Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

1. Regular versions of both

2. Both at peak

Who wins?

Surfer wins both after a good fight.

Surfer, easily.

Originally posted by carver9
Surfer wins both after a good fight.
Agreed.

serious surfer should stomp

Surfer.

silver_surfer would win with ease

How is this not a stomp

In what way did ozz81 think Magneto even had a chance?

Originally posted by Kazenji
In what way did ozz81 think Magneto even had a chance?


Probably in the way that any person not too familiar with the Surfer (myself included to some degree) likely would:

1. They've seen Magneto handle the combined forces of X-Men and Avengers TEAMS at various points of his career, teams that have included heavy-hitters like She-Hulk and Thor going at him simulataneously.

2. They've seen Magneto perform admirably against uber-mutants like Apocalypse, weaker alternate version of Magneto even rending Apocalypse asunder at the close of one storyline.

3. They see a man who looks like he is either covered in or made of metal.
Riding a surfboard. And they've been told the Black Panther put, and apparently kept, this metal-looking man in a choke hold. Despite Black Panther having no discernible super powers or strength augmenting devices.




If that were the extent of what I knew about Silver Surfer, I'd think Magneto had a very good shot of winning this, too.

Surfer can control magnetism too if he wanted

Spite.

Magneto is not even good enough to count as a threat.

Magneto, easily.

"Bueno! He's bound."

Surfer opens Magneto's shield and one shots him...

Originally posted by janus77
Spite.

Magneto is not even good enough to count as a threat.
based on what exactly?
mag wins!

Surfer

1- Surfer after a good fight
2- Surfer would wtfpwn Magneto. Magneto as 0 chance to win.

Originally posted by 9jaboy
based on what exactly?
mag wins!

Magneto can control magnetism?
Tough shit!
Surfer control matter, time and space!
What Magneto can do, Surfer does it way better. And without their powers, Magneto is a man, Surfer is a hardass who can throw 'em with the likes of Thor and Hulk.

Surfer FTW, but Mags would probably put up quite a challenge till Norrin turns it up a notch.

Surfer opens a black hole in Magneto's shield








Am I doing this right?

I dunno, maybe Magnetos control over the magnetism is better then Surfers and then he would be a challange.

And Mags fought the Phoenix which is > Surfer.

Surfer rips the iron from Magneto's blood. Turns off Magneto's brain, instantly. And then, just for good measure, skewers him with a 9' adamantium pole, rectum to pate.

surfer

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
Magneto can control magnetism?
Tough shit!
Surfer control matter, time and space!
What Magneto can do, Surfer does it way better. And without their powers, Magneto is a man, Surfer is a hardass who can throw 'em with the likes of Thor and Hulk.
1.you think ss can control magnetism way better than mags can?
2.good thing they're using their powers.

Originally posted by janus77
Surfer rips the iron from Magneto's blood. Turns off Magneto's brain, instantly. And then, just for good measure, skewers him with a 9' adamantium pole, rectum to pate.
lol,good jokes.........
Now what's your point?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Surfer, easily.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Magneto, easily.

"Bueno! He's bound."
LOL.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
I dunno, maybe Magnetos control over the magnetism is better then Surfers and then he would be a challange.

And Mags fought the Phoenix which is > Surfer.

Yeah but Surfer has fought beings that >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Magneto too

Originally posted by 9jaboy
1.you think ss can control magnetism way better than mags can?
2.good thing they're using their powers.
Plain and simple. SS operates in higher standard than Mags.

Teh is reality. Lol

Originally posted by 9jaboy
based on what exactly?
mag wins! No Surfer is above Magneto no doubt

Originally posted by Ambient
Plain and simple. SS operates in higher standard than Mags.

Teh is reality. Lol

what level would you put mags at?

Surfer

Originally posted by iceman24567
No Surfer is above Magneto no doubt
yeah,I'm aware of that.

Norrin

Originally posted by 9jaboy
what level would you put mags at?
Low herald.

Surfer phases through Magneto's shield and snaps his neck.

Rinse and repeat for a 100000000000000100000000000000/100000000000000100000000000000 victory for Surfer.

This is ridiculous spite and even worse ignorance on the part of those thinking Magneto stands a chance against Surfer.

Originally posted by Ambient
Low herald.
agreed.
seriously,surfer would win but I think mags could give him a challenge IMO unlike how Janus 77 is making it out to be a stomp.

Surfer wins and zop your avatar and Sig scares me =/ please change

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
I dunno, maybe Magnetos control over the magnetism is better then Surfers and then he would be a challange.

And Mags fought the CRIPPLED Phoenix which is < Surfer.
Fixed it for you.
http://s24.postimg.org/ljnkaj4lt/The_Uncanny_X_Men112_28.jpg

The explanation for the reason she hit a limit on her power and why Magneto beat her :
http://s22.postimg.org/a23112gh9/psychic_ciruit_breakers.jpg

Surfer destroys Magneto.

Originally posted by 9jaboy
agreed.
seriously,surfer would win but I think mags could give him a challenge IMO unlike how Janus 77 is making it out to be a stomp.

In a comicbook fight, it would be a cool fight.

But if everything showed in comics are allowed... It's impossible for Mags to win this.

Surfer can travel in time. He can manipulate matter on a molecular scale. He can open black hole. He would depower Mag, and bitchslap him all across the solar system. Or teleport his ass into the sun.

He got so much options that it would be boring. Even high heralds would be shat on by a PIS-less Silver Surfer. IMO, only Thor has the ability to survive and fight back a "I'm going all out!" Silver Surfer

Originally posted by Bouboumaster

Surfer can travel in time.


Didn't Galactus take away this power from Surfer, for his "betrayal" in aiding the Fantastic Four against Galactus?



Originally posted by Bouboumaster
He would ... teleport into the sun.


IIRC, Magneto, shielded by his force fields, has survived the near absolute zero cold of space and journeyed through the center of an active volcano unharmed.

His most recent battle with Iron Man suggests Magneto can actually USE the magnetic fields of solar objects like the sun to strengthen his shields.

Originally posted by bluewaterrider
Didn't Galactus take away this power from Surfer, for his "betrayal" in aiding the Fantastic Four against Galactus?
Nope.

AvX was garbage and that still won't save Magneto from Surfer.

Originally posted by bluewaterrider
IIRC, Magneto, shielded by his force fields, has survived the near absolute zero cold of space and journeyed through the center of an active volcano unharmed.

Are you suggesting that a volcano is comparable to the Sun?

Magneto showings against the Avengers is better. Magneto can make this a fight.

Originally posted by zopzop

Nope.

AvX was garbage and that still won't save Magneto from Surfer.

You can't discredit showings because you don't like it. Isn't AvX the main reason you low ball Namor. Can't pick and choose my friend.

Originally posted by carver9
You can't discredit showings because you don't like it. Isn't AvX the main reason you low ball Namor. Can't pick and choose my friend.
I didn't say the showing isn't valid (that's why I said it won't save him from Surfer), I just said AvX is garbage.

Fight of Iron Man versus Magneto was well thought out and inventive, though.


And, since it also reinforces the idea of Magneto being able to use non-Earth solar objects to power his magnetic fields ...



http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022738
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022797
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022745
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022748
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14319466
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14319475

(Click-able link version)


http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022738
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022797
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022745
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14022748
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14319466
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14319475

I will say if this was Eric at the top of his game and Surfer at an average showing Eric could win.

certainly his shields can withstand assaults from surfer.. They easily deflected captain universe spiderman blast.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
I will say if this was Eric at the top of his game and Surfer at an average showing Eric could win. exactly

Originally posted by 9jaboy
exactly

Unfortunately..... Neither fight is like that.

Average surfer against average Erik? Surfer.

Peak surfer against peak Erik? Surfer.

There is no permutation of peak Erik and average surfer.