How strong are the rank and file?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Q99
Rank the following:


5 KotoR Jedi

5 TOR Era Sith

5 Clone War Jedi

5 One Sith

5 Nightsisters

5 Lost Tribe members

5 NJO/Luke's Order Jedi


In all cases, rank-and-file warriors. No masters, no named characters, normal members of each of the above.

Nephthys
5 TOR Era Sith
5 KotoR Jedi
5 Clone War Jedi
5 NJO/Luke's Order Jedi
5 Nightsisters

I don't know shit about the One Sith or the Lost Tribe.

Intrepid37
One Sith is prolly the weakest lmfao

ares834
NJO Order

The rest

Astor Ebligis
KOTOR Jedi
TOR Sith
One Sith
Clone Wars Jedi
NJO/Luke's Order Jedi
Nightsisters

Don't know jack about the TLTOTS

Q99
Oh, just realized I left off Brotherhood of Darkness!

So 5 BoD Sith as well

Originally posted by Intrepid37
One Sith is prolly the weakest lmfao

Quite unlikely. They have a decade of war, performed well against NJO Jedi, and are taught in Sith ways, and taught to work together in groups, unlike many sith.


I mean, most obviously, the Lost Tribe and Nightsisters do not have the level of force knowledge of any of the big eras.

DarthAnt66
Originally posted by Q99
Rank the following:


5 KotoR Jedi

5 TOR Era Sith

5 Clone War Jedi

5 One Sith

5 Nightsisters

5 Lost Tribe members

5 NJO/Luke's Order Jedi


In all cases, rank-and-file warriors. No masters, no named characters, normal members of each of the above.
Let's look here:

1. 5 KotOR Jedi (Not trolling, confirmed superior then Clone Wars Jedi)
2. 5 Clone Wars Jedi (Stated to be the prime of the Jedi, besides KotOR)
3. 5 TOR Era Sith (Trained to kill and warfare)
4. 5 NJO Jedi (Very good Jedi, but not quite on CW era Jedi yet)
5. 5 One Sith (Mediocre Sith)
6. 5 BoD Sith (Mediocre Sith)
7. 5 Nightsisters (Get crushed by droids)
8. 5 Lost Tribe Sith (Luke killed a dozen on the brink of death)

Nephthys
Originally posted by Q99
Oh, just realized I left off Brotherhood of Darkness!

So 5 BoD Sith as well

Put them at the bottom, just above the Nightsisters.

Stealth Moose
This isn't too straightfoward for me. For one, the TOR era Sith and BoD have fought a common enemy for a long time, which breeds thorough experience, training, and innovations to combat, something that would be absent in the PT era Jedi and the laughable Lost Tribe Sith. Nightsisters are more of a side faction than a proper army in comparison. The NJO Jedi gathered a lot of war experience and training, and had some great esoteric abilities, even if some ancient knowledge was lost. They and the One Sith would be somewhat comparable, and not far behind the TOR/KotOR/BoD eras at all. I would rank them above the PT Jedi because of again, practical experience. Three years does not make the PT Jedi better than the cumulative hundreds of years combined of the others.

Q99
Originally posted by DarthAnt66

5. 5 One Sith (Mediocre Sith)

Why so low? They were on the offensive against the Jedi more than not, and did quite well.

DarthAnt66
Sorry Q, but I decided to read some more Legacy comics and Cade and Wolf Sazen alone were enough to stand against dozens of them, and still kick all their asses.

Nephthys
Originally posted by Stealth Moose
This isn't too straightfoward for me. For one, the TOR era Sith and BoD have fought a common enemy for a long time, which breeds thorough experience, training, and innovations to combat, something that would be absent in the PT era Jedi and the laughable Lost Tribe Sith.

Q99 made a great case that the BoD Sith were pretty shitty in this thread, based off of the fact that the Sith had only recently centralised and most of them were still poorly trained and over specialised. From what Q says it was only very recently that the eras Sith had started actually fighting Jedi.

Even in the Bane comic I noticed that a few of the Sith mooks didn't even have lightsabers and only fought with spears and stuff.

Stealth Moose
Originally posted by Nephthys
Q99 made a great case that the BoD Sith were pretty shitty in this thread, based off of the fact that the Sith had only recently centralised and most of them were still poorly trained and over specialised.

Even in the Bane comic I noticed that a few of the Sith mooks didn't even have lightsabers.

Hrm. I hadn't realized that. But it's been many years since I read the original comics. If that's the case, they would indeed rank much lower.

Q99
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Sorry Q, but I decided to read some more Legacy comics and Cade and Wolf Sazen alone were enough to stand against dozens of them, and still kick all their asses.

Sure, but when have top members of either side not been able to take out groups of the opposition? Sazen and Shado were basically Council level, Cade even better.

And while they took out lots, it's not like at any individual time they were facing dozens, they were in smaller groups. Top one sith could beat groups too.




Indeed. You'd have the most variance there both in quality and style, depending on which lord's territory they came from. Which is probably why the academy sith tended to perform better, as it was working on bringing together the splintered knowledge.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.