If you could pick 10 scientists from DC/Marvel...

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Omega Vision
If you needed to form a think tank of the best ten (Earth) scientists in DC and Marvel who would they be? You can use villains and heroes but no aliens unless they spend the majority of their time on Earth and no people from the future or past (so no Brainiac 5)
My List is as follows: (no particular order)
Reed Richards (duh)
Bruce Banner
Michael Holt
Victor Von Doom
Lex Luthor
Dr. Sivana
Niles Caulder
Ray Palmer
Bruce Wayne
Tony Stark

Colossus-Big C
1. High Evolutionary
2. Forge
3. Reed richards
4. Batman
5. tony stark
6. Professor x

-Pr-
Not in order:

1. Pym
2. Luthor
3. Reed
4. Batman
5. Ray Palmer
6. Will Magnus
7. John Henry Irons
8. Hank McCoy
9. Tony Stark
10. Michael Holt

Omega Vision
Crap I meant to say Wil Magnus, not Niles Caulder.

galactusischere
Originally posted by -Pr-
Not in order:

1. Pym
2. Luthor
3. Reed
4. Batman
5. Ray Palmer
6. Will Magnus
7. John Henry Irons
8. Hank McCoy
9. Tony Stark
10. Michael Holt

what happend to the HE?

Prep-Man
T.O. Morrow and Rip Hunter would definitely be in the mix. Morrow's tech was manipulating a universe.

Will Magnus for robotics. Creating the Metal Men for one.

Reed Richards is a no brainer. Ha!

Ray Palmer is the Reed Richards of the DCU

Forge from the X-Men.

Batman from the JLA.

Classic Captain Comet is close to Reed Level.

And the proffesor from Challengers of the Unknown. Could understand Hypertime.

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Crap I meant to say Wil Magnus, not Niles Caulder.

Niles Caulder might make it in my top 10. Definetly top 10 for DCU, because he is one of the smartest men in DCU. Read last Doom Patrol. He defeated the FIRST scientist.

-Pr-
Originally posted by galactusischere
what happend to the HE?

don't want him. though i'd take Sinister over McCoy.

1. Pym
2. Luthor
3. Reed
4. Batman
5. Ray Palmer
6. Will Magnus
7. John Henry Irons
8. Mister Sinister
9. Tony Stark
10. Michael Holt

Omega Vision
The Brain was smarter than him though IIRC

Colossus-Big C
feat wise. no one has surpassed HE

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Omega Vision
The Brain was smarter than him though IIRC

Talking to me? How is the Brain smarter than the Chief? Just wondering.

T.O. Morrow is smarter than Lex or Mr. Terrific, BTW.

Omega Vision
Originally posted by Prep-Man
Talking to me? How is the Brain smarter than the Chief? Just wondering.

T.O. Morrow is smarter than Lex or Mr. Terrific, BTW.
Didn't Caulder cause the accident that made the Brain what he was out of jealousy of his superior intelligence?

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
feat wise. no one has surpassed HE

What has he done feat wise that puts him over Reed or Brainiac?

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Didn't Caulder cause the accident that made the Brain what he was out of jealousy of his superior intelligence?

I'm not an expert on the Doom Patrol, but remember Caulder did create the Candlemaker's body, which is uber reality manipulator.

Omega Vision
Hmm for medical science you'd probably want Doctor Mid-Nite.

Galan007
rip hunter
professor stein
ray palmer
reed
doom
professor ivo
tony stark
tom morrow
doctor who
vril dox

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Galan007
vril dox
rip hunter
professor stein
ray palmer
reed
doom
professor ivo
tony stark
tom morrow
doctor who \

Just out of curiosity, do you think Stein is above Will Magnus?

Galan007
Originally posted by Prep-Man
Just out of curiosity, do you think Stein is above Will Magnus? when stein returned to earth after his 'exile', he'd learned the secrets of the universe. he actually began to master the firestorm-matrix, in fact.

so yeah.

Bouboumaster
Reed Richards
Doctor Doom
And I don't need anyone else.

Prep-Man
Originally posted by Galan007
when stein returned to earth after his 'exile', he'd learned the secrets of the universe. he actually began to master the firestorm-matrix, in fact.

so yeah.


Hmmm, didn't know this. What were the secrets? If they revealed it.

Galan007
Originally posted by Prep-Man
Hmmm, didn't know this. What were the secrets? If they revealed it. not really secrets, but intricacies. stein was able to see/sense the ebb and flow of the universe.

Prep-Man
wow, not too many people can do that in comics. Not even Lex Luthor or TO Morrow.

Colossus-Big C
what is reeds greatest feat?

Prep-Man
Probably creating a test universe for Thing.

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by Prep-Man
Probably creating a test universe for Thing. lol why would thing need an entire universe to himself What the f**k?

iceman24567
What about his current feat? Having weapons in his lab that could put Celestials down.

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by iceman24567
What about his current feat? Having weapons in his lab that could put Celestials down. yea i know he is probably the smartest

Mindset
People are seriously not picking Doom? facepalm

thumb up Galan

Prep-Man
That was ok. Those weren't 616 Celestials, though. They looked more like jobbers.

Omega Vision
I picked Doom.

iceman24567
Originally posted by Prep-Man
That was ok. Those weren't 616 Celestials, though. They looked more like jobbers. Yeah thats what i was thinking they weren't the real thing but honestly if Reed didn't have some cosmic level weaponry after all he's been threw i wouldn't think him to be the greatest mind on earth erm

Mindset
He's not.

Colossus-Big C
High Evolutionary Fixed celestial tech

iceman24567
Originally posted by Mindset
He's not. roll eyes (sarcastic)

Mindset
Doom used Galactus tech.

Mindset
Originally posted by iceman24567
roll eyes (sarcastic) Fool.

http://www.samruby.com/Villains/DoctorDoom/DrDoomChap.gif

iceman24567
I love Doom one of my favorite villains but Reed is his kryptonite son

Mindset
Yea, backed by the the other 3 members and him being a hero and all.

iceman24567
No just him being Reed is enough kiddo erm

Mindset
Let's be real here iceman, you probably have not read more than 10 FF comics.

iceman24567
LOL




























sad

Mindset
laughing out loud

iceman24567
Too be honest i have read less than a hundred well over 10 though.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Prep-Man
What has he done feat wise that puts him over Reed or Brainiac?

Figure out a way to restore the X-Gene something Reed said he couldn't do.

iceman24567
Beast? He didn't do it on his own no expression

Mindset
I've read 600...thousand.

Mindset
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Figure out a way to restore the X-Gene something Reed said he couldn't do. Reed just didn't care.

iceman24567
Originally posted by Mindset
I've read 600...thousand. laughing I don't believe you.

Originally posted by Mindset
Reed just didn't care. thumb up Nobody really cared actually

Titsgalore
He did care, his son is one. Or does Reed not care about Franklin.....HE>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reed

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by Titsgalore
He did care, his son is one. Or does Reed not care about Franklin.....HE>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reed i wouldnt put all thos >'s reed is not far behind at all

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
i wouldnt put all thos >'s reed is not far behind at all

Call me when Reed creates an Adam Warlock or a Man Thing.

iceman24567
Originally posted by Titsgalore
He did care, his son is one. Or does Reed not care about Franklin.....HE>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reed What negative affects did M-Day have on his son for him to care?

Titsgalore
Originally posted by iceman24567
What negative affects did M-Day have on his son for him to care?

The fact that it affected mutants of whom his son is one would cause him some concern. Im sure if Franklin was born when the Legacy Virus was running rampant Reed would have created the cure in a second.

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Call me when Reed creates an Adam Warlock or a Man Thing. yea you are right. by the way i never knew HE created warlock

iceman24567
Nah it didn't seem to bother Reed that much.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
yea you are right. by the way i never knew HE created warlock

Not directly

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by iceman24567
Nah it didn't seem to bother Reed that much. so reed doesnt give a Sh*t about his son?

Mindset
Originally posted by Titsgalore
The fact that it affected mutants of whom his son is one would cause him some concern. Im sure if Franklin was born when the Legacy Virus was running rampant Reed would have created the cure in a second. Franklin didn't lose his powers from M-day.

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Not directly what do you mean

iceman24567
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
so reed doesnt give a Sh*t about his son? Not what i said M-Day had nothing to do with Franklin no expression

Titsgalore
Originally posted by iceman24567
Nah it didn't seem to bother Reed that much.

Yeh cos Reed doesn't care about his son roll eyes (sarcastic)

Mindset
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Yeh cos Reed doesn't care about his son roll eyes (sarcastic) You don't know what you're talking about...

Titsgalore
Anyways I dnt care much for DC so my 5 from Marvel are in order

1. HE
2. Reed Richards
3. Dr Doom
4. Mr Sinister(HE mentor)
5. Scientist Supreme Hank Pym

iceman24567
Originally posted by Mindset
You don't know what you're talking about... thumb up Obviously

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
You don't know what you're talking about...

Yeh I do. Beast a friend of Reed asked him to try an fix M-Day and Reed was like no i can't because I am not smart enough, but HE lied to Beast and figured it out all by himself. HE>>>Reed Richards in all scientific branches.

Mindset
Reed didn't care.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
Reed didn't care.

Proof please.

Mindset
Did he try to help?

iceman24567
He didn't work day and night to try and solve the problem as he usually does when faced with such an issue? Or maybe that fact that it didn't affect him in the slightest and Reed is a selfish prick?

Colossus-Big C
why wont some one just post a scan to end this???

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
Did he try to help?

Yes he did actually. AND FAILED

Mindset
What are you talking about, kid?

Titsgalore
Originally posted by iceman24567
He didn't work day and night to try and solve the problem as he usually does when faced with such an issue? Or maybe that fact that it didn't affect him in the slightest and Reed is a selfish prick?

Yeh the guy who wants to SOLVE EVERYTHING doesn't care about M-Day...great logic.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
What are you talking about, kid?

Read X-Men Endangered Species

iceman24567
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Yeh the guy who wants to SOLVE EVERYTHING doesn't care about M-Day...great logic. Yes because their weren't more pressing matters to attend to?

Mindset
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Read X-Men Endangered Species I have.

Around 50 times.

Mindset
Ok, I'm gonna go finish watching the Lakers game.

I won.

iceman24567
Originally posted by Mindset
Ok, I'm gonna go finish watching the Lakers game.

I won. You never win

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
I have.

Around 50 times.

Read the start when Beast, Reed, Tony Stark and Scientist Supreme can't figure a way to reverse M-Day, therefore Beast was like **** you guys and went to HE

Mindset
Originally posted by iceman24567
You never win I gave your sister crabs.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
I gave your sister crabs.

And she probably gave you herpes. Herpes is the friend that never leaves. You lose

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Read the start when Beast, Reed, Tony Stark and Scientist Supreme can't figure a way to reverse M-Day, therefore Beast was like **** you guys and went to HE ive read it before. but do you have the scan?

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
ive read it before. but do you have the scan?

No. I buy my comics.

Mindset
Originally posted by Titsgalore
And she probably gave you herpes. Herpes is the friend that never leaves. You lose You can't give someone what they already have.

That reminds me, I also gave your sister herpes.

Colossus-Big C
you still can scan it with a scan machine

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by Mindset
You can't give someone what they already have.

That reminds me, I also gave your sister herpes. sick

Mindset
He doesn't have the comic.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
He doesn't have the comic.

Yes I do.

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
You can't give someone what they already have.

That reminds me, I also gave your sister herpes.

She gave you chlamydia as revenge though roll eyes (sarcastic)

Mindset
Are you just gonna keep listing different stds...? no expression

Titsgalore
Originally posted by Mindset
Are you just gonna keep listing different stds...? no expression

Whats worse than an STD?

Omega Vision
Originally posted by Titsgalore
Whats worse than an STD?
Cancer?

The Nuul
1. Superman?
2. Otto Octavius
3. Reed
4. Batman
5. Ray Palmer
6. En Sabah Nur
7. Dr Doom
8. Hank McCoy
9. Bruce Banner
10. Mr Sinister



In no order.

Omega Vision
I would think the four scientists that should be on everyone's list would be Dr. Doom, Lex Luthor, Reed Richards, and Ray Palmer.

The Nuul
Tony, Pym and Forge are more about robotics then science.

-Pr-
Originally posted by The Nuul
Tony, Pym and Forge are more about robotics then science.

pym is one of the best bio-chemists in existence.

Prep-Man
Adam Strange is another that should be close to top 10. He repaired a space ship for interstellar travel while BLIND.

Will Magnus and To morrow are above Stark in terms of tech, IMO.

Omega Vision
But Adam Strange doesn't live on Earth.

Prep-Man
He may not live on earth, but that's where his origins are and he still helps earth heroes out all the time. He's an adventurer like Reed Richards.

redhotrash
I may be remembering wrong, but when Beast was trying to convince all those villains via tele-confrence, didnt he say that he and Reed were up all night and discovered a bunch of other things? Regardless, Reed showed his motivation by not bothering to do jack for Ben Grimm's condition, meanwhile Dr. Doom has depowered him like 3 times..

Omega Vision
My theory is Reed is a bastard that knows he needs the Thing's strength so he's not going to cure his condition even though he could easily. Honestly after Civil War it wouldn't surprise me in the least.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.