Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Again..........the title asks the question.

He would be pretty useless. DCU needs him and it doesn't fit well. Banner thought, why not

Nicely, Dc doesn't really have a top tier non flying brick

Now that I think of it Dc can't write top tier characters without blanket powers

He would become a JLA enemy just like all of his other counterparts are. Then, more then likely, he would probably join the JLA and become a top player hero.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Nicely, Dc doesn't really have a top tier non flying brick

Now that I think of it Dc can't write top tier characters without blanket powers Solomon Grundy is kinda like Hulk... Different incarnations different strength level though much more static

he'd play a somewhat similar role to what he plays in various avengers incarnations - occasionally out of control, being stopped by the league and occasionally helping them out.

He'd fit in just fine. I think Superman would be more negatively affected than Hulk with the change. Having a superhero (Albeit sometimes in a villanous role) physically superior to the Man of Steel takes away from him to an extent imho.

He'd be maybe a more impressive Grundy, but I doubt we'd ever see him in the League. He'd certainly never be their villain; he doesn't have enough to him for that.

Given how many active heralds there are on DC Earth, he'd be fighting a new one every issue.

Death of superman II: No comebacksies

More impressive Grundy?

Nah, he doesn't have the depth.

......

Wwh went over 90% people's heads apparently

Yeah, because that would the characterisation they're likely to choose. ermm

So he'd be the new Black Adam, then?

I didn't even remotely elude to that, however the food chain would inevitably have to be exhibited at some point.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
I didn't even remotely elude to that, however the food chain would inevitably have to be exhibited at some point.

alude

Then what were you talking about?

Autocorrect, limey

That curry guy tried to say grundy was deep.... moreso than hulk to the point they are incomparable.

Phucking grundy

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Autocorrect, limey

That curry guy tried to say grundy was deep.... moreso than hulk to the point they are incomparable.

Phucking grundy

Don't be mean.

oh lol.

interesting stories would come about from DC groups trying to control and exploit him

Does DC really need another "omnipotent" character?

They already have like 5.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
He'd fit in just fine. I think Superman would be more negatively affected than Hulk with the change. Having a superhero (Albeit sometimes in a villanous role) physically superior to the Man of Steel takes away from him to an extent imho.

Glad you still have a sense of humor

Originally posted by xJLxKing


Glad you still have a sense of humor


Its true.

Yeah, because DC would ever write Hulk as being stronger than Superman.

Please.

That's as likely as Marvel letting Superman be stronger than Hulk.

Hulk doesn't care what DC writes.

He'll punch the writer in the mouth and break Superman.

Originally posted by 753
he'd play a somewhat similar role to what he plays in various avengers incarnations - occasionally out of control, being stopped by the league and occasionally helping them out.

Hard to explain it any better then this.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Yeah, because DC would ever write Hulk as being stronger than Superman.

Please.

That's as likely as Marvel letting Superman be stronger than Hulk.

Superman words about the Hulk.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=12704275

I honestly believe DC thinks highly of Savage Hulk strength. '

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=6606747

Don't get all hot headed about my scans Pr...I'm just messing with ya (even though I think DC have high standards of Hulk).

Originally posted by carver9
Superman words about the Hulk.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=12704275

I honestly believe DC thinks highly of Savage Hulk strength. '

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=6606747

Don't get all hot headed about my scans Pr...I'm just messing with ya (even though I think DC have high standards of Hulk).

lol.

Nobody said DC wouldn't respect Hulk.

You just don't think that they can still respect him without making him stronger than Superman. Don't get hot-headed because you know DC would have Superman kick his ass.

Lol. Im not even going to respond to your last comment. Free-be.

Concession accepted.

I would see it going like Planet Hulk where he goes off taking on a team of JLA numerious times and then finally being stopped by Martian Manhunter and maybe Wonder Woman's lasso and sent off planet arriving in war world taken if over and coming back for revenge.

Really depends on how they interpret both Banner and Hulk.

But it wouldn't be difficult to integrate him, imo.

He'd just destroy the planet and kill everyone it.

He has no emotional attachment to anyone there

Superman kicks his ass like he does everytime they meet in crossovers.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman kicks his ass like he does everytime they meet in crossovers.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Nicely, Dc doesn't really have a top tier non flying brick

Now that I think of it Dc can't write top tier characters without blanket powers

They have several.

I meant heroes

OMAC recently has been up there. Even giving Superman trouble.

Yeah, if Omac keeps getting a push then he might fill the void.

More than likely he will evolve flight and superspeed first though

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
He'd fit in just fine. I think Superman would be more negatively affected than Hulk with the change. Having a superhero (Albeit sometimes in a villanous role) physically superior to the Man of Steel takes away from him to an extent imho.

It might be because both wear a red cape, but you are confusing Superman with Thor.

Those are usually symptoms of gamma convertion.

I was hoping a thread like this never surface.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
I meant heroes

Aquaman. Grundy.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Aquaman. Grundy. Originally posted by carver9

They're heralds that can't fly. shrug

are they really pr? really?

Yes.

Also, Cyclops was wrong.

deep in your heart, you know both of those statements to be false

Originally posted by 753
deep in your heart, you know both of those statements to be false

Or true.

Hulk would fit fine, but wouldn't be necessary at all.

DC's already got enough grounded bricks (e.g Lobo, Grundy, Doomsday, General/Shaggy Man, etc.) and rage based characters (e.g. Atrocitus, Orion; both of whom have far more interesting stories than the Hulk).

Originally posted by Cogito
Hulk would fit fine, but wouldn't be necessary at all.

DC's already got enough grounded bricks (e.g Lobo, Grundy, Doomsday, General/Shaggy Man, etc.) and rage based characters (e.g. Atrocitus, Orion; both of whom have far more interesting stories than the Hulk). all those grounded bricks are villians, so there would be a role for him.

hulk's stories> atrocitus's and orion's

Originally posted by 753
hulk's stories> atrocitus's and orion's

Please.

Atrocitus maybe, his isn't that original or anything, but Orion's backstory shits on the Hulk's

Hulk, Bizarro and Grundy start a vigilante trio that handles small incidents like cat stuck in a tree.

Originally posted by Cogito
Please.

Atrocitus maybe, his isn't that original or anything, but Orion's backstory shits on the Hulk's you mean his origin story? big deal, hulk has accumulated better stories over time.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Hulk, Bizarro and Grundy start a vigilante trio that handles small incidents like cat stuck in a tree. Naming the three of them in a group together may have given me an idea for a new thread, lol.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Hulk, Bizarro and Grundy start a vigilante trio that handles small incidents like cat stuck in a tree. Now I'd pay money to see that. The trio attempting to improve their public relationships by becoming heroes for hire(sue me)...they end up causing more trouble than they're worth.

Gold right there.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Hulk, Bizarro and Grundy start a vigilante trio that handles small incidents like cat stuck in a tree.

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lgyaxdtsKK1qg636ko1_500.png

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Now I'd pay money to see that. The trio attempting to improve their public relationships by becoming heroes for hire(sue me)...they end up causing more trouble than they're worth.

Gold right there.

superpowered three stooges.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lgyaxdtsKK1qg636ko1_500.png Damn I miss this dude XD

A few things that everybody knows deep inside:

a). Superman will always be shown to beat Hulk in a straight comic fight.
b). Hulk will never be shown to be stronger than Superman, but will almost everytime be said to be "one of/the strongest opponents he has ever faced" and maybe even a "given time, this might have gone south".

As for the thread:

He would fit in fine, just as Superman would in Marvel. His fights against somebody like Black Adam would be awesome.

mary sueperman

Originally posted by Cogito
Please.

Atrocitus maybe, his isn't that original or anything, but Orion's backstory shits on the Hulk's

Whatever your opinion on the Hulk stories may be, numbers don't lie. The Hulk would outsell Orion all day everyday, and that is how you measure better from worse in this world. Not a swipe at you, but the truth.

hulk is far more popular but that has no reflection on the content of the comics, however hulk would win that argument most likely. again, sales don't really mean shit.

flash would outsell orion as well, doesn't mean there is any substance to it

Originally posted by psycho gundam
sales don't really mean shit. x 10000

Originally posted by Stoic
Whatever your opinion on the Hulk stories may be, numbers don't lie. The Hulk would outsell Orion all day everyday, and that is how you measure better from worse in this world. Not a swipe at you, but the truth.

Would you rank movies based on sales? How about books? Cars? TV Shows?

Yes.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Nicely, Dc doesn't really have a top tier non flying brick

Now that I think of it Dc can't write top tier characters without blanket powers

I think superman covers that

Age of Ultron is a consistent best seller as far as comic book shops are concerned.

I would like to see more of dr. banner teaming up smarts with the likes of batman and mr. terrific. Occasionally hulk out for some crazy arcs or something.

World War Hulk outsold Final Crisis.

All this said, I do think Hulk has had great arcs and storylines regardless of sales. And as character who is more popular in his universe as opposed to Orion in his, he has more material to drawn upon. The flipside to that is that while he may have more instances of better storytelling, he'll invariably have more instances of "eh" and not so good storytelling. And all in all, I do prefer Orion more as a character, but I acknowledge Hulk's had some great arcs and storylines outside of just ridiculous feats for the sake of ridiculous feats.

But yeah, sales don't coincide with quality. SHIELD by Hickman was one of the best series I've read (and I'm psyched to hear they will pick up where they left off soon, probably after Infinity), but Bendis' Avengers outsold it.

Originally posted by ODG
World War Hulk outsold Final Crisis.

Originally posted by ODG
World War Hulk outsold Final Crisis.

One of the reviewers on IGN ripped into WWH and he got put off comics for a long time....

Ign sucks at everything.

Originally posted by curryman
One of the reviewers on IGN ripped into WWH and he got put off comics for a long time....


Originally posted by Mindset
Ign sucks at everything.