Guy Gardner Vs Martian Manhunter
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Prep-Man
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/54/79595-132234-guy-gardner_large.jpg
vs
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/9/96523/1922532-76083_149782_martian_manhunter_super_large.jpg
CPT Space Bomb
Head tells me Guy, Heart tells me MM. Going with heart on this one.
nimbus006
Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Head tells me Guy, Heart tells me MM. Going with heart on this one.
You must be slow as both should tell you MM.

j/k
JakeTheBank
Guy kicks his ass.
Bentley
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Guy kicks his ass.
And its all he manages to do before going down like a chump.
Parmaniac
Originally posted by Lord Feron
MM
vansonbee
Telepathic attack, phase through the green lantern shielding, super strength?
MM for the majority.
Cogito
Originally posted by vansonbee
Telepathic attack, phase through the green lantern shielding, super strength?
Won't work (GL rings protect against TP), may not work (any evidence?), Guy also has super strength/durability (GL ring...)
That said, MM would win unless Guy pulls fire out of his ass. Even then, I feel like MM hasn't been showing the same level of weakness to fire recently.
MM 6/10
Badabing
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Guy kicks his ass. You are truth! Originally posted by Bentley
And its all he manages to do before going down like a chump. You are French.
Truth>>>>>>French. sneer

zopzop
Originally posted by vansonbee
Telepathic attack, phase through the green lantern shielding, super strength?
MM for the majority.

CosmicComet
Guy impales J'onn on his hard nipples.
Badabing
Originally posted by CosmicComet
Guy impales J'onn on his hard nipples. You are a scholar and a gentleman.

vansonbee
Originally posted by Cogito
Won't work (GL rings protect against TP), may not work (any evidence?), Guy also has super strength/durability (GL ring...)
That said, MM would win unless Guy pulls fire out of his ass. Even then, I feel like MM hasn't been showing the same level of weakness to fire recently.
MM 6/10 Tp worked on John and Kyle if I recall the burning lantern incident.
OneDumbG0
Originally posted by vansonbee
phase through the green lantern shielding He's done that?
CosmicComet
Originally posted by Badabing
You are a scholar and a gentleman.
http://img819.imageshack.us/img819/6558/hellya.png
vansonbee
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
He's done that? Not that I know of, but assuming its possible, otherwise none was stated that the GL shielding is special, but you did recall the TP working on John during the Burning Martian thing right?
OneDumbG0
^ GL's tp defenses are as spotty as anybody's. Few comic characters have ever exhibited truly consistent tp defense.
Martian_mind
Jonn phased out of Hal's construct in JLA:Year one.
OneDumbG0
Originally posted by Martian_mind
Jonn phased out of Hal's construct in JLA:Year one. Hal sucks.
JakeTheBank
JLA: Year One's not canon anymore.
...not that will mean anything in the coming weeks.
Prep-Man
I'm betting MM can phase through GG shields. Plus MM has tp.
Batman-Prime
MM 6/10. Guy is good but he ain't Hal.
CosmicComet
Guy always was the best, what are you talking about?
JakeTheBank
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
MM 6/10. Guy is good but he ain't Hal.
Yeah, he's better than Highball.
Batman-Prime
Originally posted by CosmicComet
Guy always was the best, what are you talking about?
Who took out Krona? vin
JakeTheBank
Geoff Johns' wankery?
OneDumbG0
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Who took out Krona? vin The schmoe who got immediately owned by a random Guardian immediately thereafter.
Prep-Man
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Who took out Krona? vin
Hal Fckn Jordan!
Batman-Prime
Originally posted by Prep-Man
Hal Fckn Jordan!
Why are there so many Hal Haters here on board, do you understand this Prep-Man?
Cogito
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Why are there so many Hal Haters here on board, do you understand this Prep-Man?
Hal's return usurped Kyle, who's a far better character. That's the main reason I don't care so much for him.
Hal is the 4th best GL, at best. (Kyle =/> Guy > 'Wog > Hal)
Prep-Man
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Why are there so many Hal Haters here on board, do you understand this Prep-Man?
This generation mostly will like Kyle. Hal is old school. I don't prefer one over the other, but I like Hal and he has some of the best feats ever. PC, of course.
Zack Fair
Originally posted by Cogito
Hal's return usurped Kyle, who's a far better character. That's the main reason I don't care so much for him.
http://28.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lhmof9cx5p1qhepwdo1_250.gif
aztec
Guy has never impressed me. He always gets steamrolled. Just to compare, John fared better against Doomsday than Guy.

OneDumbG0
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Even%20More%20Random/Phail07.jpg
SuperiorTech
Order of greatness.
Kyle
Hal
Guy
CPT Space Bomb
I prefer Hal over everyone else. Kyle second. I think Guy is actually my least favorite GL..
cdtm
Originally posted by aztec
Guy has never impressed me. He always gets steamrolled. Just to compare, John fared better against Doomsday than Guy.
Guy also brought the entire Corp together in Recharged, thought up that "trawling net" in Blackest Night, and defeated Eclipsed Superman..
Plus, he was tossing Despero around and holding his own, until Ice got hurt and he lost his cool.
Guys a pretty awesome character, that often gets shortchanged because of years of being written down as a one dimensional joke character in the Giffen days..
OneDumbG0
Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
I prefer Hal over everyone else. Kyle second. I think Guy is actually my least favorite GL.. http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Even%20More%20Random/Phail14.jpg
Wrong. Just, so wrong.
leonidas
heh. hal is #1 for me too in terms of gl ability, but i like both kyle and guy better as characters. i like hal too--he's kinda classic, but the others are a little more... modern, if that makes sense.
BattleMage
MM will blow guy's back out!
Zack Fair
Originally posted by BattleMage
MM will blow guy's back out!
http://www.threadbombing.com/data/media/2/maxwell_smart__confused.gif
cdtm
Guy should certainly be powerful enough to hurt MM.
He's hurt Superman, after all.
He's also contained Lobo for a brief time, when he got his yellow ring.. That's pretty impressive, if you consider how strong Lobo is often portrayed.
carver9
Originally posted by -Pr-
Split imo.
This.
Mindset
Originally posted by -Pr-
Split imo. I agree, they both suck so much it's hard to tell who wins.
OneDumbG0
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/More%20Random/GuyGardner02.jpg
DARTH POWER
If MM can phase through GL's shield then I dnt see any GL defeating him.
Even if he cant he still beats Guy. Strength and Speed in league with the big guns plus Advanced Shapeshifting abilities plus one of the most Powerful Telepaths in comics.
aztec
Originally posted by cdtm
Guy also brought the entire Corp together in Recharged, thought up that "trawling net" in Blackest Night, and defeated Eclipsed Superman..
Plus, he was tossing Despero around and holding his own, until Ice got hurt and he lost his cool.
Guys a pretty awesome character, that often gets shortchanged because of years of being written down as a one dimensional joke character in the Giffen days..
To be honest, I don't follow Guy other than the small apperances he's made in Superman, Blue Beetle etc.. He hasn't shown anything to prove that he's an elite hero. He's by far the least interesting Green Lantern: Hal, Kyle, John, Alan, Wog.... then its Gardner. He doesn't bring anything to the table. Anyway, I was rereading DC #0 from 2-3 years ago and was cracking up when Batman mentioned to Clark and Diana that he punched him in the face. Bruce reminded me of a three year old haha.. Also, Black Canary took a picture of the fiasco and sent it to WW lawls...
aztec
Originally posted by aztec
To be honest, I don't follow Guy other than the small apperances he's made in Superman, Blue Beetle etc.. He hasn't shown anything to prove that he's an elite hero. He's by far the least interesting Green Lantern: Hal, Kyle, John, Alan, Wog.... then its Gardner. He doesn't bring anything to the table. Anyway, I was rereading DC #0 from 2-3 years ago and was cracking up when Batman mentioned to Clark and Diana that he punched him in the face. Bruce reminded me of a three year old haha.. Also, Black Canary took a picture of the fiasco and sent it to WW lawls...
I'm still going with the Martian for the majority.
cdtm
Batman one shot KOing Guy WAS pretty funny.
But the joke was on him, because soon after the Grey Man started taking the League apart, and Guy wasn't able to come to the party. Nice leadership skills, Bats.
Hell, Mr. Miracle and Captain Marvel were debating on quitting the league because Bats was enjoying egging Gardner on a little too much.
JakeTheBank
Originally posted by aztec
To be honest, I don't follow Guy other than the small apperances he's made in Superman, Blue Beetle etc.. He hasn't shown anything to prove that he's an elite hero.
Reading Green Lantern stuff helps.
aztec
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Reading Green Lantern stuff helps.
I do read Green Lantern, his name is Hal Jordan.
I own all of his individual issues since Rebirth up until Blackest Night #1.. However, I own Blackest Night tbp, Sinestro Corps War, The Flash & Green Lantern: Brave & Bold, Justice League and most of his current apperances since 2007 that he's made outside of his book.
abhilegend
Originally posted by abhilegend
http://s3d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/17522086_9530384.jpg http://s3d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/17522087_283474.jpg http://s3d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/17522088_8811083.jpg http://s3d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/17522089_010-Green_Lantern_Rebirth_003Rembrandt-DCP.jpg
cdtm
Originally posted by cdtm
Batman one shot KOing Guy WAS pretty funny.
But the joke was on him, because soon after the Grey Man started taking the League apart, and Guy wasn't able to come to the party. Nice leadership skills, Bats.
Hell, Mr. Miracle and Captain Marvel were debating on quitting the league because Bats was enjoying egging Gardner on a little too much.
Post made in 2011.. Jesus christ.
Feeling old.
Mshinu
Guy wins by flamethrower construct.
Hal is stil >>>>> Guy tho.
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2025 KillerMovies.