Does the Trilogy have plot holes ??

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



coolmovies
I know alot of you love sw to bits but the thing is its been 30 years since sw and thats more then enough time to understand three movies .

e.g why did this happen ? and so on ! why do fans still ask questions about the star wars ?

Did GL leave Plot holes ??

Are they the most confusing films ever made ?

General G
I would say there has to be some. I am just not to good at finding them.

Sesse
The reason people have wondered all these years if the "prophecy was true" was:

Once there was a movie Star Wars, and a great movie it was. So good that it ended up forming a holy trinity with its two sequels in the theaters. Then the milking movie-cow died, but people knew that there was another Skywalker to save the day, Anakin. He was the chosen one who would bring back the balance to the Movie-Force (and some dollars into Gorges purse).

So people now had a messiah to wait for, he died in a last of the three movies, but one could not easily miss the little smirk on the lips of his spirit form... He would be back to bring his Empire to the whole galaxy. And there he shall rule the galaxy by the right side of his master. And we shall be able to see these movies, till the end of our days.

Yee-Haw. Happy Dance

Alliance
Originally posted by coolmovies
Did GL leave Plot holes ??

No. The OT is infallible.

General G
Of course it is.

queeq
ROTJ is the plothole.

Alliance
Most definately. Most holes in the saga trace to ROTJ.

queeq
Unfortunately... a blemish on the OT.

Alliance
"Which will explain your hysteria over a simple blemish on the "

*BLEMISH!!!*

coolmovies
The PT is kinda crap

General G
Holy crap! This place was shrunk down! Way to go queeq.

I wouldn't say the PT was crap, I rather enjoyed it.

queeq
But not up to par.

coolmovies
time for part 7 lolz

queeq
Not after seeing the PT, thanks.

Count Makashi
Originally posted by queeq
But not up to par.

Its as good as the OT, maybe even better.

coolmovies
Better then the OT ? No way

queeq
Nope...

Quinlan-Vos
Originally posted by Count Makashi
Its as good as the OT, maybe even better. What? How...? Did the OT have Jar Jar Binks? Did the OT have Ray Park with all those ruttin' tattoos? Did the OT have masses of ridiculous, pathetic battle droids that make stormtroopers look like Robin Hood!? Did the OT have "Hold me Ani"? Did the OT have gorram whiney Hayden Christiansen? Did the OT have cheap plot efforts to include droids? Did the OT have an overabundance of overrated special effects? Did the OT have a century-long shitbag of a podrace? Did the OT have 'Yipee' Darth Vader?
And did the PT have mother f*cking Han Solo? Did it have Alec Guiness? Did it have Darth Vader kicking anus? Did the PT have, hell, did the PT have ewoks? DId the PT have a Wookiee used to any reasonable effect in the story? Did the PT have Boba Fett doing something cool, rather than that tosser Jango- who is NOT Boba by any means! Did the PT have the Death Star? Did the PT have a gold bikini?
All that's going for the PT is Ewan McGregor, so...
Guess which is better????

MasterAshenVor
The PT was good i mean listen to me....It Gave us a satisfying turn of Anakin it let us Understand the Sith and the Origins of Sith and it unlocked a Bunch of EU books


The OT was the best of course because it came out first and it was just SO original and it changed the world it started the series and made a crap load of EU books

So both are VERY GOOD in a point of view the only reason yall dont like PT was because of JAR JAR BINKS i belive and a few plot holes.

queeq
Oh no... not the point of view approach....

MasterAshenVor
*Force Crushes Queeq* HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!

Tangible God
Originally posted by Quinlan-Vos
What? How...? Did the OT have Jar Jar Binks? Did the OT have Ray Park with all those ruttin' tattoos? Did the OT have masses of ridiculous, pathetic battle droids that make stormtroopers look like Robin Hood!? Did the OT have "Hold me Ani"? Did the OT have gorram whiney Hayden Christiansen? Did the OT have cheap plot efforts to include droids? Did the OT have an overabundance of overrated special effects? Did the OT have a century-long shitbag of a podrace? Did the OT have 'Yipee' Darth Vader?
And did the PT have mother f*cking Han Solo? Did it have Alec Guiness? Did it have Darth Vader kicking anus? Did the PT have, hell, did the PT have ewoks? DId the PT have a Wookiee used to any reasonable effect in the story? Did the PT have Boba Fett doing something cool, rather than that tosser Jango- who is NOT Boba by any means! Did the PT have the Death Star? Did the PT have a gold bikini?
All that's going for the PT is Ewan McGregor, so...
Guess which is better???? Take out the Ewoks and high five.

Very nice.

queeq
Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
*Force Crushes Queeq* HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!

You powers are weak... I don't feel anything. And put down that crushed can.

coolmovies
Theres no such thing as the force in real life

queeq
Oh really?

General G
I beg to differ.

queeq
Of course you do.

Alliance
Stupid droid.

General G
Stupid clone.

Damn nice sig though.

Alliance
Thats one of the successful Halo ones.

and Yes. I still remember your requests.

And no one EVER says "stupid clone" in any Star Wars product smile

General G
Still no rush though.

I haven't heard it too often. And perhaps the droids have a certain etiquette protocol?

Alliance
Perhaps its never said because its never correct.

queeq
It's correct alright. But maybe not appropriate.

General G
Why not appropiate?

queeq
Because you're a droid.

Alliance
slam DUH.

General G
Ouch...

Alliance
Don't worry, you're woth it,

queeq
Hehehehe, works everytime.

General G
The hell it does.

queeq

General G
Umm...nope.

Fardin Vassisk
Hey!

Count Makashi
Originally posted by General G
Umm...nope.

Your saying your not a droid, then what are you, junk?

General G
Nope.

coolmovies
when ever i go you start fighting lolz

Mr Parker
Originally posted by Alliance
Most definately. Most holes in the saga trace to ROTJ.

yep.ROTJ IS the plothole.That movie went against everything the other two films accomplished.Wish it had never been made. mad

Mr Parker
Originally posted by coolmovies
when ever i go you start fighting lolz

yeah you go away and look what the thread becomes. big grin

General G
Originally posted by coolmovies
when ever i go you start fighting lolz

Thats the way it goes.

queeq
Originally posted by Mr Parker
yep.ROTJ IS the plothole.That movie went against everything the other two films accomplished.Wish it had never been made. mad

It had some good scenes though. It was the movie that gave us Ian McDiarmid.

General G
I love those scenes...

chewy16
The only plothole I found in the OT was having Lukes last name the same as his fathers, when they were trying to hide him!

Leia was Leia Organa, so unless Vader sensed her, he would never suspect her to be his child. Now he hears about Luke Skwalker, who is 20 years old, and Vader remembers impregnating his wife 20 years ago.......put 2 + 2 and it equals 4.

General G
Yeah, that wouldn't make much sense.

queeq
It wouldn't... plus to place him on the very planet Vader comes from... it's like looking for the blatant obvious.

General G
Hehehe, didn't think of that part.

queeq
Really? It's one of the major plotholes in the OT, created by the PT.

Count Makashi
That was explained in RODV, why he didn't want anything to do with his past and Tatooine.

Fardin Vassisk
Yes but he doesnt discover Lukes name until the ESB when the Emperor explains what he wants Vader to do.

Emperor: "There has ben a great disturbance in the force....we have a new enemy, the young rebel who destroyed the Death Star. I have no doubt that this boy is the offspring of; Anakin Skywalker."
Vader: "How is this possible?"
Emperor: "Search your feelings Lord Vader. You will know it to be true."

Something like that............lol This help?

General G
I would say it helps...a little.

queeq
Vader: "how is this possible?"
Emperor: "His surname didn't ring any bells?"

General G
Hehe.

queeq
GL had three movies to fill up the plotholes...instead he made more.

Fardin Vassisk
He is making another three tooo VII, VIII, IX

queeq
No he isn't. He's going to make all new ones in the live action series. wink

Jedireaper
No no no no! That has nothing to do with the next trilogy. 7, 8 & 9 have been slated for a 2019 release but ill check just to make sure. In the name of Sith, the live action is just Tv series, it will have very little to do with the films and Lucas is hoping that his adopted, will continue the trilogy in X, XI, XII which are planned for about 2050 release. I will consult my friend at Lucas Film...he should know....

Darth Subjekt
Jesus Christ - the saga is over movie-wise. He IS NOT making more movies. Go to SS.com to talk about that dumb shit.

Ya know what...provide proof. A link, an article, something saying that he's making more. If its "slated for a 2019 release" it should have something on it somewhere, right? This isn't the 70's where he can mask it by calling it Blue Harvest. So find proof...but i know you wont be able to.

queeq
Movies are over.

General G
Yeah, they are done.

Darth Subjekt
"But my god SS told me that GL is letting him make the movies and so he is and so it'll be really neat!!"

General G
no expression

Darth Subjekt
Making fun of the people that think there's going to be another trilogy cause they read it on SS.com...

queeq
Hehehe

General G
What losers.

Darth Subjekt
indeed...but seriously though, when Lucas is 105 he's gonna make 8 more prequels about the kotor era...

JCapt Jaeh_K.S
Originally posted by queeq
Vader: "how is this possible?"
Emperor: "His surname didn't ring any bells?"

laughing out loud




Lucas would reach a hundred and five?! eek!

Mr Parker
Originally posted by General G
Hehehe, didn't think of that part.

yeah all good points.I never thought of that.Ive always said its so damn obvious that Luke and Leia being brothers and sister was something Lucas just made up at the last minute while making jedi just so han could get the girl and there would be no hard feelings between the two.Now I am also suspecting that Lucas also just made it up in empire to have Vader be his father.

queeq
Ah, no... that was always the plan.

General G
Hehehe.

queeq
Stupid droid.

coolmovies
there wont be 7-9 trilogy

queeq
Of course not.

coolmovies
ameen

queeq
How mean?

General G
You are quite mean.

queeq
*Han Solo voice* I know.

General G
Haha.

*Excellent*

queeq
I know... And I now I close this joint.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.