Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

who's better?


I'd Eddie Van Halen NO DOUBT. Eddie's an innovative virtuoso and is the BEST guitarist of all time while Satch is just one of the greatest guitarist - no innovation, no imagination imo.

I don't wanna hear a bad word bout Satriani! Got it!

Both these guys freakin rock. I ain't comparing them. But to say Joe has no imagination is insanity/

Satriani

Personally though I think Steve Vai is better than both.

And lol at the OP's bias.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
And lol at the OP's bias.

So the OP can't have an opinion on his post.


Anyway I gotta go with Van Halen. Both are amazing, but Van Halen edges him out IMO.

Eddie Van Halen is a virtuso artist and musician who created some of the best rock music EVER .

not to mention his numerous innovation in the 70s and 80s paved the way for Satch, Steve Vai, etc. Eddie MAKES GREAT MUSIC.



Satch on the other hand is a technician. he is a "TECHNICALLY" good guitarist who knows a lot about music. His music is "OK" though. His solo albums bores the shit out of me after listening to them two-three times. and i Love Hagar but Chickenfoot sucks.
Also, there is nothing revolutionary about Satch.

Van Halen is revolutionary, Satch is a follower.

Eddie Van Halen vs. Satriani is like the difference between an awesome NASCAR DRIVER and an awesome CAR REPAIR MAN.

Or between a FORMULA 1 DRIVER and a NASCAR DRIVER.

Or between a MICHELLIN STAR CHEF and a FRY COOK.

Or between a SHAREHOLDER IN A MULTINATIONAL and an OWNER OF A SMALL COMPANY.

Or between a AN ACCOMPLISHED WIZARD or a FRESHMAN AT HOGWARTS.

Or between a VICTORIA'S SECRET MODEL and YOUR GIRLFRIEND.

Or between A JUICY STEAK and BEEF JERKEY.

Exactly Slay lol

I gotta go with Satch.
The guy tells a story without words.
Eddie gets his due no doubt, but the only true instrumental effort we got from him was in a porno................
Or at least as far as I know.

Originally posted by mr.smiley
I gotta go with Satch.
The guy tells a story without words.
Eddie gets his due no doubt, but the only true instrumental effort we got from him was in a porno................
Or at least as far as I know.


Absolute BS!

Satch is a great "technician". he knows HOW to play the guitar TECHNICALLY he's awesome. but he's a shitty musician and artist.

EVH on the other hand is a TECHNICALLY AWESOME GUITARIST, MUSICIAN AND ARTIST. He created some of the best rock music of all time! PERIOD.

Originally posted by shokosugi
Absolute BS!

Satch is a great "technician". he knows HOW to play the guitar TECHNICALLY he's awesome. but he's a shitty musician and artist.

EVH on the other hand is a TECHNICALLY AWESOME GUITARIST, MUSICIAN AND ARTIST. He created some of the best rock music of all time! PERIOD.


.............

I don't disagree that VH created some amazing riffs. My issue is that he has yet to show he can put out a whole album of his riffs and succesfully tell a story without words. As far as I know that is.
For what it's worth,I don't think Eddie has ever created anything remotely equal to Surfing with The Alien or Flying In a Blue dream.

Originally posted by shokosugi
Absolute BS! but he's a shitty musician and artist.


Oh Shokosugi. To say Satriani was a shitty musician blows my mind.

Your bias was truly legendary.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Satriani

Personally though I think Steve Vai is better than both.

And lol at the OP's bias.

You took the words right away from my fingertips. Vai is the best.

Steve Vai was Joe's student.

here's my ranking.

EVH > John Petrucci > Joe Satriani > Steve Vai

Originally posted by shokosugi
Steve Vai was Joe's student.

here's my ranking.

EVH > John Petrucci > Joe Satriani > Steve Vai

Have you ever heard of the Student surpassing the Teacher? In Vai's case, this is especially true. Steve Vai would destroy Eddie Van Halen if they were cutting heads.

It's even arguable, if Eddie is even in the top 10 best guitarists ever. I think Slash would give him a hard time to be honest.

Vai and Satch are touring Sydney next month. F Yeah!.

you're just a stupid kid who's into some rock band crap you'll never understand satriani's music unless you take a journey into classical music and got your heart hooked for couple of years in that kinda music then maybe you'll appreciate the soul of his music a bit more maybe then you'll realize that van halen as unique and genius as he is his music had never the soul and dept of joe's

Originally posted by ares834
So the OP can't have an opinion on his post.

Essentially what he posted:

"Who's better between these two (I actually think it's not a contest, and right away will doubt anything the Satriani camp says)?"

Originally posted by pinky1
you're just a stupid kid who's into some rock band crap you'll never understand satriani's music unless you take a journey into classical music and got your heart hooked for couple of years in that kinda music then maybe you'll appreciate the soul of his music a bit more maybe then you'll realize that van halen as unique and genius as he is his music had never the soul and dept of joe's
Use some commas, kid.

Originally posted by shokosugi
EVH > John Petrucci No.