Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I'm tired of that blasted magneto and his freakish power. i want something that can penetrat that forcefiled of his. you think a green ring on the most creative guy on the planet could do it?

*side question who's forcefield is stronger invisble woman's or magneto's?*

ok i know a landslide is goning for magneto so skip this and answer my orignal question.

GREEN LANTERN VS. MAGNETO

*side question #2 has green lantern's yellow flaw been dealt with by a writer or is i t still the stupidest weakness in thworld? (yellow items)?*

id take magneto. i dont see g.l. defending him self agaisnt the onslaught of metal led attack from magneto.

yeah the long running joke is someone could just chuck a schoolbus at green latern.

but he wass the one the writers chose to face silver sufer in the dc vs marvel. so he might stand a change no?

1. Magneto when he was at optimum strength could defnitely beat G.L., but that also depends on which Lantern. I think Kyle Rayner would have the best chance.

2. Magneto's force field is stronger than Invisible Woman's.

3. Magneto kicks serious butt no matter how you look at it.

uh...i dont think so. surfer dispensed him so easily, made him look bad. that tarnished him in my mind forever

no way he would overcome the Surfer

not a chance.

Bojangles
2. Magneto's force field is stronger than Invisible Woman's.

Stronger? Sue broke through a Celestial's armor with her force field.

GL wins it, no doubt. And the GL/surfer fight was ok. GL did not go out like a chump.

magneto can beat the lantern any day, if they write well the story

Magneto could always use his blood trick, you know, stopping or reversing the blood in a person's body by using their iron content...

lol.
Anyways, Wouldnt magneto be able ot just take over silver surfer? Or are we talking about the lead surfer? Cause... last time I checked silver is a metal... and if his whole body is covered in it...

very true

surfer operates at a differnte level he is a cosmic being, i doubt magneto could controll him, althoug it kinda makes some sense, if he did, but maybe the cosmic power is able to protect him.

MAYBE... But still, I can see magneto scrapping him up, and turning him into a doggy for a little boy.

im talking about Magneto at his full strength. at full strength, his is stronger

magneto is one of most powerful mutants on the plant. and gl cant take a twinkie. so that is my answer.

No, they got rid of that weakness, the ring isn't weak to yellow anymore.

so he can finally take a cab. he must be very thankful he can go downtown so much easier now.

LOLOL, the guy who invented the yelow thing on the GL ring should receive an award.
And now the winner for the most ridiculous thing invented in comics is................

WHAT? Not even.

i dont think magneto could stand the strain from trying to match invis. women's force field strength.

magneto

Bojangles
2. Magneto's force field is stronger than Invisible Woman's.

Stronger? Sue broke through a Celestial's armor with her force field.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

im talking about Magneto at his full strength. at full strength, his is stronger

NOOOOO. If your using Magneto at full strength try to argue it as being superior to Sue who isn't at full strength, then why in the hell even try to make an argument? Your simply stating that Magneto's force field is far inferior to that of Sue's that we can only put him above her if we're using him with full strength.

Here's how I see it:

You: Magneto's force field > Sue's

Me: No, no that's wrong. Sue's force field > Magnus'

You: No, I meant at full power. Magneto's (at full power) force field > Sue's

Me: Sue's (at full power) force field > Magneto's (at full power)

Conclusion: Sue's force field > Magneto's force field

Going back to Magneto v.s. Silver Surfer, Magneto's powers wouldn't work. He should only be able to control ferrous metals (iron, cobalt and nickel). Other metals, like silver, are unaffected by magnetism.

No Chilled, that's not how his powers work. He CONTROLS electromagnetism, which is a fundamental force of nature. ALL matter has positively and negatively charged particles in them(there's a name for the particles, but it's slipped my mind). In magnets, the particles are seperated, and each end of the object has a different charge. In ferrous metals, the charged particlesare placed a bit more randomly, but are still pretty seperated, thats why it's easy to make them magnetic. In other metals, the charged particles are even more randomly placed, but notice, it's still effected by electricity, an essential product of electro-magnetism. Magneto can use his powers to draw one type of charged particle(i.e. positively charged particles) to one side of the object, making it temporarily magnetic.

ALL matter has these particles, essentially, with enough concentration, Magneto can magnetize a peice of rubber, which seemingly has NO magnetic or electircal properties.

very good, one more to join the group of people that knows that magneto can do much more then control metal.

Ah, I see now. Thanks for clearing that up.

By the way, the term for +ve and -ve particles are protons and electrons.

Yea, protons and electrons, I wasn't sure if those were the names at first, but they were right there on the tip of my tongue. Thanks for the reassurance.

this is like science class all over again.

GL WINS.

flawless victory

magneto whould kill him quick

eleveninches has been voting for Gl over any oponents with no reason what so ever.

Power of imagination against electromagnetism, i mean...

Of course you be the ass-hole and say well..well magneto is God and can tear the iron out of Gl's blood, of course you would have to be ass-hole that exxagerates every single comic characters ability way past it's potential Then again i guess Gl is alien, and doubt that he even has iron, probably plastic in his blood

Magneto wins by tearing the iron out of GL's blood.

Oops.

Superman Blue once used his electromagnetic powers to somehow block the neuron receptions in his brain thus rendering him powerless to operate his ring because his brain was all kaplooey.

Originally posted by demigawd
Magneto wins by tearing the iron out of GL's blood.

Oops.

dude, magneto can do that? holy crap

ok he open a wormhole and puts him in one with all the force his got.

LMAO

Originally posted by ragesRemorse
dude, magneto can do that? holy crap

Yep. But im not sure if GL putting a force feilds around himself would stop it. Anyone else know?

Didn't help against Superman Blue or Dr. Polaris.

Originally posted by demigawd
Didn't help against Superman Blue or Dr. Polaris.

Ouch. Nuff said lol. And im a GL fan too. Maybe Hal could pull it off. Hes the most resourcefull and powerfull GL ever. Not so sure about Kyle. We have to remember that Magneto using the iron in the blood technique would be last resort. Hal may finish him quick, but i think Kyle would waste time thus getting Mags angry enough to use that tactic. IMO.

Wasn't a last resort when Mags nailed the Avengers. It was the first attack. Also wasn't a last resort when Mags held X-men, X-Force, X-Factor in stasis at the exact same time while lecturing. Wasn't a last resort during Eve of Destruction, either. In fact, it was pretty much always his first attack.

Mags is pretty efficient.

Uhh I was ferreing to him ripping the iron out of peoples blood. Ive never seem that as a first attack. Holding ppl in place is totaly different.

Oh, yeah, true, true. But hell...if you latch on to someone's blood, you can do anything you want, and it doesn't necessarily have to be lethal. He's put people to sleep, or mind-controlled them that way before.

Originally posted by demigawd
Oh, yeah, true, true. But hell...if you latch on to someone's blood, you can do anything you want, and it doesn't necessarily have to be lethal. He's put people to sleep, or mind-controlled them that way before.

Once again we agree. I just think that if he were fighting Hal it might be able to go either way. That just might be the Hal fanboy in me talking cause im glad hes back now.

lol. I'm sure there are situations in which a writer can write anyone to beat anyone else, so, why not?

He has new comic coming out. It's gonna be called Green Lantern: Reborn. It comes out in May 2005. It's going to be written by Geoff Johns and Carlos Pacheco

current magneto VS green lantern

Originally posted by stormfront13
current magneto VS green lantern

interesting match (if it hasnt been done before...)

but one thing stormfront, you have to state which green lantern...

oh lol um... how bout hal jordan and i searched it and nothing came up

Originally posted by stormfront13
oh lol um... how bout hal jordan and i searched it and nothing came up

Alright then...

Well after Magneto's recent power up he is super powerful... i don't know if he could take Hal...

i'd say he could maybe. they both seem super powerful so it's be a good match imo

i'd say magneto might prevail

Originally posted by stormfront13
i'd say he could maybe. they both seem super powerful so it's be a good match imo

You don't know anything about Hal Jordan, except what you've read online. Please don't post fights with only one character you understand.

what is ur problem?? i know plenty about hal jordan and the ring- you obviously don't know much about the new magneto

Why do you say that? I never said anything about the fight at all. Stop assuming things.

and neither did i- stop assuming things(hypocrit)

wow nataku and stormfront get along worse then stormfront and alphacenturi LOL

Green Latern would prevail.

New Magneto

new magneto will shut his mind.

Rip him to bits.

and then dumb him in a blackhole.

LMAo

and ya he has a shield rite Magneto will break that too.

Whats up with Magneto's new power levels? Same old magnetism but amplified? I am curious.

I think he eventually "subconciously held back because of guilt" so many times that his powers went from controlling magnetism to controlling everything. It went from just controlling metal to controlling the charges on an atomic level to controlling everything related to magnetism (which seems to be everything) and now to just anything.

It's funny because many a-years ago I read a theory that Magneto was actually a very powerful telekinetic but because of his terrible childhood it manifested as "magnetism". Back then I thought "no way, that just make him stupidly powerful"

Green Lantern would win.

Because I SAID SO!!!!

green lantern

Hal.

Maggie wins easily. No reason why GL should win.

Magneto ripped Apocalypse to shreds with magnetic fields alone. He'd do the same to a GL.

I think you know what I'm going to say. But just to be creative - he takes over Hal's mind and makes him blast himself with his ring.

Is the ring made of metal? Wouldn't Magneto just be able to pull it off his hand? Then again, can't GL control the ring when he's not wearing it? Correct me if I'm wrong.

Magneto with ease.

Hal or Kyle (or even john, with his guardian power) could beat Maggie with ease

do you know aboutn the new ,agneto w/ the power upgrade or whatever its called??

he is the stupidest piece of crap a writer could have thought up with. Next he will be made an avatar of the Phoenix Force. Their is no Xman that can beat him. what is the point of having a villian so insanely powerful none can stand up to him.

God-like Cable will beat him

well hes not there anymore is he?

Yeah, I think they realized that current Magneto is waaaaay beyond the X-men. He's still currently a good guy and not doing much fighting. But when the House of M starts, he's going to be going against the likes of Sentry, Dr. Strange, the Avengers and X-men at the same time.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Maggie wins easily. No reason why GL should win.

Magneto ripped Apocalypse to shreds with magnetic fields alone. He'd do the same to a GL. Yeah, I can't think of any magnetic powered villians in the DC world so the lanterns don't have to worry about people ripping open their life supporting metallic suits.

Besides, the ring would protect them from that.

After thinking about it i gotta go with Hal... he's cosmic level, Magneto even with his power boost is still slightly below that imo...

It all depends on the surroundings imo, but more often than not i'd go with Hal...

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
Yeah, I can't think of any magnetic powered villians in the DC world so the lanterns don't have to worry about people ripping open their life supporting metallic suits.

Besides, the ring would protect them from that.

Hal: Behold how your flying metal debris flies harmlessly off my shield!

Magneto: ****Lower your shield****

Hal: ok

Magneto: Kill yourself

Hal: Sure, boss.

waht about
dr. polaris, who's his arch enemy?

Originally posted by demigawd
Hal: Behold how your flying metal debris flies harmlessly off my shield!

Magneto: ****Lower your shield****

Hal: ok

Magneto: Kill yourself

Hal: Sure, boss. If GL shields couldn't block telepathy I'd say GL just got mindtricked.

Plus the ring would prevent that.

Magneto is A LOT more powerful than Dr. Polaris. GL shields have never really impressed me - every time I read an issue they're getting smashed. Mags control over the EM spectrum allows him to sense whatever is getting through the shield. For example - light. Magneto can then generate light to go through the shield, then once it's inside the shield, convert it to lethal radiation.

Current Magneto doesn't even have to work that hard. He controls reality...oops, no more shield, no more ring, no more Hal.

Magneto doesnt have COMPLETE controll over the EM spectrum, otherwise he would have been able to stop a sentinal from destroying genosha

When did hal go cosmic level? You talking about his spectre form? I am familiar with the Green Lanterns, and they are tough. I refer to kyle or John because I actually like those two. The others or just creepy. Guy "I am not a third rate hero" Gardner. And Hal "please forgive me for my sins against the universe and make me a hero again" Jordan. Anyway, a green lantern is equivalent to magneto's current power level or right under it. Kyle--teleportation, and containing an exploding star. John, destroying a planet, building machines that can do whatever he thinks of, and taking out fenris after he kicked the JLA's collective buts. But magneto has always been able to amp up his power level by tapping into earths magnetic grid. When push comes to shove magneto can surpass anyone.

magneto was week when the sentinals attacked. The question was about current magneto, who is anything but weak

I'm just saying Magneto can't make a GL kill themselves because the ring prevents them from killing AND does its best to protect the GL from mortal harm.

Originally posted by eleveninches
Magneto doesnt have COMPLETE controll over the EM spectrum, otherwise he would have been able to stop a sentinal from destroying genosha

Magneto was stuck in a wheelchair at a Genoshan hospital at the time. He only had enough power to stay alive.

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
I'm just saying Magneto can't make a GL kill themselves because the ring prevents them from killing AND does its best to protect the GL from mortal harm.

ok, fair enough. Lots of other ways to make GL die...

Especially when the the pride of your Magneto's on the line, eh?

*shrug* I'm not that worried, lol.

am tried of the will power bullshit.

Mag wins

Hal WINS!!!

who takes this?

Magneto wins

Depends.

Which Lantern? Some are a bit more experienced than others.

the average normal one

magento losses come on be real people and by the way his bac http://dccomics.com/comics/?cm=4153

Kilowog is bac thats so ****ing cool his one of my fav GL

An 'average' Green Lantern?

Are you familiar with their books?

You mean like John or Hal league, or like Ch'p and Kilowog league? Either way, if they put there mind to it (and finished things within a reasonable amount of time), they could take Magneto. Some less than most though. Magneto's not the greatest when it comes to physical stamina, if a GL could form a vice around his energy field and exert enough force on his shield, it would wear him out. And with a GL's protective aura, I'm not sure the iron in the blood trick would work. If he can instantly place a black hole within someone's brain or something like that, I'd be more inclined to take him over a GL. As is, a well trained GL can probably stalemate Mags if they went all out, and a high end GL would take him with much less effort, but not easily.

But then again, that's all dependent on if the Power of Oa isn't within the realm of the EM spectrum. If it is, they might actually be in trouble against Mags. I know Oan power can substitute for and create energies within the EM spectrum, and these energies can be used energies to recharge a GL Ring if necessary, but I'm not sure Oan Power is wholely an EM based energy source, if at all.

Hope that doesn't confuse you too much.

Oan energy is part of the EM spectrum, apparently, since Photon was able to absorb and process it. If that's the case, all GL's are in serious trouble against Magneto.

GL Hal (the best of them) was narrowly beaten by Dr. Polaris, and Polaris didn't even try any of the Magneto tricks.

Magneto also controls light, he could easily blast a GL with yellow-colored radiation, which would go right through the shields. Remember, yellow weakness is back.

^ Interesting.

That answers my question then. If the Oan Power is part of the EM Spectrum, a GL is in trouble against Magneto (or Surfer). He can counter all of their attacks, and go through their shields to pull off the old "forcibly remove the iron in their blood" technique (at least on some of the Humanoid GLs, some don't have iron in their body composition).

Yellow is only a weakness for newbie Lanterns. Any of the big 4 wouldn't have trouble with it.

Originally posted by demigawd
Oan energy is part of the EM spectrum, apparently, since Photon was able to absorb and process it. If that's the case, all GL's are in serious trouble against Magneto.

GL Hal (the best of them) was narrowly beaten by Dr. Polaris, and Polaris didn't even try any of the Magneto tricks.

Magneto also controls light, he could easily blast a GL with yellow-colored radiation, which would go right through the shields. Remember, yellow weakness is back.

Oan Energy is NOT part of the EM spectrum. It's connected to the Presence itself. It CAN however become any type of energy it wants. Light is it's most common form.

The third part of arguement is null since Magneto doesn't KNOW that GLs are vulnerable to yellow themed attacks.

A GL can counter anything Mags does. ESPECIALLY now that the A.I. is back.

Or using his imagination, he'll locate the mutagenic gene in Magneto and turn off his powers.

Originally posted by Draco69
Oan Energy is NOT part of the EM spectrum. It's connected to the
Or using his imagination, he'll locate the mutagenic gene in Magneto and turn off his powers.

he coud do that?

The ring can do anything. GL's are seriously written to about 5% of their potential. There's alot more to it than making giant green hands.

dude you guys are crazy magneto would murder green lantern...he'd just pick up some cars or somethin and chunk em at em n crush em

"There's alot more to it than making giant green hands."

yeah, like making giant green spoons and forks

those energy utensils are so handy

Originally posted by braz
dude you guys are crazy magneto would murder green lantern...he'd just pick up some cars or somethin and chunk em at em n crush em
Yes! That would most definitely work. Magneto 10/10

Originally posted by Draco69
Oan Energy is NOT part of the EM spectrum. It's connected to the Presence itself. It CAN however become any type of energy it wants. Light is it's most common form.

The third part of arguement is null since Magneto doesn't KNOW that GLs are vulnerable to yellow themed attacks.

A GL can counter anything Mags does. ESPECIALLY now that the A.I. is back.

Or using his imagination, he'll locate the mutagenic gene in Magneto and turn off his powers.

If it weren't capable of being processed via EM manipulation, Photon wouldn't have been able to take out Guy the way she did. Booster Gold did something similar. If Photon could do it, I have no doubt Magneto could.

The yellow weakness is there for all green lanterns. a GL with sufficient will could overcome it. What that means is if Magneto were to put up a yellow forcefield, a good GL could break through it regardless of it being yellow. But that doesn't apply to a sudden yellow attack, which wouldn't be subject to willpower overcoming it. It would just cut through it.

Remember board rules, too. Characters have knowledge of each other's abilities and limitations as long as it's generally known. The opponent would know Superman is weak to K-nite, but not that Superman is Clark Kent, for example.

Magneto could just penetrate the shield and cause the GL's brain to cease functioning.

Originally posted by demigawd
If it weren't capable of being processed via EM manipulation, Photon wouldn't have been able to take out Guy the way she did. Booster Gold did something similar. If Photon could do it, I have no doubt Magneto could.

This is based on the very same crossover where Hawkeye took out Captain Atom with a containment arrow. And where Wonder Woman, She-Hulk, and Hipployta managed to defeat Surtur.

Crossovers are bull.

And Booster Gold's forcefield is YELLOW. He didn't absorb it. He deflected it.


Originally posted by demigawd
The yellow weakness is there for all green lanterns. a GL with sufficient will could overcome it. What that means is if Magneto were to put up a yellow forcefield, a good GL could break through it regardless of it being yellow. But that doesn't apply to a sudden yellow attack, which wouldn't be subject to willpower overcoming it. It would just cut through it.

A GL is vulnerable to yellow. But it simply doesn't matter. Green Lantern is simply to versatile for Magneto. While Magneto is limited to the laws of physics, GL is limited only to his imagination.

Originally posted by demigawd
Magneto could just penetrate the shield and cause the GL's brain to cease functioning.

So could GL. Or he could turn off his powers. Or he could whip out an "anti-magnetic" ray. Or he could put a forcefield inside Magneto's head and cause it to explode.

Really there's so many options GL has at it's disposal. The ring can do anything the ringbearer wants it to.

Originally posted by Draco69
This is based on the very same crossover where Hawkeye took out Captain Atom with a containment arrow. And where Wonder Woman, She-Hulk, and Hipployta managed to defeat Surtur.

Crossovers are bull.


But it IS canon, so it DID happen, so when looking for evidence about the nature of Oan energy and its reactivity to other forms of energy, that's fair game. As it stands, an EM person tried to manipulate it in canon and was successful in doing so...in canon.



The feedback was mighty painful for mere deflection. No reason Magneto couldn't do the exact same thing. He's made blue and gray forcefields before to block people's ability to see into it.




But the laws of physics to the extent Magneto controls it with his intelligence and ruthlessness are more than enough to take out a GL long before they do the same to Magneto.



Magneto can turn off GL's ability to access his powers. Or take control of the oan energy, a la Photon, or turn the GL's own body against him. There are lots of options at Magneto's disposal too, and he can enact them instantly.

Originally posted by demigawd
But it IS canon, so it DID happen, so when looking for evidence about the nature of Oan energy and its reactivity to other forms of energy, that's fair game. As it stands, an EM person tried to manipulate it in canon and was successful in doing so...in canon.

Canon? WW defeating SURTUR?! As much as I like that notion, I still say bull****

Also this was Kyle. Without A.I. rings.



Originally posted by demigawd
The feedback was mighty painful for mere deflection. No reason Magneto couldn't do the exact same thing. He's made blue and gray forcefields before to block people's ability to see into it.

Of course it was powerful. Once a villain had a yellow stopsign that deflected the energy right back at him. Because it was YELLOW.




Originally posted by demigawd
But the laws of physics to the extent Magneto controls it with his intelligence and ruthlessness are more than enough to take out a GL long before they do the same to Magneto.

Says who? All GL has to do is think. And Magneto's down in the dust. Anything thrown at him can be absorbed. Anything attempted will be countered.

And now that the A.I. is back the victory is that much easier since the ring will automatically counter anything attempted against GL.





Originally posted by demigawd
Magneto can turn off GL's ability to access his powers.

How? Even the Primodial Sun couldn't accomplish that. GL ring finds mutagenic gene in a tenth of picosecond. GL ring turns of mutagenic gene.

Originally posted by demigawd
Or take control of the oan energy, a la Photon,

That also isn't happening. Anti-Monitor and the Starheart tried that. And failed miserably.

Originally posted by demigawd
or turn the GL's own body against him.

If you mean deciding to do a nude strip and causing GL to spontaneosly combust, sure.

But no. The ring will protect him since they already have millions of counterinitiatives.

Originally posted by demigawd
There are lots of options at Magneto's disposal too, and he can enact them instantly.

Magneto's options are futile and limited. GL's options are limitless and effective.

And what in hell makes you think Magneto will be quicker on the draw?

Originally posted by Draco69
Canon? WW defeating SURTUR?! As much as I like that notion, I still say bull****


WW's lasso tied up Surtur. In theory, even he wouldn't be able to get out of it. I'm fine with that, actually.



Which means nothing. Oan energy is oan energy. Got effected by an EM manipulator. End of story.



Indeed? That's a damn shame. Too bad Magneto can't make things yellow.

Oh wait!



Didn't work particularly well for Hal against Dr. Polaris, did it? And as I recall, Polaris owned the entire JLA during Emperor Joker. That's right - GL AND the rest of the league. What's one GL against that?



When does the AI do that? In Hal's new series, the AI advises him, but doesn't automatically fight for him.




The Primordial who?

I don't believe GL's work that fast. I've never seen it. Magneto, on the other hand, is ruthlessly fast. As for who is going to disable who first? I have no doubt that goes to Magneto.



It's not how powerful you are, it's the nature of your power. Anti-Monitor and Starheart don't do the same thing Photon and Magneto do. So the comparison is invalid. A Manhunter drained Hal dry last issue. So what?



No, I'm talking about taking over his nervous system and its electrical impulses, as soon as he bypasses the oan energy field, which would be instant because EM manipulators can do that.



Didn't do much good against Polaris last time.




Evidence says otherwise. But you're welcome to think that.



It's what he does best. He takes people out instantly. He was fast enough to block an attack by Galactus that moved at the speed of thought. That's fast.

Originally posted by demigawd




Indeed? That's a damn shame. Too bad Magneto can't make things yellow.

Oh wait!

What is he gonna make that is yellow?

A casket for his body?

hello crossovers are bull. They aren't good. They decide who should win beforehand and then they tell the writers to make stories that make "sense". Examples of this "sense" is Lobo being beaten by Wolverine, Storm beating WW, Superman getting his buttocks handed to him by Venom, and there are countless more.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
What is he gonna make that is yellow?

A casket for his body?

With designs and everything.

i like the super old not ring but latern one lmao but really too me mi fav green latern is the 4th one

Originally posted by snoopdogg
What is he gonna make that is yellow?

A casket for his body?

Yes, yes, I've seen that one before and already explained it in my other post. If Magneto made a yellow forcefield, I'm sure Hal could now get through it. It's a function of willpower, as your own scans say. How's that going to help a sudden burst from behind? No willpower involved. there. Sorry, doesn't help.

Originally posted by Superherovandal
hello crossovers are bull. They aren't good. They decide who should win beforehand and then they tell the writers to make stories that make "sense". Examples of this "sense" is Lobo being beaten by Wolverine, Storm beating WW, Superman getting his buttocks handed to him by Venom, and there are countless more.

This isn't like any other crossover. This is a crossover acknowledged by both companies as being canon.

Originally posted by legacy92
i like the super old not ring but latern one lmao but really too me mi fav green latern is the 4th one

...

Originally posted by demigawd
Yes, yes, I've seen that one before and already explained it in my other post. If Magneto made a yellow forcefield, I'm sure Hal could now get through it. It's a function of willpower, as your own scans say. How's that going to help a sudden burst from behind? No willpower involved. there. Sorry, doesn't help.





... Im willing to bet you dont read much GL.

I could be wrong though.

GL wins. Mags has little chance.
A weapon limited by your imagination is nothing to sneer at.
GL puts mags in a field that limits his powers altogether.
Turns off his mutant gene.
Sucks MAGS himself into a wormhole.
Turns mags shields into confetti while a GL imaginary Hulk beats Mags down.
Etc Etc...

Originally posted by Superherovandal
hello crossovers are bull. They aren't good. They decide who should win beforehand and then they tell the writers to make stories that make "sense". Examples of this "sense" is Lobo being beaten by Wolverine, Storm beating WW, Superman getting his buttocks handed to him by Venom, and there are countless more.

Photon absorbing and manpulating OA energy happened in the JLA/Avengers crossover. A crossover said by Juntai, Ion, Whirly and the gang is canon. According to 2 sentences in an Avengers glossary and Busiek's comments.

Photon can manipulate OA, so can Mags. According to Whirly, it's canon.

This battle could go either way.

Kyle also absorbed the power of a Cosmic Cube in that issue also..........................

This battle is pretty interesting.

I think Magneto's abilities are nigh-limitless themselves. I mean, think about it. Think about all the powers he has. He might as well have limitless possibilities with as much as he can do. So don't think he's got like two moves to utilize.

And as stated before, Mags has been well-known for his quick-incapacitating of his enemies. As soon as the green light shines for the start of the match, Magneto would've already found a way to cripple the GL.

Does no one remember that Magneto can also create wormholes?

Magneto is just much more ruthless, too. Don't get me wrong, I love Green Lantern and think he's amazing and could take out 95% of both Marvel and DC characters, just not Magneto. Not as powerful as Magneto is.

So I'd have to give this fight to Magneto, 7.5/10

A GL could simply do this to mags in addition to what I said in my earlier post.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/avalonofthewind/Respectkyle.jpg


Absorb Mags own energy and convert it to sound, cosmic energy, or water against him...basically whatever he wishes.

GL's are cosmic policemen...their rings can do just about anything for a reason... on a universal scale you have to be ready for whatever you come up against. Mags is a powerful earth villain, but his power pales next to a good GL.

What is the GL ring made of?

A metal, I'm guessing. Correct?

Since I believe that it is indeed a metal, could Magneto not just pull it right off of his finger INSTANTLY as soon as the fight begins? And I mean like...INSTANTLY. Before GL can do anything.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
What is the GL ring made of?

A metal, I'm guessing. Correct?

Since I believe that it is indeed a metal, could Magneto not just pull it right off of his finger INSTANTLY as soon as the fight begins? And I mean like...INSTANTLY. Before GL can do anything.

Rings have auto defense against that type of thing and can be willed back to the owner if the owner took it off for some reason.

Check the GL ring vs Quantum band thread.

Remember, the ring could let u do just about anything you want.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Rings have auto defense against that type of thing and can be willed back to the owner if the owner took it off for some reason.

Check the GL ring vs Quantum band thread.

Remember, the ring could let u do just about anything you want.

I didn't doubt that there was a way for it to be willed back actually. I agree with you there. But look at it in my point of view. If Magneto basically ripped it off his finger, he would have SUCH a firm and ultra powerful hold on it, I don't think the GL would have a chance of retrieving it. ESPECIALLY if it's metal. This is Magneto, afterall.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
I didn't doubt that there was a way for it to be willed back actually. I agree with you there. But look at it in my point of view. If Magneto basically ripped it off his finger, he would have SUCH a firm and ultra powerful hold on it, I don't think the GL would have a chance of retrieving it. ESPECIALLY if it's metal. This is Magneto, afterall.

It's a great thought, but the ring has auto protection against such things..plus GL's have a protective barrier around them. That trick won't work.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/avalonofthewind/glcantloselims5xz.jpg

It seems to me that the robot there has the upper hand. And is actually absorbing GL's power? I assume that's what "Power retrieval" refers to. So...that's not very good for your argument. Although it did prove that the ring would be pretty much impossible to get off. Unless you absorb his power. Which is what I believe Magneto can do if he wanted to.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
It seems to me that the robot there has the upper hand. And is actually absorbing GL's power? I assume that's what "Power retrieval" refers to. So...that's not very good for your argument. Although it did prove that the ring would be pretty much impossible to get off. Unless you absorb his power. Which is what I believe Magneto can do if he wanted to.

That scan was meant to show that the ring isn't coming off. If we are going to use a full potential Mags, then it's only fair to use a GL at full potential. GL outclasses him in every way. Did you know a GL ring has even brought the dead to life? Thats how powerful they are. He could contain Mags, turn off Mags power, absorb mags shield. Its basically like if Mags fought Surfer....but even worse.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/avalonofthewind/Respectkyle.jpg

Originally posted by Metalmanx
It seems to me that the robot there has the upper hand. And is actually absorbing GL's power? I assume that's what "Power retrieval" refers to. So...that's not very good for your argument. Although it did prove that the ring would be pretty much impossible to get off. Unless you absorb his power. Which is what I believe Magneto can do if he wanted to. A couple of pages later Hal absorbed the power back that the Manhunter took from him........................

Originally posted by Sentry
Photon absorbing and manpulating OA energy happened in the JLA/Avengers crossover. A crossover said by Juntai, Ion, Whirly and the gang is canon. According to 2 sentences in an Avengers glossary and Busiek's comments.

Photon can manipulate OA, so can Mags. According to Whirly, it's canon.

This battle could go either way.

Not his comics, but the fact that what happened in the JLA/Avengers has actually been written into the DC universe. The Egg has Krona in it, the one they trapped him in in JLA/Avengers, the Crime Sydicate got ressurected... they died in JLA/Avengers, but where alive and well before that...

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
That scan was meant to show that the ring isn't coming off. If we are going to use a full potential Mags, then it's only fair to use a GL at full potential. GL outclasses him in every way. Did you know a GL ring has even brought the dead to life? Thats how powerful they are. He could contain Mags, turn off Mags power, absorb mags shield. Its basically like if Mags fought Surfer....but even worse.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/avalonofthewind/Respectkyle.jpg
That was nutzo.
Turning any effort or energy into sound
lmao

Go to this thread:


http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=4966605#post4966605

The Green Lantern Respect Thread answers any and all questions about how utterly outclassed Magneto is.

i give the GL the slight nod cuz he could literally say,"ring make sure that he cant control my blood, or short out the circuitry in my brain." also, the fact that they could proably survive a blackhole.

however, mags is very adpet at ripping ppl apart at the seams just by smashing thier molecules. on genosha dazzler blitzed magento with light and he siad something to the effect of "as i control the EM spectrum, watch as i bend photons to my will," and he diverted her attack, so the fact that the rings emit light, its part of the EM spectrum so mags could at least divert the GLs attack if not control it altogether.

however, ive seen kyle defeat polaris by creating something that looked a tuning fork, that blasted him with frequnecy of energy the polar opposite of polaris was manipulating and it did well in neutralizing his powers, but then again polaris and magneto are two different animals.

but i still maintain that GLs have a slight advantage, experience being the key. cuz its one thing to become a GL and run around shooting at ppl but only hal, kilowog, Sinestro, and the chick who trained John Stewart have completed training in Willworld. so they are the most experienced and versatile Gls, you could probably throw kyle in there too, cuz once he became ion and gained nigh-omnipotence, he proably bypassed the necessity for that training.

plus magento admitted to charles that he created a black hole. though he was at his weakest state, so imagine how powerful he would be at full potential

DUDE THEESE DUDES ARE LIKE BOTH MY SECOND FAV IN BOTH UNIVERSE !!!!

Merging.

And the day I see Magneto contain a supernova is the day I may consider him in any GL's league.

Originally posted by Tron
Merging.

And the day I see Magneto contain a supernova is the day I may consider him in any GL's league.
And that day I can tell you I'll stop buying Marvel comics.

lol....Green Lantern all the way

Couldn't Mag's just open up a Blackhole , which would suck the GL in......

Originally posted by grey fox
Couldn't Mag's just open up a Blackhole , which would suck the GL in...... A GL could just close it.
There's really not much of a chance for Magneto.

GL's use black holes to travel space.

If Mags best attack is a black hole, he better throw in the towel.

Magneto wins but close

if it's Hal i whould say 7/10 Hal wins
Kyle mag wins 7/10

Originally posted by kgkg
Magneto wins but close

if it's Hal i whould say 7/10 Hal wins
Kyle mag wins 7/10
You're so mean to me kg.

Originally posted by kgkg
Magneto wins but close

if it's Hal i whould say 7/10 Hal wins
Kyle mag wins 7/10

Kyle is actually more powerful than Hal post crisis.
If you say Hal wins 7/10 then Kyle wins 9/10.

Originally posted by kgkg
Magneto wins but close

if it's Hal i whould say 7/10 Hal wins
Kyle mag wins 7/10 hell yah

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Kyle is actually more powerful than Hal post crisis.
If you say Hal wins 7/10 then Kyle wins 9/10.
Prove it

Hal battled Senistro Kyle was able to hang but Hal did better.

Kyle has more feats no doubt…… Then Pre Crisis Hal

if Hal beats him 7/10 Kyle wins 9/10

I don't think so especially after JLA/Avenger he couldn't handle Wonder man

Can Gl's win of course it's a close battle.

I give mag the wins because 1.) His shield never gets broken……….. Gl’s well……..
2.) Powerful enough to take on Avengers etc


Can Green lanten Neutralize Magneto's power? Ya they can Kyle did it to Polaris once ......... but polaris wasn't in the mood.

and Polaris did beat hal ......

Mag > Polaris

Originally posted by The Ion
You're so mean to me kg.
Sorry man

Are you one of those people who think Kyle is stronger than Hal?

Originally posted by kgkg
Sorry man

Are you one of those people who think Kyle is stronger than Hal?
I'm one of the people who thinks Mags has no chance against a GL whether it be Hal, Kyle, or Joey Noname from Planet Unpronouncable.

When Mags shield can take a planet destroying blast at ground zero or when his feats come close to GL I'll believe he can win. Remember we use characters at their peak here.