Which street hero would you call upon in the following situations?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Starscream M
Pick ONE per scenario:

List:

Batman (regular equipment)
Captain America
Punisher (fully equipped and armed)
Spider-Man
Iron Fist
Daredevil

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Scenarios (not necessarily in any order of difficulty):

1) find and assassinate King Pin

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything

10) KO Wolverine

psycho gundam
this smells like a punisher stomp

3 is maybe an issue, but guns are allowed i presume, and a van full of them also

byrdgang21
1. punisher
2. batman
3. iron fist
4. captain america
5. spider-man
6. batman
7. punisher
8. captain america
9. batman
10. spider-man

psycho gundam
Originally posted by byrdgang21
9. batman punisher has less to give away http://i49.tinypic.com/14aaohf.gif

Starscream M
Originally posted by psycho gundam
this smells like a punisher stomp

3 is maybe an issue, but guns are allowed i presume, and a van full of them also no van. only carryon weapons.

twizzlers713
1 punisher
2 batman
3 punisher
4 punisher
5 captain america
6 batman
7 batman
8 captain? spiderman?
9 captain? batman?
10 captain america

psycho gundam
Originally posted by Starscream M
no van. only carryon weapons. so batman is without his vehicles also? good luck with stealth

JakeTheBank
1) find and assassinate King Pin - Punisher

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught - The Goddamn Batman

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas - Iron Fist

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid - Captain America

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking - Captain America

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden - The Goddamn Batman

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters - Punisher

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time - Captain America

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything - Iron Fist

10) KO Wolverine - Iron Fist

srankmissingnin
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
1) find and assassinate King Pin - Punisher

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught - The Goddamn Batman

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas - Iron Fist

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid - Captain America

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking - Captain America

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden - The Goddamn Batman

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters - Punisher

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time - Captain America

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything - Iron Fist

10) KO Wolverine - Iron Fist

Pretty much bang on except for 9. In this group, Danny is one of the few guys where cracking under torture is even a remote possibility.

I'm thinking Punisher for number 9. Batman and Cap have equally firm resolve, but Frank's insane damage soak means he is going to take more torture before he finally checks out for good, so I'll give him the nod purely for hours clocked in.

marwash22
1. Batman
2. Batman
3. Danny
4. Spiderman
5. Cap
6. Batman
7. Punisher
8. Cap... but he slightly edges out Spiderman 'cause he was a soilder
9. Danny
10. Danny... though hasn't Wolverine taken his punches before? this is a hard one.

Darth Martin
We need more threads like these. thumb up
1.If Batman is willing to kill then him; if not: Punisher
2.Batman; He's done this plenty of times already.
3.Captain America; I doubt anybody can do this here. Spider-Man is by far the most superior physically here but I doubt he knows how to deal with ninja. If this were a couple hundred I'd go with Daredevil. But with so many I'd give it to Cap. He's arguably the best H2H combatant here, has a deadly weapon, and is physically 2nd only to Spider-Man.
4.Daredevil; He's a marksman with any weapon. His senses will allow him to know when and where the enemy will be so him and his package won't be caught or fired upon.
5.Batman; He's by far the most intimidating here and regularly deals with street gangs of sorts.
6.Batman; Daredevil may be the best tracker here; but he's never been in contact with Bin Laden. Batman has the most resources by far and is hands down the greatest detective here.
7.Punisher; Resourcefulness and booby trapping is Punisher's calling card.
8.Cap; Cap is the most prepared psychologically. Spider-Man would freak at people screaming at him and would be thrown out for being a smart ellic. Cap is also second to Spider-Man physically.
9.Batman; The Joker is his archnemesis.......
10.Batman; various gases, restraints, sonics, knowledge of killing manuevers and pressure points. Wolverine would just tank Iron Fist or Spider-Man.

Bouboumaster
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
1) find and assassinate King Pin - Punisher

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught - The Goddamn Batman

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas - Iron Fist

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid - Captain America

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking - Captain America

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden - The Goddamn Batman

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters - Punisher

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time - Captain America

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything - Iron Fist

10) KO Wolverine - Iron Fist

thumb up

Mshinu
1) assasination: Frank
2) infiltration: Bruce
3) 1000 Ninjas: Danny
4) escort: Matt
5) talking: Steve
6) Bin Laden: Bruce
7) Booby trap: Frank
8) boot camp: Steve
9) torture: Steve
10) KO Wolverine: Danny

Once again, Parker is useless wink

marwash22
Is everyone picking Cap for the 4th one because he has soldier experience?

IMO, Parker is a much better choice for the 4th scenario than Cap is. What Spidey lacks in military training, he more than makes up for in sensing danger. Plus, he's (more) superhuman than Cap. Cap gets taken out by an IED/sniper fire waaaaaay before Parker does.

D_Dude1210
Originally posted by marwash22
Is everyone picking Cap for the 4th one because he has soldier experience?

IMO, Parker is a much better choice for the 4th scenario than Cap is. What Spidey lacks in military training, he more than makes up for in sensing danger. Plus, he's (more) superhuman than Cap. Cap gets taken out by an IED/sniper fire waaaaaay before Parker does.

Good point about the spider sense. But doesn't it only apply to danger targeting him? I can't remember when he's used it to sense danger on other ppl.

Also, I'm assuming without the use of most standard equipment for number 4. Otherwise, Batman would just get the batjet and fly the kid away.

Q99
Originally posted by marwash22
Is everyone picking Cap for the 4th one because he has soldier experience?

IMO, Parker is a much better choice for the 4th scenario than Cap is. What Spidey lacks in military training, he more than makes up for in sensing danger. Plus, he's (more) superhuman than Cap. Cap gets taken out by an IED/sniper fire waaaaaay before Parker does.

Capt's really good at protecting people with his shield, though, and Parker really doesn't have any place to swing around.

Mshinu
Sure, send the teenage nerd with no military training into Afghanistan to escort & protect a child against the Taliban...

But he gots the infallible spider sense right?

http://www.imagebam.com/image/678dad82790990/

yeah.. perfectly safe.

Besides.. Parker got good looks so the Talib would probably make a dancing boy out of him. evil face
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacch%C3%A1

Parmaniac
1) Punisher

2) Punisher / Batman / Spider-man

3) Punisher (with guns of course)

4) Spider-man / Punisher (with the van)

5) Captain America

6) Batman / Captain America / Punisher

7) Punisher / Spider-man

8) Spider-man

9) Batman / Punisher

10) Iron Fist

Mshinu
Also LOL at Parker passing trough boot camp the fastest. His smart ass attitude alone would earn him months of toilet scrubbing.

Parmaniac
Originally posted by Mshinu
Also LOL at Parker passing trough boot camp the fastest. His smart ass attitude alone would earn him months of toilet scrubbing. Whoops I was mistaken the boot camp with the parcour where you have to run through in a certain time.

marwash22
Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Good point about the spider sense. But doesn't it only apply to danger targeting him? I can't remember when he's used it to sense danger on other ppl. Well, if the boy is close enough, like on his back, it should work no problem. Spidey sense is a proximity sorta thing, the attack doesn't have to be directly aimed at him for it to activate, it just has to be close. Also, it works especially well when he is expecting danger. Unless Venom, Kraven or someone like that is apart of this group trying to kill the kid, nothing they do is gonna catch him off guard.

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Also, I'm assuming without the use of most standard equipment for number 4. Otherwise, Batman would just get the batjet and fly the kid away. I would think "escort" means that they are on foot.

Originally posted by Q99
Capt's really good at protecting people with his shield, though, and Parker really doesn't have any place to swing around Hmmm, true about the swinging, though not entirely 'cause there are structures around, Afghanistan isn't just a big open field. Also, Parker's webbing makes for a much more potent weapon than what Cap has. Eh, either one is a good choice, i picked Parker due to spidey-sense and being able to do more while protecting someone. Cap's shield only protects from one side, if there's fire coming from multiple angles he's screwed.

Originally posted by Mshinu
Sure, send the teenage nerd with no military training into Afghanistan to escort & protect a child against the Taliban...

But he gots the infallible spider sense right?

http://www.imagebam.com/image/678dad82790990/

yeah.. perfectly safe. OP said nothing about PIS being on. That wouldn't happen 'cause Parker wouldn't ignore the spidey-sense like he did in that panel. And yeah, you're right, it's not like Spidey has fought off much more dangerous people while protecting someone. There is nothing Cap can do in this kind of situation, that Spidey can't do just as well, if not better.

marwash22
Originally posted by Mshinu
Also LOL at Parker passing trough boot camp the fastest. His smart ass attitude alone would earn him months of toilet scrubbing. yeah, that was also a reason i didn't pick Parker over Cap. Spidey could do it physically, but he's way too much of a smartass for the military.

Mshinu

marwash22
difference of opinion. no worries. Though, you're making it seem as if i said Cap would be rubbish in this situation. I said it was a toss up between the two and only went with Parker because of Spidey Sense and offensive capabilities.

You think Cap would fair better against multiple assailants, while also trying to protect the kid? I don't.

I suppose they could both put the kid in a safe place, kick ass and then retrieve the boy when the bad guys are defeated; if that's the case, it really doesn't matter which of the two we choose.

Question: Can Daredevil be sniped? Has this ever be attempted? if he can be, the person who chose him for the 4th scenario made a bad choice.

Mshinu
Originally posted by marwash22
I suppose they could both put the kid in a safe place, kick ass and then retrieve the boy when the bad guys are defeated; if that's the case, it really doesn't matter which of the two we choose.


Yeah, because that would totally solve everything and get you safely trough Taliban infested Afahnistan.

http://26.media.tumblr.com/irZDSs1Jyqil2mkvNi1y7vKKo1_500.jpg

marwash22
dude, i meant, put the kid down each time trouble arises. Not put the kid down and seek out all the bad guys at once.

Interpretation fail on your part.

Mshinu
Originally posted by marwash22
dude, i meant, put the kid down each time trouble arises. Not put the kid down and seek out all the bad guys at once.

Interpretation fail on your part.

Not at all.

Give yourself a few minutes and think about the nature of the mission, the land and the enemy. You are making a fool of yourself.

marwash22
It's your world.

tru-marvell
Originally posted by Starscream M
Pick ONE per scenario:

List:

Batman (regular equipment)
Captain America
Punisher (fully equipped and armed)
Spider-Man
Iron Fist
Daredevil

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Scenarios (not necessarily in any order of difficulty):

1) find and assassinate King Pin.....Big Pun

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught..........Batty (Spidey as backup)

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas.......Batty

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid........Cap

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking........Cap

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden.....Batty

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters.....Batty (Big Pun as a backup)

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time....Cap

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything....Cap

10) KO Wolverine ......Danny -two fisted- iron fist

marwash22
lulz. just realized Mshinu sent in the blind guy... but he says I'm the fool. erm

Mshinu
Originally posted by marwash22
lulz. just realized Mshinu sent in the blind guy... but he says I'm the fool. erm

Wanna guess why?

Mindship
1) Punisher
2) Batman
3) Punisher
4) Punisher
5) Captain America
6) Batman
7) Batman
8) Spider-Man
9) Captain America (he lives for that stuff)
10) Spider-Man

Parmaniac
Originally posted by Mshinu
Wanna guess why? Cause DD can't even read the news paper?

marwash22
Originally posted by Mshinu
Wanna guess why? Why? 'cause he has a power similar to Spiderman, except worse.

Mshinu
Originally posted by marwash22
Why? 'cause he has a power similar to Spiderman, except worse.

Well when it comes to protecting someone it might actually be better..

Anyway Matt could for instance locate the local Talib people (lie detector ftw), grab and interrogate one of them for information as well as getting into their communication network and even plant misinformation. Using this they could stay under the radar, create diversions, travel trough areas where there are no Talib etc.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Parmaniac
Cause DD can't even read the news paper?

no expression

Joke fail.

Parmaniac
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
no expression

Joke fail. Why?

marwash22
Originally posted by Mshinu
Well when it comes to protecting someone it might actually be better..

Anyway Matt could for instance locate the local Talib people (lie detector ftw), grab and interrogate one of them for information as well as getting into their communication network and even plant misinformation. Using this they could stay under the radar, create diversions, travel trough areas where there are no Talib etc. Pretty good reasoning. Though, with those tactics, I'd think Batman would be the even better choice; especially since he has actual diversionary weapons in his arsenal. I'd pick Frank over Matt as well.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Parmaniac
Why?

Because Matt can read faster than you biscuits And been doing that since the beginning of his career.

marwash22
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Because Matt can read faster than you biscuits And been doing that since the beginning of his career. he probably forgot about the touch thing being apart of his senses. though, i don't know how you can forget one of the 5 senses.

grimify
List:

Batman (regular equipment)
Captain America
Punisher (fully equipped and armed)
Spider-Man
Iron Fist
Daredevil

1) find and assassinate King Pin - Punisher

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught - Batman

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas - Batman

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid - Captain America

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking - Batman

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden - Batman

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters - Punisher

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time - Spider Man

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything - Captain America

10) KO Wolverine - Captain America

Mshinu
Originally posted by marwash22
Pretty good reasoning. Though, with those tactics, I'd think Batman would be the even better choice; especially since he has actual diversionary weapons in his arsenal. I'd pick Frank over Matt as well.

Sure Bats and Frank would be good too, however the point is that this is an extended operation against a smart enemy rather than surviving a few half-assed ambushes. It calls for strategy, cunning, ruthlesness etc, much more than the ability to take out a few towelheads with kalashnikovs.

mondru
daredevil and batman for everything here

Mshinu
Originally posted by mondru
daredevil and batman for everything here

You don`t think Cap would have an edge on them in boot camp?

mondru
Originally posted by Mshinu
You don`t think Cap would have an edge on them in boot camp?

no...

Darth Martin
Originally posted by marwash22
Question: Can Daredevil be sniped? Has this ever be attempted? if he can be, the person who chose him for the 4th scenario made a bad choice. Joke, right? roll eyes (sarcastic)

I wasn't aware that personal resources were allowed. If so, Batman would be my choice for #4 with ball of his different road, sea, and aerial transports. Or Punisher with his Battle Van.

Anyone who doesn't pick Cap for boot camp is unintelligent.

marwash22
Personal resources like automobiles, i don't think so. But Batman gets his gadgets 'cause that's who Batman is. Otherwise, the OP should have said Bruce.

Darth Martin
But, seriously. You asked could Daredevil be sniped. Was that an attempt at humor or a serious question?

mondru
Batman rolls

mondru
i just played batman arkham asylum on ps3 and batman is very cool i could beat up 10 guys at the same time with him so he is the best in this list

marwash22
Originally posted by Darth Martin
But, seriously. You asked could Daredevil be sniped. Was that an attempt at humor or a serious question? It was in jest, but it was an actual query. I realize why it SHOULDNT work, I'm just asking if it's possible. i think it is.

Darth Martin
Unless the sniper is a couple thousand feet(which isn't exactly Taliban tactics) away I'd say no. Bullseye, S.W.A.T., The Hand, Hydra, thugs, Punisher, S.H.I.E.L.D., various assassins, Widow, etc. have all tried. That type of shit doesn't work against him. He knows everything that's happening around him in roughly atleast a couple thousand feet radius. He's literally that good.

That's why I picked him. Where others would be in combat situations Daredevil could potentially avoid most of them. Whoever is knocking him in this particular situation because he's blind is stupid. That's what all the people in the books do; he's made a career of kicking their asses. He's superior to Punisher by a wide margin in most everything that doesn't involve prep.

marwash22
Uh, I'm knocking him in this situation (the 4th one only) because it doesn't matter how good his senses are when bullets are flying and he has to protect someone... he's not THAT good.

As for the sniping thing, it can be done, but not in a Daredevil comic.

Darth Martin
Really? Who better would you want? Daredevil knows the trajectory of the projectiles before thay've even been fired. He's peak human in strength and possibly superhuman in reflexes and agility(rivals Spider-Man). He dodges bullets and even deflects them BACK at the enemy. If he has to kick ass, store the child in a relatively safe hiding spot, pwn the terrorists and retrieve the package. But for the most of it he'd AVOID most of the situations all together.

marwash22
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Really? Who better would you want? I picked Spiderman.



Originally posted by Darth Martin
Daredevil knows the trajectory of the projectiles before thay've even been fired. He's peak human in strength and possibly superhuman in reflexes and agility(rivals Spider-Man). He dodges bullets and even deflects them BACK at the enemy. lulz. I think you're slightly overestimating Daredevil. No way in hell is he dodging or redirecting automatic machine-gun fire and missiles, while simultaneously protecting the kid from getting killed. Nor is he predicting a damn thing when he's getting shot at from multiple angles and crap is blowing up around him.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
If he has to kick ass, store the child in a relatively safe hiding spot, pwn the terrorists and retrieve the package. i find it funny you also came up with this idea, i got called an idiot for suggesting it as a possibility.

Mshinu
Originally posted by marwash22
i find it funny you also came up with this idea, i got called an idiot for suggesting it as a possibility.

Actually you failed to think of the scenario as anything more than surviving an ambush. As Darth Martin pointed out, Daredevil (also Cap, Bats and Pun) has what it takes to avoid being detected. Once the Talib makes you in their back yard, believe me, your odds of succeeding drops considerably no matter how badass you are.

Kid Kurdy

Darth Martin
Originally posted by marwash22
i find it funny you also came up with this idea, i got called an idiot for suggesting it as a possibility. Well, to be honest, none of these guys can directly take on an army while protecting the child. Iron Man would struggle and he dwarfs these guys as far as power and versatility goes.

Spider-Man is the most powerful of the five superheroes here. But he's by far the weakest when it comes to actual combat training and tactics. Batman and Daredevil are uber elite ninjas who have different abilities to aid them, and Cap and Punisher are top of the line soldiers who have actual military combat experience.

Spider-Man is capable of taking guys with machine guns down, don't get me wrong, but I'm not taking him over these four who are all tactical geniuses when it comes to war tactics and resourcefullness. Daredevil has soloed over a hundred ninjas while out of costume, Batman is arguably DC's smartest human, Cap and Punisher have soloed armies by themselves.

Now, as I said, Spider-Man does have advantages over these guys. For one he could likely bring down any vehicle the Taliban brings to the fight with his bare hands. Battle-wise: he may be the best here. But when their on the run? I'll take the other four guys over him anyday of the week.

Cap, Daredevil, and Punisher were the ones on the run from the Pro-Reg; not Spider-Man. Batman's record speaks for itself. He's repeatedly snuck up on the Justice League; if he doesn't want to be found chances are your not going to locate him.

Kid Kurdy
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Cap, Daredevil, and Punisher were the ones on the run from the Pro-Reg; not Spider-Man. Batman's record speaks for itself. He's repeatedly snuck up on the Justice League; if he doesn't want to be found chances are your not going to locate him.
You know that Spider-Man switched sides during Civil War ?

Darth Martin
Originally posted by Kid Kurdy
You know that Spider-Man switched sides during Civil War ? True; Depending on the book you read though he may not have done much. I remember Iron Man destroying him and Cage, not much else.

Kid Kurdy
Originally posted by Darth Martin
True; Depending on the book you read though he may not have done much. I remember Iron Man destroying him and Cage, not much else.
Oh I remember him completely webbing up Iron Man.

Mshinu
Originally posted by Kid Kurdy
I go with the fastest and strongest... me thinks this is Spider-Man.

I think you are looking for a differnent kind of escort there, kid.

Darth Martin
Originally posted by Kid Kurdy
Oh I remember him completely webbing up Iron Man. Scan? Are we talking about the same fight?

Kid Kurdy
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Scan? Are we talking about the same fight?
Here's a link:

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2007/09/06/amazing-spider-man-544-one-more-day-part-1-review/

Spire
Originally posted by Starscream M
Pick ONE per scenario:

List:

Batman (regular equipment)
Captain America
Punisher (fully equipped and armed)
Spider-Man
Iron Fist
Daredevil

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Scenarios (not necessarily in any order of difficulty):

1) find and assassinate King Pin

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything

10) KO Wolverine

1. Punisher
2. Batman
3. Captain America
4. Punisher
5. Batman without a single word
6. Batman
7. Punisher
8. Captain America
9. Punisher

namorsubby
Spider-man does them all the best.........

Blanket
Originally posted by Starscream M
Scenarios (not necessarily in any order of difficulty):

1) find and assassinate King Pin

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything

10) KO Wolverine
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman
Iron Fist/Batman

marwash22
Lot's of people are picking Cap for the 9th scenario; what makes him a better option than Batman, patriotism?

grimify
Originally posted by marwash22
Lot's of people are picking Cap for the 9th scenario; what makes him a better option than Batman, patriotism?

Honestly, Cap, Batman, and Punisher are all equal here, none of them have any chance of cracking. However, Batman technically wouldn't make it through because he's going to escape any restraints and put the hurt on the torturers.smile

marwash22
lulz. all of them could escape the torture if they wanted to, that's not the point. I just wondered why people chose Cap over Batman.

Darth Martin
Originally posted by grimify
Honestly, Cap, Batman, and Punisher are all equal here, none of them have any chance of cracking. However, Batman technically wouldn't make it through because he's going to escape any restraints and put the hurt on the torturers.smile thumb up

bobbi
1) find and assassinate King Pin - Punisher cus he's the only guy who kills people

2) infiltrate a high security government installation and steal sensitive information without getting caught - batman obviously

3) defeat 1000 Hand Ninjas - Setting really matters here but I assume it's a building or something with at least some cover. I'd go with batman cus he does have some equipment and is better at stealth. I'd feel like 1000 of them might get lucky a few times against any of the straight fighters who doesn't hide.

4) escort a child across Afganistan while Taliban soldiers are targeting the kid - Like was said, don't know if spideysense works on people he's protecting. Daredevils senses seem better though since he can avoid people before they're shooting at him as well as dodge once he's getting shot at.

5) convince a unruly street gang to lay down their weapons only through talking. Can batman do some hypnosis thing to do this? Otherwise I guess Cap. If we're talking outside of comics, I'd go with punisher threatening them since inspirational speeches don't work in real life.

6) track down the whereabouts of Osama Bin Laden. batman. He has the resources and the tracking ability.

7) Booby trap an abandoned apartment complex using only materials from Home Depot to take down a gang of 100 mobsters. I don't know much about punisher but this is what he generally does.

8) get through marine boot camp in the shortest amount of time - Cap for obvious reasons

9) make it through an interrogation torture session by North Korean soldiers without giving away anything - I'd say batman. Didn't he go through like an eternity of torture when Joker became omnipotent? He had to be memory wiped but I thought someone here mentioned he got his memory back and was able to deal. That should help him, although Cap and Punisher wouldn't crack in this situation either. probably none of them would.

10) KO Wolverine - Can I assume prep? If so batman. Some sonics or flash grenades or something should work. Without prep, I guess Iron Fist can hit the hardest and keep up with wolves

psycho gundam
daredevil would just tell the 1000 hand shinobi to stop, since dude commands them.

Darth Martin
Originally posted by Kid Kurdy
Here's a link:

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2007/09/06/amazing-spider-man-544-one-more-day-part-1-review/ Different fight.

Originally posted by bobbi
That should help him, although Cap and Punisher wouldn't crack in this situation either. probably none of them would. Your right in the fact that neither Cap, Punisher, or Bats have any chance of talking. But I wouldn't exactly trust Spider-Man here.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.