Batman, Reed Richards, Dr Doom vs Thanos in a prep battle

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



golem370
Both sides have 10 days of prep equal resources but no outside help. Can these three defeat Thanos?

armedforbattle
Bats reed & doom win.

ColossusGrundy
Team wins

Tony Stark
Reed vs Bats, DOOM, THANOS= Reed

TheLordofMurder
Spite...

Reed alone could potentially out-prep Thanos; adding Doom and the Bat to the equation makes this completely unwinnable for Thanos...

Badabing
Thanos is backed by Death, he wins. thanduros

Odekahn
Batman solos

Mindset
Team easily.

golem370
Thanos imo is smart enough to defeat these three.

Mindset
laughing out loud

753
team

pym-ftw
Doom or Reed solo

Batman isn't a factor

KuRuPT Thanosi
Batman is a non factor... All these being equal.. I think the team wins... Had they not hadicapped Thanos for this match.. it wuold be closer.

golem370
Thanos has the smarts and the power to win imo. Thanos on the fly was able to stop Galactus from destroying the Ragelian world and stop the intial attack of hunger. He had only maybe an hour to prep

Mindset
Doom with a couple hours of prep was able to steal Galactus' and Beyonder's powers.

Reed has probably done something to.

golem370
That was the weaker Beyonder and Thanos almost killed Galactus.

BruceSkywalker
Originally posted by Badabing
Thanos is backed by Death, he wins. thanduros

but you cannot kill The Batman big grin

oh and team wins

Mindset
Originally posted by golem370
That was the weaker Beyonder and Thanos almost killed Galactus. What do you mean it was a weaker Beyonder?

Yea, Doom could have killed Galactus if he wanted to. On multiple occasions, in fact.

kgkg
Reed is too much.

pym-ftw
Originally posted by Mindset
What do you mean it was a weaker Beyonder?

Yea, Doom could have killed Galactus if he wanted to. On multiple occasions, in fact.
Beyonder allowed Doom to control his power, that's what I assumed he meant

Mindset
But...he didn't.

golem370
I mean he was the weaker Beyonder the one who lost to Kubik

Mindset
I don't recall this?

I do recall Beyonder in SW, even in the retelling, having power that dwarfed Galactus and Spiderman was able to easily manipulate reality using it.

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by golem370
Thanos has the smarts and the power to win imo. Thanos on the fly was able to stop Galactus from destroying the Ragelian world and stop the intial attack of hunger. He had only maybe an hour to prep

Reed beat the Living Tribunal...

Doom beat Classic Beyonder...

Thanos gets his sh!t pushed in by these two...

Mindset
Batman beats Robin.

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by Mindset
Batman beats Robin.

On a daily basis...

Peni$ vs anu$

golem370
Thanos killed everybody including LT and everybody under him. Thanos was only stopped by Thanos.

Mindset
Not sure what him getting the HOTU is supposed to prove here.

golem370
I guess no real prep went into that the HOTU. But Dr Doom stealing Beyonder's powers I am pretty sure it was Beyonder after he was downgraded.

Mindset
At most he was downgraded to a cube being that dwarfed Galactus in power and could easily manipulate reality on a massive, perhaps, universal scale.

Diesldude
Thanos wins.

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by golem370
Thanos killed everybody including LT and everybody under him. Thanos was only stopped by Thanos.

Bah...

Thanos needed the Heart of the Universe to beat the LT...

Reed beat the LT with his own tech; no artifact of ultimate power needed...

And Doom beat Classic Beyonder in the original Secret War (Pre retcon Beyonder, not Post retcon Beyonder); without an artifact of ultimate power as well...

Thanos is weaksauce compared to these two combined...

Team wins 10/10 without effort...

tkitna
Team wins and then Doom kills the other two for spite.

TheGodKiller
Team for a solid majority.

Mr Master
Originally posted by TheLordofMurder

Reed beat the LT with his own tech; no artifact of ultimate power needed...
When did the LT and Reed ever battle?
Originally posted by TheLordofMurder

And Doom beat Classic Beyonder in the original Secret War (Pre
retcon Beyonder, not Post retcon Beyonder); without an artifact of
ultimate power as well...
That Doom plucked from a future he Never even existed in
could've used some gadget from his closet
and he still was gonna get what he wanted,
especially since Beyonder coerced that non-existent Doom's actions.

(aside from it also being plot so Beyonder could gain curiosity and visit Earth the next year) thumb up

Interesting thing is, that 616 Doom's body was completely destroyed/dead
during SS-I,
and his spirit/consicousness was in the body of a man named Norman McArthur,
and as Norman he was living a life with Norman's woman
while the Heroes/Villains were ducking it out on Battleworld. hm

This happened to Doom in 1983 when Terrax and him exploded together.

Doom's physical was utterly atomized, until 1986,
So ... how was 616 Doom (scarred body and all) in the Beyonder's
Battleworld universe in 1984, when he was actually living a quiet life with Norman's woman? smile

Exactly.

There's a whole story to that, and I'll return later with the visual goods to accompany the truth.

zopzop
Originally posted by Mr Master
When did the LT and Reed ever battle?

That Doom plucked from a future he Never even existed in
could've used some gadget from his closet
and he still was gonna get what he wanted,
especially since Beyonder coerced that non-existent Doom's actions.

(aside from it also being plot so Beyonder could gain curiosity and visit Earth the next year) thumb up

Interesting thing is, that 616 Doom's body was completely destroyed/dead
during SS-I,
and his spirit/consicousness was in the body of a man named Norman McArthur,
and as Norman he was living a life with Norman's woman
while the Heroes/Villains were ducking it out on Battleworld. hm

This happened to Doom in 1983 when Terrax and him exploded together.

Doom's physical was utterly atomized, until 1986,
So ... how was 616 Doom (scarred body and all) in the Beyonder's
Battleworld universe in 1984, when he was actually living a quiet life with Norman's woman? smile

Exactly.

There's a whole story to that, and I'll return later with the visual goods to accompany the truth.
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_7xhau3IqWZs/S9xKhl9lpqI/AAAAAAAAAnk/2F5aOTMXM5Q/s400/ff_2880009.jpg

God, I hate Reed but saying that, team wins.

Galan007
And zop solves Mr Master's riddle with a single click of his mouse. thumb up

Mindset
Originally posted by Mr Master
When did the LT and Reed ever battle?

That Doom plucked from a future he Never even existed in
could've used some gadget from his closet
and he still was gonna get what he wanted,
especially since Beyonder coerced that non-existent Doom's actions.

(aside from it also being plot so Beyonder could gain curiosity and visit Earth the next year) thumb up

Interesting thing is, that 616 Doom's body was completely destroyed/dead
during SS-I,
and his spirit/consicousness was in the body of a man named Norman McArthur,
and as Norman he was living a life with Norman's woman
while the Heroes/Villains were ducking it out on Battleworld. hm

This happened to Doom in 1983 when Terrax and him exploded together.

Doom's physical was utterly atomized, until 1986,
So ... how was 616 Doom (scarred body and all) in the Beyonder's
Battleworld universe in 1984, when he was actually living a quiet life with Norman's woman? smile

Exactly.

There's a whole story to that, and I'll return later with the visual goods to accompany the truth. Cool.

Doom beat Beyonder.

Branlor Swift
There's not many people who have the tech available to beat Reed in prep

Galactus, maybe Darkseid, Celestials (?)

Mihsnme
Originally posted by Mr Master
When did the LT and Reed ever battle?

That Doom plucked from a future he Never even existed in
could've used some gadget from his closet
and he still was gonna get what he wanted,
especially since Beyonder coerced that non-existent Doom's actions.

(aside from it also being plot so Beyonder could gain curiosity and visit Earth the next year) thumb up

Interesting thing is, that 616 Doom's body was completely destroyed/dead
during SS-I,
and his spirit/consicousness was in the body of a man named Norman McArthur,
and as Norman he was living a life with Norman's woman
while the Heroes/Villains were ducking it out on Battleworld. hm

This happened to Doom in 1983 when Terrax and him exploded together.

Doom's physical was utterly atomized, until 1986,
So ... how was 616 Doom (scarred body and all) in the Beyonder's
Battleworld universe in 1984, when he was actually living a quiet life with Norman's woman? smile

Exactly.

There's a whole story to that, and I'll return later with the visual goods to accompany the truth. Reed punked the LT in Last Planet Standing, it isn't canon though

Oh and Thanos wins, Cosmic geniuses are above Eath genusies

Mr Master
Originally posted by zopzop

God, I hate Reed
Yea, I know that scene well but here's my take and I'll use some of that scene as well.

Don't get me wrong, someone took most of Beyonder's power,
but it wasn't 616 Doom. It was a Doom from a Future he didn't exist in,
this is why it created a loop in the Timestream,
because when the Future came around as the Present,
the Doom Beyonder plucked from the Timestream was missing, because he never existed.

616 Doom basically took his place and replayed all of the SW events
so that when the Future arrived again as the Present THIS time there was a Doom.

Heck, 616 Doom had never met, or even seen the Beyonder before this issue:

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/744420_beyondercontrolovertimelifejo7.jpg

Heck, he never had even seen or known about She-Hulk either.

This is nearly two years after Secret Wars 1. smile

Mr Master
^^ .. to add to that ...

So, 616 Doom had absolutely nothing to do with the original Secret Wars.

The future Doom came from a future he did not exist in,
this future later became the real present and guess what,
there is NO Doom in this present with his original body in the entire Universe,
so I'd like to know how 616 Doom, in McArthur's body, ended up being the Secret Wars Doom,
who had a completely different body and aura?

On Panel truth 1:

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/746806_Doom.jpg
http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/746807_Doom2.jpg

616 Doom was living a life with McArthur's woman, while Secret Wars was happening,
way before Secret Wars, since his body was obliterated in the Terrax incident back in 83'
up until # 288 below:

On Panel truth 2:

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/746808_Doom3.jpg
http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/746809_Doom4.jpg

So either,
616 Doom was existing in both Universes (616 & Battleworld) simultaneously,
which is ridiculous,
or the Doom that originally appeared in Secret Wars came from a Future he never existed in,
which is true.

....................................................................................


Remember what Reed said:

After Beyonder sent 616 Doom to the past, to repeat the actions of the orginal culprit,
Reed clarifies what 616 Doom will be doing there:

She-Hulk: ... "He's (616 Doom) gone into the Past hasn't he"

Reed: ... "Yes, but there he will begin a CYCLE
that will end with the Beyonder banishing him 'across time & space,'
at the conclusion of the First Secret Wars."

....................................................................................


Reed knows exactly what 616 Doom will do, and how it will end for him,
cause it already happened, as I said and proved without this blatant proof,
616 Doom is only replacing the actions of another.

Surely you will agree now true debater. swank

Mr Master
Originally posted by Galan007

And zop solves Mr Master's riddle with a single click of his mouse.
Not at all. But his efforts are respected. stick out tongue

leonidas
team pretty thoroughly stomps.

Mr Master
Originally posted by Mindset
Cool.

Doom beat Beyonder.
That Alternate Future Doom (who Never existed where he came from)
accomplished his feat, because he was surrounded by stipulations.

1. The reason he didn't die after his battle with the Beyonder,
is cause the Concept of Death was warped in the Battleworld universe:

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/750731_Doom.jpg

"Doom only barely survived that battle with the Beyonder.
But Death,
we had already learned was NOT the same force in that realm
as it had been at home"

...........................................................................


2. The reason this Doom is able to get close to the Beyonder in this stomped state,
is cause Beyonder was intricately studying his body with its torn limbs:

(I mean he's being dissected, half his body is being peeled by layers,
he was already missing one arm, one leg, other forearm, other chin)

Yet, he's still alive? ... laughing out loud ... like I said, surrounded by stipulations.

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/766115_Do1.jpg http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/766116_Do2.jpghttp://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/15259763_Doom_beats_Beyonder.jpg
...........................................................................


3.We later learn from Beyonder's own mouth,
he was actually trying to help Doom at this point,
this is when Doom pulled out this monster PIS feat.

Mindset
Yea, I have the comics too.

Doom stole his powers.

Mr Master
Originally posted by Mindset

Yea, I have the comics too.

Doom stole his powers.

I think this says it all:

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/744398_Doom.jpg

You're (616 Doom) only involvement in this feat is because of me, (Beyonder)
and even though now you (616 Doom) can take credit for it, (cause of me)
someone else (non-existent future Doom) accomplished it,
then you (616 Doom) came,
and like a puppet (616 Doom) was placed in the other's (n-e future Doom) stead,
and exactly everything that he (n-e future Doom) did,
you (616 Doom) were forced to repeat.


* That's Beyonder Choreographing 616 Doom's history.
Literally manipulating his involvement in SW 1 nearly TWO Years later.

Mindset
Does it say Doom stole Beyonder's powers?

Because that's what happened.


Beyonder knew he couldn't escape his fate of Doom stealing his powers, so he let 616 Doom do it, because better it be the best Doom than another. thumb up

golem370
Originally posted by Branlor Swift
There's not many people who have the tech available to beat Reed in prep

Galactus, maybe Darkseid, Celestials (?)

In this thread both sides have equal prep devices and even still I would imagine Thanos has tech equal to or better then Reed's tech

golem370
I am still pretty sure that was Beyonder that lost to Kubik

Horrificus
Originally posted by Mindset
Does it say Doom stole Beyonder's powers?

Because that's what happened.

laughing
Made my night.

Horrificus
Originally posted by golem370
I am still pretty sure that was Beyonder that lost to Kubik He didn't just lose to Kubik. Kubik was giving Beyonder a training session. Kind of a "Big Brother" kind of thing.


http://i138.photobucket.com/albums/q253/ArealSTUPIguy/th_2103473-letter_26_zps3b467590.jpg

golem370
Even if it was a training session he was still wiping the floor with Beyonder. He didn't become as powerful as Kubik until him and Owen were joined in a cosmic cube.

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by golem370
In this thread both sides have equal prep devices and even still I would imagine Thanos has tech equal to or better then Reed's tech

Yeah, and what tech might that be?

Reed has a Celestial killing device under his bed; what does Thanos have thats equal to or better than that?

Take your time answering...I'll wait.

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by Mihsnme
Reed punked the LT in Last Planet Standing, it isn't canon though

Oh and Thanos wins, Cosmic geniuses are above Eath genusies

It was canon for the LT though...wasnt it? wink

The LT was stopped by Reed Richards; The Tribunal had a plan and Richards foiled him...

So what if Thanos is a "cosmic genius," Earth based genius's have better feats performed with tech than Thanos does...so that cosmic genius tag means nothing.

Thanos gets annihilated by Richards and Doom together...

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by Mindset
Does it say Doom stole Beyonder's powers?

Because that's what happened.

thumb up

Galan007
Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
It was canon for the LT though...wasnt it? wink

The LT was stopped by Reed Richards; The Tribunal had a plan and Richards foiled him...

So what if Thanos is a "cosmic genius," Earth based genius's have better feats performed with tech than Thanos does...so that cosmic genius tag means nothing.

Thanos gets annihilated by Richards and Doom together... It was a canon showing for LT because there is only one LT throughout the omniverse, and the MC2 universe is an officially recognized alternate universe in Marvel.

However, MC2 Reed=/=616 Reed-- they are 2 completely different characters whose feats are not interchangeable. ie. just because MC2 Reed built a device capable of tooling the hierarchy with their own energies, doesn't mean 616 Reed gets said tech by proxy.

Having said that, Thanos gets shit-stomped here.

KuRuPT Thanosi
Thanos does get shit stomped here because he's limited in his resources. If not, it would be a better fight.. He would probably still lose either way, but not a stomp. In a comic, of course, this is even more a non fight.

Why are people so impressed with Doom doin what he did to beyonder. Beyonder ALLOWED Doom to even do that. He couldn't with a mere thought blinked doom away from every universe or timestream in existence. With a mere thought he could've. So because he didn't do that i.e. PIS.. and because he basically set up doom to do what he did.. this is suppose to be impressive?

golem370
The Celestial killing gun is as stupid as it sounds for 1 Odin and other Skyfathers had like 1 million years or so to stop the Celestial and couldn't come up with anything. The gun makes about as much sense as Sue stopping Exitar.Thanos with little prep almost killed Galactus and stopped the initial entry of Hunger who was a being that not even Galactus in his billions and billions of years of experience could mess with. When Galactus first came to earth was it not the Watcher that told them about the UN and saved the FF and everybody on earth?

Galan007
Originally posted by golem370
Thanos with little prep almost killed Galactus Reed, with no prep, killed a Celestial.

Reed > Thanos.

Mindset
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Thanos does get shit stomped here because he's limited in his resources. If not, it would be a better fight.. He would probably still lose either way, but not a stomp. In a comic, of course, this is even more a non fight.

Why are people so impressed with Doom doin what he did to beyonder. Beyonder ALLOWED Doom to even do that. He couldn't with a mere thought blinked doom away from every universe or timestream in existence. With a mere thought he could've. So because he didn't do that i.e. PIS.. and because he basically set up doom to do what he did.. this is suppose to be impressive? Beyonder wanted to study Doom, he didn't allow him do anything.

Doom powered through being dissected, like a boss, and jacked Beyonder's powers.

No PIS.

Galan007
At least someone gets it. thumb up

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t1/15268472_1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15268454_Spider-Man__the_Secret_Wars_4_020.jpg
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/15268476/2.jpg.html

creepsmile

dynamix
Originally posted by Mindset
Beyonder wanted to study Doom, he didn't allow him do anything.

Doom powered through being dissected, like a boss, and jacked Beyonder's powers.

No PIS.

this is true. I read that story. Secret War i think. Beyonder was depicted as some kind of heavenly beam or light lol. Crazy demonstration of will power by doom. Thanos still my dude but this is like 2 prep god vs 1.

Mr Master
^^ That scan's not from the original story. stick out tongue

Although it is accurate.

Because Doom repeated the actions of the Non-Existent Doom from the future.

He was Non-Existent because Beyonder atomized him across time & space.

So when the Future (where Beyonder got that Doom from in SS I 1984)
arrived as the Present (in FF #288 - 616 Doom sees Beyonder for the First time ever 1986)
the Doom from SS I was not around, did not exist,
because Beyonder destroyed him at the end of SSI)

This caused a Time-loop and if that gap in Time was not filled, it would collapse.

So Beyonder took 616 Doom (best/only candidate since it was his alternate future self anyway)
and literally Replaced the Non-Existent Doom's history, with that of 616 Doom's.

Simple.

So, did 616 Doom steal Beyonder's power?

Yes. But only because Beyonder placed him like a puppet in another's stead,
the one who actually did steal his powers, (an alternate non-existent future Doom)

--------------------------------------------


It's like if someone powerful enough decided to pluck the hilarious MC2 Reed,
at the point of his stipulated comedy towards the LT & Cosmics,
then this powerful being takes 616 Reed and replaces the MC2 with 616 Reed,
then he fast-forwards History (while standing with you in the Present) laughing out loud
and yada, yada, the end of Last Planet Standing and now it's 616
Reed who's victorious because he repeated the exact same actions of MC2 Reed.

Who's feat is this truly? MC2 R or 616 R?

Galan007
^ It's Doom's feat. Always Doom. thumb up

TheLordofMurder
Originally posted by golem370
The Celestial killing gun is as stupid as it sounds for 1 Odin and other Skyfathers had like 1 million years or so to stop the Celestial and couldn't come up with anything. The gun makes about as much sense as Sue stopping Exitar.Thanos with little prep almost killed Galactus and stopped the initial entry of Hunger who was a being that not even Galactus in his billions and billions of years of experience could mess with. When Galactus first came to earth was it not the Watcher that told them about the UN and saved the FF and everybody on earth?

Excellent! So you concede that Thanos has nothing equal to or superior to Reeds Celestial killing device!

Concession accepted!

Happy Dance

KuRuPT Thanosi
Originally posted by Mindset
Beyonder wanted to study Doom, he didn't allow him do anything.

Doom powered through being dissected, like a boss, and jacked Beyonder's powers.

No PIS.

Ummm okay.. but with a mere thought.. nano second of a thought.. you agree he could've wiped doom from all existence correct? Let's not act like doom overpowered beyonder and fought beyonder and won. Doom was only allowed to do what he did because The Beyonder allowed hiim to get that close.. allowed him to even exist.

Branlor Swift
Doom was holding back against Beyonder chucking limitless power against him.

And then when Beyonder thought he won, he went to check it out, and bam.

In the newer series, it seems Doom straight up overpowered him and took his power.

Because that's the power created when Doom and Galactus combine.

Mr Master
^^ laughing Doom overpowered Beyonder? Come on B.


Originally posted by Galan007

^ It's Doom's feat. Always Doom.
616 Doom ... or Non-Existent Future Doom?

Remember, 616 Doom's mind & personality was in McArthurs body,
and 616 Doom's body was utterly destroyed in the Terrax incident:

(1983)

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15268928_NE_Doom1.jpg

So 616 Victor Von Doom was on 616 Planet Earth ... prior, during, and after Secret Wars I.


616 Doom had never met or even ever seen the Beyonder: (again ... before, during or after Secret Wars I)

Until the end of Secret Wars II 1986

http://s2d1.turboimagehost.com/t/744420_beyondercontrolovertimelifejo7.jpg

Because 616 Doom was on Earth, while the other Doom was in Battleworld.

Mr Master
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi

Ummm okay.. but with a mere thought.. nano second of a thought..
you agree he could've wiped doom from all existence correct? Let's
not act like doom overpowered beyonder and fought beyonder and
won. Doom was only allowed to do what he did because The Beyonder
allowed hiim to get that close.. allowed him to even exist.
thumb up

Also ...



616 Doom was banished to the Past, but Beyonder created a circle in time,
so that he would return to this Present,
since this Present was the Future he took the original Secret Wars Doom from.

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15268965_NE_Doom5.jpg

Also, how about where Reed clearly differentiates the two:

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15268966_NE_Doom4.jpg

"The 'BANISHED' Doom may well appear here, now,
to fill the space thus created"

........................................................................................................


Now why do you think Reed labels 616 Doom the "banished" Doom,
insetad of just calling him Doom?

Answer:

Because the original Secret Wars Doom (Future Doom) was obliterated across time & space,
uhh, Reed even states it in the freakin scan,
but the banished Doom (616) never died, in fact, he was never even there originally,
but since he's the template, he can fill in for the original Secret Wars Doom,
play out everything that happened in Secret Wars 1 exactly to the T,
even getting obliterated like the original Secret Wars Doom,
but then like Reed says, to finalize the closing of the circle,
616 Doom (unlike the original Secret Wars Doom who was utterly destroyed)
now has to return to the Present, "to fill the space thus created"

What space was that?

The space left by the original Secret Wars Doom (plucked from the Future)
who was destroyed before the point from which he was plucked became the Present.

This is why Reed said: "events now in our past, have yet to happen to Doctor Doom"

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15268967_NE_Doom3.jpg

If it was always Doom 616, then why hasn't he experienced these events?

No need to answer that, I already have. stoned

Mindset
That's a lot of words just to tell me I'm right.

Mr Master
^^ You know I like yur style. Sorry I had to burst that Doom bubble with on panel proof.

Although I will submit:

Could 616 Doom do what his Non-Existent Future self did?

Absolutely. That PIS had to happen no matter what.

It was part of the plot to make Beyonder curious while near powerless,
therefore giving him a reason to return to Earth in Secret Wars II.

But the Fact is:

In Marvel, "Futures" (all outside 616) that are seen or touched by the "Present" (within 616)
are always located in a separate Alternate/Diverged Reality.
(that alternate/diverged reality is one of the countless possible Futures of 616)

In fact, even one minute into the Future leads to Another Universe:

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269087_Future.jpg

Mindset
Weren't you the one saying Black Celestial Arc Galactus was the same as 616 Galactus?

Anyway, 616 Doom took Beyonder's powers, I don't see what big deal is.

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by Mr Master
^^ laughing Doom overpowered Beyonder? Come on B. That's what was implied when Doom was forcing him to his knees.

The fear in Beyonder's eyes too

Mr Master
^^ Well in that case, since that scan you're highlighting represents Retcon Beyonder,
we can always say,
Beyonder sub-consciously allowed Doom to steal his power:

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269470_B_allowed_Doom.jpg

Simply because as an incomplete Cube Being
he had a compelling urge to satisfy the desire of others.

Doom's desire? I want your power Beyonder. smile

Originally posted by Mindset

Weren't you the one saying Black Celestial Arc Galactus was the same as 616 Galactus?

Anyway, 616 Doom took Beyonder's powers, I don't see what big deal is.
I never said a Future version of 616 Doom is not 616 Doom,
cause you're right, it still would be, just like BCA G.

Here's the difference concerning Doom:

There Never was a 616 Doom (scarred-mystic-Reed rivaling Doom) in 616.
That Victor Von Doom (the original 616) was living a quiet life in McArthur's body.

Yes. 616 Doom's Mind and Personality (everything that makes him Doom)
was NOT, NEVER in the original SSI Battleworld universe.
Again, 616 Doom was on Planet Earth doing McArthur's wife,
while the heroes & villains were in another reality on Battleworld.

This is why Beyonder plucked a non-existent Doom,
because well ... there was none in the Present of FF #288.

This is exactly the reason a Timeloop anomaly was created.
The Present was finally here FF#288 (nearly Two years AFter SSI)
and the Doom from SSI was missing from Reality,
because he was obliterated at the end of SSI by Beyonder.

Mindset ... it's a technicality issue.

Again, I agree that 616 Doom would have been able to do anything his Future-self could do.

Only that technically speaking, in that particular Beyonder feat,
it wasn't exactly him.

To be honest, since original scarred 616 Doom didn't exist in the Future Beyonder plucked SSI Doom from,
just who in the hell was that Doom in SSI is the question?

It wasn't McArthur, since his mind/personality was in limbo,
and it wasn't original scarred 616 Doom since his mind/personality
was in McArthur's body,
so ... ?

Only thing we're left with is a non-existent Doom. hm

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by Mr Master
^^ Well in that case, since that scan you're highlighting represent Retcon Beyonder,
we can always say,
Beyonder sub-consciously allowed Doom to steal his power:

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269470_B_allowed_Doom.jpg

Simply because as an incomplete Cube Being
he had a compelling urge to satisfy the desire of others.

Doom's desire? I want you power Beyonder. smile That doesn't say he allowed it.

Also, the newer Secret Wars really didn't seem to take the "retcon" into account. It was just a retelling from a different angle.

The only thing it really changed was that Doom wasn't blasted apart.

Mr Master
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

That doesn't say he allowed it.
Not in so many words, but imo, the context of what he's being told by Shaper and Owie,
signifies that Beyonder needed (sub-consciously) to give others what they wanted.

Since Doom wanted his power ... just sayin.
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

Also, the newer Secret Wars really didn't seem to take the "retcon"
into account. It was just a retelling from a different angle.

The only thing it really changed was that Doom wasn't blasted apart.
I disagree. The Retcon applies.

Beyonder's incredible omniversal feat is no surprise,
he's a unique Cube being as you know.

Kosmos, the Maker, (weaker incarnations of the retconned Beyonder)
and that aside, that Alternate Beyonder, was operating on a Multiversal scale,
but was still beneath Eternity.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift

The only thing it really changed was that Doom wasn't blasted apart.
Actually true debater, that also still applies.

Look at Klaw's conspiring smile, look at the end scene from the original
as he's losing control in front of Cap.

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269558_Doom_dies.jpg

Right after this scene, this Doom is obliterated by Beyonder.

(which isn't depicted since the next page is the last of the mini & concerns Spiderman on land)

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by Mr Master
Not in so many words, but imo, the context of what he's being told by Shaper and Owie,
signifies that Beyonder needed (sub-consciously) to give others what they wanted.

Since Doom wanted his power ... just sayin. And Beyonder stated nothing of the sorts.

And it could be talking about what Doom accomplished after he gained the powers as well.

Originally posted by Mr Master
I disagree. The Retcon applies.

Beyonder's incredible omniversal feat is no surprise,
he's a unique Cube being as you know.

Kosmos, the Maker, (weaker incarnations of the retconned Beyonder)
and that aside, that Alternate Beyonder, was operating on a Multiversal scale,
but was still beneath Eternity.


Actually true debater, that also still applies.

Look at Klaw's conspiring smile, look at the end scene from the original
as he's losing control in front of Cap.

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269558_Doom_dies.jpg

Right after this scene, this Doom is obliterated by Beyonder.

(which isn't depicted since the next page is the last of the mini & concerns Spiderman on land) Just because it's essentially a retelling printed currently, that doesn't make it factor in all the changes made to the character. Hell, Beyonder was an Inhuman by the time that series came out.
It told the original series to almost a T. It really makes no difference had it been printed or not.
For example, if Secret Wars 2 was retold in a different POV, would we say it is was retconned back to "really happening" or would we look at it, and say "Well Golly jeeze, that's an interesting scene that happened in that series where Spider-Man is beating off on JJJ's newspapers, I wonder if that was retconned to be an illusion or not."

I'm talking about blasted apart by the Beyonder when he was fighting him.
When Doom was standing over him fully limbed and had Beyonder in a mercy hold.

Mr Master
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

And Beyonder stated nothing of the sorts.
Never said he did.
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

And it could be talking about what Doom accomplished
after he gained the powers as well.
Plausible, but doubtful imo.
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

Just because it's essentially a retelling printed currently, that
doesn't make it factor in all the changes made to the character.
Hell, Beyonder was an Inhuman by the time that series came out.

It told the original series to almost a T. It really makes no
difference had it been printed or not.

For example, if Secret Wars 2 was retold in a different POV, would
we say it is was retconned back to "really happening" or would we
look at it, and say "Well Golly jeeze, that's an interesting scene that
happened in that series where Spider-Man is beating off on JJJ's
newspapers, I wonder if that was retconned to be an illusion or
not."
I don't get the analogy's relation to the Spiderman mini,
but all I know is that it's canon, and it's a retelling of Secret Wars to the T,
because Secret Wars took place to the "T" even in the handbooks of 2006, 2007 and 2008.

The only details changed (retconned) were Beyonder defeating Celestials,
and scarring the LT, and being "millions of times" you know the rest.

Everything else, did happen, from threatening Eternity's existence,
to erasing Death itself.

Btw. Beyonder was Never an Inhuman Mutant.
That was Beyonder mind-screwing the heroes.
It was supposed to be divulged as to why in a follow up to Illuminati issues,
but the series was discontinued.

I personally didn't liked the way it abruptly ended.

But again, the Handbooks of 2008 clear that up for us, so ...

http://s4d3.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269946_Cube_beings_2008_bio.jpg

That's like 3 years after Illuminati nonsense.
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

I'm talking about blasted apart by the Beyonder when he was fighting him.
When Doom was standing over him fully limbed and had Beyonder in a mercy hold.
That never happened that I recall in the original series.
I only say it didn't cause I just looked through 9-12 and couldn't
find that descriptive scene B.

What issue is this?

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by Mr Master
Never said he did.

Plausible, but doubtful imo.

I don't get the analogy's relation to the Spiderman mini,
but all I know is that it's canon, and it's a retelling of Secret Wars to the T,
because Secret Wars took place to the "T" even in the handbooks of 2006, 2007 and 2008.

The only details changed (retconned) were Beyonder defeating Celestials,
and scarring the LT, and being "millions of times" you know the rest.

Everything else, did happen, from threatening Eternity's existence,
to erasing Death itself.

Btw. Beyonder was Never an Inhuman Mutant.
That was Beyonder mind-screwing the heroes.
It was supposed to be divulged as to why in a follow up to Illuminati issues,
but the series was discontinued.

I personally didn't liked the way it abruptly ended.

But again, the Handbooks of 2008 clear that up for us, so ...

http://s4d3.turboimagehost.com/t1/15269946_Cube_beings_2008_bio.jpg

That's like 3 years after Illuminati nonsense.

That never happened that I recall in the original series.
I only say it didn't cause I just looked through 9-12 and couldn't
find that descriptive scene B.

What issue is this? Why is that more doubtful than Beyonder letting Doom steal his power?
At the end of the day, Beyonder never stated he let Doom take his power in those panels.

Yes, and I'm saying it isn't a retelling with some sort of retcon in mind. It's a retelling of a classic story not a retelling with "now we know" angles in it. Not much changes admittedly, but I wasn't highlighting "post retcon" Beyonder. I was highlighting Beyonder.

That's an assumption. But, like you said, it was never talked about, so the last thing we have on him is that he was an Inhuman Mutant.

That's a year later. Didn't know handbooks retconned comic books.


http://i238.photobucket.com/albums/ff240/Branlactus/Raw%20power/Tech/th_SecretWars10_21.jpg

It didn't happen like that in the new retelling is what I was saying. Doom overpowered Beyonder instead with mercy skills, as opposed to having his limbs ripped off.

Branlor Swift
This explains 616 Doom's happenings pretty well:
http://i1134.photobucket.com/albums/m610/sonnendawg/FF319_18.jpg
http://i1134.photobucket.com/albums/m610/sonnendawg/FF319_19.jpg
http://i1134.photobucket.com/albums/m610/sonnendawg/FF319_20.jpg
http://i1134.photobucket.com/albums/m610/sonnendawg/FF319_21.jpg

http://i1134.photobucket.com/albums/m610/sonnendawg/FF319_29.jpg

Also, if we believe CK is Eternity level, then a Cube isn't on his level:
http://i1134.photobucket.com/albums/m610/sonnendawg/FF319_36.jpg

Fun issue.

Mr Master
^^ Oh .. you came back ... I was about to let this go with your last post,
but since you decided to do that, let's play.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift

Why is that more doubtful than Beyonder letting Doom steal his power?
At the end of the day, Beyonder never stated he let Doom take his power in those panels.
Like I said, either way.
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

Yes, and I'm saying it isn't a retelling with some sort of retcon in
mind. It's a retelling of a classic story not a retelling with "now we
know" angles in it. Not much changes admittedly, but I wasn't
highlighting "post retcon" Beyonder. I was highlighting Beyonder.

That's an assumption. But, like you said, it was never talked about,
so the last thing we have on him is that he was an Inhuman Mutant.

That's a year later. Didn't know handbooks retconned comic books.
Yea, he's definitely Not an Inhuman Mutant, according to 2006-07 and 08 Handbooks,
and I'm sure if I check my Updated 2011 versions,
he's there too as a Cube being.

That aside, Handbooks may not alter on panel facts,
but Hickman presented Four different Alternate Beyonders,
and they All followed the Secret Wars scenario, and they were always from Beyond!
(except for one idiot who got killed with a pistol by Sue, don't know what his story was)

Oh, and Doom/Infinity Gauntlet What If where he took Beyonder's too,
it was a What IF Alternate diverged Reality, but Beyonder was from Beyond there likewise.
Originally posted by Branlor Swift

http://i238.photobucket.com/albums/ff240/Branlactus/Raw%20power/Tech/th_SecretWars10_21.jpg

It didn't happen like that in the new retelling is what I was saying.
Doom overpowered Beyonder instead with mercy skills,
as opposed to having his limbs ripped off.
I see.

It wasn't an actual "battle of power vs power" though.

It was a battle of "Wills."

Also Bran, let's not forget,
in the original showcase with Doom and Beyonder After he used his breast plate,
we don't see what happens. Doom just comes to the planet as victorious.




--------------------------------------------------------------


Important to understand is that the Spiderman Mini is showing things we didn't get to see on panel originally.

This battle of "Wills" as Doom puts it:

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/15272523_D_sees_F2.jpg

Is what must've taken place After he pressed the breast plate.
It's how the absorption process took place which we never saw originally.
It was a battle of "Wills' over the power.

Doom clearly states that the "Power" (which is Beyonder's essence) went to who wanted it more,
and Doom wanted it more than Beyonder.

That's dumb I know, but how else could they make sense of that cosmic PIS!
An entity Millions of times more powerful than the Multiverse combined
being somehow affected in anyway shape or form by tech? no expression (don't care who's it is)

Come on B. You know the reels on that one. PIS!

--------------------------------------------------------------


We can try and make sense of it by realizing it's what Beyonder wanted all along.

I mean, Beyonder knew the Past, Present and Future, like Doom when he had the power:

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t/15272526_D_sees_F1.jpg

So ... is it not safe to say,
that just like Doom saw/knew exactly how he would be defeated Before it happened,
that Beyonder already knew everything before hand as well?

Is it possible, Beyonder coerced the entire thing?

--------------------------------------------------------------


Beyonder was incredibly savvy in getting his power back, so much so that Klaw said:

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t/15272527_D_sees_F5.jpg

"Beyonder took over my body. He used my guile, my wits, my cunning to engineer This."
"I set you up for This"

--------------------------------------------------------------


If we move along we further comprehend that another stipulation fits in well
with what I said earlier about Beyonder wanting all this to happen.

After the Beyonder leaves back to the Beyond Realm,
the residual energy of his Power left over as an after-effect from his scuffle with Doom,
was still giving everyone there their wishes.

One example of many, Captain America controls atomic structures by force of "Will" alone:

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t/15272528_D_sees_F6.jpghttp://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t/15272529_D_sees_F7.jpg

--------------------------------------------------------------


There goes that term "Will" again.

It seems that Beyonder gave everyone in his newb state the power to make their desires come true.

Even Doom taking his power as idiotic as that is:

http://s4d4.turboimagehost.com/t/15272530_D_sees_F8.jpg

"Thus, by sheer force of his own Will, was Doom able to triumph"

And the the Spiderman mini depicts that battle of "Will."

The retcon explanation now fits in well with what we discussed earlier B.

"subconsciously wanting to give others their desires" (Owen said)

Branlor Swift
Lol at your top part. "Oh no, I was planning on hiding those scans, but now you shall pay."

Beyonder wanted to kill Doom for taking his power.

Handbooks don't override the latest comics

You think Doom rebuilt his arm and leg after throwing his armor to have a mercy fight with Beyonder? That's the only way it could be the same
That part was different, like I said. "Battle of wills" doesn't answer the difference in it happening

In the new retelling, Doom wasn't cut up like in the original, simple really

Also, just because you can see the past and present, that doesn't mean you allowed something to happen, c'mon. Hell, Doom wasn't quite sure when he'd lose his power either for that matter
Did Beyonder attempting to murder Doom for what he did in Secret Wars in a comic that was discussed all last page not happen or something?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.