Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

http://media.moddb.com/cache/images/members/1/371/370406/thumb_620x2000/wraith_hive-ship_-_stargate_atlantis.jpg
http://rpggamer.org/uploaded_images/Basestar2.jpg
http://kidologist.com/wp-content/2008/04/star-destroyer-fnt2.JPG
1 Wraith Hive Ship vs 1 (TOS) Cylon Basestar and 1 Imperial Star Destroyer.

They just bump into each other and its all out attack.
Which ship stands the best shot of coming out on top.

Can post stats if required.

ISD wins

How so and why?


Although while looking thru it. The ISD does have the most variying stats of the 3.

I don't even know whatt hose first two are. So ISD wins.

ISD most likely. Hive ships have no shields and are vulnerable to energy weapons and the basestar's most powerful weapon takes several hits to destroy a battlestar class which are very inferior to an ISD.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
I don't even know whatt hose first two are. So ISD wins.
Why are you in the Sci Fi forum?

Wraith ships have shown to stand up to the Ancients,and Asguard energy weapons a fair bit.
Can an ISD be said to have weapons that powerful?
They didn't really show anything that impressive weaponry wise in the movies? (and no I am not counting those in the prequels)
And Wraith ships have been shown to take out shisp with Prementioned A races shields,which are reported to be quite good.

And I am including the use of the fighters of all ships in the equations of this too.

And according to the info I read on Basestars,
they were rated as a much better warship then a battlestar.

Other then the cyclons being kinda stupid at times.
WHat factor would that play?

Originally posted by Flyattractor
Why are you in the Sci Fi forum? I don't know, why?

Personality quirk?

No thank you. I'll take some brandy though.

We keep uo this line of discussion and were gonna get moved to a diff forum.

Proof of said power of ISD sheilds?