Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/6535/975521-giganta017_large.jpg

vs

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/3/31566/824658-atom_smasher_1_large.jpg

Giganta. Seems a lot tougher. Blue Beetle couldn't even hurt her without resorting to pressure points, and he's hurt Supergirl, plus she's been stiff competition for Wonder Woman.

Originally posted by cdtm
Giganta. Seems a lot tougher. Blue Beetle couldn't even hurt her without resorting to pressure points, and he's hurt Supergirl, plus she's been stiff competition for Wonder Woman.

Though as giants go, Atom Smasher's a pretty strong/tough one too, more-so than most.

I think I probably agree, but he's likely to get some wins.

Atom Smasher just brawled out with some gods. lol

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Atom Smasher just brawled out with some gods. lol

That's impressive.

Which ones?

Came out yesterday in JSA All-Stars. These gods were putting a beating on Powergirl, until Atom Smasher came and helped out. New gods, haven't seen before.

I think he might even be able to get stronger than her, but I know if Atom Smasher gets too big, it hurts him.

good fight, but I think Giganta could win.

Side question, is there any other grower that'd stand a good chance against either of them? I have trouble thinking of any.

PC Colossal Boy?

Living Monolith.

Apocalypse.

LM and Apoc are both "Tons of powers, among them growth," types, though. Even at human size they're super powerful. I'm wondering more about pure growers.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
PC Colossal Boy?

Hm, possibly.

Looking back at some old scans, it looks like sometimes he was more impressive, sometimes less.

Hank Pym. biscuits

Originally posted by -Pr-
Hank Pym. biscuits

Pretty sure either of these'd take him in a giant sized fist fight.

Originally posted by Q99
Pretty sure either of these'd take him in a giant sized fist fight.

hence the smiley lol

Originally posted by Q99
Side question, is there any other grower that'd stand a good chance against either of them? I have trouble thinking of any.

Goliath

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20070105093554/marveldatabase/images/4/4c/Erik_Josten_%28Earth-616%29_004.jpg
http://marvel.wikia.com/Erik_Josten_(Earth-616)

Atom Smasher should win by slight majority.

BTW, anyone know which comic issue that picture Giganta was in?

Lesse, I don't remember the issue, but it's when Diana fought a group of villains going by 'Villainy Inc.' which included Giganta of course (and it was, as a side note, the first time post-crisis when Diana and Giganta met on panel properly) during Jimenez's run.

Originally posted by complexbrother
Goliath

http://marvel.wikia.com/Erik_Josten_(Earth-616)

Good call, yea, he's one of the stronger giants.