Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Assume peak form for everyone.

1. Mephisto

2. In-Betweener

3. Phoenix

5. Galactus

6. Death

7. Thanos w/ Infinity Gauntlet

8. Living Tribunal

How far does Mxy get?

By peak do you mean Mxy at his greatest?

If so he clears it.

Mxy clears it

Stops at 7

7.

Mxy clears it.

Goes down hard at 7.

stops at 7

Clears it.

Clears.

Either stalemates, or clear 9.

stops at seven

7

Seven.

Probably clears. In all honesty, Mxy is broken as hell. He probably can beat LT.

facepalm

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Probably clears. In all honesty, Mxy is broken as hell. He probably can beat LT.
10th Age of Magic seems to have mucked with 5D powers. Thunderbolt confessed that things were different.

Stops hard at 7

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Probably clears. In all honesty, Mxy is broken as hell. He probably can beat LT.

nopers

Originally posted by Enyalus
10th Age of Magic seems to have mucked with 5D powers. Thunderbolt confessed that things were different. But there's a difference between 'normal' imps, and genies.

And Mxy outclasses almost his entire race when it comes to his powers.

Originally posted by Galan007
But there's a difference between 'normal' imps, and genies.
Genies are supposed to be more powerful.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
And Mxy outclasses almost his entire race when it comes to his powers.

Can Mxy defeat the A

The A?

I knew I would stump u on this one



The A challenged Mxy to a game

I posted some scans of him before

Originally posted by Enyalus
Genies are supposed to be more powerful. Says who?

Originally posted by Galan007
Says who?
Erm, I think I read it on Wikipedia.



Plus, the Aladdin movies.

Anyone know what that Imp was in the JLA annual? Called a jinn or something.

Originally posted by cloud102
Anyone know what that Imp was in the JLA annual? Called a jinn or something.
Djinn = Genie. Its arabic.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Erm, I think I read it on Wikipedia.



Plus, the Aladdin movies.

hysterical

Originally posted by Enyalus
Djinn = Genie. Its arabic.

I know, but there was another type of genie or imp in that JLA one shot.

Originally posted by cloud102
I know, but there was another type of genie or imp in that JLA one shot.
Issue #? Was it vol 3?

I'm not clear on what you're referencing.

Do you remember a JLA character who was arabic and had a sword. Also had the book of Merlin. There was another type of Imp in that book.

Myx loses to Superboy Prime lmao he doesnt get past 2

Originally posted by Forever Nick
Myx loses to Superboy Prime lmao he doesnt get past 2

Are you joking with this statement?

Because I assume you are, or you know nothing at all about Mister Mxyzptlk.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Erm, I think I read it on Wikipedia.



Plus, the Aladdin movies.

Death kills him, or Thanos stops him dead.

Mxy at his peak stomps pretty much anything except pre-recton Beyonder, HMO Wanda and TOAA.

Possible stalemate at 7 or 8 tho.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Issue #? Was it vol 3?

I'm not clear on what you're referencing. He's talking about JLA Annual 4.



Around this time, DC was introducing several new foreign heros, several of whom only made minor appearances after their introduction. This one was Selma Tolon, The Janissary.

Originally posted by Juntai
He's talking about JLA Annual 4.



Around this time, DC was introducing several new foreign heros, several of whom only made minor appearances after their introduction. This one was Selma Tolon, The Janissary. Well we have a Mr. Smartypants, I see... uhuh

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Are you joking with this statement?

Because I assume you are, or you know nothing at all about Mister Mxyzptlk.

Huh...I guess I don't know much about Mxy either because I agree with this.

His 'toughness' seems to ebb and flow depending upon who is writing him.

lucky numberzz 7

Originally posted by Galan007
Well we have a Mr. Smartypants, I see... uhuh What would you guys do without me?

7.

Originally posted by theICONiac
Huh...I guess I don't know much about Mxy either because I agree with this.

His 'toughness' seems to ebb and flow depending upon who is writing him.



If you agree with this statement:

Originally posted by Forever Nick
Myx loses to Superboy Prime lmao he doesnt get past 2

Then you evidently don't know much about Mxy then.

Barring that it was utter plot induced stupidity, Superman Prime never defeated Mxy.

Lulz if you think Mxy can't get past 2. Especially since Mxy is at his best, meaning we use showings like "World's Funniest" etc.

If Prime/girl can do it, then he probably stops at one.

Originally posted by Charmander
If Prime/girl can do it, then he probably stops at one.

Again, barring the fact that it was plot induced stupidity, use the context. Prime never defeated him.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Again, barring the fact that it was plot induced stupidity, use the context. Prime never defeated him. /girl

Originally posted by Charmander
/girl

Damn. I missed that. Well, my excuse is that I'm tired and it's late....

Still, utter plot induced stupidity.

I don't know if you guys have figured this out or not. But in case you haven't, Rage throws the PIS card every single time he personally disagrees with a showing.

It doesn't matter what the showing is.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
I don't know if you guys have figured this out or not. But in case you haven't, Rage throws the PIS card every single time he personally disagrees with a showing.

It doesn't matter what the showing is. He's also apparently pretty easy to fool.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
I don't know if you guys have figured this out or not. But in case you haven't, Rage throws the PIS card every single time he personally disagrees with a showing.

It doesn't matter what the showing is.

Yes because Mxy having his powers blocked and kept in check by someone who was stated at being much less powerful than him, makes that much sense....

Originally posted by Charmander
He's also apparently pretty easy to fool.

His shown to be practically Omnipotent at times. It depends on whose writing him I believe.

Practically omnipotent means nothing.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
His shown to be practically Omnipotent at times. It depends on whose writing him I believe.
Case in point.

Originally posted by Charmander
Case in point.

His still retains his power, it's just depending on whose righting him he can be taken by surprise.

Here I'm assuming we use his abilities to their full capabilities.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
Practically omnipotent means nothing.

Mean's quite a lot actually.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
His still retains his power, it's just depending on whose righting him he can be taken by surprise.

Here I'm assuming we use his abilities to their full capabilities.

Re-read what I was responding to, then re-read all your responses.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Mean's quite a lot actually.

If it really meant anything Mxy isn't coming close to clearing this list seeing as Thanos w/ the IG and the LT are both "practically omnipotent".

Originally posted by Charmander
Re-read what I was responding to, then re-read all your responses.

Just did.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Just did. So, was I talking about you, or about Mxy?

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
If it really meant anything Mxy isn't coming close to clearing this list seeing as Thanos w/ the IG and the LT are both "practically omnipotent".

That's my bad. I meant he is shown to be practically omniscient at times.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
That's my bad. I meant he is shown to be practically omniscient at times.

Still no advantage since both the LT and Thanos w/ IG are all knowing.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
Still no advantage since both the LT and Thanos w/ IG are all knowing.

I never said that it would give him the advantage. I was simply addressing his statement.

I believe Mxy clears this, at his best.

Even if by some miracle he gets by Thanos, he won't defeat the LT.

Based on his feats at his best?

I think he does.

Give me some examples of these feats. Especially the ones you KNOW will work on someone like the LT.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
Give me some examples of these feats. Especially the ones you KNOW will work on someone like the LT.

Read "World's Funniest". That's probably Mxy at his best. At those levels he would beat Living Tribunal in my opinion.

I've read the non-canon story Worlds Funnest.

LT would just undo all that with a wave of his hand.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
I've read the non-canon story Worlds Funnest.

LT would just undo all that with a wave of his hand.

It being cannon could be argued.

Sure he would....

He's done similar before with little effort.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
He's done similar before with little effort.

I would luv to see them, any scans?

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
He's done similar before with little effort.

He has? Scans? Issue number?

I would love to see Living Tribunal, with a wave of his hand, restore the entirety of the Marvel Comic Universe. Mxy, destroyed the entire DCU. He even went back to "Crisis on Infinite Earths" and destroyed everything there.

Goes down at 7

stops @ 7 or 8

LT> MXYZPTLK U HAVE BEEN FOUND GUILTY OF COSMIC FELONY AND ARE HEREBY STRIPPED OF YOUR POWERS AND SENTENCE TO LIVE IN 2D PLANE FOR 100 CYCLES. IM ALSO ISSUE A RESTRAINING ORDER AGAINT U ON BEHALF OF SUPERMAN AND YOUR NOT TO GO WITHIN 10 LIGHTYEARS OF HIM DURING YOUR SENTENCE UNDER PENALTY OF LAW

Stops at 7.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
I've read the non-canon story Worlds Funnest. Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
He even went back to "Crisis on Infinite Earths" and destroyed everything there. And that is one of the reasons why 'World's Funnest' is canonical... There was only one COIE.

Originally posted by Galan007
And that is one of the reasons why 'World's Funnest' is canonical... There was only one COIE.
How about the Super Friends universe or the Wonder Twins universe thing.

Or even when he went to the real New York.

You can write whatever you want in an Elseworlds comic. That's why its an Elseworlds comic. There was only one Superman, too, but in practically every other Elseworlds story his origin his changed or something prevents him from being like the mainstream DC Superman.

Originally posted by Enyalus
How about the Super Friends universe or the Wonder Twins universe thing.

Or even when he went to the real New York.


He went to damn near every universe (inc. Gen World, JLA One Million, Heaven, Kingdom Come, etc, etc.) It being an Elseworlds publication doesn't change the fact that there was only one COIE.

Originally posted by Galan007
He went to damn near every universe (inc. Gen World, JLA One Million, Heaven, Kingdom Come, etc, etc.)
I know. But I don't think Super Friends was even a comic - it was a cartoon only, right? He still went there. Ditto for the Wonder Twins thing.



EDIT: Okay, apparently they were, but they were non-canon and on Earth-1A.

Originally posted by Enyalus
EDIT: Okay, apparently they were, but they were non-canon and on Earth-1A. I don't see what that has to do with anything..

Originally posted by Galan007
I don't see what that has to do with anything..
I'm not sure how Mxy in an Elseworlds story (which is usually non-canon) can go to a non-canon universe and destroy that, and have the aforementioned story be canon.

Hypertime?


You explained why it was canon to me before, using the COIE argument. But the way it seems to me, is that since its an Elseworlds story, they can write whatever they want. I mean, there was no multiverse when that story was written. No infinite earths. Yet the writers made it so, anyway. And then going around destroying a bunch of things that are already non-canon...

I'm just not getting how it could be canon, unless its explained away via hypertime or something like it. And I know you know the most about Mxy, so would probably be able to explain that best.



Lemme also preface this by stating that even if we include WF as canon and what current Mxy can do (again, 10th Age of Magic probably changed the rules for 5th Dimension entities), I probably wouldn't give Mxy the win over Thanos. It'd be a stalemate IMO, because destroying the universe (or omniverse) wouldn't be enough to kill Thanos. He's also omniscient and could trick Mxy into saying his name backwards, or possibly mindrape him into doing so (that seems unlikely, I admit to that...)

Originally posted by Enyalus
I'm not sure how Mxy in an Elseworlds story (which is usually non-canon) can go to a non-canon universe and destroy that, and have the aforementioned story be canon.

Hypertime?


You explained why it was canon to me before, using the COIE argument. But the way it seems to me, is that since its an Elseworlds story, they can write whatever they want. I mean, there was no multiverse when that story was written. No infinite earths. Yet the writers made it so, anyway. And then going around destroying a bunch of things that are already non-canon...

I'm just not getting how it could be canon, unless its explained away via hypertime or something like it. And I know you know the most about Mxy, so would probably be able to explain that best. WF being an Elseworlds story doesn't automatically make it non-canon (as there are several canonical Elseworlds tales.) But Mxy visiting the COIE-verse tells me, without a doubt, that WF was canon (there being only one COIE, and such.)

Many people don't know this, but there was a multiverse after COIE, and before 52 (it was referenced a couple times throughout a few different comics.) So a multiverse existing during WF makes sense. But Hypertime is also a potential answer.

Mxy didn't destroy a "bunch" of non-canon universes. In fact, almost every universe we saw being destroyed, was canon. Also, the ease in which Mxy vaporized universes in WF does coincide (as do many other things) with how easily Emperor Joker was able to do the same. Meaning, the feats Mxy displayed in WF weren't out of his powerset. At all.

Furthermore, Mxy is ALWAYS an excuse for DC writers to do whatever they want, such as:
own Spectre
retcon characters on a whim
destroy universes with an ACME bomb
canonically cross over into other companies
Talk to DC staff directly
etc, etc

(ALL of the above feats are indisputably canon, btw.)

So again, nothing in WF was out of Mxy's insane powerset.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Lemme also preface this by stating that even if we include WF as canon and what current Mxy can do (again, 10th Age of Magic probably changed the rules for 5th Dimension entities), I probably wouldn't give Mxy the win over Thanos. It'd be a stalemate IMO, because destroying the universe (or omniverse) wouldn't be enough to kill Thanos. He's also omniscient and could trick Mxy into saying his name backwards, or possibly mindrape him into doing so (that seems unlikely, I admit to that...) There's no evidence that Mxy's powers have been mucked with due to the 10th age of magic.

Mindrape? Since it's never happened to Mxy, I wouldn't say it's likely.

The name backwards thing? That's a stip Mxy places on himself. A stip he can choose not to abide by (as he's shown before.)

Alright man, thanks for the knowledge drop.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Alright man, thanks for the knowledge drop. It was mostly bullshit. Pay it no mind. crackers

Originally posted by Galan007
It was mostly bullshit. Pay it no mind. crackers
That's why I didn't bother getting into an argument. biscuits

Thank you. vin

Originally posted by Galan007
Thank you. vin
Shall we start an FC Darkseid vs. Mxy thread for amusement?

I'll make it

Originally posted by Enyalus
Shall we start an FC Darkseid vs. Mxy thread for amusement? I don't find that amusing. uhuh

Originally posted by Galan007
I don't find that amusing. uhuh
Interesting that Darkseid was the only one who wasn't killed when Mxy destroyed Apokalips/4th World.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Interesting that Darkseid was the only one who wasn't killed when Mxy destroyed Apokalips/4th World. Mxy kept Darky alive so he could give him the ALE. DUH!

Originally posted by Galan007
Mxy kept Darky alive so he could give him the ALE. DUH!
Ah yes, obviously.

Srsly though, the EJ arc showed us that even Darkseid is little more than a puppet compared to Mxy.

Originally posted by Galan007
Srsly though, the EJ arc showed us that even Darkseid is little more than a puppet compared to Mxy.
...I agree.

I mean, I like both, but Mxy's most awesomer.

Originally posted by Enyalus
...I agree.

I mean, I like both, but Mxy's most awesomer. +1 cool point.

um mxy destroyd "all" of DCU?

so the 6D planes too? or the homeworld of the 7D imps? the 8D octopi? the 10th dimension? all of it? ^__^

Stops at 7.

Clears it

Thanos fanboys out in full force

the funny thing is that all the thanos fanboys are all anti superman.
Weird.

Mxy clears

Clears it.

Originally posted by Stunner2xx

Thanos fanboys out in full force

the funny thing is that all the thanos fanboys are all anti superman.
Weird.
No Thanos "fanboy" over here. ... and I love Superman.
Originally posted by Stunner2xx

Mxy clears
Stalemates at 7 and gets stomped at 8 ... imo.

I know Mxy's feats,
& I have several of his great issues (also been to the well formulated RS)
there's nothing that I see he can do, that the IG in Thanos' hands can't do imo,
as the IG basically makes the wielder 'GOD' of all reality,
with only the TOAA and his personal agent above said wielder.

Mxy basically proved in WF's (if it's being considered) to be 'GOD-like' as well,
but imo it shouldn't be for all the right reasons Eny pointed out ...
but wuteva, makes no difference.

A forum (seriously written) LT is above would be "Gods" of all reality.
(yes, the kind that can unmake-remake all reality, yes, like Mxy in WF's)

stops at 6

Stops at Thanos

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
His shown to be practically Omnipotent at times. It depends on whose writing him I believe.

Ha! You agree with me!

7

Originally posted by Naija boy
7
What if it was Silver Surfer with the Gauntlet?

Originally posted by Enyalus
What if it was Silver Surfer with the Gauntlet?

What if it was Quanchi with the gauntlet??? What would you say then???

I'd say Quan doesn't need the gauntlet to pwn Mxy's ass.

Quan would straight pwn Mxy with his undeniable logic.

Originally posted by Mr Master
but imo it shouldn't be for all the right reasons Eny pointed out ... facepalm

Originally posted by Enyalus
What if it was Silver Surfer with the Gauntlet?

Surfer would clear this.

Originally posted by Galan007
facepalm
Ahem...do not facepalm the Master.

Especially when he's saying I'm right.

stop at 7

Originally posted by Enyalus
Especially when he's saying I'm right. Just made me chuckle a bit, is all.

Originally posted by Galan007

facepalm
facepalm ... my left nut hurts already.
Originally posted by Enyalus
Ahem...do not facepalm the Master.

Especially when he's saying I'm right.
And you're still right IMO! ("F" the haters)
... not to mention that the freaggin Editor in-Chief of DC
is quoted stating Elseworld titles are non-canon,

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elseworlds

(uhh, ... "Imaginary Stories" anyone?)
not to mention that a silly tv cartoon world &/or the 'real world' appears in WF.
and on and on ...
or how's about returning to a Multiverse
that according to Countdown was nullified & so never even existed. LOL!

And while there are a few Elseworlds titles that were inducted into continuity,
World's Funnest isn't one of them.
Originally posted by Galan007

Just made me chuckle a bit, is all.
lmfao

Originally posted by Enyalus

I'm not sure how Mxy in an Elseworlds story (which is usually non-canon) can go to a non-canon universe and destroy that, and have the aforementioned story be canon.

Hypertime?


You explained why it was canon to me before, using the COIE argument. But the way it seems to me, is that since its an Elseworlds story, they can write whatever they want. I mean, there was no multiverse when that story was written. No infinite earths. Yet the writers made it so, anyway. And then going around destroying a bunch of things that are already non-canon...

I'm just not getting how it could be canon,

unless its explained away via hypertime or something like it.


And ... Hypertime, doesn't exist according to DC's Editor in-Chief:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypertime

Beyond this,
even if WF were to be considered canon (which it seems not to be)
it would be a story that took place withIN a single Universe,
since ALL (a FEW literally) Elseworld titles
are considered single Universes withIN the new 52- Universe Multiverse.

For the record:

I'm not saying I'm right,
just conveying what the Editors that run DC are saying
about the company they control in terms of publication.

Now I'll be the first to throw up a middle finger
at anyone using Wiki for on panel proof to debate,
but this isn't that at all,
this is what the top Editor's of DC have been quoted solidifying,
concerning an administrative publishing issue, (like DC related titles)
so ... googogaga.

The "Worlds Funnest is canon" folks can now bow out gracefully.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
The "Worlds Funnest is canon" folks can now bow out gracefully.
Well, there's evidence that Hypertime is canon and has been used, even after DiDio was quoted as saying it was being discontinued. Galan's showed me the evidence before.

So, it's not clear cut either way, IMO.

Interesting to note that the latest "DCU" story we have (Final Crisis) only makes reference to 52 universes, though. Unless we're assuming Morrison doesn't know what he's talking about, which I'd accept, too.

Originally posted by Mr Master
not to mention that the freaggin Editor in-Chief of DC
is quoted stating Elseworld titles are non-canon,

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elseworlds

(uhh, ... "Imaginary Stories" anyone?)
not to mention that a silly tv cartoon world &/or the 'real world' appears in WF.
and on and on ... Point is, there was only one COIE (undisputable), and during WF Mxy visited that 'place' - this alone should be enough, imo. There's also Hypertime (which is very much canonical) and could certainly be used to link this story. There's also only one true Mxy/Spectre (both of which appeared in that comic.) Etc.

"Imaginary stories" - anyone who reads Elseworlds will tell you this phrase appears in the opening pages of every single comic that company produces (many of which are canonical) so...

Originally posted by Mr Master
or how's about returning to a Multiverse
that according to Countdown was nullified & so never even existed. LOL! I really hope you're not saying that the original multiverse never existed, because it was referenced throughout Countdown, as well as a few other comics. Lol?

Originally posted by Mr Master
And while there are a few Elseworlds titles that were inducted into continuity,
World's Funnest isn't one of them. ] Says what? Your wiki article?