Who Wins The Popularity Contest in Marvel ?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Supermex
Ever wondered which Marvel characters are the most popular among comic book fans? Well, after a comprehensive and sophisticated poll on this subject back in February, looking through it, some of the top contenders are pretty obvious, but others are more than a little surprising.

Two things should be mentioned first before I continue. First of all, the poll was based exclusively on the characters' comic book appearances, at least in principle. It's hard to imagine the film and TV versions of characters had no effect at all on the results, but they weren't the primary factor at least. Secondly, the poll was conducted by asking each poster in a forum to list their top 10 characters, rather than asking them to vote for one in particular. The character they ranked #1 scored the most points, the character they ranked #10 scored the least points.


I'll go ahead and list the full results below (in descending order): and get your thoughts and feed back. If you Dont agree with the top 10 on this list, plz give your top 10 if your is different.




100. Apocalypse
98. Groot
97. Enchantress
95. Wonder Man
94. Crystal
93. Star-Lord
92. Galactus
91. Norman Osborn
87. Firestar
86. Ghost Rider
84. Pixie
83. Mr. Sinister
82. Gamora
81. Moonstar
80. Chamber
79. Mockingbird
78. Moonstone
77. Venom (Brock)
76. Juggernaut
75. Drax
74. Daken
73. Rocket Raccoon
71. Johnny Storm
69. Pete Wisdom
68. Union Jack
67. Sif
66. Havok
65. Mr. Fantastic
64. Agent Venom
63. Hank Pym
62. Multiple Man
61. Mystique
59. Cable
58. Professor X
57. Vision
56. Luke Cage
55. Hawkeye
54. Quicksilver
53. Spectrum
52. Spider-Woman
51. Invisible Woman
50. Punisher
49. Colossus
48. Cable
47. Thanos
45. Nova
44. Moon Knight
43. Iceman
42. Wasp
41. Jubilee
40. Rachel Grey
39. Bucky Barnes
38. X-23
37. Hercules
36. Beast
35. Namor
34. Black Panther
33. Silver Surfer
32. Loki
31. Thing
30. Dazzler
29. Deadpool
28. Captain Britain
27. Dr. Strange
26. Hawkeye
25. She-Hulk
24. Polaris
23. Iron Fist
22. Black Widow
21. Scarlet Witch
20. Iron Man
19. Dr. Doom
18. Hulk
17. Magik
16. Psylocke
15. Carol Danvers
14. Daredevil
13. Kitty Pryde
12. Emma Frost
11. Magneto
10. Cyclops
9. Captain America
8. Jean Grey
7. Gambit
6. Nightcrawler
5. Rogue
4. Thor
3. Storm
2. Wolverine
1. Spider-Man

Gecko4lif
No idea how some of these people even made the list

Nightcrawler as 6 is a shocker, and i honestly surprised Spidey squeezed logan out of the top spot

Sin I AM
Horrible list

Branlor Swift
Iron Fist

Supermex
I Dont get how Hulk is 18

Branlor Swift
Because the list was clearly based on a forum heavy with casual female readers.

My proof: Magik is above Hulk.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Gecko4lif
No idea how some of these people even made the list

QFT.

Henry_Pym
Ms Marvel more popular than Doom?Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Because the list was clearly based on a forum heavy with casual female readers.

My proof: Magik is above Hulk. thumb up
A lot of X-females also kinda supports Bran's theory.

Also Multiple Man above Pym really hurts.

carver9
That list is jacked. Seems like it was made by an Xmen fanbase.

Mindset
Spiderman.

Supermex
Originally posted by carver9
That list is jacked. Seems like it was made by an Xmen fanbase.




I agree lol

relentless1
its a toss up between Iron Man and Spider Man at this point, Wolverine comes in at 3rd from a fair distance; everyone else eats shit

Supermex
Originally posted by relentless1
its a toss up between Iron Man and Spider Man at this point, Wolverine comes in at 3rd from a fair distance; everyone else eats shit


I would think Hulk would be somewhere in the top 5

My Top 5 I thought it be or should

1. Spider-Man
2. Wolverine
3. Hulk
4. Iron Man
5. Thor

carver9
Originally posted by Supermex
I would think Hulk would be somewhere in the top 5

My Top 5 I thought it be or should

1. Spider-Man
2. Wolverine
3. Hulk
4. Iron Man
5. Thor

He is along with Spiderman, Wolverine, and the Xmen.

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by Henry_Pym
Ms Marvel more popular than Doom? thumb up
A lot of X-females also kinda supports Bran's theory.

Also Multiple Man above Pym really hurts. The whole Gambit being in the top 10 solidifies it. That list is littered with X-Men who casual females would flock to.

Lol at Iron Man being 20th. Ms Marvel being above him kind of makes my point redundant at that stage.

golem370
You would think Captain America would be 1 Spider-Man 2 then the rest of the list.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Henry_Pym
Ms Marvel more popular than Doom? thumb up

Think about it for a sec. Plenty of fans google Danvers for fapping purposes, while nobody aside from Mindset does the same with Doom.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Lol at Iron Man being 20th.

Bigger lulz at The Punisher being 50th...

riv6672
That list is...numerical. erm

At least #1 is acceptable.

Vanguard
Panther should be higher

Board Walker
wolverine

Reflassshh
Originally posted by Vanguard
Panther should be higher Who?

Vanguard
Originally posted by Reflassshh
Who?

funny

-Pr-
lol @ Cyclops being #10. What is this, bizarro world?

zom1967
Spider man at no.1 does not suprize me at all.Galactus at 92 does,he is easaliy the most popular cosmic of all time.and was ranked 5th top villan of all time by wizard mag back in 2009!

zom1967
In fact the more I look at this list,the more it sucks!

Digi
I thought this was going to be popularity amongst themselves. Like, if they all listed their top 5 fellow heroes.

Thing would be #1. Everyone likes him. Those old comics with everyone playing in his poker tournament were the best.

Squirtle
That list sucks, who made that crap?

This is the real deal:
1. Puck
2. Snowbird
3. Guardian
4. Sasquatch
5. Shaman
6. Northstar
7. Aurora
8. Spiderman
9. Wolverine
10. Captain America

krisblaze
I remember a few years back IGN did a popularity contest among the x-men, and Cyclops won.

Not even PR bought that shit.

shadowknight
1.Spiderman
2.Wolverine
3.Cap America
4.Thor
5.Iron Man
6.Hulk
7.Daredevil
8.Thing
9.Namor
10.Magneto

iceman24567
No 99? Also Groot should be in the top 50 atleast erm

bluewaterrider
Originally posted by shadowknight
1.Spiderman
2.Wolverine
3.Cap America
4.Thor
5.Iron Man
6.Hulk
7.Daredevil
8.Thing
9.Namor
10.Magneto



Keep as is and your list is better than any presented in this thread.

Get rid of #8 and #9 and you've probably got an accurate one to boot ...

Supermex
Originally posted by shadowknight
1.Spiderman
2.Wolverine
3.Cap America
4.Thor
5.Iron Man
6.Hulk
7.Daredevil
8.Thing
9.Namor
10.Magneto


1 & 2 looks accurate..

3 thru 6 can be juggled either way..

7 thru 10 I can see Thing an Namor off the top 10 and Daredevil / Mags staying in the top 10.

Who replaces the Thing & Namor if there not in the top 10?

JayDaDon
Its probably closer to
1. Spidey
2.Iron man
3. Hulk
4. Cap
5. Logan

Once you factor in how much exposure the movies brought

Prof. T.C McAbe
Originally posted by shadowknight
1.Spiderman
2.Wolverine
3.Cap America
4.Thor
5.Iron Man
6.Hulk
7.Daredevil
8.Thing
9.Namor
10.Magneto

That one seems good.

leonidas
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Think about it for a sec. Plenty of fans google Danvers for fapping purposes, while nobody aside from Mindset does the same with Doom.


bwhahahah! thumb up

/thread

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.