DC's Elementals vs Marvel's Heralds

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Prep-Man
Elementals such as Swamp Thing and Firestorm vs Heralds like Surfer and Morg.

Spire
Elementals.

Harbinger
Team two really doesn't have a way of putting ST down.

AsbestosFlaygon
So... The Green > Power Cosmic?

galactusischere
HERALDS OF GALACTUS!!!!11!!

Prep-Man
Originally posted by AsbestosFlaygon
So... The Green > Power Cosmic?

The Red as well, right?

Prep-Man
Originally posted by galactusischere
HERALDS OF GALACTUS!!!!11!!

What can the mightest of Heralds do to Swamp Thing or Firestorm?

jasofisc
what level firestorm and swamp thing if were talking about God thing then that would be bad but anyother versions surfer stands a chance

jasofisc
just saying orginal swamp thing had a hard time with street level werewolfs, and godthing took on the specter's big brother so their is quite a bit of room for differnces in power.

Galan007
in a PIS free environment, firestorm would eventually go down after a pretty good fight.

swamp thing is a different story though.

Prep-Man
There is also that water chick. Who else are Elementals, Galan?

galactusischere
Originally posted by Prep-Man
What can the mightest of Heralds do to Swamp Thing or Firestorm?

alot.
There is Surfer who took down T&A.
Theres Morg with the WOL.
Theres the Fallen One.
Theres Tyrant(does he count as a herald)who can pretty much solo the field. Unless your talking about God Swamp Thing.

Kris Blaze
Originally posted by galactusischere
There is Surfer who took down T&A.

Context helps a lot.

Like T and A standing right by the crunch, the only way to kill them. A weakness and scenario that in no way applies to the Swamp Thing or Firestorm.

Galan007
Originally posted by Prep-Man
There is also that water chick. Who else are Elementals, Galan? swamp thing = the green.
animal man = the red.
naiad = water.
red tornado = wind.
firestorm = fire.
maya = the earth in it's entirety.

Kris Blaze
Originally posted by Galan007
swamp thing = the green.
animal man = the red.
naiad = water.
red tornado = wind.
firestorm = fire.
maya = the earth in it's entirety.

I really disagree with DC having Red Tornado as their wind elemental.

Galan007
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I really disagree with DC having Red Tornado as their wind elemental. why? because he's a friggin' robot? yeah, that is quite ridiculous.

...though i don't think he's been portrayed as 'the wind elemental' since the late 80's.

-Pr-
he's still a wind elemental. he's just housed in that body because it allows him to keep a more humanoid form. then there's his soon-to-be wife and kid...

Kris Blaze
Originally posted by Galan007
why? because he's a friggin' robot? yeah, that is quite ridiculous.

Bingo.

I don't like the idea of an elemental being created. But Ivo did not create the elemental though, right? He just created the body it "chose" ?

-Pr-
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Bingo.

I don't like the idea of an elemental being created. But Ivo did not create the elemental though, right? He just created the body it "chose" ?

yup. the android is merely a shell.

Galan007
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Bingo.

I don't like the idea of an elemental being created. But Ivo did not create the elemental though, right? He just created the body it "chose" ? correct. still doesn't change the inherent stupidity though.

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Galan007
swamp thing = the green.
animal man = the red.
naiad = water.
red tornado = wind.
firestorm = fire.
maya = the earth in it's entirety.

Cool, how powerful was Naiad?

Galan007
roughly equal to the wind elemental, it seemed.

Prep-Man
CAN REFORM IF THERE IS WATER, RIGHR? sorry.

Galan007
srug

naiad was only seen in like 2 issues, but i would assume so..

galactusischere
So the Heralds of Galactus win?

Prep-Man
Not if they can't put down ST or any of the others.

galactusischere
Originally posted by Prep-Man
Not if they can't put down ST or any of the others.

Morg w/WOL>ST
FP Tyrant>all heralds and elementals combined multiplied by 1000
God ST>Tyrant but this isn't god ST so heralds win IF Tyrant is CONSIDERED a herald

galactusischere
Originally posted by galactusischere
Morg w/WOL>ST
FP Tyrant>all heralds and elementals combined multiplied by 1000
God ST>Tyrant but this isn't god ST so heralds win IF Tyrant is CONSIDERED a herald

without Tyrant I still say heralds 6/10

Prep-Man
Not counting Tyrant or God ST. Sorry.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I really disagree with DC having Red Tornado as their wind elemental. i don't, i think it's badass, he's just it's shell anyway.

ST is the only real issue here, all the others can be dealt with and the superior numbers of the heralds is easily the cause.

but yeah, ST is not just a host, he is the power = hard to defeat.

Prep-Man
Firestorm would be a problem as well. He did fight that creature in the sun. As long as there is fire, he can reform anywhere.

psycho gundam
how many times do you think that's going to work before he gets dealt with?

Prep-Man
Originally posted by psycho gundam
how many times do you think that's going to work before he gets dealt with?

What do you mean? As an elemental, power seems endless. Unless the Heralds destroy the earth.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.