Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

who wins here

Oh my i can't decide.

Oh wait, yes i can. It is obvious that PC supes is leaps and bounds over any high herald.

SAS wins with a sneeze.

silver age thor was fighting skyfathers and above level guys..

I'm pretty sure Current Thor and Classic Thor are more or less the same barring some slight tweaks.

SA Superman beats Thor with his own hammer and then races back to stop Pat Boone from writing a hit song about him.
http://superdickery.com/images/stories/dick/1296_4_009.jpg

the ****?

Originally posted by amnesia
the ****?

Pat Boone is pretty awful indeed

PLEASE, TAKE THAT OFF!!!!

Originally posted by amnesia
Pat Boone is pretty awful indeed
He covered Metallica once:
z67IqrmygZY

Originally posted by Omega Vision
He covered Metallica once:
z67IqrmygZY

That was... Interesting..

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
PLEASE, TAKE THAT OFF!!!!


Take what off?

Originally posted by amnesia
Take what off? Your clothes

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Your clothes


Mmm

Originally posted by amnesia
Take what off?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
http://img269.imageshack.us/img269/5781/1525507803l.jpg

Why is there a shirtless guy there colossus?

http://www.geekologie.com/2007/10/16/tiny-gun.jpg

dammit, enough with the photoshops
there wasnt a guy on there i was doing work
BADA or some one, delete that shit

http://img594.imageshack.us/img594/8222/supesgrundy1.th.jpg http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/9420/supesgrundy2.th.jpg

Replace Grundy with Thor, and that's what would happen to Supes. His weakness to magic was as extreme as his weakness to Kryptonite.

Originally posted by Galan007
http://img594.imageshack.us/img594/8222/supesgrundy1.th.jpg http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/9420/supesgrundy2.th.jpg

Replace Grundy with Thor, and that's what would happen to Supes. His weakness to magic was as extreme as his weakness to Kryptonite.

"But how wrong you are superman"

http://img412.imageshack.us/img412/7600/blackpanther08p11cl0.jpg
http://img412.imageshack.us/img412/9806/blackpanther08p12ig1.jpg

Replace the bullet with Superman, considering he's faster than one, and that's what would happen to Thor. His weakness to speed was as extreme as his weakness to intelligence.

That's not Silver Age Thor.

^

Originally posted by batdude123
http://img412.imageshack.us/img412/7600/blackpanther08p11cl0.jpg
http://img412.imageshack.us/img412/9806/blackpanther08p12ig1.jpg

Replace the bullet with Superman, considering he's faster than one, and that's what would happen to Thor. His weakness to speed was as extreme as his weakness to intelligence. Good job on the double fail

Not 616 and not silver age

Oh, it was cannon -I know- but it isn't from the Silver Age. Silver Age Thor was less durable when it came to artillery but only artillery. He could take a punch or an energy blast as well as modern Thor at the very least.

Still, it was a fail on Batdude's part for using that as some kind of low showing of speed.

And Silver Age Thor did not lack intelligence. Shit, he had feats of superhuman intelligence during that era.

Lee's Thor was extremely powerful and very battle savy.

Originally posted by Galan007
http://img594.imageshack.us/img594/8222/supesgrundy1.th.jpg http://img338.imageshack.us/img338/9420/supesgrundy2.th.jpg

Replace Grundy with Thor, and that's what would happen to Supes. His weakness to magic was as extreme as his weakness to Kryptonite.
Let's be real here Galan. SA Superman did much better against PC Black Adam (also a magical being) who we all know was way more powerful than Thor.

Also those scans pretty much show Superman fighting like a dumb brick.

In a forum match Thor get's destroyed by Silver Age Superman.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Let's be real here Galan. SA Superman did much better against PC Black Adam (also a magical being) who we all know was way more powerful than Thor.

Also those scans pretty much show Superman fighting like a dumb brick.

In a forum match Thor get's destroyed by Silver Age Superman. Not really in Character Silver age Supes would stand there with his arm at his side and let Thor get the first blow.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Not really in Character Silver age Supes would stand there with his arm at his side and let Thor get the first blow.

Depends. Sometimes, Superman really could be a dick back then.

He didn't hesitate at hitting Spectre, or Martian Manhunter, or those poor pilots in planes during Superman and Captain Marvels big fight (The pilots were basically trying to stop them from wrecking the city, and Superman's like "Firing on me? I'M SUPERMAN!" *SMASH*)

Granted, he was brainwashed into fighting Cap, so his mind wasn't all there, but he really was dickish like that normally..

Anyways, the balls mostly in Supermans court here. If he strikes first, he wins. If he lets Thor strike first, he should be able to avoid the attack.

Supes is pretty good about dodging magic, when he sees it coming. He's probably even faster then the hammer itself..

But if he lets himself get hit, or for some reason can't avoid an attack, he'll lose for certain.

I think some of you took batdude's post far too seriously.

http://www.figurerealm.com/Customs/9000/8546-1.jpg

Originally posted by cdtm
Anyways, the balls mostly in Supermans court here. If he strikes first, he wins. If he lets Thor strike first, he should be able to avoid the attack.

Supes is pretty good about dodging magic, when he sees it coming. He's probably even faster then the hammer itself..

But if he lets himself get hit, or for some reason can't avoid an attack, he'll lose for certain.

yeah, Supes was extremely intelligent back then. He makes Thor look like someone from kindergarten.

Superman via farting the solar system

You mean igniting the solar system?

PC SUPERMAN

Is this really a debate?

PC Superman pulled powers out of his a**

I wonder how where the geeks back in 1973.

Hulk fans saying that Hulk could defeat Superman?

Originally posted by cdtm
Depends. Sometimes, Superman really could be a dick back then.

He didn't hesitate at hitting Spectre, or Martian Manhunter, or those poor pilots in planes during Superman and Captain Marvels big fight (The pilots were basically trying to stop them from wrecking the city, and Superman's like "Firing on me? I'M SUPERMAN!" *SMASH*)

Granted, he was brainwashed into fighting Cap, so his mind wasn't all there, but he really was dickish like that normally..


And that's what makes PC superman awesome. It is the super dickery.

http://26.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_kylamthW9i1qax06co1_500.jpg

whistling

Just kidding!

IIRC...in the Thor comic which intro'd the Asgardian Destroyer, SA Thor was taken down by a single bullet--a tranquilizer bullet at that--by a hunter in the underbrush who later found and activated the Destroyer.

SA Superman ftw.

Originally posted by Mindship
IIRC...in the Thor comic which intro'd the Asgardian Destroyer, SA Thor was taken down by a single bullet--a tranquilizer bullet at that--by a hunter in the underbrush who later found and activated the Destroyer.

SA Superman ftw.

Yeah, no. Not what happened.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Let's be real here Galan. SA Superman did much better against PC Black Adam (also a magical being) who we all know was way more powerful than Thor.

Also those scans pretty much show Superman fighting like a dumb brick.

In a forum match Thor get's destroyed by Silver Age Superman. M'kay, those scans demonstrate what the physical blows from a magical being were able to do to Supes. What happens when Thor strikes Supes with Mjolnir? Or better yet, what happens if Thor unleashes an omni-directional blast with Mjolnir?

See, this is the problem I have with pre-crisis Supes. Most people tend to look only at his "solar system-pwning11!!1" feats, and completely disregard his lower showings (and there's a lot of them.)

Originally posted by Spire
Yeah, no. Not what happened. Journey Into Mystery with The Mighty Thor Issue #118
"To Kill a Thunder God" -- "Introducing: the Indestructible Destroyer."

Page 3, panel 4. The Hunter's thoughts (upon spying an unsuspecting Thor swinging his hammer, about to take off):
"Thor!! The greatest prize of all to any hunter. I wouldn't dare risk a mere bullet on such a target--but this anesthetic shell, which can instantly stop a herd of elephants, may put him to sleep."
Page 3, panel 5. Narration: And so, the mighty Thor is temporarily felled by the one weapon which his indescribable strength is useless against--a simple, fast-acting, sleeping-gas shell!
Pictured: Thor dropping without so much as an utterence and out like a light in panel 6.

What's not clear is whether or not the shell actually pierced Thor's skin, as there is no spray of gas to suggest it exploded against him, but neither is a wound indicated. The only thing that is clear is that Thor was literally one-shotted by a hunter with a rifle, albeit with a very powerful chemical kick.

considering that later on in the very same issue thor was going blow for blow with the destroyer without even a scratch to show for it, that musta been some seriously potent anesthetic gas. none

Originally posted by john allerdyce
considering that later on in the very same issue thor was going blow for blow with the destroyer without even a scratch to show for it, that musta been some seriously potent anesthetic gas. none I wonder what the hunter was planning on shooting to begin with, since he hadn't gone out looking for Thor.

Regarding the fight: Thor was getting his arse kicked. The only blow he landed was a hammer throw, which completely unfazed the Destroyer, which then proceded to lift it and use it against Thor. Thor spends the next few pages dodging and evading--good examples of close-quarters agility, actually--but likely why he showed nary a scratch.

Bump.

Originally posted by Mindship
IIRC...in the Thor comic which intro'd the Asgardian Destroyer, SA Thor was taken down by a single bullet--a tranquilizer bullet at that--by a hunter in the underbrush who later found and activated the Destroyer.

SA Superman ftw.

Thats that whole stupid backward durability thing. I wouldn't give Superman the win based on that reason, unless Supes is gna start firing at him with a machine gun.

Anyway Thor's only hope in this fight is magical based attacks. Physically SA Supes kills him.