Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins ?

Good one. Not sure.

CM because I think that the Guardian amp wouldn't last longer then CMs amp.

DOV Spectre would probably break the armor in 1-2 solid punches.

I love this thread as it really puts to the test those who feel magic doesn't hurt him. I believe it would hurt him and think Marvel stomps.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I love this thread as it really puts to the test those who feel magic doesn't hurt him. I believe it would hurt him and think Marvel stomps.

Honestly man, have you ever read anything with Prime in it. It's been made clear multiple times throughout his runs that his immune to magic.

It was even made more clear when he said Black Adam magical hits tickle him. It was even made more clear when he was strike by an Angel's holy sword.

Anyway can't say who wins, but i see Prime winning the majority of there fights.

Prime..magic won't do much to him..

Originally posted by SquallX
Honestly man, have you ever read anything with Prime in it. It's been made clear multiple times throughout his runs that his immune to magic.

It was even made more clear when he said Black Adam magical hits tickle him. It was even made more clear when he was strike by an Angel's holy sword.

Anyway can't say who wins, but i see Prime winning the majority of there fights. That means he's highly immune not completely unaffected by magic. He doesn't have a magical weakness like Superman has. He was hurt by Zauriel whose strength is magical and claiming all the magic in the universe couldn't hurt him it's illogical since magic can recreate red solar energy etc. which does depower prime or block out the sun.

I think all powers of DOV Captain Marvel were amped by magic. Wasn't casting spells, so with that said, I think prime still takes this. They both would use up their amp and then it would be Prime vs Cap.

Originally posted by quanchi112
That means he's highly immune not completely unaffected by magic. He doesn't have a magical weakness like Superman has. He was hurt by Zauriel whose strength is magical and claiming all the magic in the universe couldn't hurt him it's illogical since magic can recreate red solar energy etc. which does depower prime or block out the sun.

Maybe he meant if they used it as a direct means to harm him? Supes Prime isn't very smart ye know?

He's not immune.

Not at all.

Just highly resistant.

does immune to magic mean a magic powered being will not hurt you no matter how hard he physically punches you?

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
does immune to magic mean a magic powered being will not hurt you no matter how hard he physically punches you?


glad you brought that up. If someone is magically amped, and this magic increased the base stats of that being then that magic wouldnt be actually used in the form of a spell. Anotherwards.


PRime being immune or highly resistant to magic dont mean jack zhit.


DOV cap i think is more powerful, i think this will be a excellent fight, dunno who wins.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Maybe he meant if they used it as a direct means to harm him? Supes Prime isn't very smart ye know? He's just highly resistant and a few blasts and punches does not equate 100 percent magical immunity.

Never said he was 100 percent immune. I just meant that I kind of understand SBP's point of view regarding magic; given his stupidity and the fact he has not been phased by anything magical thrown at him. He probably hasn't thought of how versatile magic can be.

Future Mordru could have tooled DOV Marvel Imo.

Why would DOV Marvel's attacks not effect Superman Prime?

His resistance seems to be similar to Superman's "weakness". This means it protects him from more direct magical attacks but not from amping.

Originally posted by Uriel005
Future Mordru could have tooled DOV Marvel Imo.

mabey but dov marvel has a better chance against prime then any form of mordru. DOv marvel had insane magical amps and durability. he had the specter beat if it wasnt for interference. I dont think Prime would have faired as well against dov specter. BIllys magical resistance was insane. BIlly unlike mordru will physically fight and use the magical amps in a effort to increase his physical atributes. He wont be casting spells. I dont see future mordru beating dov marvel either. Billy beats him to shit. Once you remove PRimes immunity or resistance to magic he really is only a over powered version of supes.


I think this fight goes either way.

Originally posted by Uriel005
Future Mordru could have tooled DOV Marvel Imo. Marvel would have raped future Mordru.

I'd say Captain Marvel.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Marvel would have raped future Mordru.
Please tell me someone hacked quan's account.