Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who on Marvel Earth do you consider or is considered the best detective on the planet?


Give a top 3 list plz

1.
2.
3.


....................

Who wins?
No prep..
No B.F.R..
Dcnu..


Superman
Wonder Woman

Vs

Blue Marvel
Spectrum

I asked this question last year. The results were a mixed bag.
1. Moon Knight and
2. Daredevil got a number of mentions, as well as
3. Spider-man
The rest were telepaths and scientists. Some said Black Panther was retroactively the best, which i personally found laughable.
I forget who, but someone summed it up as, whoever the best is in the MU, there is a huge gap between that person and Batman.

----------------------

BM and Spectrum>supes and WW.

Matt or Jen (Shulkie)
Wolverjerk
BP
---
Diana Soloes

Yeah i remember someone nominating Wolverine. Animal senses, LOL.

Since the marvel world has a greater focus on technology, there is less pure true detective style work.

-Punisher is in because he uses his police/military background to track down targets, with techniques similar to that line of work.

-Daredevil is lawyer by day, and as a result he has extensive cross-training with the NYPD and employs what he knows to his own work with his own gifts.

-Moon Knight is more of a trained merc, but has picked you some detective techniques.

-A small part of what Reed Richards involves detective work, combined with science.

-Jamie Madrox is also clearly a detective, and probably would be the "best detective" at Marvel purely for being one of the few, and the only one to keep his schtick.

Feel free to add names to the list.. Maybe we can boil it down to one..

Originally posted by Supermex
Since the marvel world has a greater focus on technology, there is less pure true detective style work.

-Punisher is in because he uses his police/military background to track down targets, with techniques similar to that line of work.

-Daredevil is lawyer by day, and as a result he has extensive cross-training with the NYPD and employs what he knows to his own work with his own gifts.

-Moon Knight is more of a trained merc, but has picked you some detective techniques.

-A small part of what Reed Richards involves detective work, combined with science.

-Jamie Madrox is also clearly a detective, and probably would be the "best detective" at Marvel purely for being one of the few, and the only one to keep his schtick.

Feel free to add names to the list.. Maybe we can boil it down to one..

Great choiced, but add Nick Fury.

As well as Misty Knight and /or Colleen.

The only list Logan should be on is "characters that should stay dead".

Originally posted by Silent Master
The only list Logan should be on is "characters that should stay dead".



lol dam!

I don't think Wolverine should be on here. It's not really him being a good detective if he has to rely on super powers to do it.

My top choice would Daredevil so far

There are tons actually, just no big names

Jessica Drew, Bishop, Ben Urich, Fatone, umm Madrox, Sage..castle does alotta detection in his work. Jessica Jones, the old heroes for hire, Hannibal king etc

Characters like Spiderman aren't true detectives

Originally posted by Sin I AM
There are tons actually, just no big names

Jessica Drew, Bishop, Ben Urich, Fatone, umm Madrox, Sage..castle does alotta detection in his work. Jessica Jones, the old heroes for hire, Hannibal king etc

Characters like Spiderman aren't true detectives




So who would you place as the top 3?

My Top Man is Punisher, he has to do a lot of detective work to find the criminals and kill them.

Originally posted by Supermex
Since the marvel world has a greater focus on technology, there is less pure true detective style work.

-Punisher is in because he uses his police/military background to track down targets, with techniques similar to that line of work.

-Daredevil is lawyer by day, and as a result he has extensive cross-training with the NYPD and employs what he knows to his own work with his own gifts.

-Moon Knight is more of a trained merc, but has picked you some detective techniques.

-A small part of what Reed Richards involves detective work, combined with science.

-Jamie Madrox is also clearly a detective, and probably would be the "best detective" at Marvel purely for being one of the few, and the only one to keep his schtick.

Feel free to add names to the list.. Maybe we can boil it down to one..
Hard boiled?
I see what you did there.

Detective Mac Gargan is #1, obviously.