yoshi, which would be similar to Wario and Waluigi being evil counterparts of Mario and Luigi.

Neo Darkhalen
Indeed, that and he had damn cool shades.

Yoshi Paradise
It would be great to see him in another game.

pinkfloydkor
but he is not evil

he just won the derby every year and was arrogant

yoshi talked to him after he beat him and convinced him to be a nicer person

so it probably wouldnt work out with boshi as the main villain

Yoshi Paradise
Who else would be the villain, then?

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Who else would be the villain, then? Probably Kamek, or Kid Bowser. There aren't many to choose from.

Yoshi Paradise
How about a new threat to Yoshi Island?

pinkfloydkor
sounds good to me

except a complete yoshis island, in 3d where you can go anywhere you want

thats what we need

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
How about a new threat to Yoshi Island? Like a zombie plague? Yeah!

Yoshi Paradise
no expression No.

It can't be anything scary because kids will be playing this game.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
no expression No.

It can't be anything scary because kids will be playing this game. Zombies aren't that scary.

Yoshi Paradise
To kids, they're scary.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
To kids, they're scary. Maybe to some of 'em. But so are clowns.

Yoshi Paradise
Clowns are suppose to make people happy.

Zombies cause people to be afraid and disgusted of them.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Clowns are suppose to make people happy.

Zombies cause people to be afraid and disgusted of them. The truth is in they eye of the beholder. I'm sure zombies make some people happy.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
I'm sure zombies make some people happy.

haermm I doubt it.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
haermm I doubt it. What's so bad about zombies?

They already have walking skeletons in the Mario series (Dry Bones.) Just add some rotting flesh.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
They already have walking skeletons in the Mario series (Dry Bones.) Just add some rotting flesh.

Key words: rotting flesh.

Nobody wants to see that in a Yoshi game.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Key words: rotting flesh.

Nobody wants to see that in a Yoshi game. I guess you're right...

Yoshi Paradise
Every single game that Yoshi had was rated "E".

It should stay like that.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Every single game that Yoshi had was rated "E".

It should stay like that. What are Zombies rated?

Yoshi Paradise
It depends on how they look.

If they are rotten and decomposing, then this game might be rated "T" or above if it includes them.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
It depends on how they look.

If they are rotten and decomposing, then this game might be rated "T" or above if it includes them. Yoshi would probably eat them. sick

Captain King
Yoshi should have a game involving saving the eggs of others of his own kind.

And tetris blocks falling from the sky trying to kick his ass. These "blocks" sometimes have specific squares with question marks, you kick them and stuff comes out. Might be a star, might be a poison mushroom, you don't know.


It could be a 3D platform adventure where he can kick, jump, and eat his foes.


As for the enemy, it has to be something cartoony, but have a clear motivation to kidnap the baby dinos. (I'll let your immaginations run wild of genocide or whatever)


Maybe that old super Mario RPG enemy. The Pirate. I forget his name.



People have told me I should go back to school and consider becoming a game designer..

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Yoshi would probably eat them. sick

I doubt he'll eat something that disgusting.

Originally posted by Captain King
Yoshi should have a game involving saving the eggs of others of his own kind.

And tetris blocks falling from the sky trying to kick his ass. These "blocks" sometimes have specific squares with question marks, you kick them and stuff comes out. Might be a star, might be a poison mushroom, you don't know.


It could be a 3D platform adventure where he can kick, jump, and eat his foes.


As for the enemy, it has to be something cartoony, but have a clear motivation to kidnap the baby dinos. (I'll let your immaginations run wild of genocide or whatever)


Maybe that old super Mario RPG enemy. The Pirate. I forget his name.

Good ideas.

Ozone
Although Boshi isn't evil, he should still have an evil role.

He might get corrupted by an evil force and be forced to do its bidding, which is taking over Yoshi Island.

I just want Boshi to be in another game.

He was a cool character in Super Mario RPG.

Neo Darkhalen
Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Probably Kamek, or Kid Bowser. There aren't many to choose from.

More then Likely Kamek seems to be the Yoshi's worst enemy, with baby Bowser a mere annoyance.

Violent2Dope
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Key words: rotting flesh.

Nobody wants to see that in a Yoshi game. I do. no expression

Neo Darkhalen
Shy Guys, can't forget the shy guys.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Shy Guys, can't forget the shy guys. Zombie Shy Guys!

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by Violent2Dope
I do. no expression

Well, you're a "special" boy.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Zombie Shy Guys!

It depends on how they would look.

Neo Darkhalen
Like the ghost Shy Guys, only with tattered robes and a cracked mask.

Yoshi Paradise
That might work out.

Neo Darkhalen
They could be like Dry bones, and regroup after a time, they could have their arms stretched out.

Yoshi Paradise
I'm thinking that the main villain should be a new threat to Yoshi Island.

In other words, it's a new character that will make his/her first appearance in this game.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
I'm thinking that the main villain should be a new threat to Yoshi Island.

In other words, it's a new character that will make his/her first appearance in this game.

Wart?

Neo Darkhalen
The grand daite of the Island, or the grand master who wishes to unlock the great petritria Parana, or even a new Magikoopa, Katrastophic Koopa.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by ESB -1138
Wart?

Wart isn't a new character.

He was in Super Mario Brothers 2.
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
The grand daite of the Island, or the grand master who wishes to unlock the great petritria Parana, or even a new Magikoopa, Katrastophic Koopa.

I was thinking something from another planet.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise

I was thinking something from another planet.

Like the Shrooms?

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by ESB -1138
Like the Shrooms?

No.

Some other race of aliens that want to take over Yoshi Island.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
No.

Some other race of aliens that want to take over Yoshi Island.

Like an evil space race of Yoshis?

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by ESB -1138
Like an evil space race of Yoshis?

...Maybe.

Neo Darkhalen
The Galactic Guys, lead by the Grand Tiny the Big Blazer, you could even have a second in command, Gauntlet the Boom Boom.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
The Galactic Guys, lead by the Grand Tiny the Big Blazer, you could even have a second in command, Gauntlet the Boom Boom.

no...no...just no.

I was thinking more or less that Wart should make a comeback since Birdo is getting some time in Mario Party and what not and we need to see someone other than Bowser causing destruction. Maybe have Wario and Waluigi or the Koopalings or the evil space Yoshis I mentioned before.

Yoshi Paradise
The space yoshies sound like a good idea.

They would be a team of 4 or 5 evil yoshies that will serve as the main bosses.

Neo Darkhalen
The Galactic guys sounds good, that big bird from Yoshi's Island, Kamek, Wart if you wanted, and Yoshi Space Pirates led by, Rosti the fire blasting yoshi.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
The space yoshies sound like a good idea.

They would be a team of 4 or 5 evil yoshies that will serve as the main bosses.

And Bowser was behind it all along! Or Ganondorf...

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by ESB -1138
And Bowser was behind it all along! Or Ganondorf... More likely Ganondorf.

That's his style.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by ESB -1138
And Bowser was behind it all along!

Honestly, I'm tired of Bowser always being the villain.

Yoshi needs to have a villain or evil counterpart of his own.

This is why Boshi should come back.

He was cool.

ESB -1138
Originally posted by Yoshi Paradise
Honestly, I'm tired of Bowser always being the villain.

Yoshi needs to have a villain or evil counterpart of his own.

This is why Boshi should come back.

He was cool.

Or Ridley

Yoshi Paradise
ermm Ridley isn't part of this franchise.

Neo Darkhalen
Where do you think I got Yoshi Space pirates, and Rosti, you could have that bird again, and petrifina Pirhana, as well as galactic guys.

Cosmic Cube
Pirhana*

Neo Darkhalen
Stupid Spellcheck.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Stupid Spellcheck. It sure is.

Neo Darkhalen
Are you being serious?

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Are you being serious? When am I ever not?

Neo Darkhalen
I don't really know you, so I am sorry about that, in all fairness I did not know you existed on the forum until fairly recently.

Cosmic Cube
Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
I don't really know you, so I am sorry about that, in all fairness I did not know you existed on the forum until fairly recently. I have always existed.

And for the record, I am not serious 87.24% of the time.

Neo Darkhalen
No need to be snappy, I never said you never existed, I am just saying my small knowledge of the forum, I determined that a account names Cosmic cube never existed, that was all; thank you for clearing that up, you will find I am 90.27% tired at the moment, so I may not make sense and I may be snappy or confused easily for the rest of the day.

Yoshi Paradise
Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Pirhana*

You spelled it wrong.

It's "piranha". wink

Neo Darkhalen
Owned. dice

Yoshi Paradise
ermm You spelled it wrong, too.

Originally posted by Neo Darkhalen
Where do you think I got Yoshi Space pirates, and Rosti, you could have that bird again, and petrifina Pirhana, as well as galactic guys.

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>