Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who in Comics belongs in the same league as
↓↓↓↓

The Silver Surfer
Superman
Thor
G.L Scott
Classic Strange

?

Who else is your pick ?

Plus who is your sleeper pick? A hero that you feel is underrated in your eye, but could surprise the boys up top?

Surfer is beyond the others, imo.

Surfer is a jobber in comics, he gets whooped by people he should be able to paint the town red with, on paper though and a non jobbing surfer is leaps an bounds ahead of the latter

Oh an classic strange is above the latter, but below an non jobbing surfer

Surfer is in the same class as Thor and Superman. Always has been, and for the most part, always will be.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Surfer is in the same class as Thor and Superman. Always has been, and for the most part, always will be. on paper he should be out of their league though.

Originally posted by LeonBuco666
on paper he should be out of their league though.

You could say the same about Thor and Superman.

Originally posted by -Pr-
You could say the same about Thor and Superman. i guess we'll never no for sure.

A bloodlusted alan or surfer are in a league of their own. Fate and strange as well.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Surfer is in the same class as Thor and Superman. Always has been, and for the most part, always will be. Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is.

Originally posted by JBL
Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is.

Strength is an aspect of power, imo.

Originally posted by Golgo13
A bloodlusted alan or surfer are in a league of their own. Fate and strange as well.


Agree with you on this

Originally posted by JBL
Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is.


Agree with this here

Originally posted by -Pr-
Strength is an aspect of power, imo.

Surfer and Thor get shit down with blasts and exotic displays of powers.

Superman punches to get the job done.

They are indeed in the same tier power wise IMHO.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Strength is an aspect of power, imo. Strength and power are different. If thor loses his hammer, he is not in the same class as surfer when it comes to power. His strength would be a non-factor.

Cap Marvel, Black Adam, Sentry, and Orion are all up there.

Originally posted by JBL
Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is.

Sure he is.

Originally posted by JBL
Strength and power are different. If thor loses his hammer, he is not in the same class as surfer when it comes to power. His strength would be a non-factor.

I don't agree that they're different, though perhaps our definitions of power are different.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I don't agree that they're different, though perhaps our definitions of power are different. Problem with Thor is the hammer is his biggest crutch. Without it he is just a brick. Sure he has displayed weather manipulation and flight without the hammer, but those showings are very little IMO.

Superman on the other hand has speed, maneuverability, senses and range options to compete.

*Puts on Thorbag flame shield*

As for the thread...mmm

Originally posted by ares834
Cap Marvel, Black Adam, Sentry, and Orion are all up there.



Sure he is. No hes not.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Problem with Thor is the hammer is his biggest crutch. Without it he is just a brick. Sure he has displayed weather manipulation and flight without the hammer, but those showings are very little IMO.

Superman on the other hand has speed, maneuverability, senses and range options to compete.

*Puts on Thorbag flame shield*

As for the thread...mmm Thor has all that too. Plus a hammer loaded with power. Do you remember when superman held thors hammer and found out what true power is? If he was anywhere near as powerful, he would not have had an orgasm feeling that much power.

Strange could solo all those guys

Originally posted by ares834
Cap Marvel, Black Adam, Sentry, and Orion are all up there.



Sure he is.

Originally posted by JBL
Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is. His combination of strength, speed, intelligence, and other powers make him as powerful as them if not more so.

He has the ability to beat any high herald in comics.

Originally posted by JBL
Strength and power are different. If thor loses his hammer, he is not in the same class as surfer when it comes to power. His strength would be a non-factor.

Strength is power dude. What are you smoking? Power is the rate in which work is done. Work is force times distance.

With strength Superman can move planets, destroy shit, etc. He is very powerful.
He is also very fast which again implies power.

Originally posted by h1a8
Strength is power dude. What are you smoking? Power is the rate in which work is done. Work is force times distance.

With strength Superman can move planets, destroy shit, etc. He is very powerful.
He is also very fast which again implies power.

Superman being stronger and much functionally (not flight) faster than Thor actually means he is much, much more powerful!

1. Sentry- Arguably above but that is a fight for another time.

2. Orion- A clear peer with the power of the Astro-Force and Motherbox.

3. Majestic- Lord Majestros is displeased with not being ranked.

4. Dr. Fate- Non SA Dr. Fate is still a beast.

5. Hyperion- He has enough feats to solidly place him here.

6. Mon-El- The Daxamite is a member.

7. Blue Marvel- Controversial? Maybe but deal with it.

much, much more powerful is sillly.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
much, much more powerful is sillly.

It is, but using the Physics definition it isn't. Semantics is as semantics does. ;-)

Originally posted by h1a8
Strength is power dude. What are you smoking? Power is the rate in which work is done. Work is force times distance.

With strength Superman can move planets, destroy shit, etc. He is very powerful.
He is also very fast which again implies power. Strength does not make superman anywhere near as powerful as silver surfer or thor. You think that superman can match the power cosmic or thors hammer output?? Silver surfer and thor have wrecked things that would laugh at superman. The are characters out there far stronger than superman that are not as powerful as thor or surfer. put superman in thors place and see how that celestial armor would laugh at him. Put him in thors place when thor ran off galactus with a god blast and see how quick galactus would kill him after he gets through laughing. I wont even bring up what surfer has done with the power cosmic. Superman is no-where close to thor or surfer in power. Captain Marvel is more powerful than superman and not even he is in their class when it comes to power.

Now when it comes to strength, you will say that superman is thousands of times stronger than thor? REALLY DUDE??? That would in your case place him above damn near anyone. Dont do that.

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/michael-jordan-laugh.gif

Originally posted by Zack Fair
much, much more powerful is sillly.

Thank you.

Originally posted by JBL
Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is.

Lowballing Clark there.

Originally posted by JBL
Strength does not make superman anywhere near as powerful as silver surfer or thor. You think that superman can match the power cosmic or thors hammer output?? Silver surfer and thor have wrecked things that would laugh at superman. The are characters out there far stronger than superman that are not as powerful as thor or surfer. put superman in thors place and see how that celestial armor would laugh at him. Put him in thors place when thor ran off galactus with a god blast and see how quick galactus would kill him after he gets through laughing. I wont even bring up what surfer has done with the power cosmic. Superman is no-where close to thor or surfer in power. Captain Marvel is more powerful than superman and not even he is in their class when it comes to power.

Now when it comes to strength, you will say that superman is thousands of times stronger than thor? REALLY DUDE??? That would in your case place him above damn near anyone. Dont do that. http://img.pandawhale.com/post-9778-Let-the-Hate-Flow-Through-You-uIsk.jpeg

Originally posted by JBL
Strength does not make superman anywhere near as powerful as silver surfer or thor. You think that superman can match the power cosmic or thors hammer output?? Silver surfer and thor have wrecked things that would laugh at superman. The are characters out there far stronger than superman that are not as powerful as thor or surfer. put superman in thors place and see how that celestial armor would laugh at him. Put him in thors place when thor ran off galactus with a god blast and see how quick galactus would kill him after he gets through laughing. I wont even bring up what surfer has done with the power cosmic. Superman is no-where close to thor or surfer in power. Captain Marvel is more powerful than superman and not even he is in their class when it comes to power.

Now when it comes to strength, you will say that superman is thousands of times stronger than thor? REALLY DUDE??? That would in your case place him above damn near anyone. Dont do that.

So by power, you mean energy attacks.

hulk

Gladiator
Savage Hulk/Current Grey Hulk
A controllable Sentry (an unleashed Sentry is above HH)
Magneto
Rachel Summers
Vulcan

I agree with JBL...when it comes to power, Thor and Surfer are in their own class. They have the physical aspect of all the Heralds along with the versatility of a trans and the power output of a high trans/sometimes Skyfather.

Shut up.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Shut up.

Lol...stop doing me like that Zack.

So we're all just going to forget that Superman has one-shot heralds with his heat vision.

All right.

As we say in Ireland, you're talking out your hole.

Originally posted by JBL
Power-wise, superman is not in the league with thor or Surfer. Strength wise, he is.
Yes, he's more powerful.

Originally posted by JBL
Strength does not make superman anywhere near as powerful as silver surfer or thor. You think that superman can match the power cosmic or thors hammer output?? Silver surfer and thor have wrecked things that would laugh at superman. The are characters out there far stronger than superman that are not as powerful as thor or surfer. put superman in thors place and see how that celestial armor would laugh at him. Put him in thors place when thor ran off galactus with a god blast and see how quick galactus would kill him after he gets through laughing. I wont even bring up what surfer has done with the power cosmic. Superman is no-where close to thor or surfer in power. Captain Marvel is more powerful than superman and not even he is in their class when it comes to power.

Now when it comes to strength, you will say that superman is thousands of times stronger than thor? REALLY DUDE??? That would in your case place him above damn near anyone. Dont do that.

Originally posted by carver9
Gladiator
Savage Hulk/Current Grey Hulk
A controllable Sentry (an unleashed Sentry is above HH)
Magneto
Rachel Summers
Vulcan

I agree with JBL...when it comes to power, Thor and Surfer are in their own class. They have the physical aspect of all the Heralds along with the versatility of a trans and the power output of a high trans/sometimes Skyfather.

http://s3-ec.buzzfed.com/static/enhanced/webdr02/2012/12/19/13/anigif_enhanced-buzz-8086-1355940716-8.gif

LoL That gif is awesome

Originally posted by JBL
Strength does not make superman anywhere near as powerful as silver surfer or thor. You think that superman can match the power cosmic or thors hammer output?? Silver surfer and thor have wrecked things that would laugh at superman. The are characters out there far stronger than superman that are not as powerful as thor or surfer. put superman in thors place and see how that celestial armor would laugh at him. Put him in thors place when thor ran off galactus with a god blast and see how quick galactus would kill him after he gets through laughing. I wont even bring up what surfer has done with the power cosmic. Superman is no-where close to thor or surfer in power. Captain Marvel is more powerful than superman and not even he is in their class when it comes to power.

Now when it comes to strength, you will say that superman is thousands of times stronger than thor? REALLY DUDE??? That would in your case place him above damn near anyone. Dont do that.
Hahaha. Just a quick comparison of what Superman has done power wise would put both Surfer and Thor in a league below Superman. Galactus? Celestials? Try someone who beat DC's creator Source/ALE being after laughing at his attacks, soulfire Darkseid

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414247_ds1-1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414248_ds2-1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414249_ds3-1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414250_ds4-1.jpg

Superman broke him in half without even meaning to do it.

http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_deathofthenewgods08015qf6.jpg

I would also like to see Thor and Surfer contributing in creating a Big Bang

http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_ZHpt005_pg018.jpg http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_ZHpt005_pg019.jpg http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_ZHpt005_pg021.jpg

Ready, set, go.

...You're not helping.

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130325203343/walkingdead/images/7/74/And-here-we-go-eccbc87e4b5ce2fe28308fd9f2a7baf3-1271.gif

Originally posted by -Pr-
...You're not helping.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Lowballing Clark there. How is this lowballing Clark? Superman cannot match thors hammer or surfers cosmic power. Give superman thors hammer or surfers cosmic power and then he will be in the same class power-wise. Beta ray bill when he first met thor was nearly as strong. That in no way placed them in the same class power-wise. The minute bill got that hammer and its power he knew he had elevated to the next level as stated on panel. Superman felt the power in thors hammer, take a guess at how he reacted. WW in a crossover felt that same power, guess how she reacted, Captain America felt that same power trying to get the hammer to thor, guess how he reacted? They ALL were in AWE of that POWER. If anything, its lowballing surfer and thor by trying to place superman in the same class as them power-wise. Remember that forcefield that superman could not break through with his strength or his power? We know that thors hammer will wreck that field and i bet you that surfer would have blown that field to bits and the planet if he wanted to. Supermans strength, heatvision and freeze breath vs thors strength and all that power his hammer gives him and surfers strength plus all that power the power cosmic gives him???? Dr Fate or Dr Strange yes... Superman? NO.

lol

Originally posted by abhilegend
Hahaha. Just a quick comparison of what Superman has done power wise would put both Surfer and Thor in a league below Superman. Galactus? Celestials? Try someone who beat DC's creator Source/ALE being after laughing at his attacks, soulfire Darkseid

http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414247_ds1-1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414248_ds2-1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414249_ds3-1.jpg http://s4d2.turboimagehost.com/t/16414250_ds4-1.jpg

Superman broke him in half without even meaning to do it.

http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_deathofthenewgods08015qf6.jpg

I would also like to see Thor and Surfer contributing in creating a Big Bang

http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_ZHpt005_pg018.jpg http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_ZHpt005_pg019.jpg http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/th_ZHpt005_pg021.jpg

Ready, set, go. Not trying to be funny or rude to you pal, but sugarcoating scans hurt your case. What you say happened in scans always get corrected.

Originally posted by JBL
Not trying to be funny or rude to you pal, but sugarcoating scans hurt your case. What you say happened in scans always get corrected.
Haha. Run back to CBR.

Originally posted by JBL
How is this lowballing Clark? Superman cannot match thors hammer or surfers cosmic power. Give superman thors hammer or surfers cosmic power and then he will be in the same class power-wise. Beta ray bill when he first met thor was nearly as strong. That in no way placed them in the same class power-wise. The minute bill got that hammer and its power he knew he had elevated to the next level as stated on panel. Superman felt the power in thors hammer, take a guess at how he reacted. WW in a crossover felt that same power, guess how she reacted, Captain America felt that same power trying to get the hammer to thor, guess how he reacted? They ALL were in AWE of that POWER. If anything, its lowballing surfer and thor by trying to place superman in the same class as them power-wise. Remember that forcefield that superman could not break through with his strength or his power? We know that thors hammer will wreck that field and i bet you that surfer would have blown that field to bits and the planet if he wanted to. Supermans strength, heatvision and freeze breath vs thors strength and all that power his hammer gives him and surfers strength plus all that power the power cosmic gives him???? Dr Fate or Dr Strange yes... Superman? NO.

Jesus christ.

I also think it's great that you use the JLA/Avengers crossover to prove your point. You know, the crossover where Superman beats Thor.

Well done.

Originally posted by ares834
Jesus christ.

I also think it's great that you use the JLA/Avengers crossover to prove your point. You know, the crossover where Superman beats Thor.

Well done.

I dont care who beats who in a comic book. Wolverine beat Lobo and venom was beating superman, so we know how much stock to put in comic fights. The subject is power, not who beat who. Superman holding thors hammer proves my point. But nice try though.

Considering at the time he has both his power as well as Thor's it doesn't prove your point at all.

And ignore the fight all you want, but it clearly shows Superman and Thor are in the same league.

Originally posted by ares834
Considering at the time he has both his power as well as Thor's it doesn't prove your point at all.

And ignore the fight all you want, but it clearly shows Superman and Thor are in the same league. When you get thors powers you transform like dargo, bill and masterson. captain america and superman did not transform, they merely felt the power not receive it. Also in that fight they were equals while thor used NONE of his powers on superman. Dont forget what the WRITERS had thor say about if they fought again.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ELFl2_1q7DI/TObn1HnV2fI/AAAAAAAAAaQ/5JkvAtpbv7k/s320/Not_sure_if_serious.jpg

Superman had his powers stacked on mjolnir just like what happened when he was merged with Captain Marvel.

He was amazed at Captain Marvel power as well.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman had his powers stacked on mjolnir just like what happened when he was merged with Captain Marvel. Merging with Cap was one body. Superman did NOT receive thors powers and strength or else he would have transformed into thors likeness. The same way bill and dargo did. what did superman say when he FELT thors powers?? What did Captain America say?? Now what did bill say? what did dargo say? Let me help, i have never FELT this much power... compared to..... I can feel the aliens powers added to my own or i have become thor.... See the difference??

Because it was stacked on his power.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Because it was stacked on his power. I really need a new hobby.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Because it was stacked on his power.

That was never stated. He said he couldnt believe Marvel had that much power in him.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
LoL That gif is awesome

It would be better if he were shooting beams out of his holy eyes.

Originally posted by JBL
Merging with Cap was one body. Superman did NOT receive thors powers and strength or else he would have transformed into thors likeness. The same way bill and dargo did. what did superman say when he FELT thors powers?? What did Captain America say?? Now what did bill say? what did dargo say? Let me help, i have never FELT this much power... compared to..... I can feel the aliens powers added to my own or i have become thor.... See the difference??
Superman received mjolnir's powers and it was stacked on his. He wasn't transformed into Thor because he wasn't worthy. Its one of its kind situation, everyone else who has lifted it has been deemed worthy of it so they have been transformed into Thor.

Your rambling is cute.

Originally posted by carver9
That was never stated. He said he couldnt believe Marvel had that much power in him.
Yes it was stated. Don't act like you've actually read the comic.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Yes it was stated. Don't act like you've actually read the comic.

Don't act like you know me. Every comic you tend to bring up, I tend to know about it. Ill have a scan soon.

Originally posted by carver9
Don't act like you know me. Every comic you tend to bring up, I tend to know about it. Ill have a scan soon.
Hahaha.

Go for it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Hahaha.

Go for it.

Woah...
This is...
This is...

http://ic.pics.livejournal.com/jeanne_dark/703227/45740/45740_original.jpg

Is this how it always feel? Your power? I can only feel power, so much. I had no idea what you are capable of.

http://ic.pics.livejournal.com/jeanne_dark/703227/46044/46044_original.jpg

Like I've stated, Superman was amazed at Cap powers.

The second scan confirms he is amped....

Originally posted by ares834
The second scan confirms he is amped....

Superman also states he didn't know Cap walk around with that much power. Superman contributed but overall, he is feeling Caps power which is what was repeated more than once.

"Is this... Is this how it always feels your power?"

"More or less... Well, more because of your contribution. But you don't sense that anymore, do you?"

Here we have Marvel confirming that that power Supes is sensing is not solely Marvel's power saying it is more than usual.

Edit: But, yeah, Supes is amazed by Marvel power. Which I see was your original point.

Originally posted by ares834
"Is this... Is this how it always feels your power?"

"More or less... Well, more because of your contribution. But you don't sense that anymore, do you?"

Here we have Marvel confirming that that power Supes is sensing is not solely Marvel's power saying it is more than usual.

Edit: But, yeah, Supes is amazed by Marvel power. Which I see was your original point.

"You dont sense that anymore, do you". Which means Superman portion of the power is gone. Right after that Superman states..."no, I feel nothing but POWER". I had no idea what YOU were capable of".

Before this Cap states "welcome to MY world".

Originally posted by carver9
Woah...
This is...
This is...

http://ic.pics.livejournal.com/jeanne_dark/703227/45740/45740_original.jpg

Is this how it always feel? Your power? I can only feel power, so much. I had no idea what you are capable of.

http://ic.pics.livejournal.com/jeanne_dark/703227/46044/46044_original.jpg

Like I've stated, Superman was amazed at Cap powers.
Superman's power was added to Cap's power as stated by Cap himself and that was what Superman was sensing. Can you read?

Originally posted by carver9
"You dont sense that anymore, do you". Which means Superman portion of the power is gone. Right after that Superman states..."no, I feel nothing but POWER". I had no idea what YOU were capable of".

Before this Cap states "welcome to MY world".

It suggests that their power is no longer separate but rather mixed as right before that Marvel confirms he is more powerful than usual.

You needed someone not of this earth to act as a conduit, reassemble and refocuse your power. Seeing you act decisevely, experiencing YOUR POWER FIRST HAND (not screaming at you).

http://ic.pics.livejournal.com/jeanne_dark/703227/46688/46688_original.jpg

Originally posted by ares834
I took that to mean their power is no longer separate but rather mixed or perhaps that Supes' portion can't be sensed, as right before that Marvel confirms he is more powerful than usual.

When did he say he was more powerful than usual?

Originally posted by carver9
"You dont sense that anymore, do you". Which means Superman portion of the power is gone. Right after that Superman states..."no, I feel nothing but POWER". I had no idea what YOU were capable of".

Before this Cap states "welcome to MY world".
Haha, really? Superman's contribution was there but he couldn't sense it due to the overall power.

Yeah, Cap said that after absorbing the power of Mary and Freddy which were used like separate power sources for cap.

Originally posted by carver9
When did he say he was more powerful than usual?
When he absorbed Freddy and Mary's power as Kelly's Cap wasn't power sharing.

Originally posted by carver9
When did he say he was more powerful than usual?

I posted it earlier.

"Is this... Is this how it always feels your power?"

"More or less... Well, more because of your contribution"

Thor is slow

Alan blood lusted would everyone

Originally posted by ares834
I posted it earlier.

"Is this... Is this how it always feels your power?"

"More or less... Well, more because of your contribution"
Not to mention Cap wasn't power sharing under Kelly so getting powers of Freddy and Mary would amp his power. That book was horribly written anyway. Mary was cut in half under her powered up form and somehow survived getting depowered and still cut in half in her human form. I mean WTF?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman received mjolnir's powers and it was stacked on his. He wasn't transformed into Thor because he wasn't worthy. Its one of its kind situation, everyone else who has lifted it has been deemed worthy of it so they have been transformed into Thor.

Your rambling is cute. As is your constant lying about scans.

Originally posted by JBL
As is your constant lying about scans.
Lulz. How's things on CBR?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Lulz. How's things on CBR? CBR must stand for, your " Credibility Being Ruined " by lying about what happens in scans you post. If thats the case, Its a very amusing place.

Originally posted by JBL
CBR must stand for, your " Credibility Being Ruined " by lying about what happens in scans you post. If thats the case, Its a very amusing place.
Nah, its CBR rumbles. Thou doth protest too much.

mmm

Originally posted by abhilegend
Nah, its CBR rumbles. Thou doth protest too much.

mmm Are you going to answer rages question in that doomsday thread about Odins power? Or is your statement yet another lie? I would love to see you drink some truth serum, but i fear even Wonder Womans Lasso would fail to get you to stop lying about scans and what you say happened.

We all know that Surfer, Thor, Superman, Strage sometimes Fate and the thete G.L Scott are most likely top dogs on the superhero food chian with some differences between them all, but just asking who other hero belong with them or is the power gap to wide for anybody else to even compete with them?


1. Who else should in that mix above↑↑↑

2.Who is your sleeper pick that would surprise the top boys in a fight

3. Be nice to eachother.. Everybody respect others opinion..
After all that's all they are, are opinion..

Thor, Surfer and Superman bring different strengths to the table.

- Thor (with hammer) I give the nod to in terms of sheer, overall power, not that the others are that far behind. He's also probably best at energy absorption (again, with hammer), which is extremely handy against a wide range of attacks.
- Surfer has the best overall versatility (jeez, the guy turned himself into snow!). I'm also inclined to give him the edge in durability and travel speed (again, the others not being that far behind).
- Superman, in addition to being physically the strongest and fastest in h2h speed, is the best puncher/brawler and definitely the most creative with his powers (SS and Thor should take note).

Personally, I consider any victory of one over the other circumstance determined.

Originally posted by JBL
CBR must stand for, your " Credibility Being Ruined " by lying about what happens in scans you post. If thats the case, Its a very amusing place.

Originally posted by Mindship
Thor, Surfer and Superman bring different strengths to the table.

- Thor (with hammer) I give the nod to in terms of sheer, overall power, not that the others are that far behind. He's also probably best at energy absorption (again, with hammer), which is extremely handy against a wide range of attacks.
- Surfer has the best overall versatility (jeez, the guy turned himself into snow!). I'm also inclined to give him the edge in durability and travel speed (again, the others not being that far behind).
- Superman, in addition to being physically the strongest and fastest in h2h speed, is the best puncher/brawler and definitely the most creative with his powers (SS and Thor should take note).

Personally, I consider any victory of one over the other circumstance determined.

Good post.

Methinks Carver and JBL need to go rent a room, and spend the day burning Superman comics in some sort of satanic ritual.

Originally posted by carver9
Good post. Thanks.

Originally posted by Mindship
Thor, Surfer and Superman bring different strengths to the table.

- Thor (with hammer) I give the nod to in terms of sheer, overall power, not that the others are that far behind. He's also probably best at energy absorption (again, with hammer), which is extremely handy against a wide range of attacks.
- Surfer has the best overall versatility (jeez, the guy turned himself into snow!). I'm also inclined to give him the edge in durability and travel speed (again, the others not being that far behind).
- Superman, in addition to being physically the strongest and fastest in h2h speed, is the best puncher/brawler and definitely the most creative with his powers (SS and Thor should take note).

Personally, I consider any victory of one over the other circumstance determined.




Nice post

Originally posted by -Pr-
Methinks Carver and JBL need to go rent a room, and spend the day burning Superman comics in some sort of satanic ritual. They already do. They send each other pictures and videos of them pissing on the books before burning them for lord almighty Stan Lee.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Methinks Carver and JBL need to go rent a room, and spend the day burning Superman comics in some sort of satanic ritual.

Really? I didn't say anything about Superman. My comment was made towards"all" Heralds, not just Superman.

Originally posted by carver9
Really? I didn't say anything about Superman. My comment was made towards"all" Heralds, not just Superman.



Right; because every herald was amped by Captain Marvel, according to you.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Right; because every herald was amped by Captain Marvel, according to you.

Lol...that's different. I was correcting ABHI. Nothing towards Superman...just seen a flaw in his post.

Originally posted by Mindship
Thor, Surfer and Superman bring different strengths to the table.

- Thor (with hammer) I give the nod to in terms of sheer, overall power, not that the others are that far behind. He's also probably best at energy absorption (again, with hammer), which is extremely handy against a wide range of attacks.
- Surfer has the best overall versatility (jeez, the guy turned himself into snow!). I'm also inclined to give him the edge in durability and travel speed (again, the others not being that far behind).
- Superman, in addition to being physically the strongest and fastest in h2h speed, is the best puncher/brawler and definitely the most creative with his powers (SS and Thor should take note).

Personally, I consider any victory of one over the other circumstance determined.

No bias leads to good rational views like these.

Originally posted by Supermex
Nice post Merci.

Originally posted by Zack Fair


No bias leads to good rational views like these. I try, sir. I try.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...that's different. I was correcting ABHI. Nothing towards Superman...just seen a flaw in his post.

lol.

Originally posted by Zack Fair


No bias leads to good rational views like these.

I always respect Mindship posts. He reminds me of Jake.

Scott and strange are above HH....but yea Clark, Norrin and Thor are more or less interchangable

Originally posted by JBL
Are you going to answer rages question in that doomsday thread about Odins power? Or is your statement yet another lie? I would love to see you drink some truth serum, but i fear even Wonder Womans Lasso would fail to get you to stop lying about scans and what you say happened.
Why are you concerned with that?

Also lulz @ your butthurt here. I recommend lotions.

Originally posted by ares834
I posted it earlier.

"Is this... Is this how it always feels your power?"

"More or less... Well, more because of your contribution"

I guess we are in disagreement about this ft. I care less to go any further with this debate since I'm not interested entirely with either of the characters. Lets just agree to disagree.

Shaman X-Man

Quasar

Gladiator

Originally posted by JBL
CBR must stand for, your " Credibility Being Ruined " by lying about what happens in scans you post. If thats the case, Its a very amusing place.

that was keen

These kind of topics are always fun. If you had this on CBR it would cause a huge shit-storm with people getting banned for not putting SS at the top.

Originally posted by Supermex
Who in Comics belongs in the same league as
↓↓↓↓

The Silver Surfer
Superman
Thor
G.L Scott
Classic Strange

?

Who else is your pick ?

Plus who is your sleeper pick? A hero that you feel is underrated in your eye, but could surprise the boys up top?
Orion... When he's not being misportrayed...

In the right environment, Henshaw is beyond Thor, Superman, or Surfer...

On average, Henshaw is comparable to all 3 of those guys...