Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Well?

Catch how?
Having the shield thrown AT him or catching the shield after throwing it?

toad comes to my mind

Punisher came to mine. He caught Cap's shield on his rifle barrel, spyn the momentum put of it then dropped it to the ground.

Hawkeye was able to catch it after throwing it.

Not sure which scenario we're talking here though.

Cap throwing it as hard as he can.

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Cap throwing it as hard as he can.

No one below Spider-Man. Everyone else gets sliced in half, if Captain America is serious about the shield throw:

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/6/60791/3369162-8655695450-CAPAL.jpg
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/6/60791/3369162-8655695450-CAPAL.jpg

And the only reason Spider-Man would be able to catch it are his super powers: spider-sense, super speed and super strength.

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Well?

Depends on who is throwing it. The Hulk should be the new Captain America

If Captain America is throwing it, Winter Soldier would likely be the weakest, but that would be because of his prosthetic arm. So I would say the Vision due to durability.

I think a very skilled street level char can do it, redirecting the force of the throw in a circular move.

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
I think a very skilled street level char can do it, redirecting the force of the throw in a circular move.


I think that the OP means to just catch it, as in no sell a full powered throw from Captain America. No street level character is going to do this.

http://s5d3.turboimagehost.com/t1/19732281_3520915-shieldcap.png

http://www.comicsrecommended.com/images/marvel/xmen_uncanny_009_beast_001.jpg

http://www.4thletter.net/gavok/vcr/whitehouse.jpg

I've seen Taskmaster catch it.
I guess Tasky would be the weakest since he is only suppose to have peak human strength.

Originally posted by Supermutant
http://s5d3.turboimagehost.com/t1/19732281_3520915-shieldcap.png

http://www.comicsrecommended.com/images/marvel/xmen_uncanny_009_beast_001.jpg

http://www.4thletter.net/gavok/vcr/whitehouse.jpg

I've seen Taskmaster catch it.
I guess Tasky would be the weakest since he is only suppose to have peak human strength.

When did Captain America ever come across as a murderer? If he threw his shield with the same amount of strength that he did when he wrecked that tank, I highly doubt that a street level would have an arm left after trying to catch it.

Originally posted by Stoic
When did Captain America ever come across as a murderer? If he threw his shield with the same amount of strength that he did when he wrecked that tank, I highly doubt that a street level would have an arm left after trying to catch it.

I doubt Cap was holding back against Deadpool and Red Skull. Beast has superhuman strength, coordination, balance, and agility so he should be able to do that. Taskmaster has studied Cap moves and has traded blows with him. His skill set would allow him to catch that.

And street leveler characters do things all the time that they shouldn't going strictly by power-set. Routinely out-reacting bullets fired from automatic weapons at close range for example. Just because you don't want to accept it doesn't mean it didn't happen on panel.

Originally posted by Stoic
When did Captain America ever come across as a murderer? If he threw his shield with the same amount of strength that he did when he wrecked that tank, I highly doubt that a street level would have an arm left after trying to catch it.
Captain America's killed like a hundred guys, you know that right?

certainly we aren't implying that cap throws his shield with tank-busting force every single time he hurls it at an enemy, right? that's ridiculous, imo.

deadpool, for example, is not going to just...palm a shield-throw that could have decimated a tank. how strong/durable do you people think he is for god's sake?

Originally posted by Galan007
certainly we aren't implying that cap throws his shield with tank-busting force every single time he hurls it at an enemy, right? that's ridiculous, imo.

deadpool, for example, is not going to just...palm a shield-throw that could have decimated a tank. how strong/durable do you people think he is for god's sake? Strong enough to palm a shield-throw that could have decimated a tank.

babby

Originally posted by Galan007
certainly we aren't implying that cap throws his shield with tank-busting force every single time he hurls it at an enemy, right? that's ridiculous, imo.

deadpool, for example, is not going to just...palm a shield-throw that could have decimated a tank. how strong/durable do you people think he is for god's sake?

Some of these crazy guys might even think it's dumb for Cap's shield to decimate a tank, fancy that.

But yeah, obviously that hand's supposed to be flying.

Originally posted by Mindset
Strong enough to palm a shield-throw that could have decimated a tank.

babby









....go die.

Originally posted by Enzeru
No one below Spider-Man. Everyone else gets sliced in half, if Captain America is serious about the shield throw:

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/6/60791/3369162-8655695450-CAPAL.jpg
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/6/60791/3369162-8655695450-CAPAL.jpg

And the only reason Spider-Man would be able to catch it are his super powers: spider-sense, super speed and super strength. What comic is this from?

^ Captain America: Living Legend #1.

Originally posted by krisblaze
Some of these crazy guys might even think it's dumb for Cap's shield to decimate a tank, fancy that.

But yeah, obviously that hand's supposed to be flying. i'm just saying that if we are calling the tank-buster his 'most powerful throw'(which is what the stips of this thread are), then obviously the scene in which deadpool palmed a throw wouldn't qualify.

My nomination is Reed Richards.
Originally posted by Galan007
i'm just saying that if we are calling the tank-buster his 'most powerful throw'(which is what the stips of this thread are), then obviously the scene in which deadpool palmed a throw wouldn't qualify.

Yeah it should kill most of the 'redirect force in a circular motion' theories also.

In my opinion Deadpool beats Captain America straight up, if he is serious about the fight. He has done it twice at least.

Deadpool is super underrated, because he tends to fool around a lot and he usually undersells him, because his fights don't showcase his actual physical attributes. He has actual super strength, which was stated and showcased, when he was jumping onto building floors, stopping helicopters from flying away and ragdolling people around.

Deadpool might be able to stop Captain America's shield, even if Cap fully commits to the throw.

Originally posted by Enzeru
In my opinion Deadpool beats Captain America straight up, if he is serious about the fight. He has done it twice at least.

Deadpool is super underrated, because he tends to fool around a lot and he usually undersells him, because his fights don't showcase his actual physical attributes. He has actual super strength, which was stated and showcased, when he was jumping onto building floors, stopping helicopters from flying away and ragdolling people around.

Deadpool might be able to stop Captain America's shield, even if Cap fully commits to the throw. i don't doubt deadpool's ability to beat cap in a fight. he's not catching a tank-busting shield-throw, though. he's neither *that* strong, nor *that* durable(in a comic, i could see it taking his hand/arm clean off, tbh.)

Yeah, that catch isnt happening. Pool's arm would rip off.

LOL at the Beast scan though.

Originally posted by Galan007
i don't doubt deadpool's ability to beat cap in a fight. he's not catching a tank-busting shield-throw, though. he's neither *that* strong, nor *that* durable(in a comic, i could see it taking his hand/arm clean off, tbh.)

When it comes to Deadpool it depends on how he catches it. If he places his hand in front of the approaching shield in order to stop it in its track, then it would cut through him like butter without a doubt.
But if he manages to "clap" (don't know the proper verb for it) it from both sides together he might have the strength to stop its momentum immediately before it travels any further.

Deadpool has some serious strength feats. Rag-dolling adults around might be something that even peakhumans in comics do casually, but I hardly doubt that they can replicate some of Deadpool's other strength feats:

- Here Deadpool leaps onto a building, while some people are discussing how Deadpool used two fingers two hold someone in the air and snap their neck. Deadpool himself mentions people like Spider-Man and himself being able to make that jump:
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/2/28708/685504-deadpoolstrength1.jpg
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/2/28708/685506-deadpoolstrength2.jpg
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/2/28708/685505-deadpoolstrength3.jpg

- Deadpool also used Spider-Man's webbing to stop the momentum of a helicopter and redirect it to a giant, mutated rat to blow it up:
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/108566/4035307-1.jpg
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/108566/4035308-2.jpg

The last feat caused him obvious trouble, but he was still holding against the weight judging by his stance, which is quite insane.

Nice.
That gives the concept of Pool doing it more viability for sure.

Originally posted by Enzeru
When it comes to Deadpool it depends on how he catches it. If he places his hand in front of the approaching shield in order to stop it in its track, then it would cut through him like butter without a doubt. ...which, i *think*, is what the thread is asking: ie. who can just reach out and palm an all-out throw.

Originally posted by krisblaze
Some of these crazy guys might even think it's dumb for Cap's shield to decimate a tank, fancy that.

Exactly. He is only suppose to be around 1 ton in strength. But that means nothing, because there are street levelers who are only suppose to be peak human that can apparently kick clean through a motorcycle.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/3/39001/3855523-nw2.png

Cap once threw his shield and it overtook a missile in flight.
That was pretty damn cool.

WBH

Bucky

OP says the weakest

Yeah, somehow it always winds up the opposite.

Captain America

Which version?

Originally posted by riv6672
Which version?
Falcon, of course!

Of course!

I always assumed that Cap doing that to a tank has something to do with the shield itself, not just strength. Or are we implying that Cap is 5x stronger than Deadpool? Because that's how strong he'd have to be in order to ripp DP's arm off with a throw.

Why 5x?

Just a random number. Point is Cap is nowhere near strong enough to throw the shield and ripp DP's arm off when he tries to catch it. Not with sheer force of the throw that is.

Then its just an opinion on your part. Thought you had some math formula or something!
Mine is, a throw that can sheer off part of a tank, could rip off an arm.

Originally posted by riv6672
Then its just an opinion on your part. Thought you had some math formula or something!
Mine is, a throw that can sheer off part of a tank, could rip off an arm. Lol I don't do match, try asking h1. The part about number was not a serious statement, the part about strength was. Cap is not much stronger (if at all) than Deadpool. He shouldn't be able to ripp DP's arm off with a throw. I think it has something to do with the properties of the shield.

Originally posted by SamZED
I always assumed that Cap doing that to a tank has something to do with the shield itself, not just strength. Or are we implying that Cap is 5x stronger than Deadpool? Because that's how strong he'd have to be in order to ripp DP's arm off with a throw.

Don't use 5x you sound like h1 and that is annoying

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Don't use 5x you sound like h1 and that is annoying lol noted.

Yeah i'm not annoyed but i'm not buying this argument.

I'll say Pool can catch Cap's shield. IF Cap's not trying to cut him in half with it.

Originally posted by riv6672
Yeah i'm not annoyed but i'm not buying this argument.

I'll say Pool can catch Cap's shield. IF Cap's not trying to cut him in half with it. Why not? Do you think Cap can ripp his arm off by throwing say a crowbar? Shield properties must've had something to do with it.

Yeah, it's possible.

I wouldnt want Cap hitting me with anything with intent to kill.

But yeah, the shield was obviously a factor in the tank scene.
The shield is what Pool's trying to catch though. Same level throw as that scene, Pool's not catching it. OR clapping.

Originally posted by Enzeru
In my opinion Deadpool beats Captain America straight up, if he is serious about the fight. He has done it twice at least.

Deadpool is super underrated, because he tends to fool around a lot and he usually undersells him, because his fights don't showcase his actual physical attributes. He has actual super strength, which was stated and showcased, when he was jumping onto building floors, stopping helicopters from flying away and ragdolling people around.

Deadpool might be able to stop Captain America's shield, even if Cap fully commits to the throw.

Now that you say it, I remember Deadpool grabbing a guy or two by the hair and scaling a wall at superspeed. Rip off from BP I know, but it still happened. Can't beleive a normal guy doing that. It waas in one of his respect threads

Maybe the tank cutting is the virbanium plot devicery. Like Wolverine cutting up things he shouldn't, like full power Infinity Gauntlet Thanos

I think Hulk is right.

Cap's shield doesn't make a lick of sense. It's supposed to absorb kinetic energy and other stuff, but it can still bounce and cut through things.

Tank-shearing, as dumb as it is, is probably more a case of sharpness. The shield's cutting through it. Whether or not deadpool's strong enough to stop it shouldn't matter, because the shield's going to dice through him anyways.

We need someone with durability, like Colossus.

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Now that you say it, I remember Deadpool grabbing a guy or two by the hair and scaling a wall at superspeed. Rip off from BP I know, but it still happened. Can't beleive a normal guy doing that. It waas in one of his respect threads Deadpool is a low level superhuman, not a normal guy. He has plenty of feats from breaking a guy's neck with only to fingers to ripping guy's hand off effortlessly with only two fingers. Then there's the recent feat where he used Spidey's web-shooters to change a helicopters momentum and crash it into a building. He was hurt but still pulled it off.

The Spot can do it.

Just set two portal and let it fly for long enough...then catch it when it's slowed down.

What if it never slows down? What then huh?

Then Marvel has a source of infinite energy :-)

I thought that was his jobber aura.

Originally posted by krisblaze
I think Hulk is right.

Cap's shield doesn't make a lick of sense. It's supposed to absorb kinetic energy and other stuff, but it can still bounce and cut through things.

Tank-shearing, as dumb as it is, is probably more a case of sharpness. The shield's cutting through it. Whether or not deadpool's strong enough to stop it shouldn't matter, because the shield's going to dice through him anyways.

We need someone with durability, like Colossus.
yep
and please call me HulkIsHulk or hih.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
The Spot can do it.

Just set two portal and let it fly for long enough...then catch it when it's slowed down.
Yes, an actual pick, not just complaining about the shield!

A great pick, too, that'd work just fine..

If we're using superpower end guys then Butterball.

Well what the heck do you call what Pool has?

And, someone's really named Butterball?

Aunt May

Aunt May is named Butterball?!?

Originally posted by riv6672
Aunt May is named Butterball?!?

No but she will catch the shield with ease.

Oh. Oh!

Originally posted by riv6672
Oh. Oh!

uhuh

What?
I found it funny.

Originally posted by riv6672
What?
I found it funny.

You laugh about Aunt Mays power? Beware!

http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20080612031624/marveldatabase/images/3/33/May_Reilly_(Earth-89122).jpg

-must...not laugh-

Originally posted by riv6672
-must...not laugh-

Maybe this will convince you!

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11114/111142536/3984917-what-if-aunt-may-became-a-superhero.jpeg

How about US Agent?

What, no Herald of Galactus???

Originally posted by riv6672
Well what the heck do you call what Pool has?

And, someone's really named Butterball? He's the most useless superhero in Marvel universe.