Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Just wondering how well Superman does against some of the baddies that Thor faces.

1.Skurge the Executioner
2.Loki
3.Hela
4.Seth
5.Asgardian Destroyer(since its portrayed as a Villain anyways)
6.Mangog(classic)
7.Midgard Serpent
8.Desak
9.Surtur
10.Harald Jaekelsson

1. Has some serious trouble initially, but eventually beats him.

2. Has some very serious trouble through out. Loki should get the majority.

3. Same as above. Hela could outright kill Supes if he doesn't know about her death touch or Hand of Glory.

4. Depends on how Seth is portrayed.

5. Outside of plot device or BFR, he shouldn't beat the Destroyer, period.

6. Loses hard.

7. Loses.

8. He should beat Desak, all in all.

9. Outside of PIS, he should lose a majority to Surtur.

10. Outside of PIS/plot device in the form of a mage helping him out, he should lose to Harald.

Originally posted by Igniz
Just wondering how well Superman does against some of the baddies that Thor faces.

1.Skurge the Executioner
2.Loki
3.Hela
4.Seth
5.Asgardian Destroyer(since its portrayed as a Villain anyways)
6.Mangog(classic)
7.Midgard Serpent
8.Desak
9.Surtur
10.Harald Jaekelsson

1.Skurge the Executioner - Owns him
2.Loki - Possibly loses
3.Hela - Same as above
4.Seth - Loses
5.Asgardian Destroyer(since its portrayed as a Villain anyways) - Depends on showing
6.Mangog(classic) - Owns him
7.Midgard Serpent - Owns him
8.Desak - Owns him
9.Surtur - Loses horribly
10.Harald Jaekelsson - Owns him

Superman is too weak and helpless to defeat Thor's foes. It is like pitting a marmot against a pack of wolves.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3b/Marmot-edit1.jpg/220px-Marmot-edit1.jpgg
vs
http://www.smalldoggiesmagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/wolf-pack.jpg

Originally posted by Simbon
Superman is too weak and helpless to defeat Thor's foes. It is like pitting a marmot against a pack of wolves.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3b/Marmot-edit1.jpg/220px-Marmot-edit1.jpgg
vs
http://www.smalldoggiesmagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/wolf-pack.jpg your right those wolves never stood a chance....

but no Supes magic weakness and current levels he should be beaten soundly by most on this list. Loki and Hela are reliant on magic abuses. Destroyer from the movie would get wrecked though. That thing was weaksauce.

Does he get the hammer?

why would he............

He is taken and put to fight against magical opponents. Since he is vulnerable to magic, the hammer would have helped. But with or w/o the hammer, he figures out a way to beat them. He always does.

Originally posted by Diesldude
He is taken and put to fight against magical opponents. Since he is vulnerable to magic, the hammer would have helped. But with or w/o the hammer, he figures out a way to beat them. He always does. In comic he would but on Forum he wouldn't. Thor doesn't beat anything on a higher level than Loki and Hela but thats only due to his lack of magic vulnerability combined with Mjolnir versatility which actually says more about Odin than it does about Thor if you think about it, or rather the dwarf who crafted it.

Yo.

Originally posted by Igniz
Just wondering how well Superman does against some of the baddies that Thor faces.

1.Skurge the Executioner
2.Loki
3.Hela
4.Seth
5.Asgardian Destroyer(since its portrayed as a Villain anyways)
6.Mangog(classic)
7.Midgard Serpent
8.Desak
9.Surtur
10.Harald Jaekelsson

he can beat Skurge & Loki, and can find ways to defeat Hela/the AD/Mangog/the Mid Snake/Surtur........but he'll need help and or tech to displace'em (basically, he'll hafta bfr them).

those i didnt mention I have no knowledge about.




Tazer

Originally posted by Igniz
Just wondering how well Superman does against some of the baddies that Thor faces.

1.Skurge the Executioner
2.Loki
3.Hela
4.Seth
5.Asgardian Destroyer(since its portrayed as a Villain anyways)
6.Mangog(classic)
7.Midgard Serpent
8.Desak
9.Surtur
10.Harald Jaekelsson
Beats 1-4, and 7-8. Loses to 5-6, and gets stomped by 9-10.

Superman dominates.

On the boards he should beat some of these guys soundly but others would crush him.

In Comics he would have a helluva hard time with any of these with the exception of the 1st one.