Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

So what is your take on this? Take in mind that G1 Megatron was twice as cunning and as violent as his "other" in the 2008 movie.

Yes, BUT, we then see in ROTF, Optimus basically kicking the shit out of Megs and 3 other decepticons for a good 5 minutes before being "finally" blindsided.

A few days later Prime os revived and esentially solos The Fallen (Meg's master), and in the process, rips half of Megatro's face off, and tears Starscream's wings off for good measure.

Optimus since G1 transformers aren't very durable.

I dispute that.

The G1 Formers where FAR more durable than any others sort of perhaps Energon.

Originally posted by Darkstorm Zero
I dispute that.

The G1 Formers where FAR more durable than any others sort of perhaps Energon.

I know they just did it to get some characters killed off to make room for a new generation, but in the original TF movie.

Optimus got swiped with an energy sword, then stabbed by a rock, and shot, he died. During that fight, all he did was land punches and uppercuts on Megatron, who fell a few stories after Optimus' final hit. He was nearly dead.

When the Decepticons took over the Autobot ship, they killed Brawn(one of the strongest/most durable Autobots) with one shot. THey also took down Prowl and Ironhide without much effort.

G1 TF's weren't all that durable......Let me rephrase that.

G1 TF's are very durable, or not durable at all, depending on the episode, and what the writer needs.

Originally posted by Darkstorm Zero
Yes, BUT, we then see in ROTF, Optimus basically kicking the shit out of Megs and 3 other decepticons for a good 5 minutes before being "finally" blindsided.

A few days later Prime os revived and esentially solos The Fallen (Meg's master), and in the process, rips half of Megatro's face off, and tears Starscream's wings off for good measure.

Optimus would've won their first fight if he wasn't so busy trying to keep Megatron from killing Sam or hurting innocent people. He always has been better than Megatron, which is why he always has to cheat to get ahead.

For once I'd like to know what so many people have against villains. May be some of us would like to destroy humanity but the others want to help it by killing goody-two-shoes like the heroes so that humanity can have more discipline in their lives. some of us do it for the thrill, like Carnage.

At his best? G1 Megatron.

Originally posted by KingD19
I know they just did it to get some characters killed off to make room for a new generation, but in the original TF movie.

Optimus got swiped with an energy sword, then stabbed by a rock, and shot, he died. During that fight, all he did was land punches and uppercuts on Megatron, who fell a few stories after Optimus' final hit. He was nearly dead.

When the Decepticons took over the Autobot ship, they killed Brawn(one of the strongest/most durable Autobots) with one shot. THey also took down Prowl and Ironhide without much effort.

G1 TF's weren't all that durable......Let me rephrase that.

G1 TF's are very durable, or not durable at all, depending on the episode, and what the writer needs.

Yes, alot of PIS and CIS was used and broadens basically every inconsistency in the show to unbeleivable levels.

We have seen Optimus basically dissasembled by Hook, but still survives somehow. He've seen him on an operating table with no front armour, and he still tanks a direct hit from Laserbeak to exposed vital areas, and remain functional enough to keep talking after his insides exploded.

Megs survived a nearly point blank anti-matter explosion with nothing but some surface cracks. We see Megs survive a cargo ship full of energon exploding with him on board, with enough force to push Cybertron out of a solar system....

yeah, going by the episodes, I think G1 is plenty durable enough to withstand quite a bit. Temper this with the low end durability (as you pointed out) and they still shit on almost any other TF series by at least an order of magnitude.

Something drives me to saying that I agree with you darkstorm, but I can't let my sentimental side break through. It'll leave a bad impression on the symbiotes and the boys. Not that Carnage requires it, he's already taken over the body of the human. All that's left is for him to battle the soul. But that's a bit off-topic.

Optimus is the best

Yeah and shit smells nice. Neither comment is correct, gygan.

Originally posted by lordmegatron1
Yeah and shit smells nice. Neither comment is correct, gygan.

Optimus Prime IS the best, though.

Repeat after me Mr. Rhythmic: Shit smells nice. Then look in the mirror and say to yourself: dumb ass.

G1 megatron's fusion canon was said to be a mountain buster. I doubt movie optimus could survive that

Damn right, a dark knight. Damn right.

Prime is and always will be the best.

G1 Megatron would have destroyed the movie version of Prime.

I'm just asking, but are you guys taking the poll?

Prime is always >>> Megatron.

But not movie Prime vs G1 Megs...

I mean after all, Movie Prime couldn't do this:

Hell yeah. They really captured my good side in that photo. My crowning achievement.

Movie Prime stomped Mega and his boss in TF 2.


They should have made Starscream leader at least he has a excuse for losing, Mega is a huge failure and trys to the best.

Who the hell invited you *******! Perhaps we should have a little "discussion" at your place of residence about who's the better bot, maybe then you'll agree with the Decepticon way of life. Plus blowing up buildings is fun. And it may even get you promoted if you can unleash fire for at least seven-teen blocks straight.

WOW a tie how predictable.You know what screw this, someone get two-face and have him preform a coin toss, i call heads, loser *Prime* dies.

I agree. G1 Megatron would probably win.

I swear theres a mod on here thats been deleting my posts.

Sure as hell ain't me. I'm just a member.

Movie Transformers are vulnerable to human fire, G1 transformers took no notice of it (for the most part). Although, we did see dinosaurs withstand decepticon fire in G1 and a t-rex got to chew on megatron..... Ignoring the inconsistencies I do feel G1 Megatron would defeat movie prime.

Originally posted by lordmegatron1
Sure as hell ain't me. I'm just a member.

I'm sure you've been trying to hack into this place like Skynet.

*sarcastically* Oh, yes. Look who's found me out. Like I'd really waste my time hacking this website. What the hell kind of info would I even find here? Like I really need your info.

Shut up tin can.

Ooh, your almost where Carnage's nickname for me is. "Metalhead."

Thats an honourable name indeed.

What an honour from a giant advance robot.

G1 Megatron wins.

An honor given by a schizophrenic symbiote means nothing, however his father has been reduced to calling himself, "Split". I don't really know why. It's probably due to Brock's refusal to let the symbiosis complete itself. He's "split" between Eddie Brock and the Venom Symbiote. Weird.

I'm a sucker for G1 characters so I'm biased with G1 Megatron.

I know it's a bit off topic but I'm thinking about creating....aw hell I'll just do it anyway.

Creating what exactly?......a new robot?

Nah, another poll. Galvatron and I were discussing who would've won in a fight between us, when I started the process for it the computer started to slow dramatically so I stopped. Think I'll try again.