RotS Mace, RotS Obi-Wan & Rots Anakin vs. RotS Dooku, CW GG, & TPM Maul

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



qui-gon-fanboy
Okay who would win in each category:

Force/Blaster Fight
Saber Duel
All Out

Darth Martin
ROTS Kenobi can take Darth Maul. Mace can take Grievous with Force w/ ease. Anakin and Dooku can go either way. Either Anakin pwns Dooku with the lightsaber or Dooku pwns Anakin with the Force. Either way Jedi take it.

Obi7
In the force/blaster fight, Obi shoots Greivous's guts out, Dooku crushes Anakin and Mace schools Maul. Obi and Mace then use their combined force abilities to snap Dooku.

In the saber duel Anakin would defeat Dooku, Mace could dominate Grevious and Obi-Wan could hold his own against Maul and probably win. If Obi does lose he could probably hold on long enough to allow Mace and Anakin to come and help him finish him off. Same if anakin loses.

Obi7
All out should be basicaly the same result.

Blax_Hydralisk
Maul destroys Obi-Wan and Anakin while Dooku and GG double team Yoda.

Se7in
Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Maul destroys Obi-Wan and Anakin while Dooku and GG double team Yoda.

1. Maul would lose to Obi-Wan or Anakin in a 1-on-1 fight, even more so against both.

2. Yoda? He's not even in this thread.

3. Maul and Grievous would lose to anyone from the first team 1-on-1, therefore the only viable combatant from the second team is Dooku, who would not be able to defeat Mace and any of his other two team members.

Blax_Hydralisk
Originally posted by Se7in
1. Maul would lose to Obi-Wan or Anakin in a 1-on-1 fight, even more so against both.



Not true. Maul defeated Anoon bandaras.

Se7in
Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Not true. Maul defeated Anoon bandaras.

ABC Logic is insufficient. Consider that Anoon Bondara was known to have skills second to none at a time where Jedi Masters such as Qui-Gon Jinn were also considered the finest. Also consider many of the renowned swordsman of the Prequel era were hardly established and experienced. Also consider that Obi-Wan has defeated Maul before as of ROTS, as well as has a completely different style and is much more experienced in both his Force abilities and skills with a blade.

Simply defeating some random Jedi Master who was said to be skilled doesn't warrant immediate victory.

Darth Martin
Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Maul destroys Obi-Wan and Anakin while Dooku and GG double team Yoda. What the f**k?

kiddo44
The jedi certainly win. Dooku is the only one that could fight them well, he beats Kenobi and is even with Mace. CW GG and Maul would one on one lose to all 3 no question. CW GG might be able to fight all 3 fairly well but would lose none the less.

Dooku is really the only threat, to those 3.

Obi7
The Sith would fall with ease. We don't come hear to listen to people overating Maul. The fact that he defeated some random skilled jedi doesn't change the fact that any of these jedi could take him down with their hands, legs,hair (Anakin) or fingers tied behind their back. laughing

Blax_Hydralisk
pffft you're all just a bunch of Maul haters is all.

Man of Christ
Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
pffft you're all just a bunch of Maul haters is all.

any way, as we see in rots (rots anakin>>>rots dooku) also (clone wars or not, grevious can get around obi wans 'insurmountable' soresu so rots obi wan>>>grevious) and maul vs windu? c'mon, some guy who was good at juyo vs the inventor of vaapad who works especially well against darksiders like maul? and hello windu punished palpatine, whos butt maul was on his knees scrubbing his whole life. the jedi take this hands down.

Darth Martin
Tyranus can pwn Anakin with the Force but Anakin would probably win against him with the lightsaber again. Grievous will last longer against Mace than Maul will in a duel but will be defeated nonetheless. But there's nothing really stopping Tyranus from taking Anakin out using the Force like he did Kenobi. It wil take Kenobi like forever to defeat Maul because of his patience with Soresu. But overall this will only just prolong the inevitable. The Sith have a chance but Jedi take it mostly.

Darth Hord
Originally posted by Darth Martin
But there's nothing really stopping Tyranus from taking Anakin out using the Force like he did Kenobi.

He would have to do it before they even lock blades or he will die if no one comes to his aid.

Elite Hunter
Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
pffft you're all just a bunch of Maul haters is all.

Do you remember this Blax? stick out tongue

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
I was exaggerating. But who knows, Sideous may have seen Maul as an opportunity. I'm not saying Maul isn't good, but he's not as good as many on this site say he is, I.E. "curbstomping Rots Fisto" and "Giving Rots Anakin and Oni-Wan a run for there money".

JediSamuraiMRB
This team ftw...


http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh180/DARKCAEDUS/250px-Mace_Windu.jpg
http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh180/DARKCAEDUS/250px-AnakinEstGrumpy.png
http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh180/DARKCAEDUS/Rogue_planet_cover_2.jpg

Darth Martin
Originally posted by JediSamuraiMRB
This team ftw...


http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh180/DARKCAEDUS/250px-Mace_Windu.jpg
http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh180/DARKCAEDUS/250px-AnakinEstGrumpy.png
http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh180/DARKCAEDUS/Rogue_planet_cover_2.jpg pics didn't work

MadMel
yet again erm
anywho, team jedi wins..

DARTH POWER
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Tyranus can pwn Anakin with the Force but Anakin would probably win against him with the lightsaber again. Grievous will last longer against Mace than Maul will in a duel but will be defeated nonetheless. But there's nothing really stopping Tyranus from taking Anakin out using the Force like he did Kenobi. It wil take Kenobi like forever to defeat Maul because of his patience with Soresu. But overall this will only just prolong the inevitable. The Sith have a chance but Jedi take it mostly.

Tyranus taking Anakin out using the Force?? hmm... possible, if he gets a chance he wuld do or use force lightning on him... but he may not get a chance.. but he did it to Obi-Wan in the middle of their lightsaber clashing which was very impressive!! he did the same to Sora Bulq but he used Force lightning on him.. that hand Dooku keeps free in blade fights can be very deadly like Kenobi and Sora bulq found out!

and even if he cant completely take Anakin out with a force move, he might get in a hit with say the force lightning mid fight, which could possibly hurt or weaken him enough to even the odds in the blade fighting.. but all depends on if he gets a chance to do that...

Man of Christ
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Tyranus taking Anakin out using the Force?? hmm... possible, if he gets a chance he wuld do or use force lightning on him... but he may not get a chance.. but he did it to Obi-Wan in the middle of their lightsaber clashing which was very impressive!! he did the same to Sora Bulq but he used Force lightning on him.. that hand Dooku keeps free in blade fights can be very deadly like Kenobi and Sora bulq found out!

and even if he cant completely take Anakin out with a force move, he might get in a hit with say the force lightning mid fight, which could possibly hurt or weaken him enough to even the odds in the blade fighting.. but all depends on if he gets a chance to do that...
lightening which worked on Aotc anakin working on his Rots self? c'mon

DARTH POWER
Originally posted by Man of Christ
lightening which worked on Aotc anakin working on his Rots self? c'mon

??? force lightning can hurt anyone if they get hit by it

darthsith19
Kenobi beats Grievous, Anakin beats Maul, Mace holds off Dooku. Soon, it's Mace, Anakin and Kenobi vs. Dooku and Dooky gets smashed.

truejedi
ever think of Obi-wan and anakin against dooku that way? we always say "Obi-Wan got pwned by dooku in the force during that duel!" but if you think about, Anakin was the one combating dooku at that moment, i think Obi-wan just got done killing the droids or something, I think obi-wan wasn't expecting an attack in the force from dooku, because anakin was SUPPOSED to be pressure on the count, and instead dooku was able to attack Obi-wan at a moment it didn't seem possible he could be attacked with the force.

DARTH POWER
Originally posted by truejedi
ever think of Obi-wan and anakin against dooku that way? we always say "Obi-Wan got pwned by dooku in the force during that duel!" but if you think about, Anakin was the one combating dooku at that moment, i think Obi-wan just got done killing the droids or something, I think obi-wan wasn't expecting an attack in the force from dooku, because anakin was SUPPOSED to be pressure on the count, and instead dooku was able to attack Obi-wan at a moment it didn't seem possible he could be attacked with the force.

Well thats just part of the fight.. Dooku wasnt expecting Anakin to get him in an armlock either.. Dooku was just superior to Obi-Wan... I mean he did that move while simultaneously lightsaber clashing with Obi-Wan and kicking Anakin away!!! "Impressive! Most Impressive!!"

hes superior to both Obi-Wan and Anakin with his use of the Force(during ROTS) so it should be expected that he will use that to his advantage when he can..

On that note if Dooku pulls something like that off in this fight, then suddenly we would have 3 vs. 2 and the baddies will have a Much improved chance of winning this!

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.