Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Slugfest only. No mjolnir for Thor. Who wins?

Thor.

Thor starts the fight conscious, right?

Since we're using standard versions, and unconsciousness pretty standard state for him.

Originally posted by carver9
Thor.

Can he even fly without his hammer?

Thor's nerfed pretty badly here, against a character that almost defines versatility.

It's a slugfest

Thor.

Jonn.

Modern Thor, right?

J'onn wins.

MM

I love J'onn, but has he beaten physically any opponent worth a damn?

We know that Thor hasn't, so its a pertinent question.

Thor.

Originally posted by Bentley
I love J'onn, but has he beaten physically any opponent worth a damn?

We know that Thor hasn't, so its a pertinent question.
He has beaten cap with a suckerpunch and has restrained PG. He also oneshotted male cheetah who was compared to WW/cap strength level by superman.

Thor solidly.

Thor.

Thor

Thor

Originally posted by abhilegend
He has beaten cap with a suckerpunch and has restrained PG. He also oneshotted male cheetah who was compared to WW/cap strength level by superman.

Beat down Kanto, too.

Right in Barda's/Wonder Womans ball park, like most elite New Gods.

Originally posted by Damborgson
It's a slugfest

J'onn still has his shape shifting.

Can create stabbing weapons that could tear through Thor as they have Etrigan.

And he's shapeshiftes himself into bizarre warrior forms before, with giant shield, third fist out his chest, right arm like a cleaver..

Well then MM. Cause Thor has to hit stuff with a hammer so he don't mess up his nails. He spends so much time looking pretty and what all.

He's naturally pretty.

Thor solidly

Thor wins a comfortable majority.

Slugfest? Does this mean MM can shapeshift and use other powers?

No, they stand there and trade punches.

Even if they were completely equal in stats, Thor would still win imo. Just a tougher disposition when it comes to straight physical battle.

I'm not sure of MM's strength level as I don't follow his strength feats much. What natural strength feats does he have?
But wouldn't he be faster than Thor?
If so then I see MM winning this.

Originally posted by h1a8
I'm not sure of MM's strength level as I don't follow his strength feats much. What natural strength feats does he have?
But wouldn't he be faster than Thor?
If so then I see MM winning this.

Does slugfest imply no super speed, too?

thor

Is this current MM, cause if it's not then Thor.

While current Thor seems to job so much these days, classic MM is the epitome of DC's jobbers.

When did Thor job recently?

Originally posted by cdtm
Does slugfest imply no super speed, too? IDK

So they are taking turns hitting each other?
Or rather fighting with pure punching (boxing)?

I understand current jonn has already found his lost jobbing ways.

Thor

Originally posted by pym-ftw
When did Thor job recently?
He seemed to have been one-shotted by a Frost Giant in Indestructible Hulk.



Also Thor wins. His greater courage, warrior spirit and overall toughness will be why he is the last one standing.

Originally posted by 753
I understand current jonn has already found his lost jobbing ways.

You can take Manhunter out of the jobbing, but you can`t take the jobbing out of Manhunter.

Originally posted by 753
I understand current jonn has already found his lost jobbing ways.

Rofl always so much wasted potential with that guy.

Some characters fall victim to the "Worf Effect". I think J'onn was designed with the Worf Effect in mind. Moreso than CIS/PIS, it's almost part of his powerset.

Power #18- The ability to somehow always fall short of the big guns.

Anyway, Thor takes this. He spends most of his fights brawling anyway, while MM heavliy relies on the other aspects of his powerset. IMO, anytime you take away J'onn's telepathy, you take away most of any effectiveness he has.

Thor wins cuz he ranks higher in Marvel's pantheon than Manhunter does in DC's.