Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

So who wins

WWH put down Sentry,

and rocked the east cost with one stomp.

Captain Atom is Captain Atom, a powerhouse in his own right.

Neutral setting let's get it on.

I think Captain atom wins.

Just to versatile and has the definitive speed advantage.

newjak peaches

Hulk wins, absorbs CA's energy and become a celestial.

Originally posted by Mindset
Hulk wins, absorbs CA's energy and become a celestial.
Is that possible?

I think the Hulk has absorbed strange energy before to become stronger hasn't he?

Originally posted by Fuzzy Hawkeye
newjak peaches Red uhuh

Originally posted by Newjak
So who wins

WWH put down Sentry,

and rocked the east cost with one stomp.

Captain Atom is Captain Atom, a powerhouse in his own right.

Neutral setting let's get it on. dur

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Yeah because the argument was



We all know Captain Atom was not using his powers with KMC efficiency in their fight so I simply pointed out why that's not so impressive to WWH.

Captain Atom was holding back. That's hardly relevant if you want to speak in terms of a fight between Hulk and Captain Atom.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Captain Atom was actually in character, in character Captain Atom doesn't possess the power to put down WWH.

Captain Atom was holding back because Angie was his girlfriend. The only way this argument would hold any weight is if Banner and Nathaniel started dating.

Then, I'd say you have a point. Captain Atom fighting in character = more than enough to take out Hulk.

I also saw that you mentioned Captain Atom vs. Mary Marvel. And I guess you neglected to mention the fact that Atom was brainwashed in that case, so there goes your "fighting in character" argument.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
OOC Captain Atom uses a trick he just discovered 2 years ago to put him down.

Atomic manipulation is hardly necessary when energy absorption will suffice.

And that's not even close to being out of character. In fact, it's one of his main abilities, which is why I said that Captain Atom is custom made to take down Hulk ala Silver Surfer.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Then you commence the Captain Atom street team trumping Monarch feats like they mean something.

I wasn't the one who brought up Monarch. Monarch v. Hulk is overkill.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
You mean, where everybody fights like they normally do.

If it helps you sleep at night...

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
Well considering Greg Pak has the ability to actually make events canon, I tend to give him more leeway/credibility then online fans.

This makes absolutely no sense. It'd be like asking Rob Liefeld to write a Spectre story.

Pak has probably never read a Captain Atom story in his life, and will never be the author of a Captain Atom title. Therefore, his opinion isn't anymore justified than your average schmo.

Guarantee you that I know more about Nathaniel than he does.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
IOW, out of character.

False. Out of character would be for Captain Atom to go h2h against Hulk while neglecting his energy manipulation powers. That's the only way Hulk would have a legitimate shot at defeating Atom.

In character, Atom rapes Hulk. On KMC, Atom rapes Hulk. Out of character, Atom rapes Hulk. The way Papa Smurph wants Nathaniel to be portrayed... eh, I guess Hulk wins. srug

does batdude intentionally say the opposite of the correct answer when he debates?

Considering you mentioned Hulk at World Breaker Levels not even KMC Captain Atom could take him.

Hulk in a brutal stomp 10/10.

If he even TOUCHES Captain Atom, CA would be KO'd.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
does batdude intentionally say the opposite of the correct answer when he debates?

Considering you mentioned Hulk at World Breaker Levels not even KMC Captain Atom could take him.

Hulk in a brutal stomp 10/10.

If he even TOUCHES Captain Atom, CA would be KO'd. http://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g79/hazelanimenut/magicfail7sv.png

You are well on your way to becoming the worst debator on KMC. doped

LMFAOx(1/0)

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
You are well on your way to becoming the worst debator on KMC. doped He's just got to lose to yo... oh wait... he has.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
does batdude intentionally say the opposite of the correct answer when he debates?

Considering you mentioned Hulk at World Breaker Levels not even KMC Captain Atom could take him.

Hulk in a brutal stomp 10/10.

If he even TOUCHES Captain Atom, CA would be KO'd.

Great use of evidence and debating.

Hulk is the strongest there is, that's canon.

WWH taps into the power of Dragonforce and sends him through the Fire and Flames.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
He's just got to lose to yo... oh wait... he has. oh snap!

Hulk has unlimited power.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Great use of evidence and debating.

What evidence and debating? I pointed out Captain Atom would lose to WWH in WWH (and it's obvious he would) so SmurphSmash!'s ABC claim of Engineer > Captain Atom > WWH holds no water.

I don't see where the argument is besides batdude ducking theoreticals and applying board rules to Comics.

I'm noticing that papa smurph, tricksterpriest, batdude 123, and symmentric chaos are a volatile combination.

I love all my fans/children the same.

to bad it's not mutual.

So who did WWh at World Breaker levels ko again? All i remember was a satellite owning him.

Oh most of them are just butthurt over lost debates.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
What evidence and debating?

Holy failure to see sarcasm Batman!

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
I pointed out Captain Atom would lose to WWH in WWH (and it's obvious he would)

No you assume he would. It didn't happen and Hulk lost in the end. Pak could easily have written WWH with Atom involved and had Nate be the one that blasted him into the ground at the end.

You're making baseless, meaningless assumptions.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
I don't see where the argument is besides batdude ducking theoreticals and applying board rules to Comics.

Crazy isn't he? It's like he thinks we're on a forum or something.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
I'm noticing that papa smurph, tricksterpriest, batdude 123, and symmentric chaos are a volatile combination.

Nah

Didn't Pr just locked his CA vs WWH thread because it took one post and CA won?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos




Crazy isn't he? It's like he thinks we're on a forum or something.



Yeah, and we're arguing about portrayals in comics, we're not arguing powersets, we're dipping into character and intention now, which goes a bit beyond the feat hunting "debates" that these things typically devolve into and require a lil bit of critical thinking. Pak wouldn't have written Captain Atom to beat Hulk and you know it shoooot most of the arc was devoted to hyping up a Sentry/Hulk climax and it was OBVIOUS that, that was the only person who would take him.

Calling out Pak's credibility doesn't really mean much because when writers write the comics they aren't thinking about _____ (feat/rarely used ability/obscure fact from 5 years ago), they're thinking about the average portrayal.

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
I love all my fans/children the same. Irony from the name stealing stalker troll.

Captain Atom wins.

Originally posted by Mindset
Hulk has unlimited power.

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y37/Nightmareman95/HAL10WEEN/unlimitedpower1.png

Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
WWH taps into the power of Dragonforce and sends him through the Fire and Flames.

thought somebody should acknowledge it.

WB would win but normal wwh would lose on account of energy absorption

Originally posted by Papa Smurph
What evidence and debating? I pointed out Captain Atom would lose to WWH in WWH (and it's obvious he would) Yup...

Their jus beeing teh retardz!! durfist

Originally posted by endrict
Didn't Pr just locked his CA vs WWH thread because it took one post and CA won?

and i didnt want to have to close this one too, but, well, sorry newjak...