The Hobbit vs Lord of the Rings

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



C-3POTheClever
Which do you like better out of the Hobbit & LOTR?

Lord Lucien
Since only one of the Hobbit is released, it's not a fair comparison.


But I'll take any of the LotR over Unexpected Journey any day.

Newjak
I much prefer An Unexpected Journey over the Fellowship.

Omega Vision
Fellowship>Unexpected Journey>>>Two Towers and ROTK

I wanted to put Unexpected Journey higher, because the Hobbit was/is my favorite children's book ever, but they changed a lot and split it into two movies needlessly which annoyed me.

C-3POTheClever
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Fellowship>Unexpected Journey>>>Two Towers and ROTK

I wanted to put Unexpected Journey higher, because the Hobbit was/is my favorite children's book ever, but they changed a lot and split it into two movies needlessly which annoyed me. Not just 2, but 3.

Omega Vision
Originally posted by C-3POTheClever
Not just 2, but 3.
From what I understand the third movie may not be a part of the story proper but a supplemental account.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Since only one of the Hobbit is released, it's not a fair comparison.

thumb up

elrond72
I agree lets wait until all 3 films are released before we can make a fair comparison. Plus splitting into 3 films means we can see more of the back stories such as Gandalfs journey into Dol Guldur and the first hints at the degeneration of Saruman by trying to stop driving the Necromancer (ie Sauron) from Mirkwood. In the words of Treebeard, lets not be hasty!!

StiltmanFTW
Knowing Jackson, all three films might get extended versions later.

C-3POTheClever
I think I've heard they will

JohnathanP
For me its Hobbit.

ajayaggarwal254
I like both equally

sorrowmovie
Originally posted by ajayaggarwal254
I like both equally

me too...

AncientPower
The Lord of the Rings is in a league of it's own to be honest.

PaulsHomeAlone
Both equally 6 of the best movies out there.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by AncientPower
The Lord of the Rings is in a league of it's own to be honest.

thumb up

NemeBro
LotR. It helps that it had a considerably better source material.

Robtard
LoTR by far, some of my favorite movies all around. Ones I can start watching at any point of the film and enjoy.

In order of preference:

TT/Fellowship
RoTK

Unexpected
Desolation
Five Armies

queeq

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.