Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Captain Rogers has Thor's Hammer and his shield

Kal-El has Stormbreaker and an identical shield

Both have 3 days prep on using the weapons.

Kals powers do not stack

Who Wins.

You must be joking.

Spite. Superman would wipe his ass with Steve under these circumstances.

Mjoinir > Stormbreaker.

Not to mention the skill advantage.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Mjoinir > Stormbreaker.

Proof?

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Mjoinir > Stormbreaker.

Not to mention the skill advantage.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Mjoinir > Stormbreaker.

Not to mention the skill advantage.

What skill advantage?

Kal has studied under wildcat, Batman, and Diana. Plus he has his Kryptonian martial arts to fall back on.

He's close to master in pressure points also.

Originally posted by SquallX
What skill advantage?

Kal has studied under wildcat, Batman, and Diana. Plus he has his Kryptonian martial arts to fall back on.

He's close to master in pressure points also.
nono

Originally posted by Supra
Kals powers do not stack for both of you to readOriginally posted by SquallX
What skill advantage?

Kal has studied under wildcat, Batman, and Diana. Plus he has his Kryptonian martial arts to fall back on.

He's close to master in pressure points also. really? You honestly believe Superman is as skilled as Cap?

Originally posted by Brockalizer
Spite. Superman would wipe his ass with Steve under these circumstances.

How is this spite, they have the same weapons and Kal's powers do not stack.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
for both of you to read really? You honestly believe Superman is as skilled as Cap?

They cant read.

lol at rogers being more skilled than clark.

Sarcasm?

Originally posted by SquallX
What skill advantage?

Kal has studied under wildcat, Batman, and Diana. Plus he has his Kryptonian martial arts to fall back on.

He's close to master in pressure points also. Mohammad Ali

Originally posted by deathslash
Mohammad Ali

Cause that makes sense.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Mjoinir > Stormbreaker.

Like when Rulk lifted it in zero gravity? Stormbreaker no-sold anti-grav tech

So, at least in that department, Stormbreaker is superior.

It's had the benefit of not being assaulted by PIS. It's blessed, not superior. They were created to be equals, that's what I usually go with.

Also Lord Rogers spite stomps the boyscout.

Originally posted by Damborgson
It's had the benefit of not being assaulted by PIS. It's blessed, not superior. They were created to be equals, that's what I usually go with.

Also Lord Rogers spite stomps the boyscout.

Im pretty sure its not spite considering they have the same powers and Kal El is used to using his own powers at god level of Thors and Rogers is not.

Rogers has never faced the murderer's technique of the dreaded Torquasm-Rao!

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Like when Rulk lifted it in zero gravity? Stormbreaker no-sold anti-grav tech

So, at least in that department, Stormbreaker is superior.

It wasn't just lack of gravity. One of the reasons given was that Odin was dead. Yea, Loeb.

When did Stormbreaker no-sell anti-gravity tech?

Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
Rogers has never faced the murderer's technique of the dreaded Torquasm-Rao! Kal El has never had to face the dreaded America force before, so I guest that makes them both equal in that regard.

On a more serious note, Rogers is definitely more skilled in h2h than Clark and the difference in skill is actually a fairly big one. Also, Rogers has used Thors hammer on more than one occasion and is already fairly skilled with it. Superman would utilize his time to learn quite a few tricks with Stormbreaker, but Rogers has spent years seeing what Thor's hammer hammer can do. I feel like Cap would know how best to utilize the hammer.

How is Rogers watching the Hulk use the hammer going to help him actually use it.

Kal is used to using his own powers and knows he really has no limits, I think those could be extended to the powers granted to him by Stormbreaker.

Originally posted by Supra
How is Rogers watching the Hulk use the hammer going to help him actually use it.

What? Hulk has never used Thor's hammer. And he's referring to Rogers watching Thor use his hammer to do damn near everything under the Sun over the decades.

He's even lifted the hammer on occasions. When it comes to mortals, aside from Thor's hosts like Jake Olsen or Donald Blake, Captain America is the most familiar with Mjolnir.

Originally posted by Damborgson
It's had the benefit of not being assaulted by PIS. It's blessed, not superior. They were created to be equals, that's what I usually go with.

Didn't Odin himself say he'd make Bill a hammer equal to Mjolnir if he gave Mjolnir back to Thor? I don't think Odin was lying to Bill. Mjolnir=Stormbreaker.

Originally posted by zopzop
Didn't Odin himself say he'd make Bill a hammer equal to Mjolnir if he gave Mjolnir back to Thor? I don't think Odin was lying to Bill. Mjolnir=Stormbreaker.

Yeah, something along those lines. It doesn't have Mjolnir's plethora of feats of course but it's supposed to be equal and that's how I consider them.

Captain America wins.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
What? Hulk has never used Thor's hammer. And he's referring to Rogers watching Thor use his hammer to do damn near everything under the Sun over the decades.

He's even lifted the hammer on occasions. When it comes to mortals, aside from Thor's hosts like Jake Olsen or Donald Blake, Captain America is the most familiar with Mjolnir.

Meant Thor..sorry..

Ok Cap wins fair enough.

Who would you guys say is more worthy to wield the hammer?

Between Superman and Captain America?

Superman doesn't have the character to lift it at will. He usually doesn't do what needs to be done when the time comes, mostly his inability to kill. Wonderwoman would be a much more suitable candidate.

Cap on the other hand is a soldier, will kill if he needs and is able to mix in a warriors code with compassion and humility like Thor. (Excluding Fraction Thor). Cap is easily the choice to make.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Between Superman and Captain America?

Superman doesn't have the character to lift it at will. He usually doesn't do what needs to be done when the time comes, mostly his inability to kill. Wonderwoman would be a much more suitable candidate.

Cap on the other hand is a soldier, will kill if he needs and is able to mix in a warriors code with compassion and humility like Thor. (Excluding Fraction Thor). Cap is easily the choice to make.

If Superman killed one person, he would have no ethical code to stop him from killing anyone he fought though right? Once you cross that line more then once you cant go back right?

Originally posted by Supra
If Superman killed one person, he would have no ethical code to stop him from killing anyone he fought though right? Once you cross that line more then once you cant go back right?

Well its not rampaging killing spree type killing. It's a warriors ability to kill who needs to be killed, and restrain himself on those who don't. Clark seems like he'd have some heavy issues with that line.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Well its not rampaging killing spree type killing. It's a warriors ability to kill who needs to be killed, and restrain himself on those who don't. Clark seems like he'd have some heavy issues with that line.

So why does he not kill?

Superman? Because he's a pussy of course.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Superman? Because he's a pussy of course.

Then why does he fight to protect the innocent.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Superman? Because he's a pussy of course.

So you're saying Kal is a pussy because he doesn't kill?

You know it takes more will power not to kill someone right?

Originally posted by Damborgson
Well its not rampaging killing spree type killing. It's a warriors ability to kill who needs to be killed, and restrain himself on those who don't. Clark seems like he'd have some heavy issues with that line.

Except that Superman has killed when it's been absolutely necessary, so that logic doesn't really work.

Sure, he's not as worthy to lift the hammer, but there's more to being a warrior than being willing to kill.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
It wasn't just lack of gravity. One of the reasons given was that Odin was dead. Yea, Loeb.

When did Stormbreaker no-sell anti-gravity tech?

In this issue, iirc (link to the proper scan is broken):

http://img32.imageshack.us/img32/9347/thor198941220.jpg

Originally posted by zop. Those two aliens were doing their best to lift it, after they muscles failed, they tried with the "anti-gravity braces".

The supes hate is strong in this thread, and I'm not talking about the fight between cap and supes in this thread.

How the **** is Cap winning this? Superman with stormbreaker would split open a thor level guy's head with one shot. He's not that pussy thor who doesn't knows how to swing a hammer and has actually used DC Thor's hammer for a thousand years. Sure Cap is more skilled but Superman's speed, strength gap and durability added with stormbreaker's striking power would ****ing end him even with Thor level stats.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Well its not rampaging killing spree type killing. It's a warriors ability to kill who needs to be killed, and restrain himself on those who don't. Clark seems like he'd have some heavy issues with that line.
Like Doomsday, or Pocket Dimension kryptonians?

Originally posted by Supra
Captain Rogers has Thor's Hammer and his shield

Kal-El has Stormbreaker and an identical shield

Both have 3 days prep on using the weapons.

Kals powers do not stack

Who Wins. https://fbcdn-sphotos-h-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/t1/1510688_10151751160896923_157366376_n.jpg

Originally posted by abhilegend
How the **** is Cap winning this? Superman with stormbreaker would split open a thor level guy's head with one shot. He's not that pussy thor who doesn't knows how to swing a hammer and has actually used DC Thor's hammer for a thousand years. Sure Cap is more skilled but Superman's speed, strength gap and durability added with stormbreaker's striking power would ****ing end him even with Thor level stats. This fight isn't as onesided as you might like to think. What's to stop Cap from teleporting Clark away from the fight? I'm not saying that Cap wins. I'm just saying that this fight isn't a curbstomp.

Originally posted by deathslash
This fight isn't as onesided as you might like to think. What's to stop Cap from teleporting Clark away from the fight? I'm not saying that Cap wins. I'm just saying that this fight isn't a curbstomp.
And what's stopping Superman from teleporting right back? You'd think he was some kind of energy being once and had actually teleported before or something..........

Originally posted by abhilegend
And what's stopping Superman from teleporting right back? You'd think he was some kind of energy being once and had actually teleported before or something.......... Sorry to tell you this, but since the thread doesn't specify, this is New 52 Superman.