Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Title says it all.
The Mirage Comics TMNT vs the IDW versions of TMNT.

You can find respect links (which i cannot post as of now) by Googling both Mirage TMNT Comics Respect Thread and TMNT IDW - Respect Thread in the search bar for info on both.

Tough fight. The IDW TMNT can take alot of damage and keep going but the Mirage TMNT have absolutely no problem with killing and are more prone to go for the lethal strike when the opportunity presents itself. 6/10 for the IDW turtles because they are pretty good with coming up with random prep strategies and have shown a good deal of diversity with their fighting abilities.