Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins?

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/77/78678-51147-stardust_super.jpg vs http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/40/684308-gview_super.png

Stardust stomps.

Originally posted by Konton
Stardust stomps. No son.

Hal attacks with a giant pair of scissors.

How in the world can anyone beat that?

Hal

I'd say Stardust would take a healthy majority against current Hal. Classic Hal would be different.

Originally posted by Starscream M
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/77/78678-51147-stardust_super.jpg so this is the pre-evolved/sub-BRB version of stardust?

Originally posted by Galan007
so this is the pre-evolved/sub-BRB version of stardust? no, going by forum rules, its the current form (minus any unique powerups or powerdowns)

don't go by the image

m'kay.

stardust ftw. i can't see hal winning before his ring ran out of juice.

stardust

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Hal attacks with a giant pair of scissors.

How in the world can anyone beat that?

Or the Worlds biggest Violin.

Probably Stardust.

Stardust

Hal.

Period.

Stardust will out last the ring.

Hal wins.

Originally posted by Galan007
m'kay.

stardust ftw. i can't see hal winning before his ring ran out of juice.
HE can always recharge

Bump

Originally posted by Rao Kal El


for once we agree on something and this hot chick today actually gave me her number .. must be a cold day in hell or heaven

o and by the way stardust does stomp this fight

Stardust

Hal, a good fight though.

Would be a good, close fight whoever wins.

How is this a debate. Stardust probably has one comic book worth of feats...maybe two. Hal wrecks

His feats are predominantly from one six issue series, but he has barely appeared in more than two or three series. Percentage wise, he is high in feats. Do we totally penalize for limited appearances?

Hal takes this.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
His feats are predominantly from one six issue series, but he has barely appeared in more than two or three series. Percentage wise, he is high in feats. Do we totally penalize for limited appearances?

Short answer No.

But take this in consideration when placing bets on a fighter generally the one with more exp, tkos, under his belt has a higher probability of winning.

probably hal

plot device Hal wins, regular loses.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
How is this a debate. Stardust probably has one comic book worth of feats...maybe two. Hal wrecks So does the Living tribunal

Hal wrecks him too

Originally posted by psycho gundam
So does the Living tribunal

Stardust is no LT. Even LT is no longer living up to his hype anymore so your point is moot

The point is that you can still get a gauge on where the character sits power-wise even with limited showings. One of the best fights in comics was Stardust vs Beta Ray Bill and it had enough content in it to know how Stardust gets down against a strong opponent.

Living tribunal is just jobbed by a cosmic being they need to push at the time, it's not low showings other hooded cosmic beings have against far less

Also, regarding the boxing analogy, a fighter with limited experience who upsets a top ranked fighter will make a jump in the ranks regardless of having few fights.

Yep. Don't know what sin is talking about

Originally posted by psycho gundam
The point is that you can still get a gauge on where the character sits power-wise even with limited showings. One of the best fights in comics was Stardust vs Beta Ray Bill and it had enough content in it to know how Stardust gets down against a strong opponent.

Living tribunal is just jobbed by a cosmic being they need to push at the time, it's not low showings other hooded cosmic beings have against far less

Even so. Stardust doesnt have much to draw on feat wise and Bill is still considered Thor-lite by comparison so im sticking with the experienced vet. Whos currently operating outside Stardusts weight class.

Touche

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Also, regarding the boxing analogy, a fighter with limited experience who upsets a top ranked fighter will make a jump in the ranks regardless of having few fights.

That has nothing to do with how hed fair in said fight though.

Hal.

Stardust gets this...








In the butt!

Hal 9/10.

Technically, Stardust is female.

Hal.

Hal Jordan got this.
naughty tomcat

Originally posted by Galan007
m'kay.

stardust ftw. i can't see hal winning before his ring ran out of juice.

Noob